Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

Brazil

Brazil

So it doesn't get lost in the last page.

Brazil said:
And you're right, Kawl. Even if I think a scenario in which town!Kalor flips out and tries to be the hero is likely, the ideal town move for him would've still been to follow through and eliminate the three players people have suspicions of, as opposed to shooting someone else no one is suspicious of simply because he could.

Considering the rest of the players we have,

rac - Someone with a confirmed power that we're all 99% sure is not scum.
Ynnek - Confirmed townie.
Kawl - Green-checked with someone else already flipped as scum godfather.
LuxCommander - Trusted player with confirmed actions and role/motivations for actions that fit with a townie's.
Fandorin - Trusted player who was shot by Coolest this very phase.
Poltergust - The player who killed LP.
oreo - ITA immune.

Shooting me was actually the only possible "wrong move" scum!Kalor could've possibly been able to justify.
Click to expand...

I'm a little bothered by oreo not showing up at all during the ITA, though. Like he doesn't want any of it.
 
LuxCommander

LuxCommander

Bro.
Dang it, can't believe I missed ITAs again... Ended up working through lunch, sorry guys. Would have probably shot at Kalor. Speaking of Kalor, shooting Brazil? Not a good look.

VOTE:Kalor

Leaving that there for now.
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

==== DAY 6 VOTES ====
Day Start
kalor (3 votes)
brazil - #7751 #8063
kawl - #8090
brazil - #8101
luxcommander - #8103
oreomunsta (1 votes)
zubz - #7644 #7684
poltergust - #7988
brazil - #8076 #8101
geno (0 votes)
rac - #7646 #7726
zubz (0 votes)
kalor - #7635 #7940
poltergust - #7682 #7988
faircure (0 votes)
brazil - #8063 #8076
coolestspot (0 votes)
geno - #7640 #7727
Post Counts:
brazil: 76 kalor: 70 rac: 55 poltergust: 51 kawl: 50 fandorin: 49 sorian: 36 coolestspot: 20 faircure: 17 oreomunsta: 17 zubz: 15 luxcommander: 7 ynnek7: 4 geno: 3 grizzly: 3
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!

MAJORITY IS 5
 
Brazil

Brazil

Upon further reflection, the last scum, be it Kalor or someone else, probably felt even worse than I did when the shot was blocked.

Silver lining.
 
Fandorin

Fandorin

I’m kinda lost on reading Kalor at this point. Earlier I thought he was playing like a bit like flustered scum, his shot at Blarg was bad and his defense felt too deflective to me. Brazil argued that was not the case and I kinda disarmed myself about it after Extreme appeared as a viable lynch candidate.

His shot at Brazil doesn’t make sense as scum; no way he is getting out of this. I even thought rac would shoot him dead right after it.

I suppose it might make sense if he’s actually not the last scum member and just wanted to kill Brazil for outing him, but that’s still weird, since he could’ve just shot rac to secure his lynch and give his team another day in the game.
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Fandorin said:
I’m kinda lost on reading Kalor at this point. Earlier I thought he was playing like a bit like flustered scum, his shot at Blarg was bad and his defense felt too deflective to me. Brazil argued that was not the case and I kinda disarmed myself about it after Extreme appeared as a viable lynch candidate.

His shot at Brazil doesn’t make sense as scum; no way he is getting out of this. I even thought rac would shoot him dead right after it.

I suppose it might make sense if he’s actually not the last scum member and just wanted to kill Brazil for outing him, but that’s still weird, since he could’ve just shot rac to secure his lynch and give his team another day in the game.
Click to expand...
What was going to happen if kalor shot Faircure like we had planned?
 
Fandorin

Fandorin

What really got on my mind now though is that I’m against an oreo lynch.

His alignment is still pretty questionable, but his delay role has been confirmed by Lux. If he’s actually town, scum can’t risk leaving him alive since he can delay the night kill and completely out the remaining scum, especially if we have only one left at this point.

Between both lynches, I lean over Kalor’s.
 
Fandorin

Fandorin

Kawl said:
What was going to happen if kalor shot Faircure like we had planned?
Click to expand...

rac would’ve shot him.

Kawl said:
“No way is he getting out of this”

As you talk yourself into letting him get out of this...
Click to expand...

You feel that I’m defending him? The only other lynch available at this point is oreo’s and I’m not feeling it.

