Spectator Thread Inside Muffin

LMAO

How did Vincent know that? Like, I remember Rad Mobile, and I remember Sonic, but I did not remember that Sonic was in Rad Mobile, let alone before his first game came out lol.

Just looked it up, Sonic was hanging in the car view from the vid I saw lol. (like those airfreshners and stuff that can be put on the middle mirrors in cars lol)
 
Fucking nerds man...oh wait.
GNxpCZD.png
 
Yeah, that thread was a legendary mafia moment, for sure.
In a game where only select players can post in a thread, we had a separate thread to help us solve a question from the exclusive thread.
Too great
 
Yeah, and that character was hella obscure too. Zipped was the last person I'd think would've guessed it.

I had a weird PS2 era, at least tangentially familiar with every single Atlus game.

But what I really did it was scour TV tropes after remembering what the hair style is called. It would have been much longer if the game had started with a letter at the end of the alphabet.
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
Well scum can shoot each other, plus town has a lot of roles that confirm themselves, it's not my fault you guys lynched the cop...
Yeah, I think town's got decent odds. If Muffin goes for VA, FoD has a decent chance of NKing him for being a green check before we all bite it.
And I guess everyone knows who is holding like half of all the items now
I took an inventory in scumchat and I think we had everything except the Gyroid and the Microchip, so it was 3/4. Down to half now because Geno wouldn't let me offload my holdings.
 
Yeah, I think town's got decent odds. If Muffin goes for VA, FoD has a decent chance of NKing him for being a green check before we all bite it.
I took an inventory in scumchat and I think we had everything except the Gyroid and the Microchip, so it was 3/4. Down to half now because Geno wouldn't let me offload my holdings.
did you guys know who has the stones?
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
did you guys know who has the stones?
No, that was a controlled post. FoD has nothing on the stones. I had a number of mentions of Illuminati in my role PM but they're all censored in the flip, including some interactions with my abilities. I legit thought they might be a cult for a time.
 
No, that was a controlled post. FoD has nothing on the stones. I had a number of mentions of Illuminati in my role PM but they're all censored in the flip, including some interactions with my abilities. I legit thought they might be a cult for a time.
Damn, I love how I hit exactly the only player in the game that had a Illuminati mention in their role PMs with that controlled post. Too bad it didn’t lead to much.
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
I definitely will and I am prepared for it.
My only issue with how it was handled was that the moderator posted an image that seemingly endorses his roleclaim in addition to announcing him as town, which feels like it goes beyond the scope of what that interaction should entail.
Damn, I love how I hit exactly the only player in the game that had a Illuminati mention in their role PMs with that controlled post. Too bad it didn’t lead to much.
Is there any reason why you didn't just force a cop claim down someone's throat? Feels like the easiest move to make to bait out the real one, and probably wins you a free day either way.
 
My only issue with how it was handled was that the moderator posted an image that seemingly endorses his roleclaim in addition to announcing him as town, which feels like it goes beyond the scope of what that interaction should entail.

Is there any reason why you didn't just force a cop claim down someone's throat? Feels like the easiest move to make to bait out the real one, and probably wins you a free day either way.
First day I wanted to test the waters and didn’t go overboard with it, but as we saw Chuggs managed to completely null that power. I guess that made me hesitant towards the power so I didn’t do much with it. Well, at D2 I tried something cool by having AB say that he had investigated you, but in the end I got RB’d by LP and that didn’t go through.
 
What's the current knowledge in here:

Muffin is last FoL, bastard confirmed as town.
Sorian is FoD and there is one more FoD.
Thanos is running around as well.
We probably drop some more info soon. Any guesses on last FoD and Thanos?

From this point onward, we will go open spoilers :)
SPOILER WARNING
 
Last edited:
FROM THESE POST ON THERE WILL BE FULL SPOILERS(although almost all of you probably have been reading them anyway)
 
Forces of Darkness left - Fran and Sorian
Jedah's Alliance left - ...
Forces of Light left - Muffin
Illuminatis left - Muffin, Sneeks, Lokiduck
Thanos is Faddy
 

Swamped

Dazzling Mafia Queen
Amazing stuff. I'm super behind but catching up on the highlights. Glad things are going well for Muffin so far, he had some bad luck before.
 
HvV2 inspired me to finish my first game.
I’ll probably run it early 2020 when I have more time :D

With how slow we're going at it, mines and Donna's first designed game (not mini since I've done one already :P) we want to run together probably won't run until then either with how slow we're going at it haha :P
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
I have two games in the works right now, Easy Allies with Melonrabbit and Stranger Things with Z-Beat, as well as a Mini that I'll be co-running with Natiko and another Mini that I want to do by myself. No idea when I'll find time to run them all now with my new job, but I'll make it happen lol.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
I gotta say I was looking forward to being more relaxed as town this time... But it seems a lot more fun to be not town.
 
