Game Thread One Night Ultimate Werewolf XV.2

After B Dubs claims I will reveal middle card 2. I doubt anything B Dubs says will be relevant but just in case I'll wait.
 
I think it's 48, if it's 24 we are screwed if B Dubs doesn't show up soon. As things are now it's either Turmoil or Faddy. I'm leaning towards Faddy.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Just so we have this role claim list on the new page:

Wolves -
Minion -
Masons - Malus/LP
Apprentice Seer - Faddy / Geno
Paranormal Investigator - Fantomas
Robber - Monkey
Witch - Natiko
Troublemaker - Chuggernaut
Drunk - Dr. Worm
Insomniac - Turmoil
Revealer -
Tanner -
 

malus

#1 official chartmaker
What I believe to be true:

Me and LP are Masons
Fantomas is the PI and checked Monkey and Apopheniac. This is too elaborate of a fake claim to pull off this early in the game since it involves 3 roles.

Following from this we have:
Monkey was the Robber and Apo was the Drunk at the start.
Apo took card 1 from the center. This is probably true since he has no reason to lie about that, but it means he could still have drawn a wolf card.

Monkey claims to have robbed Natiko who claimed Witch. There are 2 possibilities with this claim:
1. Monkey robbed someone else and got a wolf card.
2. Monkey did rob Natiko.
I think that confirms Natiko as the Witch since if he believed to be robbed he could just claim wolf to get Monkey lunched. It does leave the possibility of Monkey being a Wolf though.

So Natiko is the Witch and gave the Insomniac(center 1) to Chugg.

Chugg claimed troublemaker after Natiko said he had turned him into Insomniac, so we can probably believe that claim. Which means Monkey is now the PI and Fanto the Witch or a Wolf from the first possibility of Monkeys claim.
But since Monkey didn't adjust her claim it means she wasn't a Wolf either. Further this means that Apo is now the Troublemaker.

So far we have:
Malus: Mason
Lone_Prodigy: Mason
Fantomas: Witch
Dr. Monkey: PI
theChuggernaut: Insomniac
Natiko: Robber
Apopheniac: Troublemaker

Center1: Drunk

Further claims:
Turmoil claimed Insomniac which is clearly a lie from the reasoning above.
Faddy claimed Seer having looked at Revealer (center 1) which is also clearly a lie since center 1 was Insomniac. I don't buy his update that he actually reported the wrong card.
Geno claimed Seer having looked at Center 2 (unconfirmed).
B-Dubs hasn't claimed yet.
 
I'll just say what I saw since I'm not 100% sure if the discussion time is 24 or 48h. I saw the minion card. So we have 1 less thing to worry about since nobody claimed to have interacted with that card.
 
Gah, sorry. I got caught up studying all night and just remembered.

Damn, so we're just doing mass claims then? Is that how it works?

I'm about to fuck this whole thing up because turmoil is definitely lying. As I'm apparently the insomniac.
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Gah, sorry. I got caught up studying all night and just remembered.

Damn, so we're just doing mass claims then? Is that how it works?

I'm about to fuck this whole thing up because turmoil is definitely lying. As I'm apparently the insomniac.

You were or are now?
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Because that throws a massive wrench in this puzzle. If Dubs is telling the truth that means Turmoil is lying, but also Natiko who was counter claiming Turmoil and what
 

malus

#1 official chartmaker
If any of Fantomas, Dr. Monkey, TheChuggernaut, Natiko or Apopheniac want to adjust their claim, now would be the time to do so.
 
I think Turmoil, B-Dubs and Faddy are all lying. 2 wolves and a Jester. I don't think the 2 wolves would lie about the same role, so that means 1 of the Turmoil-B-Dubs is wolf/Jester. The safest lynch is Faddy I think.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Gah, sorry. I got caught up studying all night and just remembered.

Damn, so we're just doing mass claims then? Is that how it works?

