Costume Party |OT| The Mafia Mash

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Vote Count:

Cereal Killer - 7
Bob Ross - Post #758
Spider-Man - Post #778
Minecraft Steve - Post #884
Witch - Post #886 Post #917
Kool-Aid Man - Post #1,116
Barney - Post #1,138
Rey - Post #1,189
Prisoner - Post #1,280

Spider-Man - 7
Cereal Killer - Post #787 Post #862
Zombie - Post #821
Cereal Killer - Post #1,082
Witch - Post #1,105
Banana - Post #1,110
Baby - Post #1,210
Cinderella - Post #1,244
Jack Sparrow - Post #1,273

Kool-Aid Man - 1
Barack Obama - Post #1,394

Prisoner - 0
Barack Obama - Post #1,168 Post #1,394

Daenerys Targaryen - 0
Baby - Post #786 Post #1,139
Cinderella - Post #1,026 Post #1,244

Barack Obama - 0
Jack Sparrow - Post #979 Post #1,134

Jack Sparrow - 0
Cereal Killer - Post #862 Post #1,082

Rey - 0
Kool-Aid Man - Post #870 Post #1,116

Barney - 0
Baby - Post #1,139 Post #1,210
Prisoner - Post #1,179 Post #1,280
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
While Dracula pilling onto a joke is sus he seems pretty trolly so it's not enough for me to take it to seriously right now.
All I am saying is that while Dracula looks sus right now I do not have any strong feeling in regards to whether they are scum or not. I am not saying that they aren't on my radar though
This is just a weird sequence this early in the game before Dracula had slipped or lost his ackzent. Feels like distancing.
Vote: Jack Sparrow
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
ngl, Spidy being so frozen at EoD wasn't a good look and there is admission that this isn't too weird as a scum, but
Prisoner is in the lead? Just my luck, I haven't really engaged with him at all so don't have a good read. But I feel like Drac is town. I'll stay on Bob.
This is a weirdly townie post. It's open about the feelings and there's an out there to save Dracula, but they don't grab it.
 

Banana

Costume Account
It's not impossible for scum to act the way CK is acting but it is very uncommon and would be very unusual for a scum to have put in the work that they have done. A scum would more than likely be waiting back and jumping on things that form rather than being out front. Again not impossible scum move but one I find unlikely for now.
 

Bob Ross

Costume Account
It's not impossible for scum to act the way CK is acting but it is very uncommon and would be very unusual for a scum to have put in the work that they have done. A scum would more than likely be waiting back and jumping on things that form rather than being out front. Again not impossible scum move but one I find unlikely for now.
Depends, CK knew she'd be up for a lynch today so she couldn't really stay back and wait.
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
It's not impossible for scum to act the way CK is acting but it is very uncommon and would be very unusual for a scum to have put in the work that they have done. A scum would more than likely be waiting back and jumping on things that form rather than being out front. Again not impossible scum move but one I find unlikely for now.
That depends entirely on who they are tho, I went with the big activity flag yesterday, but people with good activity can fake stuff like that.
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
ngl, Spidy being so frozen at EoD wasn't a good look and there is admission that this isn't too weird as a scum, but

This is a weirdly townie post. It's open about the feelings and there's an out there to save Dracula, but they don't grab it.
because look what happened to people who tried to save Dracula

We're in costume here and so anon but I really doubt it's the first rodeo for you guys, come on.
 

Banana

Costume Account
ngl, Spidy being so frozen at EoD wasn't a good look and there is admission that this isn't too weird as a scum, but

This is a weirdly townie post. It's open about the feelings and there's an out there to save Dracula, but they don't grab it.

I'm going to have to dig up that context but that post was actually something that bothered me with Spidey.
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
That depends entirely on who they are tho, I went with the big activity flag yesterday, but people with good activity can fake stuff like that.
Making the big mega posts can be faked.

Responding in the moment and staying consistent can be faked. It's harder, but it can be done.

Not many people can do both.

