Spectator Thread Inside Muffin
- Thread starter Geno
- Start date
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
So....this is a Fandorin sacrifice to frame me because i keep pushing the real scums?
Fando did a thing and if Mao doesn't want to tell, I'll leave it up to the dead themselves :)
What would it look like if Fandorin didn't die?
Don't do it, Sneeks... Do not tell Sorian. :O
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
What do you mean?
You know my role lol.
I barely even lied about it. Did I have an item?
Sorian promised to give me things but he didn’t. I tried telling him I couldn’t threaten mafia in the gossip chat in the hopes of avoiding the NK, but I guess that didn’t work.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
And IS sorian scum?
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
If town takes this godfather thing to heart then i think they’ll lose.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
This is soooo sus, I would be right on this if i wasn’t ded.
Wait, what is jedah? Lol. Does that work like my prevarication?
Also i’m thinking Cat is town. Am i right? *hugs cat from the beyond*
Jedah is a self mutilating demon that fights with blood.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
But...why?Lol, Wee really wanted that Confirmed Town gif from me huh?
Replace Fireblend's avatar with Wee's and this gif from Maple Street still applies:
I thought you at least loved me fanto.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Well that doesn’t apply at all!
Still nobody gets my jokes. I will go read this to my spouse to get a laugh. :(
:( *hugs wee*
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Its a good frame tho. I did keep calling for bloodbaths.
omg, Sorian is pushing hard for who i sent the item to lmao
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
*hugs donna*
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
If I was jedah i’d have called myself a BLOODY rat. Duh.
You know. To go with the british spellings i was using for no particular reason.
You know. To go with the british spellings i was using for no particular reason.
NOOOOO Sneeekkkks :((((( Whyyyy
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Whoa, is this real? I still have role envy, i realize that i was a bit extra oomphed, but that 1 shot thing really HURT.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Also you took my view of my night chats away just because i’m ded?
Yeah, that item made you pretty much invincible if i read it right? Only death by lunch could occur, i'm guessing
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I do, I'm just terribly confused and am not paying much attention to this game anymore.
-----
So Fandorin was Scum and gave his Role PM to Wee when he died? Is that what's going on here? Or Fandorin is only fake-dead and will come back to life at some point?
And is Sorian Scum?
Spoilers for Jedah's item.
Jedah's item gave them almost all those, +1 fake flip(what happened to you) and the ability to recruit 2 townies to the team
Good job, Stu!!!!
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Holy crap. Go stu! <3<3<3<3<3
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Holy SHIT at those spoilers!
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Look, I’m assuming that Fandorin sacrificed himself to give me his role card.
I’m Raiden from MK, a time-unlimited watcher with only 1 natural shot.
I wasn’t allowed to check who hypnotized Chuggernaut because the roleblock applied for all time on me on N1. So I went for checking aeleus’ claim as best I could.
That’s all I could do, for the game. Lol.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Not MY item, puns. Not MINE.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
And the only suggestion I made about my extra capabilities was accidental lol. I did use the term “4th dimension”.
If i wasn’t ded, I’d have given rebellion to AB and the revolver back to aeleus, because although i wasn’t too sure if they were town, it seemed like it couldn’t hurt us any more in their hands.
If i wasn’t ded, I’d have given rebellion to AB and the revolver back to aeleus, because although i wasn’t too sure if they were town, it seemed like it couldn’t hurt us any more in their hands.
Last edited:
HvV1 = Pure Geno
HvV2 = Corrupt Geno
HvV3 = Punished Geno?
HvV2 = Corrupt Geno
HvV3 = Punished Geno?
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Gooo sawneeks!
Wait, is she town? Was I right about puns being a multi-team random target that they never let go of?
If all of my ideas for 3 make it in, let's just say oh boy.
So there is a 3 planned? lol
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
how many non town players are in this game? Because with like 3 janitors, i’m....confused how town has a shot from the beginning.
Kind of, I'll probably start actually making it next year though. So it will be a while before it runs.