Mystery Moustache is gone and forgotten!
Don't let it get to you, you were an integral part of the Illuminati!
Mystery person probably didn't notice you being part, because...
he got knowledge of it after you already left the group/died
 
You can TRUST me.

Or me. :P

Ya know, I get left alive because I do crap early game and then later game, I start trying to put things together even if I can't always get my thoughts out in an easy to understand manner.

But I feel like next time I'm town, I'm gonna die early due to all this haha.
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
If town wins, geno will announce me as a winner, and ALL the teams will be confused but one. I think nobody will pay attention lol, and I’ll get accused for YEARS of deliberately doing all the things they’ve dug up that were coincidental.
 
I might've fucked up tbh, I don't refund shots when someone targets someone who commuted, I only refund if you get roleblocked. I didn't know it was the norm in the community, had I known this I would've refunded the shot.
 
I might've fucked up tbh, I don't refund shots when someone targets someone who commuted, I only refund if you get roleblocked. I didn't know it was the norm in the community, had I known this I would've refunded the shot.
So anything that gets roleblocked generally gets refunded? Is this because since a role was blocked, it was technically unable to even use a shot in the first place?
Does the same apply when targeting commuters and ascetics? Since they’re untargetable, a shot can’t be used?
 
To me it makes sense to only refund a shot if roleblocked, since the action didn’t actually go through, while a shot used on a commuter is a whiff and could actually be redirected if there is lightning rod / nexus mechanics in place.
 
So anything that gets roleblocked generally gets refunded? Is this because since a role was blocked, it was technically unable to even use a shot in the first place?
Does the same apply when targeting commuters and ascetics? Since they’re untargetable, a shot can’t be used?
I don't apply the same to commuters etc, but it might be the norm in this community. Not sure. In general I don't want to reward people who target a commuter, feels like they deserve to lose that shot, while being roleblocked isn't their fault.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
I don't apply the same to commuters etc, but it might be the norm in this community. Not sure. In general I don't want to reward people who target a commuter, feels like they deserve to lose that shot, while being roleblocked isn't their fault.
I can get behind this.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
I'd put something like that down to game runner's preference. The important thing is to be consistent with your chosen approach.
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
I am pretty sure we’ve had gamerunners turn all commuter-targeting into whiffs, yeah. The POINT of a commuter is to waste shots.
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
They aren't a threat, but they don't know each other's alignments.
Do you tell them they're all town, or do you intentionally leave it vague? If it's the latter, it's a Neighborhood, not a Masonry.

(You called it a masonry here and when I read that it was a five-person Masonry I got super pissed for a second because that would've made it nigh-impossible for us to win)
I'd put something like that down to game runner's preference. The important thing is to be consistent with your chosen approach.
Yeah, this is my take on it as well
wait what'd I do
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Do you tell them they're all town, or do you intentionally leave it vague? If it's the latter, it's a Neighborhood, not a Masonry.

(You called it a masonry here and when I read that it was a five-person Masonry I got super pissed for a second because that would've made it nigh-impossible for us to win)

Yeah, this is my take on it as well

wait what'd I do
It was a neighborhood yeah, we were told nothing about the other players alignments. Also, everyone but Loki, and Muffin when he joined, were in costume accounts so we had to identity claim to each other of we wanted to know who everyone was even.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Ok, back home now (I'll be moving on Sunday! Holy shit!)

As for the spoilers mentioned above:

I am glad that I realized Fran was totally Scum, but it only hit me after I had subbed out. I can't remember what was all going on that day, but there were a lot of posts from him that reminded me of how he was in Simon Says.

Faddy is the Neutral Thanos then? Lol, god dammit, I was really hoping him and Sorian were Scum together, I thought I had the right read on that one lol. Oh well, at least the year-long streak of me and Faddy not being on the same team is still intact, the Mafia RNG Gods have refused to allow us to team up since GoT and I do not know why lol. I like Faddy!
 
Geno, was there some miscommunication with Sneeks about when I received the Chaos Emerald and when I got it stolen? Or is she lying for some weird reason?
Because it might get her lunched
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Sorian said:
For all the talk of balance, I highly doubt there are just two x-shot commuters. An odd and even is possible but two capable of leaving on the same night? Doubt it. Since the actual contradictions are cleared up, I think the scummier of the two is Fran. I’ve already went through the whole cycle of TP days ago but Fran hasn’t felt like he’s had any growth this whole game. He helped find Swamped and then has felt very coasty ever since then, a lot of his recent posts the past few days I can remember are him just defending himself.

VOTE: Fran
giphy.gif
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
LOL forgot to add that wee did vote for me and that has been the only vote on me.
Wow, Loki is really hurt by this joke I made about myself on D1.

Maybe I should stop being funny as it irritates people so badly.
 
Top Bottom