Costume Party |OT| The Mafia Mash

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Crowd: SURELY THIS WILL DO IT RIGHT
Natiko: *chuckles*

Barack Obama has died!

Please don't arrest me NSA

Welcome to Costume Party Mafia!

You are dressed as Barack Obama, a Vanilla Townie.

You have no special abilities, but you do have the ability to vote.

You are aligned with Town and win when all threats to Town have been eliminated.

Game thread is HERE

Night 7 Ends In:
6ytxpzdrsq


Actions are due 30 minutes before day starts. Yes, this is an abbreviated night. Sue me.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Increasingly Smaller Crowd: Gee, sure am glad Bob Ross slipped just like his teammates! Lets just end this ga-

Someone has died! Their costume has been stolen by the Mafia. The Mafia have left behind the costume of Bob Ross. No role PM will be revealed at this time.

DAY 8 BEGINS

Day 8 Ends:
When majority is reached.

Majority is 3
 

Barney

Costume Account
And this is pretty obvious, but Cinderella can't be Bob Ross, because Cinderella commuted last night.

So that leaves Rey (That didn't say anything the whole night) and Kool-Aid Man.

There is also me, BUT I can prove myself because I still have the chat, and if I was killed Natiko wouldn't have mentioned "Having to close the chat to prepare", or at least I think so. Natiko could have just closed it.

Rey, KAM, get in here.
 

Cinderella

Costume Account
And this is pretty obvious, but Cinderella can't be Bob Ross, because Cinderella commuted last night.

So that leaves Rey (That didn't say anything the whole night) and Kool-Aid Man.

There is also me, BUT I can prove myself because I still have the chat, and if I was killed Natiko wouldn't have mentioned "Having to close the chat to prepare", or at least I think so. Natiko could have just closed it.

Rey, KAM, get in here.
Can u explain whats going on? Bob’s killed himself and is one of you 3 now?
 

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
Wow...
And this is pretty obvious, but Cinderella can't be Bob Ross, because Cinderella commuted last night.

So that leaves Rey (That didn't say anything the whole night) and Kool-Aid Man.

There is also me, BUT I can prove myself because I still have the chat, and if I was killed Natiko wouldn't have mentioned "Having to close the chat to prepare", or at least I think so. Natiko could have just closed it.

Rey, KAM, get in here.
It's late here so I can't be around for long but this makes no sense to me, why wouldn't he also inherit your role with the costume?
 

Barney

Costume Account
Wow...

It's late here so I can't be around for long but this makes no sense to me, why wouldn't he also inherit your role with the costume?
Would he?

Wouldn't that make it really broken? What if he could inherit MS power? I don't think it would be allowed.
 

Barney

Costume Account
I think so although I'm only speculating, the only one that should be 100% cleared unless bullshit role is Cinderella
Spider confirmed that role and then died, 100% cinderella is town. And, if we decide to not lunch today, cinderella is for sure going to be killed tonight.
 

Barney

Costume Account
What really bothers me is that Rey said nothing in the neighbor chat and now has said nothing here now.
 

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
Spider confirmed that role and then died, 100% cinderella is town. And, if we decide to not lunch today, cinderella is for sure going to be killed tonight.
I don't know why but I think you're trying to push some agenda here, if we no lynch why would scum kill? They will probably leave it as is I think
 

Barney

Costume Account
I don't know why but I think you're trying to push some agenda here, if we no lynch why would scum kill? They will probably leave it as is I think
The result is effectively the same, sure, but see it this way:

We need 3 votes for majority

Cinderella votes 1 at random
DeepRoss votes 1 town

That means the other two townies that remain have to both pick the right hammer, while deciding if they follow DeepRoss or not.

Ugh, either way DeepRoss is probably not going to vote until he has a hammer.
 

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
Remember? The whole thing you said when you got introduced as the new Kool-Aid?
Are you smoking something? Let's say I was town that was taken over by scum, you think I can't just look up what you're asking me? I don't think it's you though, I think scum would go for the safest choice, that'd be Rey in my opinion
 

Barney

Costume Account
Are you smoking something? Let's say I was town that was taken over by scum, you think I can't just look up what you're asking me? I don't think it's you though, I think scum would go for the safest choice, that'd be Rey in my opinion
We agree on that, then go ahead and look for it. No need to rush.
 