I'm about to fuck this whole thing up because turmoil is definitely lying. As I'm apparently the insomniac.
echoing malus's question here: is that what you started with or is that what you think you are now? Please clarify and offer a full claim.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
I think Turmoil, B-Dubs and Faddy are all lying. 2 wolves and a Jester. I don't think the 2 wolves would lie about the same role, so that means 1 of the Turmoil-B-Dubs is wolf/Jester. The safest lynch is Faddy I think.

This. The same claim muddies the votes a bit.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
This. The same claim muddies the votes a bit.
What do you think about Faddy vs Geno here though? I'm uncertain at this time.

Geno is being very short and matter of fact - very Geno. But not really engaging despite being a counterclaim.
Faddy is being fucking wild - pushing stuff just to push it. Feels out of character for Faddy. But could be due to a dumb mistake and stubbornness, and the stubbornness is very Faddy.

I would lean toward believing Geno here but it's a very slight edge and there are a lot of doubts.
 

malus

#1 official chartmaker
Oh shit I forgot the Jester. You are right.

I think Turmoil, B-Dubs and Faddy are all lying. 2 wolves and a Jester. I don't think the 2 wolves would lie about the same role, so that means 1 of the Turmoil-B-Dubs is wolf/Jester. The safest lynch is Faddy I think.

These quotes make me think Geno is actually a Wolf and Faddy is just a Minion.
 
What do you think about Faddy vs Geno here though? I'm uncertain at this time.

Geno is being very short and matter of fact - very Geno. But not really engaging despite being a counterclaim.
Faddy is being fucking wild - pushing stuff just to push it. Feels out of character for Faddy. But could be due to a dumb mistake and stubbornness, and the stubbornness is very Faddy.

I would lean toward believing Geno here but it's a very slight edge and there are a lot of doubts.
I don't really know how to engage more, I believe we solved the game.

These quotes make me think Geno is actually a Wolf and Faddy is just a Minion.
There's a reason I said I forgot the Jester and not also the minion. It was a breadcrumb.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I just can't see Faddy forgetting which card he looked at.
Yeah, that's sticking with me a bit too. There's room for honest mistakes. But then claiming the same mistake he'd accused Natiko of and then pushing a wild-ass conspiracy theory... that's a lot.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I'll just say what I saw since I'm not 100% sure if the discussion time is 24 or 48h. I saw the minion card. So we have 1 less thing to worry about since nobody claimed to have interacted with that card.
Makes me trust Geno a little more as if he wanted to cover for the wolf team it'd be better to claim he saw Wolf in the middle.

Gah, sorry. I got caught up studying all night and just remembered.

Damn, so we're just doing mass claims then? Is that how it works?

I'm about to fuck this whole thing up because turmoil is definitely lying. As I'm apparently the insomniac.
Full claim

I just can't see Faddy forgetting which card he looked at.
Yeah, Faddy is definitely lying. Just not sure if he's trying to seem too scummy to be voted as a Wolf or if he's just the Tanner.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
These quotes make me think Geno is actually a Wolf and Faddy is just a Minion.

I'm town. Gene is lying. He is probably not a wolf though.

Turmoil is 100% wolf. Geno is probably minion or tanner. B-Dubs is almost certainly a wolf.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
It is very convenient for Geno to claim his card is the minion because it means the bad guys he is pointing to are 2/3 wolves. If you believe him the game is easy.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
It is very convenient for Geno to claim his card is the minion because it means the bad guys he is pointing to are 2/3 wolves. If you believe him the game is easy.
Hmm, I hadn't considered that. Fair enough point.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I guess Geno did see Natiko calling me a liar before he counter claimed me. I don't know what that means though. Does he do that as wolf looking to make a fake claim? But from his perspective he doesn't know why nat is calling me a liar.

It could be my role, the revealer card or the centre card I messed up. I think more likely he is the minion just trying to cause some confusion.