Anyway, I thought you townread both wagons?
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
because look what happened to people who tried to save Dracula

We're in costume here and so anon but I really doubt it's the first rodeo for you guys, come on.
It's not black and white, at the end of the day you're gonna die if you never vote also. Your job as scum is to look like town and they vote wrong too.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Vote Count:

Cereal Killer - 7
Bob Ross - Post #758
Spider-Man - Post #778
Minecraft Steve - Post #884
Witch - Post #886 Post #917
Kool-Aid Man - Post #1,116
Barney - Post #1,138
Rey - Post #1,189
Prisoner - Post #1,280

Spider-Man - 6
Cereal Killer - Post #787 Post #862
Zombie - Post #821
Cereal Killer - Post #1,082
Witch - Post #1,105
Banana - Post #1,110
Baby - Post #1,210 Post #1,425
Cinderella - Post #1,244
Jack Sparrow - Post #1,273

Jack Sparrow - 2
Cereal Killer - Post #862 Post #1,082
Daenerys Targaryen - Post #1,404
Baby - Post #1,425

Kool-Aid Man - 1
Barack Obama - Post #1,394

Prisoner - 0
Barack Obama - Post #1,168 Post #1,394

Daenerys Targaryen - 0
Baby - Post #786 Post #1,139
Cinderella - Post #1,026 Post #1,244

Barack Obama - 0
Jack Sparrow - Post #979 Post #1,134

Rey - 0
Kool-Aid Man - Post #870 Post #1,116

Barney - 0
Baby - Post #1,139 Post #1,210
Prisoner - Post #1,179 Post #1,280
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
It's not black and white, at the end of the day you're gonna die if you never vote also. Your job as scum is to look like town and they vote wrong too.
This is a sideways response.

Who is suspected today? People who swapped votes. Why? Because we always suspect people who swapped votes, no matter the flip. It is consistent. Game after game after game. We push it. Sometimes harder, sometimes less, but always.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Day 2 Ends In:
4z89725gxu


Majority is 9
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
EoD time here he's active and he was active close to it yesterday, but D1 he made his last post 3 hours before EoD.
So you have time to look at that, and to scrape together activity boards from multiple games, but not to actually get in on the same JS case that I made earlier in the thread?

that's wild
 

Banana

Costume Account
ngl, Spidy being so frozen at EoD wasn't a good look and there is admission that this isn't too weird as a scum, but

This is a weirdly townie post. It's open about the feelings and there's an out there to save Dracula, but they don't grab it.

Ok found it, feel free to look at my original post for full quote context.

I went back through and in my memory of him was more activity than was actually there. I thought it weird that he kept pushing CK early on but that could also be brushed aside as early D1 shenanigans (and I'm fine with early D1 shenanigans). Still the sequence of posts after Dracula's slip or notslip I think was what made me feel a little scummy on him.



The quoted posts don't come through obviously but a lot of going after the people that had noticed Dracula's little slip. He especially seemed to take offense to Bob pointing out that he was the first to notice the slip (which yes was a little petty) and then really seemed to focus on Bob and Zombie.



Still pushing the Bob and Zombie vibes. It should be noted that I read Bob as town for now and so I may be a bit bias on that front.



More names but always Bob in there. Plus calls out a Dracula protection.



Still wants Bob gone and trying to go with the "his elimination will give us clues" theory which ok....


To me it feels like he was worried that when Dracula flipped scum it might buy Bob some town cred and he would want the town to be a bit more disorganized. And then staying off Bob after the votes had moved off him and we know he was around at the end of the day. Yes his reasoning stands up at first glance:



So he didn't like Prisoner either but just before the day ended he said:



Maybe nitpicking here but that seems like if Prisoner was in the lead at that point and time and he didn't feel comfortable going with Dracula and he didn't really have a read on Prisoner supposedly why not switch? Why make your vote not really count? I think he was just afraid to either cause a tie or be the hammer on someone other than Dracula because he knew when Dracula was found out (and he would have been before too long) then it was going to look really bad on him.

And I just accidentally made a CK post.

Spidey was on protect Dracula most of D1 but then when it actually was time to do something about they didn't. They were throwing out a strong town read on Drac and hadn't even looked at Prisoner and yet were unwilling to be a thing or hammer vote for a train against Dracula.
 

Baby

Costume Account
Hmm, so you don't feel CK is a good lunch anymore?

Spider's fine as a lunch. But people are getting too complacent and working backwards from conclusions they've already made about the two top trains. Just trying to shake things up and see who panics where
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
Ok found it, feel free to look at my original post for full quote context.



Spidey was on protect Dracula most of D1 but then when it actually was time to do something about they didn't. They were throwing out a strong town read on Drac and hadn't even looked at Prisoner and yet were unwilling to be a thing or hammer vote for a train against Dracula.
I agree with that feels like they had more presence thing, I got the same and was surprised to see so little from Spidy
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
Anyway, KAM doesn't have a shot, DT and Barney are big time doing their own things, and meanwhile Spider-Man is watching all this go down and not participating
Ok found it, feel free to look at my original post for full quote context.