I don’t see much logic in what Kalor did as scum, but he is getting lynched for this.
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Fandorin said:
rac would’ve shot him.



You feel that I’m defending him? The only other lynch available at this point is oreo’s and I’m not feeling it.

I don’t see much logic in what Kalor did as scum, but he is getting lynched for this.
Click to expand...
Possibly getting out of a lynch sure beats getting shot don’t it? It makes perfect sense as final scum. 2% chance is better than 0%
 
Brazil

Brazil

Fandorin said:
I’m kinda lost on reading Kalor at this point. Earlier I thought he was playing like a bit like flustered scum, his shot at Blarg was bad and his defense felt too deflective to me. Brazil argued that was not the case and I kinda disarmed myself about it after Extreme appeared as a viable lynch candidate.

His shot at Brazil doesn’t make sense as scum; no way he is getting out of this. I even thought rac would shoot him dead right after it.

I suppose it might make sense if he’s actually not the last scum member and just wanted to kill Brazil for outing him, but that’s still weird, since he could’ve just shot rac to secure his lynch and give his team another day in the game.
Click to expand...
If Kalor hadn’t shot at me, he’d be dead right now (if rac had shown up, I guess).
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
No one else wanting to chime in with less than 4 hours to go and just plain old mafia left to us now?
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Fandorin said:
Wasn’t rac scum reading Kalor harder than he was faircure? I was kinda surprised that he didn’t shoot Kalor instead of her.
Click to expand...
Possibly, but he has shown that he was going to follow consensus so I imagine the earlier posted list plus Brazil’s plea has him target fair as the town pick
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
And rac actually followed through on what he said regarding how he was going to use the shot unlike sketchy mcsketch kalor
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Also he comes off looking way less good than polter from the last event. He took time looking into how to play it and what not clearly going to try and ensure he won, versus polter looking to maximize the gain for the most number of people. One of those is a very individual self centered approach, as one might expect from a lone scum feeling desperate and in need of a boost from an event win.
 
Kalor

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
Kawl said:
Also he comes off looking way less good than polter from the last event. He took time looking into how to play it and what not clearly going to try and ensure he won, versus polter looking to maximize the gain for the most number of people. One of those is a very individual self centered approach, as one might expect from a lone scum feeling desperate and in need of a boost from an event win.
Click to expand...

It's easier to read it that way after the fact but in the moment when we couldn't communicate with each other in the roughly 15 minute gap, I thought we would be playing a regular game. Especially with the precedent that was set by previous events.
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Kalor said:
It's easier to read it that way after the fact but in the moment when we couldn't communicate with each other in the roughly 15 minute gap, I thought we would be playing a regular game. Especially with the precedent that was set by previous events.
Click to expand...
Sure sure that’s somewhat reasonable. But it’s just the third thing that makes me go hmmmmmm about you now in the past two days.
 
Kalor

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
Probably shouldn't hammer until the rest of the game checks in. Whatever they say might be helpful for tomorrow.
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Honestly for half the cats still in the game I’m just assuming there won’t be anything else to say at all
 
Brazil

Brazil

Poltergust said:
No one has agreed to my idea of a mass claim. With so few unclaimed roles, though, I guess it doesn't matter now.

I'm Wolverine, Town Death Faker. I can send a command during the day phase to fake my death until the next day phase, where I'll return alive. During the time I'm "dead", I cannot post or be targeted by any actions. I can only do this once and cannot do it during any ITA phases.

I'd be glad to prove it to you guys for tonight. If someone dies tonight then it'll prove it's a town role (assuming we have only one more scum left).

And no, I don't know why this is a town role. It pretty much only benefits me and puts a lot of pressure on me to prove my self worth in order to even justify using it.
Click to expand...
 
Brazil

Brazil

Also, if we're still in here tomorrow, for Christ's sake think before you vote. Don't be that guy that causes a mislynch literally 1 minute into the phase.
 
Ynnek7

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
Only use I can think of for a power like that would be to fake your death if people were talking about ITAing you. Kill yourself, have them spend their shots elsewhere, then come back the next day. Only now to an even more suspicious and annoyed group with fresh shots.
 