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
The result is effectively the same, sure, but see it this way:

We need 3 votes for majority

Cinderella votes 1 at random
DeepRoss votes 1 town

That means the other two townies that remain have to both pick the right hammer, while deciding if they follow DeepRoss or not.

Ugh, either way DeepRoss is probably not going to vote until he has a hammer.
Cinderella can be pocketed, scum wants Cinderella around
 

Barney

Costume Account
Are you smoking something? Let's say I was town that was taken over by scum, you think I can't just look up what you're asking me? I don't think it's you though, I think scum would go for the safest choice, that'd be Rey in my opinion
Rey is only the safest option if you take into account that DeepRoss can't inherit my chat. If he can inherit my chat, then I am the safest option.
 

Barney

Costume Account
Also, KAM, it's really weird that you didn't just said your drink flavour now, you really made a whole thing about it... are you still looking for it?
 

Barney

Costume Account
Why is that?
if DeepRoss can inherit my chat then, if town decides to not lunch anyone today so we go to final game of 3, DeepRoss can control the discussion on my chat and use that as proof he is the OG Barney.

Of course this is not true, I am still the OG Barney, but DeepRoss should have considered that and KAM was fast to point it out when I said that I couldn't be DeepRoss because I still have my chat.
 

Barney

Costume Account
And, weirdest theory of all, I think rey slept through the day, night, and now this day.

If Rey starting talking now, how would Rey react?

Would DeepRoss think about how weird would it be for Rey to be chatty now? Would DeepRoss consider Rey when Rey had not posted anything?
 

Cinderella

Costume Account
I don’t think we can make a decision without Rey’s input, if they’re just not gonna talk they’ll get modkilled anyway, which might be the info we need?
 

Cinderella

Costume Account
Maybe we need to set up a quickfire question round, once you’ve said you’re ready you get hit by a question and need to answer within 30 s or something?
 

Barney

Costume Account
Kool 2.0? I don't know if that's what you want.

Maybe we need to set up a quickfire question round, once you’ve said you’re ready you get hit by a question and need to answer within 30 s or something?
I just did.

And I think it's pretty damning.

So, what Kool-Aid Man is saying is that he doesn't remember the flavour of his drink. And that anyone could just go back and figure it out, right?

Well, here is the thing, I do remember it. And I remember it because it didn't happen in the normal chat, it happened in the neighbourizer chat.

KAM made a whole point of introducing himself as a "new better flavour".

And, again, he didn't actually gave a flavour, just said "new". But this person went as far as too change his avatar and his pistol to really get into the role.

But then today's KAM think this was not a big deal? This new KAM think it was something so silly and simple that anyone could go back and look it up?

It was a big deal for the original KAM, it was memorable. The original KAM would be quick to point out "I never said my flavour, I just changed my color to blue" or something like that.

But this new KAM? Nah, the whole thing is unimportant.

I asked a loaded question because the answer was really easy and KAM still couldn't answer it.
 

Barney

Costume Account
Original KAM was trigger happy red.

New KAM was a fun loving guy.

Today's KAM is too busy playing league to answer my questions today.
 

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
Not even gonna wait for Rey to get here?

Why did you decided to change your flavour to blue?

Vote: Kool-Aid Man
I thought I'd give myself a new coat of paint since I swapped, if you want to vote me because I chose fucking blue then go ahead, I'm legit pissed we are going to lose over this bullshit.
 

Barney

Costume Account
I thought I'd give myself a new coat of paint since I swapped, if you want to vote me because I chose fucking blue then go ahead, I'm legit pissed we are going to lose over this bullshit.
I'm not voting you because you choose blue, I'm voting you because you didn't even give yourself the time to properly answer a simple question, and instead just dismissed it as "Anyone could know that if they look back".

It doesn't seem like you care that much on catching scum, you just want this over with.
 

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
Also no I don't want this over with, I just don't want town to lose due to bullshit. What you think is a clear question might not be as clear to someone else, if I were Bob Ross you think I'd forget my predecessor was red? What the fuck are these straw man's arguments, and you expect me to answer instantly after the question? Like I don't have a life?
 

Cinderella

Costume Account
Alright folks, lets take it easy. Can we wait until tomorrow? Its crazy late here and I stayed up just to see the game end. If we wait we’ll here from Rey too, lets sleep on this?
 