Spidey was on protect Dracula most of D1 but then when it actually was time to do something about they didn't. They were throwing out a strong town read on Drac and hadn't even looked at Prisoner and yet were unwilling to be a thing or hammer vote for a train against Dracula.
Yep. Spidey wanted to protect Drac until it was time to do it in a way that would get attention. First defense of Drac was as far back as #124 and then Drac was in the protect along with Witch.

Anyway, KAM doesn't have a shot, DT and Barney are big time doing their own things, and meanwhile Spider-Man is watching all this go down and not participating.
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
Banana and I have been the only people tracking and tracing these posts from Spider-Man. Most everyone else has either been on something else or just going with the flow. If it hadn't been for me and Banana I don't think it would have even come up except for the "oh why were you off wagon" questions.
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
Which, fine, if you think I'm scum, then I have an agenda. But I don't think Banana is and I don't see anyone else scumreading Banana either. But we see the same trends.
 

Bob Ross

Costume Account
Which, fine, if you think I'm scum, then I have an agenda. But I don't think Banana is and I don't see anyone else scumreading Banana either. But we see the same trends.
Banana was an early voter and believed Dracula was scum, it's difficult to scum read them rn.
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
I notice Dany ain't here in with DEAD AIR DEAD VILLAGER today either though that JS vote was the first real vote movement in a long time.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Vote Count:

Cereal Killer - 7
Bob Ross - Post #758
Spider-Man - Post #778
Minecraft Steve - Post #884
Witch - Post #886 Post #917
Kool-Aid Man - Post #1,116
Barney - Post #1,138
Rey - Post #1,189
Prisoner - Post #1,280

Spider-Man - 7
Cereal Killer - Post #787 Post #862
Zombie - Post #821
Cereal Killer - Post #1,082
Witch - Post #1,105
Banana - Post #1,110
Baby - Post #1,210 Post #1,425
Cinderella - Post #1,244
Jack Sparrow - Post #1,273
Baby - Post #1,466

Jack Sparrow - 1
Cereal Killer - Post #862 Post #1,082
Daenerys Targaryen - Post #1,404
Baby - Post #1,425 Post #1,466

Kool-Aid Man - 1
Barack Obama - Post #1,394

Prisoner - 0
Barack Obama - Post #1,168 Post #1,394

Daenerys Targaryen - 0
Baby - Post #786 Post #1,139
Cinderella - Post #1,026 Post #1,244

Barack Obama - 0
Jack Sparrow - Post #979 Post #1,134

Rey - 0
Kool-Aid Man - Post #870 Post #1,116

Barney - 0
Baby - Post #1,139 Post #1,210
Prisoner - Post #1,179 Post #1,280
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
I have made my case over and over, both for myself and against Spider-Man, who's still not here (but I'd bet lurking). I'm not moving my vote unless someone unrolls ten proofs he's town, so do what you are all gonna.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
No more fancy formatting:

Vote Count:

Cereal Killer - 8
Bob Ross - Post #758
Spider-Man - Post #778
Minecraft Steve - Post #884
Witch - Post #886 Post #917
Kool-Aid Man - Post #1,116
Barney - Post #1,138
Rey - Post #1,189
Prisoner - Post #1,280
Barack Obama

Spider-Man - 7
Cereal Killer - Post #787 Post #862
Zombie - Post #821
Cereal Killer - Post #1,082
Witch - Post #1,105
Banana - Post #1,110
Baby - Post #1,210 Post #1,425
Cinderella - Post #1,244
Jack Sparrow - Post #1,273
Baby - Post #1,466

Jack Sparrow - 1
Cereal Killer - Post #862 Post #1,082
Daenerys Targaryen - Post #1,404
Baby - Post #1,425 Post #1,466
 

Spider-Man

Costume Account
I don't know what else you all want from me. I've been open with my reasoning and reads, just go back to my posts. I've done all I can to convince people, I don't have it in me to do more. So if you scum read me for it I'm sorry and I'll do better next game!
 

Banana

Costume Account
Mr. Obama coming out from damn near being replaced for inactivity with a possible hammer vote, impressive move.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Vote Count:

Cereal Killer - 9
Bob Ross - Post #758
Spider-Man - Post #778
Minecraft Steve - Post #884
Witch - Post #886 Post #917
Kool-Aid Man - Post #1,116
Barney - Post #1,138
Rey - Post #1,189
Prisoner - Post #1,280
Barack Obama - Post #1,473
Daenerys Targaryen - Post #1,482

Spider-Man - 7
Cereal Killer - Post #787 Post #862
Zombie - Post #821
Cereal Killer - Post #1,082
Witch - Post #1,105
Banana - Post #1,110
Baby - Post #1,210 Post #1,425
Cinderella - Post #1,244
Jack Sparrow - Post #1,273
Baby - Post #1,466