Brazil

Brazil

What annoys the hell out of me is that I'd vote oreo out before Kalor 10 out of 10 times if Kalor hadn't fucked the shot up.

oreo didn't commit to a single ITA shot before this very phase (and he took one first at a townie).
oreo gave Kalor shit for something scum!LP also did, while completely ignoring LP.
oreo left a vote on Splinter during the TD - it's bizarre to me that we don't know of a single scum who left a vote there for easy town cred later out of a group of 12+.
oreo then skipped three phases-worth of voting to only show back up when over half the scum team had died.
oreo has a power with negative town utility.
oreo has admitted to using his power to the detriment of town twice.
 
Kalor

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
That sounds like 5 points against Oreo when there's only like 3 against me. I know who I'd lynch.
 
Ynnek7

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
I would be good with either a Kalor or oreo lynch.

Oreo didn't even take the shot until it was confirmed that zubz had been hit. (Granted, both his and Sorian's post are at the same timestamp for me, he may have been refreshing the thread and posting once he saw the confirmation)

Maybe theres something he's hiding about his shots?
 
Brazil

Brazil

If you're really town, redeem yourself, Kalor. Put up the best defense ever, let's lynch oreo today and sleep soundly with our minds clear.
 
Poltergust

Poltergust

Hey, I was sleeping until now. :<

Welp, we only managed to accomplish one thing this last ITA phase. That sucks.

As for me doing my death thing, I guess I might as well now. Starting tomorrow I'll basically be a vanilla townie, but hopefully there won't be a tomorrow. I trust you guys with this vote.
 
Poltergust

Poltergust

Oh yeah, one more detail about my role that came from higher up: I can't use it if it'd end the game, meaning it's useless in LYLO situations. So... better use it now before it's too late.
 
Kalor

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
I'm not even sure what I could defend myself with at this point. I don't have a compelling case against Oreo beyond whats already been said such as her throwing shade at my Blarg shot and not LPs but honestly, I see how my lynch will provide clarity for later days. If you combine my Brazil shot, Blarg shot and the Sawneeks thing (which I don't personally count but obviously it's hard to take my word for it), it all adds up to make me a pretty compelling lynch. If you go a step further there's even Hom3lands weird shot against Kawl.

Of course there's points in my favour such as my shot on LP and the fact that LP shot Blarg after I did and flipped scum. I'm sure there's other stuff but honestly, this whole game blurs together at this point.

Obviously there's the thing of "Oh hey, the game won't end if you lynch me" but again, there's no way of knowing that without my lynch.
 
Brazil

Brazil

Poltergust said:
Oh yeah, one more detail about my role that came from higher up: I can't use it if it'd end the game, meaning it's useless in LYLO situations. So... better use it now before it's too late.
Click to expand...
This is a very interesting detail. We're very far from LyLo if there's just one scum left. However, if there's still two...
 
Brazil

Brazil

Kalor said:
I'm not even sure what I could defend myself with at this point. I don't have a compelling case against Oreo beyond whats already been said such as her throwing shade at my Blarg shot and not LPs but honestly, I see how my lynch will provide clarity for later days. If you combine my Brazil shot, Blarg shot and the Sawneeks thing (which I don't personally count but obviously it's hard to take my word for it), it all adds up to make me a pretty compelling lynch. If you go a step further there's even Hom3lands weird shot against Kawl.

Of course there's points in my favour such as my shot on LP and the fact that LP shot Blarg after I did and flipped scum. I'm sure there's other stuff but honestly, this whole game blurs together at this point.

Obviously there's the thing of "Oh hey, the game won't end if you lynch me" but again, there's no way of knowing that without my lynch.
Click to expand...
Yesterday you remembered that Coolest sacrificed his powers in that event, but now you say the whole game blurs together? Come on :/

What does LP shooting Blarg tells us about you?

And why did you seem to immediately the shot at me after taking it? You had enough conviction about it to type that long post beforehand.
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Brazil said:
This is a very interesting detail. We're very far from LyLo if there's just one scum left. However, if there's still two...
Click to expand...

Mislynch puts us at 8, so if two kills for whatever reason then 6, mislynch, 5, 2 more kills puts us at 3? So could be closer than it feels
 
Kalor

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
Brazil said:
Yesterday you remembered that Coolest sacrificed his powers in that event, but now you say the whole game blurs together? Come on :/

What does LP shooting Blarg tells us about you?

And why did you seem to immediately the shot at me after taking it? You had enough conviction about it to type that long post beforehand.
Click to expand...

Some details stick out more than others, also the fact that I've got a bunch of notes to keep track of small details like that. I can't say I've spend much time thinking about points that make me look good.

