Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
I don't know if it's to throw us off or something but my instinct says town or neutral due to that vote.
If it's townie or neutral, then that person can claim it right?

This is also odd, you've thrown out the assumption here that Blade is a townie visiting me.

It feels very preemptive and gives Blade something to work with instead of letting him answer it himself.
Replace Blade with Melon and the same argument can be made with you guys giving her the "playful" excuse. Which she used.

I also think you misread that. I think he is implying blade may not have been a townie.
 
If it's townie or neutral, then that person can claim it right?

True. I wouldn't mind that. ALL the claims lol.

Replace Blade with Melon and the same argument can be made with you guys giving her the "playful" excuse. Which she used.

Melon has been around the whole time, answering questions even if they aren't the answers people want. Blade has hardly been around. Not a great comparison to me.

I also think you misread that. I think he is implying blade may not have been a townie.

You're right, I read back it several times there and I think I misread it. Sorry @Gorlak
 

Xbro

Bags his own tea
Okay, so I've got a very busy week at work and I don't really have time to focus on this game. I've put in a request for replacement, and that should take place soon. Sorry about this.
 
Okay, so I've got a very busy week at work and I don't really have time to focus on this game. I've put in a request for replacement, and that should take place soon. Sorry about this.

Okay, sorry to see you go but good luck with work and all.
 
Hello. I have work in the morning, so I need to get to bed. However, in case anything happens between now and when I get to the office, here's a pre-typed post.

We know that Apollo had the ability to give a fully-accurate ITA shot to any player. Given his target, we concluded that Mazre was the most likely recipient. Come the flip, though, it turned out that he was a town player who just happened to have a guaranteed hit anyway. So who did Apollo target in N1?

Let's consider his options - should he give out a fully accurate shot or nullify someone else's shot? While either is possible, the latter would have been a riskier choice - after only the first day, it would have been difficult to work out the motivations of how exactly so many players would want to us their shots - not to mention that with a wide field of targets, nerfing a townie could have denied scum the chance of a mis-hit. So it seems more likely to me that they would have boosted a player, and it stands to reason that they would want to help one of their own.

With that in mind, who could have received the boost? Not Terraforce or Mazre, as scum would have known that they weren't on their side. That just leaves EzekelRAGE and Extreme Tactician as the remaining two players who scored a successful hit. However, both of their targets were scum, so that would mean that whichever of the two was boosted used their shot to bus a team-mate. Who, then, would have been the worthier bus? Splinter, the relatively safe JOAT, or Vere, the outed role cop who was already well on track to getting lynched anyway? Unless they're being far craftier than I gave them credit for, I'd say Vere every time.

In short: Extreme Tactician, I think you have some explaining to do.

This ends the pre-typed post. I slep now.
Zzz.

*nods*

Mhm, mhm I surely know what you're talking about. Not lost at all.

Just let me re-read a dozen times...okay, feel slightly more caught up to game.

tenor.gif

This is an odd gif to post after DEATH Man
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
True. I wouldn't mind that. ALL the claims lol.
Melon has been around the whole time, answering questions even if they aren't the answers people want. Blade has hardly been around. Not a great comparison to me.
I disagree. perfect comparisons. She's just echoed other ppls answers of "doesnt make sense logically for scum" and "it was for fun."

Anyway

What makes you think the lone stranger is a neutral/townie based on the vote?
 
What makes you think the lone stranger is a neutral/townie based on the vote?

Going after Include mainly. I'm feeling even more that she's scum so that vote makes me feel that it's not scum doing so.

I also feel if they were scum, they would have laid low like Ry's NPC did and then ITA someone.
 

rac

whatever
Those behaviors remind me of several games I've played with him in, before he even came to this forum. But there are several off putting things in his behavior that I don't like. A little late, but there's several games on the Gamefaqs "forum mafia" board (where I'm one of the main mods) if you want to see some of his past games.