Jack Sparrow - 0
Cereal Killer - Post #862 Post #1,082
Daenerys Targaryen - Post #1,404 Post #1,482
Baby - Post #1,425 Post #1,466

Kool-Aid Man - 0
Barack Obama - Post #1,394 Post #1,473

Prisoner - 0
Barack Obama - Post #1,168 Post #1,394

Daenerys Targaryen - 0
Baby - Post #786 Post #1,139
Cinderella - Post #1,026 Post #1,244

Barack Obama - 0
Jack Sparrow - Post #979 Post #1,134

Rey - 0
Kool-Aid Man - Post #870 Post #1,116

Barney - 0
Baby - Post #1,139 Post #1,210
Prisoner - Post #1,179 Post #1,280
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Crowd: Shit, actually I think people are getting taken out covertly. Wow, you know what - that Cereal Killer sure does seem suspicious. Get her!

Cereal Killer has died!

Welcome to Costume Party Mafia!

You are dressed as a Cereal Killer, a Vanilla Townie.

You have no special abilities, but you do have the ability to vote.

You are aligned with Town and win when all threats to Town have been eliminated.

Game thread is HERE

NIGHT 2 BEGINS

Night 2 Ends In:
upq0hjxdv2


Actions are due two hours before lock. The next day phase will probably be extended to 72 hours if you all suck at posting over the weekend. TBD.
 
Last edited:

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Actions are locked. Day will start at the correct time today. For real this time.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Crowd: Okay now hold up. They killed the Banana?! Now you're taking it too far!

Banana has died!


Welcome to Costume Party Mafia!

You are dressed as a Banana, a Vanilla Townie.

You have no special abilities, but you do have the ability to vote.

You are aligned with Town and win when all threats to Town have been eliminated.

Game thread is HERE

DAY 3 BEGINS

Day 3 Ends In:
h45japsbxz


Majority is 8
 
Last edited:

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
You can start, I suck and my fiancé’s family showed up early. We’re babysitting this week (pray for me).
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
Dracula (6 votes)
Banana - 0
Zombie - 0
Bob Ross - 0
Rey - 0
Prisoner - 0
Kool-Aid Man - 0

Prisoner (5 votes)
Barack Obama - 0
Minecraft Steve - 0
Barney - 0
Cinderella - 0
Cereal Killer - 0

Zombie (5 votes)
Baby - 0
Jack Sparrow - 0
Witch - 0
Daenerys Targaryen - 0
Clown - 0

Not much of a pattern here, but late voters on both counters were town.
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
I didn't read anything last night because I'm lazy so that's all I got

Spidy wagon doesn't look like a scum wagon to me because then I'd imagine more overlap with Dracula voters (4/6 Dracula voters were on Cereal) and it was super stable next to a town wagon.
 

Barney

Costume Account
So, I visited Banana on Night 1, and invited him into my chat. Yes, the rumours are right, I have a chat. Sadly it has several restrictions and it's useless now that Banana is death.

I'm not sure if I'm allowed to quote directly, so I'll paraphrase his takes.

-Dany and spiders are his main suspects.
-Claimed vanilla (Something we can now all see)
-Doesn't have a scum read on Prisoner, but the stuff around Prisoner gave him pause.
-Had a negative read on Rey Day 1 but mellowed out Day 2

He really wanted to go against Dany today, and while I personally don't have a case against Spider, he did. So I am looking at those 2 today.
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
So, I visited Banana on Night 1, and invited him into my chat. Yes, the rumours are right, I have a chat. Sadly it has several restrictions and it's useless now that Banana is death.

I'm not sure if I'm allowed to quote directly, so I'll paraphrase his takes.

-Dany and spiders are his main suspects.
-Claimed vanilla (Something we can now all see)
-Doesn't have a scum read on Prisoner, but the stuff around Prisoner gave him pause.
-Had a negative read on Rey Day 1 but mellowed out Day 2

He really wanted to go against Dany today, and while I personally don't have a case against Spider, he did. So I am looking at those 2 today.
Interesting, how does the chat work?
 

Barney

Costume Account
Interesting, how does the chat work?
You don't need to know exactly how, it has some interesting properties, but the theory banana shared with me was really good and now I'm convinced there is a good chance you might be scum.

I do need to build my case, since it's speculation from him, but it made sense.
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
You don't need to know exactly how, it has some interesting properties, but the theory banana shared with me was really good and now I'm convinced there is a good chance you might be scum.

I do need to build my case, since it's speculation from him, but it made sense.
Did you guys crumb it D2?
 
Top Bottom