Well scum can shoot each other, plus town has a lot of roles that confirm themselves, it's not my fault you guys lynched the cop...
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Technically our vig shot the cop.
Also there's some big stuff not yet revealed in the spec chat.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Always listen to wee.
if that team is Sorian, Brazil, Fran i will never forgive you lmao
Fanto
Confirmed Town
If Brazil is Scum, my heart will literally be broken.
The only thing that makes me suspect Brazil is his defense against Fran last day phase. i wanted that lynch so damn bad and for some reason LP was being voted... I even gave reasons, but Brazil wasn't hearing it and people have been town reading him, so i knew the lunch wouldn't shift to Fran.
In retrospect, i should have just stayed there in stubbornness just like I did w/ Muffin D2
Lone_Prodigy
Am I at 10 posts yet?
Town is in an uphill battle I think with all the different factions out there. Losing the tracker hurt. The override hitting town, Kalor offing himself, and malus being killed by the event didn't help either.
I like the change from the 1st game though. In that one everyone was neutral, and it seems this time everyone is scum.
I like the change from the 1st game though. In that one everyone was neutral, and it seems this time everyone is scum.
Lone_Prodigy
Am I at 10 posts yet?
Oh and what was my item?
Dutch's revolver, also shame on you for not posting non stop michael scott gifs.
Lone_Prodigy
Am I at 10 posts yet?
Verelios
Were-elios
Jesus
Im worried about Hurricane Dorian
I should have been worried about Hurricane Sorian
<3 omg that made me laugh so hard
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Hiya stu. You and me, stu, you and me. We KNOW.
I tried so hard :(
Stu, I wasn’t going to post this but you of all people deserve this to see it. This was going to be my opening D5 post before I saw the mod confirm on Muffin.
VOTE: Muffin
Potentially could be in FoL.
He could have tried to bus Swamped right before the EOD she was lunched. The vote was 9 Swamped, 7 Aeleus after Muffin placed his vote on her. 4 POSTS LATER (the next vote that was placed) Swamped voted for Aeleus and this was her last post of the game. Over 30 minutes left until EOD and she made no other posts. Could have been a coordinated bus by Swamped and Muffin since Swamped was more than likely getting lunched.
But I admit, this isn’t the team I think he’s on.
He’s most likely on Mao’s team:
I don’t find this interaction genuine. Mao easily unvoted Muffin, and even though he placed a vote on Muffin, he claims there wasn’t a really good reason for it. Yet, he voted for me during the TD and even after the TD was over with he stayed on me. There were more suspicious players last day phase, and his argument against me was poorly relayed and relied on a post that Fanto made on D1... I told him he should look at other players too but he refused. Yet, Muffin easily got him to unvote...
We just learned that fake claims can be from alternate universes than the character. Thus, i do not believe Mufifn’s megaman claim.
i do believe Geno has been mixing in the fake names with the real names in each of AB's character choices. I dont think the main focus of that ability is to red check and/or green check a player; the purpose is to simply force a player to claim a character.
So, now we need to figure out if Muffin gave the fake claim or the real claim.
I believe Muffin was watching the game thread the entire time and he knew what was going on in the thread 10 minutes before EOD, so he was totally prepared to fake claim. If he did it short notice right before EOD it would garner him town points.
Next, Muffin didn’t disclose his item when he lost it. He should have done it right away without anyone having to question him about it one time, two times, any times. Period. Just like Apo did.
Which brings me to this.
I never understood this. He said this immediately when he entered the thread that day, yet he can’t tell us immediately when he loses an item or who he copied?
Muffin wanted people to know he’s been infected by something so Townies would believe a neutral or scum team had targeted him the night before. I think he wanted the townie points.
Mooore:
He pretty much shoved this post in Stu’s face to discredit him for suspecting him.
I don’t think Stu is dumb enough to go out on a limb and make a huge scene like he did last day phase without a reason. Thus, i believe there is essence in his accusations. At the worst, Stu is on the opposite scum team and trying to get Townie points by calling out Muffin. We will cross that bridge in the near future.