Anyway, after thinking about it, I lowkey feel I'd rather try for Brazil before Geno. I'll have to ISO Brazil for a better gauge, but offhand he doesn't feel as invested as I'm used to seeing him being, and there were a few smaller things that caught my eye before but just didn't write down. But I mainly say this because Geno bussing is nothing new, but his Brazil vote doesn't feel like it would be a bus. Geno pegging Brazil for scum soon after Brazil replaced in makes me think the two aren't of the same alignment (unless it's town on town then this is all moot). Just something I've been idly thinking over.

next moments terra is dead, someone tell me if im wrong but it didn't seem like there was enough time between apollo dying in the event and choosing a kill for apollo to confirm who should be killed in scum thread
could this be at all reactionary

or just trying to make geno and brazil look bad
 

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
So I'm guessing next ITA phase people are going to shoot at Include or Natiko.

One thing I wanted to remind everybody beforehand: If we hit one of them, STOP shooting the other one until we get the flip. Just to be safe.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Going after Include mainly. I'm feeling even more that she's scum so that vote makes me feel that it's not scum doing so.
Could be a bus

I also feel if they were scum, they would have laid low like Ry's NPC did and then ITA someone.
iirc ryn's npc only purpose was to ITA. wasnt it?

@Mysterious Entity has joined the game.

You may not interact directly with this player in any way (including but not limited to, votes, PRs, ITAs). They also do not effect the majority which at this time is 23.

Game Continues
 
One thing I wanted to remind everybody beforehand: If we hit one of them, STOP shooting the other one until we get the flip. Just to be safe.

Neither flip confirms the other imo. Considering the way the games gone down so far. So much bussing, even more wouldn't be unexpected.

iirc ryn's npc only purpose was to ITA. wasnt it?

Yes but I mean with first ITA soon, I'd have thought they would lay low until then if they were scum and try to take someone who is town out then. Just how I feel, could be wrong.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
A second scum joat?
omg seriously there could be ten, stop

Yeah, this is bullshit. Took you a really long time to spit out a name and then you come out with someone that (please correct me if I'm wrong someone - at work and can't really do a deep dive) you have basically not mentioned at ALL previously. Then your JOAT is unverified previously, you don't go into any info on D1, and if you're town thinking that you've caught scum why be cagey? You should be gleeful to go 1:1 if you're telling the truth.
This is true, that stall is a problem.

Melon won a 1-shot track, which means I got my copy. Hence why I could confirm that was the item. I tracked @BladeSymphony to @Stuart444 last night. I was going to leave it alone since nothing bad has happened to Stu and drop my scumread on Blade so as to not draw attention to him. That being said, since scum is now trying to throw a hail mary I figured it was pertinent to just come out with it all.
This bears out and it makes me inclined then to believe that Natiko's role is less likely to be scum. Would not rule out neutral for him or Include; a gambler could be the type to stand aside, but if he is vanilla after, that points more to town, I think.

How in the world was I evasive in HVV? I got checked and owned up to it. I got to play for like a singular phase after subbing in for Lifeline.
You were evasive in that you kept having to go do things. We all talked about it and we talked about it again in the mini. Don't be shocked, my dude. I'm not using it as a strict measure or anything here; this game impacts meta hard, I think.

I'm more willing to believe Nat over Include at the moment. While I know she has said she is short on time, in general she has been fairly passive. I remember her much more fiery and a willingness to jump in.
Yeah, this does not bear out. She's gone after people, she's put up reads, she's gotten into arguments. How's she not "fiery" and willing to jump in? All claims aside, where do you prove this and how? I can see Natiko's point about her stalling. Not this, though.
 

rac

whatever
Okay, so I've got a very busy week at work and I don't really have time to focus on this game. I've put in a request for replacement, and that should take place soon. Sorry about this.

so close to itas

when people have the bloodlust for inactives
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
@Include Am I still scum? What happened there? Why aren't you saying anything after spending all D2 tunneling me?
Don't do that. She said she was at work. The world doesn't revolve around whatever claims are on the table, let's have a modicum of respect for folks when they say they're out.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Wait, it we can interact with the LS as if it was a normal poster.