I'm not sure if turmoil/dubs is wolf/wolf since both claiming the same thing is pretty lolsy but if they are just attempting to split the vote to win then I guess it works.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Just to double check - Insomniac only wakes up and sees their role if they start as Insomniac, yes?
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Just to double check - Insomniac only wakes up and sees their role if they start as Insomniac, yes?

Yes Dubs is lying... The real problem here is that if Geno is the minion then it could be 1 wolf and 1 tanner between Turmoil and Dubs.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
If there is a fourth bad guy it is chuggs who waited for the claims and picked from what was left.

If it is Dubs and Chuggs as wolves they were the last two to claim so all the town roles were out.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Ok, bear with me here, I think I have all the facts straight but correct me if I got something wrong.


So as far as I can see, there are two likely worlds we are inhabiting, one in which Faddy is the Seer and another in which Geno is the Seer. The claims from Turmoil and Dubs are irrelevant to these claims, so I'll touch on those later.

The Faddy world is where we are to believe that he told us he checked Card 1 and saw Revealer, but actually he was just mistaken and it was Card 3 that he checked, not Card 1. He only told us this after Monkey backed up Natiko's Witch claim in which (ha, pun) he told us that he checked Card 1, saw Insomniac and gave it to Chugg. This gave Nat much more credibility than Faddy at that point, so Faddy was either openly caught in his lie, or was genuinely mistaken and corrected himself.

The Geno world is where we believe that he checked Card 2 and saw that it was the Minion. Geno's claim falls between the spot where Natiko was saying that Faddy and Turmoil were lying, and Nat claims Witch with Monkey backing it up with her Robber claim.

Faddy and Turmoil.
I'm apprentice seer and looked 2. Won't say what it was for now but Faddy is lying.
I’m the Witch, and I know both of you to be lying. I saw the Insomniac under Card 1.
So I robbed Natiko and he was indeed the Witch.
Big misunderstanding. I looked at card 3.

It's kind of hard for me to believe that Faddy was genuinely mistaken here honestly, he's a very good player in general, and he's definitely very good at ONUW after seeing him last game. I could see a world where Faddy the Wolf decides he's going to go for an early gambit, using info from the thread, like the fact that there was no Reveal at day start, to put together a fake claim and see where it went. He got caught quick because of Natiko and Monkey, so he wasn't able to keep pushing against Nat, but he thought fast and decided to just say "Oops, wrong card" and continue on with his claim like nothing happened.

Since no one else interacted with Card 3, and there was no Reveal, it's entirely possible that Card 3 is the Revealer, but that doesn't mean that Faddy actually knew that or has been being honest with us this whole time.

At this moment, I would choose to believe Geno over Faddy for the Seer claims I think.

--------------

Now, as for Turmoil and Dubs:

Natiko claimed Witch, saw Insomniac under Card 1, and gave it to Chugg. Neither of these two started as the Insomniac if we are believing Natiko and I think it's almost impossible for me to believe that Nat is lying here. I know that Monkey was the Robber, and she claims to have robbed Nat of the Witch role, so that backs up his original claim quite a bit.

So where does that leave the two "Insomniacs" then? I would guess one of them is the Tanner, leaning towards Turmoil, and then the other is the second Wolf, which I'm leaning towards B-Dubs for that.

--------------

So in conclusion, this is where I'm at for how the roles were distributed originally, and then how they wound up after the Night Actions.

START OF GAME:
Wolves - Faddy and B-Dubs
Masons - Malus and LP
Apprentice Seer - Geno
Paranormal Investigator - Fantomas
Robber - Monkey
Witch - Natiko
Troublemaker - Chuggernaut
Drunk - Dr. Worm
Tanner - Turmoil

Center Card 1 - Insomniac
Center Card 2 - Minion
Center Card 3 - Revealer

AFTER NIGHT ACTIONS:

Wolves - Faddy and B-Dubs
Masons - Malus and LP
Apprentice Seer - Geno
Paranormal Investigator - Monkey
Robber - Natiko
Witch - Fantomas
Troublemaker - Dr. Worm
Insomniac - Chuggernaut
Tanner - Turmoil

