Ok, honestly I really don't have the energy to read through this whole day and pull out a bunch of quotes and start nitpicking over posts people made. Not sure how much help that would be anyways.
I think most of my thoughts are going to come from EoD, so I'm going to start from when I woke up this morning and just reread all of that to EoD and just make some notes here and there on different players, and then use that to make a read list next.
------------------------
Tough for me to get a read on Fireblend here. Yeah, he could be Scum, but why really? Because he thought Saenima was Scum? So did I. So did Weemad. I suppose his lack of effort for anything else seems a bit suspect maybe, he mentioned Ynnek plenty of times but was definitely all in on Sae once that became a reality. Made sure to defend himself hard against Weemad, even though she had already said he was her second choice and she wanted Sae first. He'd pop in at times during the lead up to EoD like a shadow lurker too, and I hate shadow lurkers. Sae was insistent that he was Scum. Doesn't mean he has to be, but we can't let him get it away with it if he is lol.
Ynnek... I don't know if I'll be able to last in this game much longer without seeing the Ynnek flip lol. Really should have just believed myself when I was talking to you and said that he was the better choice to do first. Dude is just slipping away from each of these EoDs now and why? Because we all talk ourselves in to some other target instead while he just twiddles his thumbs and tells us he'll vote self preservation if he has to. LP is right, the guy plays like him lol.
Seeing CaptainNuevo as pretty scummy here. You are right that it did seem like he was engaging in a bit of breadcrumbing though, not fully sure what to make of that, but I don't want it to completely color my perception of him. He immediately seemed into the claim from Saenima, bought it and switched his vote over to FB, which is interesting to me. Then, as soon as it became apparent that there was suspicion on Sae's claim, he swapped it back over there and goes "Oh, nvm, you are sus here Sae..."
Z-Beat is a possible Scum candidate here. He pulled a similar thing as CaptainNuevo, removed his vote from Sae after the claim, and then decided he was ok with putting it back once others, like myself, casted doubt on the claim. He's also hard town reading me, which isn't that strange since a lot of people do... but I see you Z-Beat lol. (We're friends outside the game)
LP is a mystery. I liked his read list. Honestly, I think his EoD voting behavior on both days could totally be seen as Scum WIFOM, especially considering we've only taken out Town so far, and therefore I think it's NAI. "He's made some good points." Seriously though, I am actually not thinking too many scummy thoughts about LP here after the first couple days, which is gross. Null to slight Town lean.
Getting some newbie-town vibes from Vincent, same kind of stuff I started picking up on in the GTA Costume game where he was Town, after starting off with lean scum feels on him. I might need to ISO him though, he makes some wordy posts and I sometimes forget all of what he says, but I felt like after I got him to bring his reads in, he had more of a presence and didn't feel deceptive to me really through EoD.
Reading Aeleus as pretty townish here, though I'll admit some of it is because I find myself agreeing with their reads a lot. They did have one bit that I thought was either a newbie mistake, or a bit of a perspective slip. Post #1560, they seem to fully believe our Neighbor claim here, enough to consider it confirmed information to them. That should not be the case until one of us flips for anyone but Scum (or perhaps the person who checked me last night if it was an alignment or role check.) We could be Scum together still for all they know. Still though, feeling pretty good about this Town read actually.
Kopite, not a lot of content from him, but what he does have is mainly directed at Ynnek, so the Ynnek flip would probably be helpful there. Would these two only engage with each other and scum read each other so much if they were Scum partners? I feel like that's a no, so probably not Scum/Scum here. Could still be Town/Town, but I am feeling heavy scum feels about Ynnek at this point. I just don't get those vibes from Kopite for whatever reason, could just be bias since I've played with Kopite and have never played with Ynnek though. Anyways, slight Town leans here.
WSD is a tough read, mainly Null on him. He definitely wanted Ynnek more than Sae and maintained that. Then he had the weird stuff with bringing up the Psychic role and starting to try speculating about what role Weemad had, which might just be newbie stuff, but it might have been something a bit more... devious.
FEPs, definitely still a Scum candidate. Refused to commit at EoD, kept his vote on you for the second day in a row. Seems to be looking for mega "I told you so" points after these flips, and I am not a fan of it.
I'm still leaning pretty Town on you here. Can't really think of anything that I would want to like, question you over really? Your play makes sense to me from playing with you when you were Town in the past. We were both pretty quiet in here today until EoD, but we both thought that claim smelled fishy which I think was a legit way to feel about it, so I can't really say that there was anything in here that made me suspicious of you. I think you have healthy paranoia about me since I am kind of making myself look like shit at times, but it's not making me think you have an agenda against me here.
Weemad, we know she was protected by a Doctor and that there was no kill that night. Occam's Razor say she's in a pretty good Town read category there because of that, I'd need to start reaching to find other explanations.
--------------
Ok, so trying to put my thoughts in order here.
Each section is ranked most to least, so FEPs feels more scummy than WSD, for example.
Townish Thoughts:
Weemad
Zeke
Aeleus
Slight Townish Thoughts:
Vincent
Kopite
LP
Slight Scummy Thoughts:
FEPs
Z-Beat
WSD
Scummy Thoughts:
Ynnek
Fireblend
CaptainNuevo