Also game mechanic question. Does a peeping tom/looking power not require someone to move and thus doesnt count as them visiting someone?
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
You were evasive in that you kept having to go do things. We all talked about it and we talked about it again in the mini. Don't be shocked, my dude. I'm not using it as a strict measure or anything here; this game impacts meta hard, I think.
All I can say is that all three of these games have taken place after I started my new job which has left me a lot busier than I was the year and a half prior. The two games you're pointing at even I was two different alignments. Just is my life now, sorry. (And I know you're not attacking real life things, no worries there)
 
==== DAY 3 VOTES ====
Day Start

include (8 votes)
brazil - #4018
sawneeks - #4059
luxcommander - #4070
melonrabbit - #4072
natiko - #4116
nomad sparkster - #4273
swamped - #4347
lone stranger - #4368

natiko (1 votes)
blargonaut - #4200

Post Counts:
ezekelrage: 73 gorlak: 71 stuart444: 64 blargonaut: 41 melonrabbit: 33 heymonkey: 25 brazil: 21 extreme tactician: 18 stanleypalmtree: 17 geno: 15 luxcommander: 13 muffin: 12 sawneeks: 12 natiko: 11 poltergust: 10 dcpat: 10 include: 8 alexem: 8 kawl: 8 sorian: 7 ynnek7: 6 rac: 6 zippedpinhead: 5 faircure: 4 swamped: 2 zubz: 2 lone stranger: 1 nomad sparkster: 1 xbro: 1

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Remember those people. And don't give them the benefit of doubt when I flip.

By the way my first power that I'm willing to reveal and can green check me is I can send BP. Yes, I can send a vest but I can't use it on myself. Thus why I'm important and can be proved and thus why I said I can do it tonight if a watcher is on me and if you trust the people I mentioned. That's why I wanted to be 100% we trust the person I send it, I wanted to keep until we have a cop green check someone and send to them but I can do it now with Stu/Ynnek7, I still need someone else on one of them though since they work in pair as a cop or secret admirer or whatever you guys call this.

Everyone is fixated for the power I wanna hide and not the one I am OK revealing.

Deal. With. It. Not gonna reveal it. Not gonna give any anti town that satisfaction.

And no if I wanted to lie I had lie better, I'm not that dumb, I just see no point in lying in the first place but It's fine I'm willing to be the sacrifice if needed to be. We still have enough people, losing me isn't gonna really change the outcome of the game, we have been doing crazy well so far already.

Sorry, I don't know what you expected when I can just check this every few hours.
 
I do think Blarg is scum. I think I should shoot him or Gorlak, as I think Include will probably get voted out.

I disagree. Getting Include will cause some interesting discussions and other scum won't be able to hide behind that obvious bus so easily if we hit Include.

Also why Gorlak?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Those are the people that didn't shoot during D2 ITA and are still alive:
  • briefs_cat
  • Ferg
  • BladeSymphony
  • StanleyPalmtree
  • Lone_Prodigy
  • Nomad Sparkster
  • CoolestSpot
  • oreomunsta

"Low" posters:
  • xbro: 38
  • zubz: 37
  • luxcommander: 33
  • swamped: 27
  • hom3land: 27
  • necktochicken: 26
  • nzjubjub: 19
  • ferg: 16
  • oreomunsta: 12
  • lone_prodigy: 7
  • briefs_cat: 3
Coincidently - briefs cat, lp, oreo and ferg also missed the chance to shoot.
don't shoot rac, though, he's my dope ass blob

unless he's scum. But I didn't scumread Ferg.

Anyway, USEFUL LISTS!
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Remember those people. And don't give them the benefit of doubt when I flip.

By the way my first power that I'm willing to reveal and can green check me is I can send BP. Yes, I can send a vest but I can't use it on myself. Thus why I'm important and can be proved and thus why I said I can do it tonight if a watcher is on me and if you trust the people I mentioned. That's why I wanted to be 100% we trust the person I send it, I wanted to keep until we have a cop green check someone and send to them but I can do it now with Stu/Ynnek7, I still need someone else on one of them though since they work in pair as a cop or secret admirer or whatever you guys call this.

Everyone is fixated for the power I wanna hide and not the one I am OK revealing.

Deal. With. It. Not gonna reveal it. Not gonna give any anti town that satisfaction.

And no if I wanted to lie I had lie better, I'm not that dumb, I just see no point in lying in the first place but It's fine I'm willing to be the sacrifice if needed to be. We still have enough people, losing me isn't gonna really change the outcome of the game, we have been doing crazy well so far already.

Sorry, I don't know what you expected when I can just check this every few hours.
And your N1 action was..? Your mysterious third power on some mysterious person I'm guessing lol
 

Swamped

Dazzling Mafia Queen
I disagree. Getting Include will cause some interesting discussions and other scum won't be able to hide behind that obvious bus so easily if we hit Include.