LP shooting Blarg theoretically clears me. That is if you think the idea of two scum shooting Blarg to be unlikely. It felt like LP saw my vote as an opportunity to hop on and potentially get away with a shot without much suspicion, which they would want when Blarg could give out armour.

I was doubting myself the whole time when I was thinking about taking the shot. I didn't regret it fully until I saw that you survived because I knew that I had wasted a shot that could have helped out.
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Kalor said:
Some details stick out more than others, also the fact that I've got a bunch of notes to keep track of small details like that. I can't say I've spend much time thinking about points that make me look good.

LP shooting Blarg theoretically clears me. That is if you think the idea of two scum shooting Blarg to be unlikely. It felt like LP saw my vote as an opportunity to hop on and potentially get away with a shot without much suspicion, which they would want when Blarg could give out armour.

I was doubting myself the whole time when I was thinking about taking the shot. I didn't regret it fully until I saw that you survived because I knew that I had wasted a shot that could have helped out.
Click to expand...
Next time listen to those doubts
 
Kalor

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
ET really making a strong case to lynch me. Maybe he tied the two of us together and said to ignore it because singling out one person as suspicious just invites the idea of having double standards.
 
rac

rac

whatever
Fandorin said:
since he could’ve just shot rac to secure his lynch and give his team another day in the game.
Click to expand...
i was quickly copy and pasting someone's command and saw brazil going crazy about shooting fandorin didn't even know what kalor did
 
Brazil

Brazil

ET's initial reaction to that ITA Phase was "Yeah, LP and Kalor, but what about Geno and Blarg?".

Then when ET was hit, he quickly took a shot at Kalor (15%) and seemingly cut his losses with the post above.

Extreme Tactician said:
Oh we posting Mafia reads?

Kalor
Zubz
LuxCommander

Seriously, that dude has barely appeared in this game.
Click to expand...

Extreme Tactician said:
I would vote for LuxCommander, but it seems that Zubz is even more suspicious. Lux at leat chimed in every now and then was more consistent. Zubz seems to be just ignoring what he posts.

VOTE: Zubz
Click to expand...
And then when the vote leads are himself and Kalor, he votes Zubz instead and Kalor disappears from his "mafia reads".
 
Brazil

Brazil

But then again, where's oreo? Jesus.

The more time passes, the more suspicious I grow of both. Maybe that really is our duo.
 
Brazil

Brazil

giphy.gif


Suffering alone

One of these days I'll get offed early on, and then I'll be able to watch the mess from afar

And in that day

I will be a happy man
 
Sorian

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
==== DAY 6 VOTES ====
Day Start

kalor (3 votes)
brazil - #7751 #8063
kawl - #8090
brazil - #8101
luxcommander - #8103

oreomunsta (1 votes)
zubz - #7644 #7684
brazil - #8076 #8101
kalor - #8108

geno (0 votes)
rac - #7646 #7726

zubz (0 votes)
kalor - #7635 #7940
poltergust - #7682 #7988

faircure (0 votes)
brazil - #8063 #8076

coolestspot (0 votes)
geno - #7640 #7727

Post Counts:
brazil: 101 kalor: 79 kawl: 67 rac: 56 fandorin: 55 poltergust: 53 sorian: 38 coolestspot: 20 faircure: 17 oreomunsta: 17 zubz: 15 luxcommander: 7 ynnek7: 6 geno: 3 grizzly: 3 stuart444: 1

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!

Majority is 5

Day ends in:
pur_1531436400.png
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
It’s simple we just lynch kalor.

And go quietly into the night one way or the other. Don’t get so worked up.

Is only game.
 
Fandorin

Fandorin

The shot surprisingly wasn’t that bad. Kalor reasoning is pretty thin but I totally get the appeal of shitty town gambits, the power of a kill might have gone over his head.

But fact is that there is way too many WIFOMS in here for us to keep Kalor around. Like Kawl said, if he’s town he’s too far gone to be believed. On retrospect I think that the Sawneeks mix up with melon is the ugliest thing on his record.

These weird defense posts from Extreme aggravate it too. I think that’s the only instance I can remember of him defending someone other than himself, and we know how confusing that one ended up being.
 
Brazil

Brazil

Fandorin said:
The shot surprisingly wasn’t that bad. Kalor reasoning is pretty thin but I totally get the appeal of shitty town gambits, the power of a kill might have gone over his head.

