Scooby Doo 2: Mafia Unleashed - This time there are costumes!

Status
Not open for further replies.

San Franpsycho

Costume Account (She/Her)
Can we talk now? I still have so much I want to say

Lol thank you San. Even if you fooled me I appreciate all the advice you gave me throughout the game.
I'm really glad you came to play and I hope you succeed in finding some balance. I struggle a lot with that (obviously) so while I love the game, my solution has to be not playing often.

I am sorry for my Sorian cosplay. I had a whole silly plan after I rolled mafia and it just got shattered, but it was a bad plan in the first place. I hate rolling mafia and I am very glad it is over. These last many days were so so tense.
 

BooBeard

Costume Account (He/Him)
I'm really glad you came to play and I hope you succeed in finding some balance. I struggle a lot with that (obviously) so while I love the game, my solution has to be not playing often.

I am sorry for my Sorian cosplay. I had a whole silly plan after I rolled mafia and it just got shattered, but it was a bad plan in the first place. I hate rolling mafia and I am very glad it is over. These last many days were so so tense.
Thank you, I hope I can find some balance. I think I need to just take it a bit less seriously and step away more. I'm not gonna play the immediate next game, I think Fate/Mafia 2 is the second next one so I'll have a bit of a break
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I thought one of Pazzo and San would be scum but I didn't want to bet on both of them being, so great job. Y'all are pros and now I will never trust you again
You really should never trust them.


ghostcop.png


They cost you the game. If you and them had voted out Sparks you would have won too.
 
Player identities:

Lightning Strikes was jman1954goat
Technicolor Phantom was LP
The Ghost of Stealin' Stan was Hawthorn
Scooby Snack Monster was LaunchpadMcQ
Frankenstein was AllThingsPurple
Wax Phantom was Sparkster
Hyde Monster was The Bear
Spooky Space Kook was Ketkat
Ghost Bear was Zippedpinhead
Alien was HPSauce
Anthos was rac
Captain Skunkbeard was A Wild Ambulance Appears and was replaced by Weemadarthur
Neon Phantom was Ephidel
Baba Yaga was Yuta
Snow Ghost was Kyanrute
Cat Creature was Fanto
Snow Creature was Bojack Horseman
Gnome was Chuggernaut
Char Gar Gothakon was Geno
Pazzo the Ghost Clown was Natiko
San Franpsycho was Dr. Monkey
Woodsman was malus
BooBeard was Randomless (NEW)
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Is this true? My wincon says I need to be last alive though...
It's how neutral Ephi one MGS lol.

If scum had voted out sparks and then not killed you during the night, they would have won leaving you as the last one standing and you would have won.
 

BooBeard

Costume Account (He/Him)
It's how neutral Ephi one MGS lol.

If scum had voted out sparks and then not killed you during the night, they would have won leaving you as the last one standing and you would have won.
Oh well that's lame. I'm still happy I just made it this far. My goal was really to live past Night 1 so making it to endgame was plenty of experience.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Oh well that's lame. I'm still happy I just made it this far. My goal was really to live past Night 1 so making it to endgame was plenty of experience.
LOL I was rooting for you all game and you really had a chance at victory but it got swiped from you at the last second. :<

You did great tho :D Basically the main thing against you was you didn't burn scum, but aside from that it was a really impressive first game for you!
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Player identities:

Lightning Strikes was jman1954goat
Technicolor Phantom was LP
The Ghost of Stealin' Stan was Hawthorn
Scooby Snack Monster was LaunchpadMcQ
Frankenstein was AllThingsPurple
Wax Phantom was Sparkster
Hyde Monster was The Bear
Spooky Space Kook was Ketkat
Ghost Bear was Zippedpinhead
Alien was HPSauce
Anthos was rac
Captain Skunkbeard was A Wild Ambulance Appears and was replaced by Weemadarthur
Neon Phantom was Ephidel
Baba Yaga was Yuta
Snow Ghost was Kyanrute
Cat Creature was Fanto
Snow Creature was Bojack Horseman
Gnome was Chuggernaut
Char Gar Gothakon was Geno
Pazzo the Ghost Clown was Natiko
San Franpsycho was Dr. Monkey
Woodsman was malus
BooBeard was Randomless (NEW)
OH GOD ANTHOS WAS RAC?
BRB THROWING MYSELF OFF A BUILDING

Also, KET!!
I NEVER would have guessed Kyan.
 
If boobeard had survived today scum could have let him kill one of them off, allowing both factions to win (I would have used a fast forward to make it more bearable)
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Was it you natiko or both who called my bluff.


I sent you s reset era message but I will say again GG

You and Pazzo played really well it was inspiring.
Neither - we expected to whiff it but then we knew we could get you the next night. You did great. Don't be so down on yourself, btw.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I'm massively upset Boo lost, but congrats scum team :p You on my shit list forever Monkey and Natiko but you played great.

It was fun again seeing a game where I knew the set up from being the reviewer, but now who was what costume and only what i remembered of the roles.

I remembered most of the scum team and especially remembered Boo was Scrappy but it was a lot of fun on that end.

I found it hilarious Natiko insisted that there wouldn't be a player guessing role considering it was his role, but also because I was a bit worried about that in review and Aeleus joked about having me as a special scum meta guide if the player that rolled that role was a newbie. XD
 

BooBeard

Costume Account (He/Him)
Oh I can read the other chats with this account now

I need to get myself a real outermafia account though
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I will read all the things later. I am wiped out and now very late making dinner.

I'm gonna say something, though, that I think needs to be said to @Nomad Sparkster/ @Wax Phantom:
If you just want to holler about the game, please just hang out in spec. You were a confirmed town and your presence should have changed the entire game, but you have to read and participate. We were absolutely able to exploit your inattention to the game and it's not fair to anyone. Please. Pay attention and play or replace out and go to spec.
 

Nomad Sparkster

This is some wild shit maynard
I will read all the things later. I am wiped out and now very late making dinner.

I'm gonna say something, though, that I think needs to be said to @Nomad Sparkster/ @Wax Phantom:
If you just want to holler about the game, please just hang out in spec. You were a confirmed town and your presence should have changed the entire game, but you have to read and participate. We were absolutely able to exploit your inattention to the game and it's not fair to anyone. Please. Pay attention and play or replace out and go to spec.
Fucken costume games can't do them on my phone

You're right but also I was not made for the long game

also it hot outside
 

Nomad Sparkster

This is some wild shit maynard
Boy I need to stop doing these bastard/costume games or just general fucking mafia games

because I never pay attention and it gets too long and I forget Im so much better* at ONUW

*(relatively)
 

Nomad Sparkster

This is some wild shit maynard
Woof might need some mentorship or something again this sucks

There needs to be something with lovers or masons but that's gonna be bastard as hell
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Fucken costume games can't do them on my phone

You're right but also I was not made for the long game

also it hot outside
You knew all of this before you signed up. It’s summer. It’s hot. You will be in a costume account. You made a choice. And then you stayed in. We have a system if you can’t play- you replace out.

Please have a little basic respect for the other people who sign up. For the game runner and the game watchers.
 

Nomad Sparkster

This is some wild shit maynard
Seriously Im not made for long games


There's only so much time and brainspace I can give to mafia before everything gets on fire
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Seriously Im not made for long games


There's only so much time and brainspace I can give to mafia before everything gets on fire
Then as Monkey is suggesting, replace out in cases where you feel you've reached your stopping point and can't play anymore.

It's what the replacement system is partly there for.
 

Nomad Sparkster

This is some wild shit maynard
In so many ways this hurts way worse then MGS redux because it is my actual fault

I literally don't want to play another mafia game until someone can set my brain straight
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
@lokiduck since your a reviewer what's your thoughts on how the game played out?

What went different or similar to how you imagine?
Honestly i was mostly concerned about if a newer player got the player guessing role, but since they were on a scum team I figured also they'd have back up to help with that.

Since it was Natiko there wasn't an issue there.

I don't remember what else really happened in review. To be honest, a lot of my review style is mostly keeping the game the way the maker wants it, and just pointing out any concerns I have if they come up. This game was largely Aeleus' baby with little involvement from me except for wanting the Harlem Globetrotters, and ultimately my only goal was making the game balanced which is what most reviewers want.
 
With the game over I'd problably have made scooby just a multishot switcher rather than a JOAT to push for more risky switch usage (and thus more likely to be quasi strong kills like I had hoped for)

I also would have made the doctor and backup doctor not be able to self target, though that didn't come into play this game.
 

Lightning Strikes

Costume Account (He/Him)
Honestly i was mostly concerned about if a newer player got the player guessing role, but since they were on a scum team I figured also they'd have back up to help with that.

Since it was Natiko there wasn't an issue there.

I don't remember what else really happened in review. To be honest, a lot of my review style is mostly keeping the game the way the maker wants it, and just pointing out any concerns I have if they come up. This game was largely Aeleus' baby with little involvement from me except for wanting the Harlem Globetrotters, and ultimately my only goal was making the game balanced which is what most reviewers want.
Interesting.