Also why Gorlak?

I'll shoot Include then, that's a good point. No point in a runaway lynch.

Gorlak because I don't really trust his 'melon is scum' arguments.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
I dont understand the reasoning for switching yourself with someone you think is scum?

If I think someone is scum, the last thing I do is switch myself with them on the off chance a vig thought they were scummy to and tried to shoot them.
 
don't shoot rac, though, he's my dope ass blob

unless he's scum. But I didn't scumread Ferg.

Anyway, USEFUL LISTS!

I'm not shooting at rac and I hope no one else does and hits him. Not because of any reads but because I feel it's a dick move to do so right after he replaced someone lol.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
All I can say is that all three of these games have taken place after I started my new job which has left me a lot busier than I was the year and a half prior. The two games you're pointing at even I was two different alignments. Just is my life now, sorry. (And I know you're not attacking real life things, no worries there)
That's why it would never be my only measure. But that they were two different alignments was part of the point lol.

I switched myself with someone! It was with eram

... It’s Natiko!

This is a lie. The way she withheld information throughout multiple posts for no reason, too, is a clear sign of someone who hadn’t prepared all of her material and needed some time.

Include would’ve used a power like that either against Geno or Saw, the two players she was fixated on yesterday. Natiko as a target came from absolutely nowhere. I’d be flabbergasted if it was true.
Maybe. I think this only absolutely bears out if she's under particular threat and she wasn't, but it's a point to consider.

This is probably the hardest I’ve ever seen you reach, Monkey.
Except I'm not reaching for anything, dude. Just commenting as I go. And yeah, those two posts just didn't feel like you to me. Felt flat.
 

rac

whatever
I dont understand the reasoning for switching yourself with someone you think is scum?

If I think someone is scum, the last thing I do is switch myself with them on the off chance a vig thought they were scummy to and tried to shoot them.
but people are shading include for not switching with her top scum read geno
 

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
Neither flip confirms the other imo. Considering the way the games gone down so far. So much bussing, even more wouldn't be unexpected.
One of them is scum or neutral at least. There is absolutely no reason for two scummies to do what Include and Natiko are doing. If the first one flips scum, the second one is with almost certainty town are neutral at worst.
 
Lux's claim went a little under the radar but I do townread him for now because of it

His claim combined with a shot that I just don't believe scum would take if Include is scum. Of course if Include flipped town and she ended up telling the truth, I'd be scum reading Lux hard from it.
 

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
Remember those people. And don't give them the benefit of doubt when I flip.

By the way my first power that I'm willing to reveal and can green check me is I can send BP. Yes, I can send a vest but I can't use it on myself. Thus why I'm important and can be proved and thus why I said I can do it tonight if a watcher is on me and if you trust the people I mentioned. That's why I wanted to be 100% we trust the person I send it, I wanted to keep until we have a cop green check someone and send to them but I can do it now with Stu/Ynnek7, I still need someone else on one of them though since they work in pair as a cop or secret admirer or whatever you guys call this.

Everyone is fixated for the power I wanna hide and not the one I am OK revealing.

Deal. With. It. Not gonna reveal it. Not gonna give any anti town that satisfaction.

And no if I wanted to lie I had lie better, I'm not that dumb, I just see no point in lying in the first place but It's fine I'm willing to be the sacrifice if needed to be. We still have enough people, losing me isn't gonna really change the outcome of the game, we have been doing crazy well so far already.

Sorry, I don't know what you expected when I can just check this every few hours.
There is no reason for us to wait till tomorrow. Hell, there's not really much reason for you to be mad about doing a 1:1 for scum.

And Natikos claim sounds more honest to me than yours.
 
One of them is scum or neutral at least. There is absolutely no reason for two scummies to do what Include and Natiko are doing. If the first one flips scum, the second one is with almost certainty town are neutral at worst.

Can't say it, scum has done a lot of things that weren't needed this game. And depending on who else is scum, there might be even more things that scum didn't need to do but did.

But of course that's a lot of speculation but I'd be very very hesitant to say "Neutral at worst" just because of current conversations.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
There is no reason for us to wait till tomorrow. Hell, there's not really much reason for you to be mad about doing a 1:1 for scum.