Last reason: I think Muffin’s claim is bs. After this Mao flip, Muffin could very well be collecting souls, not doing megaman “copies.” There’s no way to prove he’s x-shot because our tracker has been killed and he knows that.
He’s probably All For One from MHA:
Seems like scum in Jedah’s Alliance needs to collect souls, so every member has a “soul stealing” ability instead of a faction kill. Saddler’s was the Las Plagas and Muffin’s is Quirks.
Potentially could be in FoL.
He could have tried to bus Swamped right before the EOD she was lunched. The vote was 9 Swamped, 7 Aeleus after Muffin placed his vote on her. 4 POSTS LATER (the next vote that was placed) Swamped voted for Aeleus and this was her last post of the game. Over 30 minutes left until EOD and she made no other posts. Could have been a coordinated bus by Swamped and Muffin since Swamped was more than likely getting lunched.
But I admit, this isn’t the team I think he’s on.
He’s most likely on Mao’s team:
I don’t find this interaction genuine. Mao easily unvoted Muffin, and even though he placed a vote on Muffin, he claims there wasn’t a really good reason for it. Yet, he voted for me during the TD and even after the TD was over with he stayed on me. There were more suspicious players last day phase, and his argument against me was poorly relayed and relied on a post that Fanto made on D1... I told him he should look at other players too but he refused. Yet, Muffin easily got him to unvote...
We just learned that fake claims can be from alternate universes than the character. Thus, i do not believe Mufifn’s megaman claim.
i do believe Geno has been mixing in the fake names with the real names in each of AB's character choices. I dont think the main focus of that ability is to red check and/or green check a player; the purpose is to simply force a player to claim a character.
So, now we need to figure out if Muffin gave the fake claim or the real claim.
I believe Muffin was watching the game thread the entire time and he knew what was going on in the thread 10 minutes before EOD, so he was totally prepared to fake claim. If he did it short notice right before EOD it would garner him town points.
Next, Muffin didn’t disclose his item when he lost it. He should have done it right away without anyone having to question him about it one time, two times, any times. Period. Just like Apo did.
Which brings me to this.
I never understood this. He said this immediately when he entered the thread that day, yet he can’t tell us immediately when he loses an item or who he copied?
Muffin wanted people to know he’s been infected by something so Townies would believe a neutral or scum team had targeted him the night before. I think he wanted the townie points.
Mooore:
He pretty much shoved this post in Stu’s face to discredit him for suspecting him.
I don’t think Stu is dumb enough to go out on a limb and make a huge scene like he did last day phase without a reason. Thus, i believe there is essence in his accusations. At the worst, Stu is on the opposite scum team and trying to get Townie points by calling out Muffin. We will cross that bridge in the near future.
Last reason: I think Muffin’s claim is bs. After this Mao flip, Muffin could very well be collecting souls, not doing megaman “copies.” There’s no way to prove he’s x-shot because our tracker has been killed and he knows that.
He’s probably All For One from MHA:
Seems like scum in Jedah’s Alliance needs to collect souls, so every member has a “soul stealing” ability instead of a faction kill. Saddler’s was the Las Plagas and Muffin’s is Quirks.
btw, nice turbo
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
I still don’t get how you are so sure about muffin, but i avoided giving him an item....if i had been allowed to get to Give.
Oh man, I missed some of those. They would have strengthen my arguments.
At first, I was bluffing for a reaction. It's a tactic I've used successfully in the past. (his reacting to every accusation I lay at him reminded me of the last game I was in with him when he was Scum. KH Mafia maybe?)
Then the mod-confirmed townie check on him came and I just didn't believe it at all. It's a bastard game but there had hardly been any visibly bastard elements. A mod-confirmed green check and one that uses the FAKE CLAIM NAME was just so Bastard that I could see Geno doing it.
Then there was his poor vote record that I pointed out.
Some other stuff too maybe but my head hurts too much to think atm :(
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Ah. Meta.