Center Card 1 - Drunk
Center Card 2 - Minion
Center Card 3 - Revealer
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Well I was hoping B-Dubs would full claim first to see what he'd say, but I'm honestly just getting impatient. I lied about one thing - I did check Card 1 and see Insomniac, but I switched it with B-Dubs. I wanted to pick someone that I didn't think would be targeted by multiple people. B-Dubs is the Insomniac and Dr. Worm is now ??? - whatever B-Dubs original role was. When Faddy pushed me to reveal my target I decided to pick someone that hadn't claimed to see if it would have any impact on what they revealed and there weren't a lot of choices left.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Well I was hoping B-Dubs would full claim first to see what he'd say, but I'm honestly just getting impatient. I lied about one thing - I did check Card 1 and see Insomniac, but I switched it with B-Dubs. I wanted to pick someone that I didn't think would be targeted by multiple people. B-Dubs is the Insomniac and Dr. Worm is now ??? - whatever B-Dubs original role was. When Faddy pushed me to reveal my target I decided to pick someone that hadn't claimed to see if it would have any impact on what they revealed and there weren't a lot of choices left.
Ok, so because Dubs came out and claimed Insomniac, he wouldn't have known his role switched overnight, right? Meaning he was probably a Wolf or Tanner and that went to Card 1 which Worm picked up as the Drunk.

My instincts still tell me that with the way Faddy was claiming, I would still put him in the Wolf category if I'm believing Geno over him.

Turmoil came out hot with that Insomniac claim, which almost felt like he wanted to get countered, which makes me lean Tanner.

B-Dubs I still think was a Wolf, but yeah, you swapped him to Insomniac so that went to Card 1 which our Drunk picked up.

That would mean, I would look at it like this now:

AFTER NIGHT ACTIONS:
Wolves - Faddy and Dr. Worm
Masons - Malus and LP
Apprentice Seer - Geno
Paranormal Investigator - Monkey
Robber - Natiko
Witch - Fantomas
Troublemaker - Chuggernaut
Insomniac - B-Dubs
Tanner - Turmoil

Center Card 1 - Drunk
Center Card 2 - Minion
Center Card 3 - Revealer

Does that make sense?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Natiko gave a card to Chuggs so after night actions, Chuggs would not be the troublemaker. He says he gave Chuggs the Insomniac. That would change card 1 and Dr. Worm as well, yes?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Well I was hoping B-Dubs would full claim first to see what he'd say, but I'm honestly just getting impatient. I lied about one thing - I did check Card 1 and see Insomniac, but I switched it with B-Dubs. I wanted to pick someone that I didn't think would be targeted by multiple people. B-Dubs is the Insomniac and Dr. Worm is now ??? - whatever B-Dubs original role was. When Faddy pushed me to reveal my target I decided to pick someone that hadn't claimed to see if it would have any impact on what they revealed and there weren't a lot of choices left.
Oh, scratch my last, I missed this post. Let me reassess.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Well I was hoping B-Dubs would full claim first to see what he'd say, but I'm honestly just getting impatient. I lied about one thing - I did check Card 1 and see Insomniac, but I switched it with B-Dubs. I wanted to pick someone that I didn't think would be targeted by multiple people. B-Dubs is the Insomniac and Dr. Worm is now ??? - whatever B-Dubs original role was. When Faddy pushed me to reveal my target I decided to pick someone that hadn't claimed to see if it would have any impact on what they revealed and there weren't a lot of choices left.
So, because I don't play a lot of ONUW - Dubs knew what he was first and then he wakes later and learns he is the Insomniac, which seems confirmed by the weird way he phrased his "I guess I'm the Insomniac now??" post.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Ok, so because Dubs came out and claimed Insomniac, he wouldn't have known his role switched overnight, right? Meaning he was probably a Wolf or Tanner and that went to Card 1 which Worm picked up as the Drunk.

My instincts still tell me that with the way Faddy was claiming, I would still put him in the Wolf category if I'm believing Geno over him.