And Natikos claim sounds more honest to me than yours.
It's not a zero sum game here though. Natiko's claim is more straightforward and has some slight verification behind it (a process begun before the claims) but it doesn't automatically make Include scum.

Though there's for sure some kinda shenanigans happening. I wonder if we'll see another boss battle in the ITA.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Her role as claimed doesn't sound scum (but if she is, she's almost certainly making up aspects). But it doesn't particularly sound neutral, either. It's not a terrible claim - just the timing, and the choice of Natiko. It makes me wonder if she's scum who's left on the time since this would probably be a group effort. Something to possibly speculate on after flip. I think it would point to at least one more veteran player left on the scum team.
 
Don't know what's wanted so here we go y'all.

I was mainly looking for clarification. There should be a "not sure" in my original post since I didn't know if he was picking something up from the intro post that I was missing, or something else.


From reading here, he messed up once. Not much suspicious, just clarification and all that jazz. Also calling out my previous gameplay which is fair.


Good morning-ish!

I've caught up on the thread, and have a free moment at work to get some thoughts in.

I definitely think we should lynch today. Pretty much agree with the sentiment that not doing so will just give mafia a free day to work with.

I'm not sure where my vote will go yet, and don't really have anyone I want to pressure, so I'll hold off for now. Maybe not the best plan, but I'll probably hold off until closer to the end of the day to see what groups start forming.

I saw someone mention another flavor/mechanic that I didn't notice anyone else pick up on, but after falling into the item talk myself, I wanted to see if anyone else noticed it first. Anyone know what I'm talking about?

Pro Lynch is neither a sign of town or scum by themselves, unfortunately (cause if so we'd have an easier game). Waiting to see what group forms comes off as scummy, just waiting to help whatever kill helps them and all that. Seems scummy to see what wait to see what death would be more advantageous then just making a move and prodding a current player, even those without groups.

Not really "hop on a wagon". I want to see how people's votes start lining up with their previous thoughts.

Does ITA stand for in thread attacks? I am curious about how those will play out, and whether they are normal powers that people already have, or something that will be event rewards. I didn't really notice anything out of the ordinary from Apollo talking about that. Also, it's day one, so RNG votes don't seem that weird to me, and even self voting at point is more just for fun than anything else, I'd think.

The person mentioned a very specific place, which I hadn't noticed being mentioned anywhere else. They might be referencing an upcoming event, but for some reason only they have talked about it. Maybe I'm wrong and am just missing it in the opening post flavor.

Eh, here he defends himself from what I brought up, but still comes across as a scum covering tracks with this line of logic, at least on first read. No player should wait for votes in my opinion, but maybe I'm too hard on him for a different playstyle. Also I got what ITAs are now, I think (knew they were for attacks in game, didn't know what it stood for).

Yep. Did that come from anywhere?
tenor.gif


Ah, okay. Thanks! So that must be where we'll go for the events. I've only had this page open so I never even saw that.

Often gone and only has certain pages open? Poor player/Scum tells here people.

I'm not feeling too confident about voting for either melonrabbit or Splinter right now. Neither of them seem particularly scummy to me, and I don't think there's any reason this couldn't be a "town vs town" situation.

This will be over by time I wake up. Luckily I checked the thead before heading to bed.

Can't spell thread, obivous scumtell. I think maybe this shows he's a not cofident in his own choices and maybe that's why he waits on sidelines? Yneek is a true mystery.

I just don't see that being a safe assumption here. Wouldn't really be fair to either side, I think?

This isn't a divorce where we're trying to make both sides happy, kill bastards and get results.

Yeah, Sorian mentioned a tie will result in a no lynch.

Fuck no lynchs, am I right?

If that's the case, we could make the arguement to lynch one of them in the event, then if they end up as town lynch the other one for the official day end. Either way we'll end up ahead, trading one town for one scum/neutral.

Fair point, though from my skimming and brief understanding this could lead to two town deaths right? It's odd how killing as much as possible is advantageous to both town and scum in early game in different ways.

Actually, just thought about this since Stuart quoted a post from Mazre. Once the low activity posters are taken care of, it may be worthwhile to avoid discussing future ITA's.