Now that I’ve SEEN some geno bastard stuff I can get it. I never read HVV1.
I was going to also add overly angry-defensive muffin is usually non-town. But idk how it would have went over lol
Yeah. best I could add was the meta thing from the last time I played with him when he was scum.
But never worked. And people seem to believe that he's town due to the check so who knows if they will get him before it's too late. If he dies, I think it will be by another scum faction.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Anyway, now that they want to kill the doctor instead of sorian, I give up.
Thanks, I hope so too.
Got a major cold (or flu idk) plus my eyes have been hurting since yesterday. Going to opticians tomorrow after I get an emergency appt so hopefully I'll be better soon.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
We did indeed try.
I had faddy and sorian and swamped and aeleus. If those are all scum. And got killed for it i guess.
I had faddy and sorian and swamped and aeleus. If those are all scum. And got killed for it i guess.
I said it in thread. Never believe Sorian.
People who have played with him should know this by now haha.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Poor Cat.
*hugs Cat again*
I am sure you’re hurting if you’re reading this. Now, please, always kill sorian.
*hugs Cat again*
I am sure you’re hurting if you’re reading this. Now, please, always kill sorian.
I should also admit this just now
I was bluffing about my SK kill order.
It actually would have been:
Sorian -> Muffin -> ???
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Geez stu if you had said THAT i would have been giving you all the items.
Haha, I was too worried that a Doc or RB would have prevented me.
I knew saying Muffin would result in someone protecting them right away if I said I became an SK (or even if I said nothing, some may have assumed I became one anyway haha) So I figured this way I could get my way and get rid of Sorian (and now that I know he is defo scum, be glad I got rid of scum even if I had became neutral by that point lol)
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
AND you would shoot whoever I asked you to.
We are a good team.
We are a good team.
So if I’m understanding this right:
FoD shot Fandorin and that’s why Sorian claims he has Frostmourne
I am really glad I subbed out of this stupid game.
(Sorry Geno. I actually think the game itself is good, it's just the players and some of the shots that gets me)
I wouldn’t say the game is stupid but there are aggressive players in this game so you’re bound to get some attacks.
It’s easy to get frustrated when you’re set on something so much and you know a person is scum but you can’t do anything about it.
You just gotta formulate your reasoning. Dig it into peoples heads a little, and keep chugging, hoping it will come in handy sometime during the game.
Gotta trust in your teammates
And if I would’ve gotten my way, Fran would’ve been gone last day phase btw lol
I clarified by saying I don't think the game itself is stupid. It's actually quite a fun design.
I already explained in this and other games that I suck at getting my reasoning and other stuff across to people.
It's even worse in a game with Sorian and Faddy especially who are so god damned loud and particularly the first one, so good at bullshitting that it's easy to discredit me or make everyone not believe or even care about me.
But some of the shots taken at me. Stan, Sorian and even that post from Fran which is basically the equivalent of saying "you might as well not post here at all" is just fucking... urgh.
Aggressive players or not, I feel like there should be some sort of fucking line in these games. (I felt the same way last game I played with godfather, some people just go over the line too fucking much x.x. At least when I go over the line and it's pointed out to me, I apologize usually)
Yeah, usually mods or game watchers will take players aside if they start getting to blatant disrespectful territory. Usually it’s privately so idk if anyone’s gotten warnings this game. I got a couple in HvV1, that’s why I’ve switched my play style up immensely lol
It’s good you brought it up though, it should be a talking point postgame.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
How great can he be if he leaves me out of the gif love forEVER?
I enjoy that I know what you're talking about, lol.
Yeah, I was scum together with Mao as Jedah. I was able to discuss everything about [REDACTED] as it was clarified by Geno on his first post in our scum thread. At this point it should be clear that I wasn’t the only one though.
At first I thought it was Ketkat but after D5 end, you were on my list lol
I was actually trying to be a little suspicious to avoid getting NK’d that phase, since I had my fake claim ready to go. Didn’t expect that kill on me.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
You probably are, now, taking info for your real team.