Turmoil came out hot with that Insomniac claim, which almost felt like he wanted to get countered, which makes me lean Tanner.

B-Dubs I still think was a Wolf, but yeah, you swapped him to Insomniac so that went to Card 1 which our Drunk picked up.

That would mean, I would look at it like this now:

AFTER NIGHT ACTIONS:
Wolves - Faddy and Dr. Worm
Masons - Malus and LP
Apprentice Seer - Geno
Paranormal Investigator - Monkey
Robber - Natiko
Witch - Fantomas
Troublemaker - Chuggernaut
Insomniac - B-Dubs
Tanner - Turmoil

Center Card 1 - Drunk
Center Card 2 - Minion
Center Card 3 - Revealer

Does that make sense?
Yes, that's correct. Not sure why B-Dubs would claim Insomniac knowing it is a contradiction though if he's a wolf - the easier path would've been claiming revealer or troublemaker. I do tend to believe Geno here because it's hard for me to find a configuration where Geno is a non-Villager that works with the weirdness we've seen. Perhaps Faddy's fake claim of seeing Revealer would explain B-Dubs being reluctant to go that route and he might not want to have further split the vote by dragging Chugg into this as well.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
So, because I don't play a lot of ONUW - Dubs knew what he was first and then he wakes later and learns he is the Insomniac, which seems confirmed by the weird way he phrased his "I guess I'm the Insomniac now??" post.
Nah - B-Dubs was for sure lying. He did finish as Insomniac, but he wouldn't have been informed of that since he didn't start with the role. Hopefully he shows back up and can confirm what Dr. Worm actually is now. @B-dubs set us free
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Yes, that's correct. Not sure why B-Dubs would claim Insomniac knowing it is a contradiction though if he's a wolf - the easier path would've been claiming revealer or troublemaker. I do tend to believe Geno here because it's hard for me to find a configuration where Geno is a non-Villager that works with the weirdness we've seen. Perhaps Faddy's fake claim of seeing Revealer would explain B-Dubs being reluctant to go that route and he might not want to have further split the vote by dragging Chugg into this as well.
Nah - B-Dubs was for sure lying. He did finish as Insomniac, but he wouldn't have been informed of that since he didn't start with the role. Hopefully he shows back up and can confirm what Dr. Worm actually is now. @B-dubs set us free
Yeah, if B-Dubs can tell us what his actual role was, then we should be able to solve it I think.

If he was a Wolf, it should be an easy lunch on Worm for the win. If he was the Tanner, we can assume Turmoil is most likely a Wolf. If he was the Minion, then we know Geno was lying about what he saw on Card 2.

I think that all makes sense?
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Why aren't you pushing for me? Curious, you are convinced I'm Jester?

Because I think you are the minion. I think that you are too obvious to be a wolf and Turmoil is much more likely.

You could be jester too. But most likely not wolf.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Yeah, if B-Dubs can tell us what his actual role was, then we should be able to solve it I think.

If he was a Wolf, it should be an easy lunch on Worm for the win. If he was the Tanner, we can assume Turmoil is most likely a Wolf. If he was the Minion, then we know Geno was lying about what he saw on Card 2.

I think that all makes sense?
Yeah, that's where I'm at as well.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Yeah, if B-Dubs can tell us what his actual role was, then we should be able to solve it I think.

If he was a Wolf, it should be an easy lunch on Worm for the win. If he was the Tanner, we can assume Turmoil is most likely a Wolf. If he was the Minion, then we know Geno was lying about what he saw on Card 2.

I think that all makes sense?

Dubs is obviously a bad guy.

I don't think it is obvious he is going to tell the truth though because Natiko could be lying now about switching his role. And he is still whatever role he got originally.
 
Dubs has no choice though, if he doesn't say then Natiko comes out saying he lied and we lynch Dubs, it's a win-win scenario for us.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Dubs is obviously a bad guy.

I don't think it is obvious he is going to tell the truth though because Natiko could be lying now about switching his role. And he is still whatever role he got originally.
True, I suppose he could just tell us anything, but he's basically been given a way out of losing here if Nat is telling the truth, so I don't see why he wouldn't go for it? Even if Nat does turn around and go "Sucker!" then whatever, Dubs was already on the table since we're believing Nat's Witch claim regardless.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Dubs has no choice though, if he doesn't say then Natiko comes out saying he lied and we lynch Dubs, it's a win-win scenario for us.

Dubs doesn't have to do anything. He is fine right now.

Natiko is town and says Dubs is town therefore we can't lynch him and he doesn't have to claim anything.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
True, I suppose he could just tell us anything, but he's basically been given a way out of losing here if Nat is telling the truth, so I don't see why he wouldn't go for it? Even if Nat does turn around and go "Sucker!" then whatever, Dubs was already on the table since we're believing Nat's Witch claim regardless.

What if Dubs is the tanner, not speaking up and getting lynched wins him the game?

In all circumstances Dubs doesn't win if Natiko just says he didn't actually make the switch.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
So in the world where Faddy and Dubs were the two original Wolves, this is just Faddy telling Dubs "Don't say shit, bro!" right? Lol.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
It's entirely possible B-Dubs will choose to not believe me, but if we guess wrong because he didn't reveal his info he'll end up losing with us. It should be pretty obvious I'm telling the truth based on how convenient it was that I fake targeted the only other person who didn't have a claim on the board and provided no reasoning at the time and didn't remotely follow up on it once it didn't get us anything spicy.

Regardless though - Faddy's strong push to try and convince B-Dubs to not reveal just tells me that Faddy and B-Dubs started as wolves and Faddy is openly howling. He has my vote at this point.
 
Does town ever lose in this? It feels like the only thing town had against them was time, and that's eliminated here because we have way too much. Like to lose you either have to be really dumb or really unlucky.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
But it isn't. Geno is the liar.
I'm willing to take the odds on this. If you're in fact telling the truth then shame on you for completely fumbling the opening lol There's absolutely nothing at this point that's going to get me to switch onto Geno over you if those are my choices.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I'm willing to take the odds on this. If you're in fact telling the truth then shame on you for completely fumbling the opening lol There's absolutely nothing at this point that's going to get me to switch onto Geno over you if those are my choices.

Unless Dubs comes out and says Geno is the wolf I am not voting Geno either.

Right now I am voting Turmoil.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Does town ever lose in this? It feels like the only thing town had against them was time, and that's eliminated here because we have way too much. Like to lose you either have to be really dumb or really unlucky.
I think any path to us losing involves accidentally hitting the Tanner or you also lying (with Faddy also still lying) and hitting a Minion. Middle cards at start would've been Insomniac, Apprentice Seer, and Revealer.
 
I think any path to us losing involves accidentally hitting the Tanner or you also lying (with Faddy also still lying) and hitting a Minion. Middle cards at start would've been Insomniac, Apprentice Seer, and Revealer.
I think I would be pretty dumb to lie about that, if I was a minion I wouldn't have claimed the same thing as Faddy.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I think any path to us losing involves accidentally hitting the Tanner or you also lying (with Faddy also still lying) and hitting a Minion. Middle cards at start would've been Insomniac, Apprentice Seer, and Revealer.

If you want to lynch me then we are going to lose.

This is dumb. It is Geno, Turmoil, B-Dubs.
 
Why? as minion you would want to take the lynch.
Because I would want to distance my claim from a wolf's. Making the same claim is dumb. Also it would've been a risk since at the time I didn't know what role Chuggs, B-dubs and 1 more had iirc. Awful play all around.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I think I would be pretty dumb to lie about that, if I was a minion I wouldn't have claimed the same thing as Faddy.
I don't think it's likely, simply is the only other situation I could see being theoretically possible.

If you want to lynch me then we are going to lose.