We already saw that Gamora had the ability to boost the attacks. It's possible that scum might have a similar ability to boost an attack if they think it will be used on town, or maybe a way to lower the chance if they think a target will be scum.

So are you trying to hint players keep powers from each other? It's always a hard balance if players should hide powers from team mates for planning or not, but in mafia don't people tend to share most by end game? Otherwise players can fuck each other up and scum can play game guessing game's framework with their skills and what they see from players?

I'd imagine Sorian would at least have checked in on him after the first day, to make sure he hadn't forgotten. At this point it's very possible he's aware, and just waiting.

You know who else is super aware and just waiting?
tenor.gif


Good morning, all!

I'm awake and at work right now, but I've skimmed over everything that's happened since I went to bed.

I know there was still some talk about me going on, which I'll get back to. I was actually up at 4 when it was going in, but I promised myself that I wouldn't get posting that late.

I'm glad we're down three scum now, but I wish it weren't the people that I suspected as town/neutral, and who I'd give that imaginary bulletproof to.

...Yeah maybe show up more? Like I'm a hypocrite and this is large game, but damn most your posts are "Hey girlfriends, out of town, try not to get covered in blood too much tee hee". Which worries me is some slipping into the shadows bullshit.

Damn, thank you. Yeah, that should be role cop. I think I had that stuck in my head since the roleblock was part of the arguement regarding the two.

Out of my realm of understanding/skimming, moving right along, da dum da dada dum. Foot loose and fancy free ~

Heya, all. Sorry for disappearing after the last event last night. A friend came into town unexpectedly and I pretty much only took a chance participating in that since it was a low involvement one.

We're actually going out to a festival today, so I'm not really sure I'll have much of a chance to post today.

I can completely understand if I end up voted out tonight, or killed in the ITA, but hopefully I'll still be around tomorrow.

I will say that I had something happen to me during the last night phase, but since it's pretty NAI I didn't think it was that important or useful to bring up.

Sure, this "friend" came in and let you slip away and you're hiding powers. I mean I could be an ass here and you could have a social life, but you're playing mafia online and on a video game forum so I say you're a liar, a killer, and scum.

Or, more likely, I don't have much to say besides wth would you hint at it and not bring it up? Stir conversation away from more important topics?

So, I said I that something happened to me during Night 1. The same thing happened to me Night 2, and as much as I hate to admit it, I really don't know what to make of it.

Gonna do a partial role claim here. I am a Heartthrob. I don't get to do anything during the Night, but somewhere out there I have a secret admirer who can send me information every night. I don't know anything about this person, so they could either be town sending me the truth, town sending me their opinion, or scum sending me lies. I've paraphrased their messages here:

N1 - The person you're looking at is Town
N2 - The person you're looking at is not Town.

I've gone through all of my posts from the game so far and put my noticeable interactions with people below. Sorry about not directly quoting anything here, but it should be easy to search for these interactions. I know it might seem like I'm roleclaiming too early, but if the person who's sending me messages is Town, we may have something close to a red check on someone.

People I Interacted with Day 1
-CoolestSpot - Opening Post
TOWN-CrimsonFist - I noticed that he mentioned the Galactic Arena, which I was not yet aware of.
-Stuart444 - Talked about GA
-Faircure - Talked about GA
-Gorlak - Talked about GA
-Melonrabbit - In reference to the TD
SCUM-Splinter - In reference to the TD
-BladeSymphony - Did not agree with his assumption that one of them had to be scum.
-Zubz - I noted that a tie would result in a No Lynch in the TD
SCUM-Verelios - Commented on my belief that if one of them had to be scum, that would mean if town died, we'd just have to lynch the other to break even.
-Poltergust - I pointed out that he was mainly just posting about vote formatting than anything else.
SCUM-Grizzly - I vote for him close to day end.
SCUM-Rynam - I mention that he might end up being town or neutral due to his play during the event.
-Kawl - I mention that I don't know where I stand on him.

Night 1 I receive a message stating that someone I focused on is town. I really don't know who I looked at here that ended up town. Grizzly was scum. Rynam ended up being scum the next day. And the other person that was high on the vote list when I made my vote was Vere, another scum.