Barney

Costume Account
Also no I don't want this over with, I just don't want town to lose due to bullshit. What you think is a clear question might not be as clear to someone else, if I were Bob Ross you think I'd forget my predecessor was red? What the fuck are these straw man's arguments, and you expect me to answer instantly after the question? Like I don't have a life?
But it was just such an obvious question, the answer was "I never gave a drink flavour", because, well, you didn't. It's obvious you didn't. Is blue even a flavour?

But then you instead of saying the obvious answer you pretty much dismissed the question. Because you didn't want to take the time to look back.

Even if you didn't remember, it would be really easy to just check.
 

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
Actually you know what, you said Rey then made up an excuse for it to not be you, then went and made up an excuse to vote me. All the while you wanting to be in the clear. It's you isn't it?
Vote:Barney
 

Barney

Costume Account
Alright folks, lets take it easy. Can we wait until tomorrow? Its crazy late here and I stayed up just to see the game end. If we wait we’ll here from Rey too, lets sleep on this?
You got the hammer vote, we have to wait for you either way.
 

Barney

Costume Account
Actually you know what, you said Rey then made up an excuse for it to not be you, then went and made up an excuse to vote me. All the while you wanting to be in the clear. It's you isn't it?
Vote:Barney
If it was me, why would I be antagonizing you? I can just as easily go along with your Rey vote and wait for Cindy to nail that down.
 

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
But it was just such an obvious question, the answer was "I never gave a drink flavour", because, well, you didn't. It's obvious you didn't. Is blue even a flavour?

But then you instead of saying the obvious answer you pretty much dismissed the question. Because you didn't want to take the time to look back.

Even if you didn't remember, it would be really easy to just check.
That's a trick question because I thought you meant Kool 2.0 or wanted to hear "new and improved"
 

Barney

Costume Account
That's a trick question because I thought you meant Kool 2.0 or wanted to hear "new and improved"
Either answer would be right.

But your answer was pretty much "I can't answer that" because I caught you off-guard, something I don't think would have happened to the real Blue KAM.
 

Cinderella

Costume Account
Is there an easier way to look thru previous posts? On their profile it’s limited, do I have to look back through the thread?
 

Barney

Costume Account
Because it might've been obvious, you don't even know who Cinderella will side with. And when have you called her Cindy before? That's the first time.

I'm sure I have, don't even need to look this up, I just forget sometimes.
Ok "Barney", whatever you say, I'm going to sleep.
I can quote my other times I have said Cindy, I can vaguely recollect when I said stuff, something you seem to not be able to.

I gotta wait to see what Rey has to say, but damn this is the most scum-hunting I have done the whole game.
 

Cinderella

Costume Account
I can quote my other times I have said Cindy, I can vaguely recollect when I said stuff, something you seem to not be able to.

I gotta wait to see what Rey has to say, but damn this is the most scum-hunting I have done the whole game.
Could you go ahead and do that please? Thanks.
 

Barney

Costume Account
Yep, actually, yeah.

It fits, I don't know why cinderella got defensive when spider's claim fits exactly with his role.

No result on night 3 because Cindy commuted.
Positive on night 4 because I visited Cindy.

The fact remains that spider's, mine and cindy's roles all fit and don't contradict each other

And rey didn't move or was targeted on the night that Bob Ross lost his BP, so there was (likely) a shot and Rey was not involved.

So it really is BO vs JS.



It's not a crazy idea, but it's also a very risky play

This is how the voting looked like. Jack was on Rey, you stayed on Prisoner. This and only this is the reason I'll vote Jack over you today, because if there was only two scum's left I wouldn't think a scum player would bus a teammate in such a close race and with that time remaining.

But, borrowing your words, would it be so crazy for the last scum to bus their partner, knowing all cop roles are dead now?
 

Barney

Costume Account
I even mentioned I had Déjà vu. I had to google that back then becuase I was not sure how to spell it.
 

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
I can't sleep, I don't think scum would've done that much homework for this, possible but Barney answered instantly. I was wrong Unvote
 

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
So I guess it's Rey, Barney's set on me, Rey votes me out of self preservation, it takes 3 to hammer. GG scum, you played us good.
 

Rey

Costume Account
I didnt even know i was in the neighbours chat, but looks like it was only open for 6 hours at the time so fuck you if your trying to use that as some gotcha.
 

Rey

Costume Account
wait, why is Barney trying to even use me not posting in the neighbour chat against me when i couldnt have even had my costume stolen then?
if anything thats just consistency.
 
Top Bottom