Yeah that's probably true. Also now that we are learning a lot more about all the flavors in the game, I'm really wondering if town really needs two vig's even if one is basically an avenger only.Pearl as a Bodyguard, Steven as a Doctor maybe? That's a lot of protection roles though so the last scum must have a strongshot
Mainly I'm wondering if he somehow knows about us and that we are town so he's trying to find other reasons to say as much without it being weird.One thing that made me feel weird about neon today though was that he gave the green check on you (which could have actually happened), and he gave me a big positive town read on saying he agreed with my theory about Z-Beat.
It feels almost like he is going out of his way to say we are town and I wonder if there's something up with that.
Mainly I'm wondering if he somehow knows about us and that we are town so he's trying to find other reasons to say as much without it being weird.
I actually not that worried. I was just speculating that he knows about us but is also town.I wouldn't worry about that. It's possible that the green check wasn't real, but they just picked someone that they were hoping to pocket in that case, and I doubt they know about our role. If scum knew, they'd want to kill us as early as possible to knock out two town at once.
Yeah, whoever it is going to be trying to pull a really ballsy move I assume.It's definitely possible that there's 2 scum left, but I'm assuming there's only 1 right now. And whoever it is must be in a tight spot with 2 deathless nights and 3 scum down
Very true.I wouldn't worry about Z-beat to be honest. He helped start that train on Oreo and if he was just looking for a self-preservation angle he could have voted for Neon and kept a teammate alive.
Well at least the catching up aint too bad yet.
Xodus's claim is weird, i was thinking i would wait to see if it turns out to be more complicated via X-shots or whatever but the fact hes throwing it out today willy nilly makes that seem unlikely. eh, will look more into em later.
Weemad feels...off?
Zeke is still seeing sinister intent in every shadow, so good to know that hasn't changed.
Light theme is for cowards.
I didnt suspect Zeke?
i brought up hoe he is prone to seeing conspiracy where there isnt any, but thats cartainly NAI for him.
honestly i would be more worried if he wasn't doing it, tho i cant remember playing any games with him as scum so im not sure if he can fake it well or not.
So yeah, NAI.
Man i just did a reread on Zeke as i had been getting odd vibes from him, and iv came out with like nothing useful.
Best i could see is that he was (maybe still is it just kinda stopped coming up) on Chuggs calling him frustrating at the start of the game and reacted indignantly. Pretty standard reaction for him but i cant help but wonder if its still coloring his read.
And the recent drill Exo on the particulars of his claim went into excess given that so much of it was just having Exo repeat the exact same explanation hes said multiple times now, but again its pretty standards behavior for him.
theres decent play there but all well within his capacity to fake.
Dear god that STANDBY happened while i was typing this and i thought we were gonna see more bodies, but this is actually kinda nice.
Welp its well past 3am so imma be heading off now.
Looks like things are heading Oreos way atm, i cant say im against that in any real way, been a total blindspot for me but the arguments others have been putting down seem adequate i guess. Imma leave my vote on Zeke in the hopes things stay interesting.
Party on friends.
Sorry for the absense, kinda swamped at work today so took a while to catch up.
Well first of all im pleasantly surprised my vote on Zeke lead to not only a lunch but a scum flip to, clealy everyone that joined on that train are both wise and handsome.
Tho i do think your giving me a bit too much town cred there, as i voted when there was relatively little heat on him and no (proper) votes, especially given how i hadnt really made a case against him either.
That said since its me imma just take the credit anyway thankyouverymuch.
I definitely agree with you on nin. One aspect of his inconsistency that really stood out even before zekes flip that just looks even worse now is how twice nin listed two people that he would be open swaping his vote to. I cant remember all the names, nor do i have the time rn to go find and quote them, but i do remember that both times the alternatives were completely different with no reasoning given, and the first time zeke was listed as one, but the second time he was not.
Hes up there but probably not. I finally looked back at dubss claim an behaviour last night and found things at least checked out. Theres syill room for doubt there but for now im cool with it.
I would also use it on malus,
this whole semi-counter on exo (whose claim and shit i also checked out before and felt pretty good on) just smells super fishy atm, and i was hardly thinking highly of WSD before the replacement, so malus coming in with it hot out the gates sure dont help.
Hes up there but probably not. I finally looked back at dubss claim an behaviour last night and found things at least checked out. Theres syill room for doubt there but for now im cool with it.