People I interracted with Day 2
-Sawneeks - Calls me out on a scummy vote for Grizzly, wonders why I wouldn't vote for Kawl.
-Oreomunsta - We discuss the possibility that multiple scum could do night kills at once.
SCUM-Verelios - Same
-Heymonkey - Says I should try to engage more instead of focusing on mechanics and speculation.
-Extreme Tactician - I tell him that they should still post, even if what they want to say has already been said. Also confusion with his fluff post.
-Stuart - Because of him I notice something from Mazre
TOWN-Mazre -I agree with him that people might want to not openly discuss future ITA targets, to prevent powers meddling with the results.

Special question from heymonkey-
Who to shoot? Rynam/Scum or CoolestSpot
Who to bulletproof? Melon or Splinter/Scum​

Geno - I point out that the roleblock was more a status ailment, on not something that could have been reflected.
Include - Wished her well while taking time away from the game. (Thought about leaving this out, but kept it since I'm not sure whoever I'm getting these messages from would ignore it.)
Natiko - Points out that I was calling the role cop a role blocker.

Night 2 I receive a message stating that someone I focused on was not town.

Once again, apologies for the wall of text, but I kind of need more eyes on this since I'm a bit lost with what to do with it.

WTF is a heartthrob? Is this a fake claim and an ego boost? Gonna google and get back to this, but this seems iffy to me.

If you are my secret admirer, you could have just said so. Finding all these notes in my locker was weird.

...Is someone else claiming to be your lover? Love in this game is weird. It's like when they shoehorned Banner wanting to experiment on Widow's body with some green tools. Forced, unneeded, and cluttering my game.

Also, I'm fluffing as much as you, cause see, that's what you're doing.

Yeah, Stuart doesn't get the results, they come to me. That's why even after checking Kawl Night 1, he didn't change his opinion on him.

...Hm. Will report back when my thoughts are fully formed on all this but..
tenor.gif
 

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
It's not a zero sum game here though. Natiko's claim is more straightforward and has some slight verification behind it (a process begun before the claims) but it doesn't automatically make Include scum.

Though there's for sure some kinda shenanigans happening. I wonder if we'll see another boss battle in the ITA.
???

One of the two is scum. We have two people, Ynnek and Stuart acting as a cop together and they gave us a redcheck on Include. Either Include is scum, or Natiko is because Include is telling the truth regarding the switch.

I retract what I said about one of them being neutral at least. One of them is definitely scum if our lover cop isn't lying. The message Ynnek got specifically says scum.
 
Gorlak because I don't really trust his 'melon is scum' arguments.
Seriously?

The day phase I mention you as a scum candidate and point out your weak presence you decide you have to shoot me? What's so horrible about my arguments that I deserve to be killed, huh?
 
...Is someone else claiming to be your lover? Love in this game is weird. It's like when they shoehorned Banner wanting to experiment on Widow's body with some green tools. Forced, unneeded, and cluttering my game.

I am. If you read the rest of the thread from his claim post, you'd see that instead of iso (did I use that correctly?) him lol.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
The message Ynnek got specifically says scum.
Where was that clarified? I might have missed it; I was working from this:

Gonna do a partial role claim here. I am a Heartthrob. I don't get to do anything during the Night, but somewhere out there I have a secret admirer who can send me information every night. I don't know anything about this person, so they could either be town sending me the truth, town sending me their opinion, or scum sending me lies. I've paraphrased their messages here:

N1 - The person you're looking at is Town
N2 - The person you're looking at is not Town.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Oh, I guess that got resolved there. It's pretty rare for a red check to specify mafia (here at least).
 

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
???

One of the two is scum. We have two people, Ynnek and Stuart acting as a cop together and they gave us a redcheck on Include. Either Include is scum, or Natiko is because Include is telling the truth regarding the switch.

I retract what I said about one of them being neutral at least. One of them is definitely scum if our lover cop isn't lying. The message Ynnek got specifically says scum.

No, it specifically says not town.
 

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
None of the two have claimed neutral yet, and we're 15 minutes from the ITA phase. So either one is scum or a neutral with a role thats very anti-town, otherwise they'd have claimed already I suspect.
 
None of the two have claimed neutral yet, and we're 15 minutes from the ITA phase. So either one is scum or a neutral with a role thats very anti-town, otherwise they'd have claimed already I suspect.