But fact is that there is way too many WIFOMS in here for us to keep Kalor around. Like Kawl said, if he’s town he’s too far gone to be believed. On retrospect I think that the Sawneeks mix up with melon is the ugliest thing on his record.

These weird defense posts from Extreme aggravate it too. I think that’s the only instance I can remember of him defending someone other than himself, and we know how confusing that one ended up being.
Click to expand...
The weird thing with those posts is that he threw some shade at Kalor at first, but then did a 180º. I can see that being because Kalor’s his mate, or because he’s not. As you said, full-on WIFOM.
 
Brazil

Brazil

oreomunsta said:
Sooo... the fact that I did take a shot at Kalor in this previous ITA doesn't matter?

As for LP, I did constantly suggest at the beginning of the game to target low posters. Rynam and LP were in that group, maybe a few other scum. I woudn't go and pick out a large group with several scummies in there with no regard to them in specific. I didn't make mention of LP's flip, because it wasn't that surprising to me, like the Natiko flip was, for example
Click to expand...
Kalor has said things that make sense, while oreo’s stuff is just bad all around.
 
Sorian

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
==== DAY 6 VOTES ====
Day Start

kalor (3 votes)
brazil - #7751 #8063
kawl - #8090
brazil - #8101 #8185
luxcommander - #8103
fandorin - #8184

oreomunsta (2 votes)
zubz - #7644 #7684
brazil - #8076 #8101
kalor - #8108
rac - #8181

zubz (1 votes)
kalor - #7635 #7940
poltergust - #7682

geno (0 votes)
rac - #7646 #7726

faircure (0 votes)
brazil - #8063 #8076

coolestspot (0 votes)
geno - #7640 #7727

Post Counts:
brazil: 109 kalor: 81 kawl: 68 fandorin: 59 rac: 57 poltergust: 53 sorian: 39 coolestspot: 20 faircure: 17 oreomunsta: 17 zubz: 15 luxcommander: 7 ynnek7: 6 geno: 3 grizzly: 3 stuart444: 1

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Sorian

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Kalor

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
It'd be nice if more people were here instead of someone like Lux just leaving a vote with a simple excuse and leaving. People keep doing that in this game.
 
Sorian

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Final Vote Count:
==== DAY 6 VOTES ====
Day Start - Day End

kalor (4 votes)
brazil - #7751 #8063
kawl - #8090
brazil - #8101 #8185
luxcommander - #8103
fandorin - #8184
brazil - #8194

oreomunsta (2 votes)
zubz - #7644 #7684
brazil - #8076 #8101
kalor - #8108
rac - #8181
brazil - #8190 #8194

geno (0 votes)
rac - #7646 #7726

faircure (0 votes)
brazil - #8063 #8076

coolestspot (0 votes)
geno - #7640 #7727

Post Counts:
brazil: 112 kalor: 82 kawl: 68 fandorin: 61 rac: 57 poltergust: 53 sorian: 42 coolestspot: 20 faircure: 17 oreomunsta: 17 zubz: 15 luxcommander: 7 ynnek7: 6 geno: 3 grizzly: 3 stuart444: 1

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Sorian

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
The game was coming to a close soon and Thanos stood above the arena, looking down on the last of Earth's heroes.

They had surrounded Danny Rand now, slowly closing in for the kill. No matter how hard he tried, the Iron Fist would not come to him anymore. Not a trick from Thanos this time, but just a failure on his own part, like usual.

Watching the scene unfold, a hint of emotion crossed Thanos' face. Frustration. Anger. Sadness. And as it did, the cosmic cube in his hand radiated blue once more, different this time. While the edges glowed, it seemed the center had stayed silent....

Kalor has died

Welcome Kalor,

You are Iron Fist. True Identity Danny Rand.

Your role is Mafia Role Claim Vigilante. You may use the command KILL:<playername> once per night phase. In addition to the kill command, you must provide the name of the player’s role (mechanical role, not flavor role) and the post number where the player claimed. If the player has no protection and the claim is found to be correct, the player will be killed.

You may also use the command KILL:<playername> once per night to execute the mafia factional kill. Your target will be killed assuming they have no form of protection. You may use both your individual ability and the factional ability in the same night, if applicable.

You win when the mafia team outnumbers all other players.
Click to expand...

Starting in the next day phase, we will be moving to a 24/24 hour cycle

Night 6 ends in:
pur_1531522800.png


Actions due to me an hour before time.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom