Verelios
Were-elios
That's the launch magic. WILDCARD.
Spectator Thread Chilling at Neutral Holy Ground
- Thread starter lokiduck
- Start date
Hawthorn
I'll explain my reasons later
My first time as scum, it was me, Sneeks, and GoG, who hasn't been around in a minute, but it was an all-woman mafia team and two of us were first-time scum. We made it without losing anyone.
It was a fine enough moment to bring a tear to the eye.
That sounds pretty awesome :-D
Alexem
Yeah, I'm town
I came so close to working you all out at the end. SO. CLOSE.
We baaaaarely made it out at the end. It was real close all around, but we did it!
Lone_Prodigy
Am I at 10 posts yet?
This was Cluedo Mafia, right? I was voted out the day before despite figuring out scum but no one believed me. Story of my mafia life.
I think scum always feels like that at the end regardless of how close it actually was.
SalvaPot
YEAH
It's just nervewrecking to be scum, that is why I always play as if I'm scum, lol. It's just more fun that way.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
LOL that didn't stop you and Hagi (two of our three newbies) being on the scum team in Nier Mafia :P
You guys did pretty great too.
it was!!
Nah, see above. We were on the brink of getting found out - a mostly new mafia team is pretty hard, haha. But we managed to gamble well on who to push when.
SalvaPot
YEAH
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
*readies the flavor*
RIP TWE.
Only him dying as a master so maybe they could try to work through who is servant might be. I can't believe we haven't gotten more double kills yet, feels setup for scum to get one tonight and potentially put the game in myvo tomorrow if they get another pair during the day.
Only him dying as a master so maybe they could try to work through who is servant might be. I can't believe we haven't gotten more double kills yet, feels setup for scum to get one tonight and potentially put the game in myvo tomorrow if they get another pair during the day.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
LOL I'm also surprised by this too, but town and scum have both been heavily killing servants sooo it happens. Scum does still have a shot at killing a master servant pair I will say though.
Certainly wasn’t me.
This was/is an awesome game Vere/Loki. I couldn’t really dive in until later but the design of the game is great.
Thooooooorn...when I saw you died I was legitimately sad and THEN my investigate got blocked last night when I tried to investigate Stan. I wanted to go as long as possible without claiming or saying anything but I’m pretty sure I left enough breadcrumbs in the last page to indicate something between us had happened.
I scum read you Day 1 but then didn’t really scum read you at all after that but I was kinda forced into my vote unfortunately :/
Lone_Prodigy
Am I at 10 posts yet?
Working off hindsight here but I think regardless of the flip, that was a bad play. Now there's no vote movement and another town will die tonight.
I can understand holding the shot in case you hit a pair early, but when you use it later, you better not miss.
Regardless, I don't think town had much of a chance even without the shot.
I can understand holding the shot in case you hit a pair early, but when you use it later, you better not miss.
Regardless, I don't think town had much of a chance even without the shot.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
RIP
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Tonight is tense guys .-.
If they kill a pair then we are in Lylo. If they kill one player and then town votes out a pair then scum wins. And even if town doesn't vote out a pair they are still in lylo because if scum can get a successful night kill in they win anyways. .-.
Town has to hit a scum member today if they want a chance at winning.
Right now scum is deciding between a master who lost their servant already and the master whose servant is still in the game .-.
Their problem solving on figure out who was paired up despite the no revealing rule is impressive as fuck.
If they kill a pair then we are in Lylo. If they kill one player and then town votes out a pair then scum wins. And even if town doesn't vote out a pair they are still in lylo because if scum can get a successful night kill in they win anyways. .-.
Town has to hit a scum member today if they want a chance at winning.
Right now scum is deciding between a master who lost their servant already and the master whose servant is still in the game .-.
Their problem solving on figure out who was paired up despite the no revealing rule is impressive as fuck.
Last edited:
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Sure why not. Everyone post your final reads!!! We'll go open spoiler when night actions lock me think.
We'll do it sooner if everyone checks in between then.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Based on my math they are in lylo even if they scum only kills one person so why not go open spoilers like I said.
Verelios
Were-elios
You're right, tomorrow is do or die.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
lol I just realized. Because they will be in Lylo all of the remaining town will be vanillas basically.
If Fran uses his shot tonight.
I would love open spoilers. I'm actually super curious.
Verelios
Were-elios
Whew,
Fran
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Scum have one strong man shot and can get another one if they use that one skill tonight. So Fran might as well be vanilla too.
Hawthorn
I'll explain my reasons later
Hi TWE!! I'm sorry you got killed like that :-( Of course I always thought you were town all along.
I would love open spoilers!
My final reads:
Natiko - Town, due to Salva's gambit not really making sense as mafia/mafia
LaunchpadMcQ - Town, TBH partly due to some posts in this thread.
Zipped - town, partly because of his failed plan to use the pair chat numbers
Stan - town, that didn't seem like a mafia power.
Maol - town, Launchpad was right that Maol is more cautious as mafia. His advice on how to stay in the background effectively was pretty formative for me!
Fran - town, just do not see him offering up Jman like that if it was going to be a mafia/town one for one trade.
EzekelRAGE - seems town. I never really got where all the suspicion came from, and he seems to be getting more annoyed than I would expect from mafia.
So, eliminating all my town reads leaves me with the very idea we all said would be so cool: the scum team of all newbies + Salva. I hope it's true!
I would love open spoilers!
My final reads:
Natiko - Town, due to Salva's gambit not really making sense as mafia/mafia
LaunchpadMcQ - Town, TBH partly due to some posts in this thread.
Zipped - town, partly because of his failed plan to use the pair chat numbers
Stan - town, that didn't seem like a mafia power.
Maol - town, Launchpad was right that Maol is more cautious as mafia. His advice on how to stay in the background effectively was pretty formative for me!
Fran - town, just do not see him offering up Jman like that if it was going to be a mafia/town one for one trade.
EzekelRAGE - seems town. I never really got where all the suspicion came from, and he seems to be getting more annoyed than I would expect from mafia.
So, eliminating all my town reads leaves me with the very idea we all said would be so cool: the scum team of all newbies + Salva. I hope it's true!
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
it's nice being able to edit lol.
Verelios
Were-elios
Yeah, he needs to hold off tonight and save it for tomorrow
Verelios
Were-elios
It felt scary at first, then good, and then powerful.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
True... But again a certain person is planning on using their shot tonight which means the strong man is getting a second shot so it doesn't matter. Basically, if town doesn't kill scum today and it comes down to the NK, if he has that shot we can just end the game at day end. Especially if Fran uses his last shot tonight.
Verelios
Were-elios
No consecutive shots =p
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I don't know what you mean? If M uses their shot then S gets another Strong man shot tomorrow night, this means that S will have access a strong man shot both nights making what fran does moot. If M doesn't use their shot then S will only have one shot which may save the day tomorrow, but if Fran uses his shot then it doesn't even matter.
I still have no idea who is scum. Right now, FateShirou is one of my big scum reads, thanks to how opportunistically he latched onto the misconception that he was my partner. That is a cunning move that belies his rookie facade.
The fact that zipped has played along has given me some pause, but I don't think my partner is scum.
I've scum read Maol all game, but I can't really back that up with anything other than a gut instinct. My gut instincts are terrible, but that's all I have to go on.
I would say Stan is scum, but I am pretty confident that an override wouldn't be a scum role. Not unless scum can steal powers.
I don't think HPSauce is scum. I just think HP is a struggling newbie townie.
Fran's out.
That leaves Natiko, Ephidel, and Zeke? Out of those, I lean town on Zeke. His single-minded tunnel on me, like a crocodile biting down on its prey, felt like genuine town.
Ephidel is good, so I can't say that I can read her alignment at all. I give her 50/50.
Natiko is the remaining 50/50 by process of elimination.
The fact that zipped has played along has given me some pause, but I don't think my partner is scum.
I've scum read Maol all game, but I can't really back that up with anything other than a gut instinct. My gut instincts are terrible, but that's all I have to go on.
I would say Stan is scum, but I am pretty confident that an override wouldn't be a scum role. Not unless scum can steal powers.
I don't think HPSauce is scum. I just think HP is a struggling newbie townie.
Fran's out.
That leaves Natiko, Ephidel, and Zeke? Out of those, I lean town on Zeke. His single-minded tunnel on me, like a crocodile biting down on its prey, felt like genuine town.
Ephidel is good, so I can't say that I can read her alignment at all. I give her 50/50.
Natiko is the remaining 50/50 by process of elimination.
Agree with Thorn on all of this except maybe maol and stan (though I think stan could be neutral now). If only we were able to live on together...
Verelios
Were-elios
It takes a true one to not leave their partner behind, and you guys beat those odds.
Hawthorn
I'll explain my reasons later
And here are my final pair guesses (some cheating because people said in spec XD):
Stan - Natiko (town servant / town master)
Launchpad - Salva (town servant/mafia master)
SkyOdin - Zipped (town servant/town master)
Maol - HP (town servant/mafia master)
Zeke - Ephi (town/mafia, IDK which is the servant)
Weemad - FateShirou (town servant / mafia master)
Stan - Natiko (town servant / town master)
Launchpad - Salva (town servant/mafia master)
SkyOdin - Zipped (town servant/town master)
Maol - HP (town servant/mafia master)
Zeke - Ephi (town/mafia, IDK which is the servant)
Weemad - FateShirou (town servant / mafia master)
Hawthorn
I'll explain my reasons later
If only we didn't suspect each other so much! But I think we worked together pretty well even so
I didn't ever suspect you until Launch used that 2nd vote haha then I was...concerned. We did work well together. Wish I had better reads for you.
Lone_Prodigy
Am I at 10 posts yet?
I think it would be appropriate for the game to end the same way it started: with a double kill.
Not salty.
Not salty.
Lone_Prodigy
Am I at 10 posts yet?
I'll be honest though I'm just half following along and have no idea who's paired and who's scum.
I'm pretty confident that Fran, Zeke, and Stan are town though.
I'm pretty confident that Fran, Zeke, and Stan are town though.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Well a double pair may die tonight, but we'll see.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
:I Scum just submitted the kill and it's on the master whose servant is still alive. Everyone should give them a warm congratulations when they get here (if the scum team doesn't change their mind) because...
THEY ARE THE LAST PURE TOWN TEAM IN THE GAME AND LASTED THE LONGEST OUT OF ALL OUR TEAMS \o/
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Okay everyone. Submit final thoughts on the scum team and who you think is partnered up if you got them. I'm going to get up an hour before day start, but when I have the chance we will open this thread up to open spoilers. Maybe even with welcoming the newly dead to the thread lol.
Verelios
Were-elios
Yep, scum won their gamble tonight. I've been super impressed by their ability to parse pair reads this game, just phenomenal.
Verelios
Were-elios
There is one path to life for town if they grab it, but they have to be pretty united to do so.
well, RIP, we're bad at that
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
With how deepwolf Nat was, I was def kind of hoping/wondering if town would kill Shirou and thus Natiko it'd be kind of hilarious lol especially since it'd open up Zeke to suspicion as well. XD
If only Stan had killed him man. XD
But oh well. We'll see how town handles today. This is literally their final chance to stay in the game. If not it's over.
Ephidel
How do you do, fellow mafia?
Firstly I would like to apologise to my partner for being an idiot.
Secondly I would like to apologise to town for being an idiot.
Thirdly I would like to apologise to TWE for being an idiot.
... Fourthly I would like to thank Stan for making my dreams of TWE's death come true.
Hello everyone
Hawthorn
I'll explain my reasons later
Wow, I was completely wrong!! Pretty good job staying in the shadows there mafia team :-D
Ephi! I'm sorry I scum read you so hard. I was fairly confident you were the one who roleblocked me last night after having targeted you so much. I was wrong :(
Fanto
Confirmed Town
And since spoilers are out now, FateShirou is who I was mentoring.
When I found out I was going to be mentoring, at first I was like, "Ok, time to get these old Obi-Wan robes on again!"
And then Fate said he rolled Scum, and I was like "Welp, time to put on the Palpatine robes instead I guess!"
When I found out I was going to be mentoring, at first I was like, "Ok, time to get these old Obi-Wan robes on again!"
And then Fate said he rolled Scum, and I was like "Welp, time to put on the Palpatine robes instead I guess!"
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Scum have been playing amazingly well this game, it's been hard for me to not root for them even without my connection to the team. Like, reading D1 while knowing that Natiko and Zeke were Scum together was an absolute trip, Oscar worthy shit from those two, just ridiculously good Scum players that everyone should take notes from.
Verelios
Were-elios
Absolutely. Scum gave a masterclass performance this game and it's amazing when seeing how many times they've walked a fine line of over bussing.
Yeah, zipped is lying. I was his partner. I think zipped really is under the mistaken idea that town still has a day before Lylo and is trying to throw off the scum kill.
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
Listen when i say "imma fuck it up" i mean it.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
No Kill tying with a Scum player on D1 was the most *chef's kiss* D1 for Town in this community that I could ever have imagined.
I feel like I've been taught a lesson that no kill is bad
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
Sorry i got us super murdered Ephi