Include claimed green check earlier. Which is specifically claiming Town since red check could be neutral or scum.
 

Stantastic

Our Badminton Stanpion
I scum read Nat more than include atm.
Why are you so sure delaying this a day and/or killing include over nat works better?
literally in no way have i said im sure about this idea, i even started the proposition like this:
Actually, this is probably never going to work, but we could just like, lynch niether of them?
i just think its a course of action that should at least be properly considered, and if iv had to push it more than i really care for it its because yall are so damn ready to dismiss it immediately because yall some blood thirsty motherfuckers.

you really like to try and twist whatever you can into some kinda underhanded insinuation dontcha?

was looking over teh ace game. i mistakingly joked that I was missing some words from the Ascetic cop name. Turns out I was lol

Xam was Neutral Ascetic One-Shot Bulletproof Serial Killer and Alignment Cop

LOOL

please never mention this in my presence ever again.
*shudders*

I did indeed win a 1-shot Track from the event.
and i was even a 1-shot!
My oh my melon if you keep this up i may start to get the wrong impression here.

Are you buying me dinner after all this is over or would you rather eat your words now?
:fire: :fire: :fire: :fire: :fire:

So.. can it talk?
of course it can talk, it just doesnt have anything to say.
 
The murkier things around the red check get, the more tempting it is to leave Include alive. Although I think the play here is to lynch or kill Include later in the day; even if she is town surely there are still scum players able to roleblock her, rendering confirmation unlikely. Include and Natiko are in similar spaces in my head in terms of reads, but Natiko's version requires less of a leap so I'm inclined to side with Natiko anyway. Of course that leads into the possibility that BladeSymphony has caused the situation and both Include and Natiko are telling the truth. I wouldn't be keen to go down that particular line without some more info coming to light first as it is rather insane and quite a stretch.
 

Stantastic

Our Badminton Stanpion
Y'know if it was anyone saying exactly what Include is saying i'd already have a vote on em, but damn it its honing in on the exact facet of how iv seen Include act as town in previous games thats giving me such pause.
The resolutely obstinate 'fuck you im right' attitude, just disregarding what literally anyone else says because include knows best.
seen it a bunch before and got the receiving end full blast of it in HvV, its frustrating as hell but i cant really buy that include is faking it this well.

well hopefully itll be solved in the coming minutes.
Its 4 fucking AM but hey the ITAs start like now and i really dont wanna miss these like last days so I GUESS IM GONNA STAY BE UP YAY FUCKING ME.

i think im at the point where im about to start becoming increasingly vulgar.

i just want you all to know that i do not apologise for this.
 

Swamped

Dazzling Mafia Queen
Seriously?

The day phase I mention you as a scum candidate and point out your weak presence you decide you have to shoot me? What's so horrible about my arguments that I deserve to be killed, huh?

Wait you did where

I'm glad people are finally talking about me. Felt a bit lonely
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Idle thought:
thinking back to Febe's initial joke vote on Include, if she does flip scum, we maybe look at Brazil. Early votes adjacent to scum can so often be soft bus votes so later there's a record of voting on a teammate. Not a huge lead, but just something to put out there, especially in this game with all the bussing.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Going to start the ITA in a few minutes but first

PLEASE STANDBY
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
@Stuart444 has been killed

Welcome Stuart444,

You are Quicksilver. True Identity Pietro Maximoff.

Your role is Town Secret Admirer. Each night, you may use the command CHECK: <playername> to check the alignment of another player in the game. You don’t care about the actual results though, this is all to impress your one true love. The results of your investigation will never go to you, instead going to the heartthrob you are trying to impress. Should they ever die, you will become vanilla town.

You win when all threats to town are eliminated.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
And now ITA PHASE STARTS

I’m on mobile at work so be patient with me on results
 

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
Include or Natiko scum/neutral confirmed with that death.

Bye Stuart, you did well!
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Since I put my idea forward earlier, I'm going to have to follow through with this and stand by my thinking. If I'm wrong, I'll gladly eat my words - although unless someone's boosted me, I wouldn't hold my breath for anything happening:

PRE-TYPED SHOT: Extreme Tactician

Also, RIP Stuart.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Unless Include pops back up there's another scum present currently. Something to keep in mind after all these bullets fly and bodies drop.
 
Top Bottom