This is dumb. It is Geno, Turmoil, B-Dubs.
And yet you seemed oddly invested in talking B-Dubs into staying quiet.:pikathink:
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Because I would want to distance my claim from a wolf's. Making the same claim is dumb. Also it would've been a risk since at the time I didn't know what role Chuggs, B-dubs and 1 more had iirc. Awful play all around.
In the scenario I outlined you would be Minion and Faddy would be Tanner in all likelihood. Faddy as Tanner would want to discourage initial Wolf B-Dubs from fully outting now Wolf Dr. Worm as it would prevent him from hitting his wincon. Turmoil would then just be a Wolf that is happy to stay back and let others take most of the heat.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Because I would want to distance my claim from a wolf's. Making the same claim is dumb. Also it would've been a risk since at the time I didn't know what role Chuggs, B-dubs and 1 more had iirc. Awful play all around.

But if you are the minion you only know the wolves names. You can't co-ordinate with them at all. You still wouldn't know what roles they would claim.
 
In the scenario I outlined you would be Minion and Faddy would be Tanner in all likelihood. Faddy as Tanner would want to discourage initial Wolf B-Dubs from fully outting now Wolf Dr. Worm as it would prevent him from hitting his wincon. Turmoil would then just be a Wolf that is happy to stay back and let others take most of the heat.
Eh, I guess. Although like you said it's an extremely unlikely scenario even considering the fact that I'm not actually lying.
But if you are the minion you only know the wolves names. You can't co-ordinate with them at all. You still wouldn't know what roles they would claim.
I would've just afk'd and waited until everyone did.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Eh, I guess. Although like you said it's an extremely unlikely scenario even considering the fact that I'm not actually lying.

I would've just afk'd and waited until everyone did.
Yeah, if we lose due to that scenario it is what it is. Would mean the wolves were stuck losing either way and decided to just throw by giving the Tanner a win. Not a big deal.
 
Yeah it's pretty obvious Faddy is a wolf at this point. Is there a way to turbo early or do we have to wait the whole 48h? (Unless it's 24)
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I'd at least like to see if @B-dubs will choose to reveal. If he outs Dr. Worm as a wolf I'd sooner vote there. My main concern is that Faddy could just be Tanner.

@Faddy You seem to have settled on Geno being a Minion (a bad one that doesn't even want to attempt to get votes on himself). Who is the Tanner in your mind then?
 
I'd at least like to see if @B-dubs will choose to reveal. If he outs Dr. Worm as a wolf I'd sooner vote there. My main concern is that Faddy could just be Tanner.

@Faddy You seem to have settled on Geno being a Minion (a bad one that doesn't even want to attempt to get votes on himself). Who is the Tanner in your mind then?
Fair, let's wait for B-Dubs then, although we might be here for a while.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I'd at least like to see if @B-dubs will choose to reveal. If he outs Dr. Worm as a wolf I'd sooner vote there. My main concern is that Faddy could just be Tanner.

@Faddy You seem to have settled on Geno being a Minion (a bad one that doesn't even want to attempt to get votes on himself). Who is the Tanner in your mind then?

Geno doesn't need to do anything. He is getting me lynched by the looks of it. That is a win for wolves.

B-Dubs or Turmoil. I think Turmoil is less likely to be tanner because he was more careful.

Or Tanner is in the middle.
 
Geno doesn't need to do anything. He is getting me lynched by the looks of it. That is a win for wolves.

B-Dubs or Turmoil. I think Turmoil is less likely to be tanner because he was more careful.

Or Tanner is in the middle.
After the game you should tell us what you were thinking when you made your claim, like that was a bad play. I don't understand.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
After the game you should tell us what you were thinking when you made your claim, like that was a bad play. I don't understand.

I was thinking I had sent card 1 to Fireblend but at the last minute I forgot I switched to 3. (because no one ever chooses 1)
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I will admit I picked #1 expecting no one else to interact with the card, was hoping to reduce the number of variables.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Maybe if we all wish for it hard enough he'll feel our energies calling out to him.
 
Top Bottom