I would also use it on malus,
this whole semi-counter on exo (whose claim and shit i also checked out before and felt pretty good on) just smells super fishy atm, and i was hardly thinking highly of WSD before the replacement, so malus coming in with it hot out the gates sure dont help.
Put me down for this also,
Reki is one of my better town leads rn so i think i trust there jusgment over the general publics.
Malus is the easiest choice but wouldnt mind a more wild cardish option. Honestly im pretty down for any pick.
So its 3am, i cant keep waiting.
Not gonna lie, did not give this game half the attention i should have this day, I blame Shadowbringers and my totally lack of self-discipline.
Im not against Z-Beat lunch by any means, but imma put my vote here where im also totally cool with a lynch, because things being closer is both more fun and insightful.
vote: malus
call me lazy, its true.
Also it'd be weird to pick Zeke over oreo since oreo was just a goon and Zeke was a roleblocker which is very handy role against town.
You bet!
lokiduck - town read. I find them to be generally sensible about questions, and feel like they are scumhunting
NeonBorealis - null. They have a good bit of activity, but I don't find myself reading town or scum on them
EzekelRAGE - slight town read. Not always sure what they're aiming for, but don't read it as anti-town
Sawneeks - slight scum read. A scum Sawn would be some of the worst news for town, so I'm generally wary of Sawn out of respect o7
Stantastic - null. They've posted about as much as I have... and I'm near the bottom of the post list lol
TheChuggernaut - slight town read. Though I don't agree with their decisions, I get the feeling that they are looking for scum
nin - null. Nin's posting a lot, but feeling like their cards are held close to their chest. Where's my ninsanity?
Z-Beat - slight scum read. I find them to be focusing way too much on flavors to be a solution to the game, where I think we can only use them to guesstimate powers
exodus - town read. More likely to me that their power demonstrations are town, rather than scum
KetKat - slight town. Think that they do some good prodding and questioning. Don't feel like they take much of a stance on things, though
oreomunsta - wants to help town get the W, but seeing a bad vote build up on them :(
Queen Kong - null. I can appreciate the "new player" vibe, but you're being mentored. That angle could be used dangerously between you and cabot
WhySoDevious - slight scum read. Anyone should be suspicious of low posters. I want to know - WWWSDD? What Would WSD Do?
B-Dubs - town read. like exo, B-Dubs power demo seems more town than scum to me
Reki - null. Not really sure what to make of their activity, to be honest. This read is the most likely to change, I feel
So, I'm going to post my list in a before-after format, where the divide is caused by the EoD madness
lokiduck - town read -> town read. hasn't changeed much, but I'm not appreciating the "oreo cooould be town. if that's the case, my bad, dawg" angle >:[
NeonBorealis - null -> null. Not much of a change
EzekelRAGE - slight town read -> total scum. I did not read Zeke correctly here :(
Sawneeks - slight scum read -> slight scum. No change here
Stantastic - null -> null. No change here
TheChuggernaut - slight town read -> null. I'm seeing vote skipping happening here
nin - null -> scum. WSD and nin had some interactions here that read to me like scum helping each other, then busing each other
Z-Beat - slight scum read -> slight scum read. No change here
exodus - town read -> town read. No change here
KetKat - slight town -> null. Prodding around, but not really committing gives me a less positive read
oreomunsta - wants to help town get the W - no change here
Queen Kong - null -> null. No change here
WhySoDevious - slight scum read -> scum. I think I was watching nin and WSD interacting in such a way that made me really suspect
B-Dubs - town read -> town read. No change here
Reki - null -> slight town. The EoD activity gave me a more favorable look on them
@Z-
Okay, so estimate a scum team of 5 or so. Based on what you know of SU, what's a list of possible villains, and what powers could they possibly do?
I wonder if this could give us an idea of what we might be up against. I don't think people claiming flavors is useful, since people can always lie about them, but maybe estimating roles can give some insight into the role madness
That's kind of what I've been thinking too. It's pretty standard to not claim how many shots you have so you can bait scum.I don't think bdubs has another shot if he's town. He used that first one pretty quickly
Okay thanks. I'll edit my post for the start of the day then.No shot tonight, ladies.
That is true :o Maybe the reason he wanted everyone to reveal is because if he had revealed the stuff about Z-Beat too early, the day would turbo but scum wouldn't know all the flavors yet,Something that's worth noting from Stan is that he heavily hinted that his power would help reveal scum through flavor only, but he wasn't willing to give us results until we all revealed what our flavor was. The people that he had checked had already revealed their flavors before he asked for this mass claim as well, so it makes me wonder what he was fishing for