@Aeleus same question to you.


How did the game go for you?

Outcomes that surprised you?

Favorite moments?

Would you change anything about design in hindsight?
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
no one but us and 30 foot shaggy can post until boards are made public but well done scum!

shame on you for not helping boo beard out
He didn’t want to join the Wax vote! He spent all of his game end continually talking about helping town! You gotta know when to reach out to the dark side instead when you’re a neutral lol

Was it you natiko or both who called my bluff.


I sent you s reset era message but I will say again GG

You and Pazzo played really well it was inspiring.
I think I commented in scum chat that I could see you bluffing because of how insistent you were that you were self protecting that night, but we were always going to just shoot you twice to be safe. With your claim as it was we assumed anywhere we could shoot that we would WANT to shoot would get blocked.

I'm massively upset Boo lost, but congrats scum team :p You on my shit list forever Monkey and Natiko but you played great.

It was fun again seeing a game where I knew the set up from being the reviewer, but now who was what costume and only what i remembered of the roles.

I remembered most of the scum team and especially remembered Boo was Scrappy but it was a lot of fun on that end.

I found it hilarious Natiko insisted that there wouldn't be a player guessing role considering it was his role, but also because I was a bit worried about that in review and Aeleus joked about having me as a special scum meta guide if the player that rolled that role was a newbie. XD
Yeah I absolutely gaslit Jman with that my bad dude lol

Well the mass claim certainly didn't help. All it led to was you dying and Sparks not healing anyone lol.
To be fair I had already used my power on Jman and knew he was the doctor. We were always going to be shooting there in short order.

Boy I need to stop doing these bastard/costume games or just general fucking mafia games

because I never pay attention and it gets too long and I forget Im so much better* at ONUW

*(relatively)
Look, Sparks, I genuinely try and give you the benefit of the doubt ever since we were partners in Love Boat 2. You can’t just keep using excuses everytime you join a game and then check out. You’re sitting here saying how you need a mentor but you were literally a mason with a confirmed town player to work with and you still did absolutely nothing. My man, you did so so little that I didn’t even want to believe it was actually you because I expect better than this. For awhile there it felt like you were slowly getting the hang of things, but lately it’s been a steep downward turn. You need to really look inward and figure out why it is that you aren’t putting literally any effort into the games, and determine if that can change or if you should stick to ONUW, mini mafia, and spec. When game designers pour a ton of effort into a game and it gets disrespected by completely checking out it really sucks for them. I can say that as someone that watched you completely give up on Metal Gear Solid Redux.

—————

Great game Ael, thanks for running it! Was my first ever costume game and I really enjoyed it even if I felt obligated to not fuck around too much with costume stuff since I was mafia. Wanted to give praise to my fellow scummates of course for being ride or dies. Kyan was killing it as Snow Ghost and I never would’ve guessed that was you. Ketkat and Bojack were another two I never would’ve guessed. Of course big thanks to Boo for clearing the path for us to snatch victory from the jaws of defeat. Sorry we didn’t get you the win, being a neutral is a lot of playing both sides - gotta know when to make the heel turn.
 

BooBeard

Costume Account (He/Him)
He didn’t want to join the Wax vote! He spent all of his game end continually talking about helping town! You gotta know when to reach out to the dark side instead when you’re a neutral lol

Of course big thanks to Boo for clearing the path for us to snatch victory from the jaws of defeat. Sorry we didn’t get you the win, being a neutral is a lot of playing both sides - gotta know when to make the heel turn.
"You win when you have killed 3 players, this must include at least one member of the mafia faction. If you have not achieved this condition when all mafia are dead you will instead win if you are the only player alive."

I'm sorry I didn't know the rules based on this wincon? Like, what?
 

Neki

Bought a book once
"You win when you have killed 3 players, this must include at least one member of the mafia faction. If you have not achieved this condition when all mafia are dead you will instead win if you are the only player alive."

I'm sorry I didn't know the rules based on this wincon? Like, what?

When mafia win they exit the game so technically you are the only player alive. Players exiting based on their win conditions is weird to me still and it is especially for newer players.
 

BooBeard

Costume Account (He/Him)
When mafia win they exit the game so technically you are the only player alive. Players exiting based on their win conditions is weird to me still and it is especially for newer players.
Mafia scum wiki did not prepare me for this, and believe me I looked
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Yeah I'll stick with spec for the rest of the season

uh @Natiko do I have you on steam?
That’s a good first step, but that doesn’t mean next season you just go back to the status quo of joining games and then not playing. I’m sure getting criticized so harshly sucks, but when you put no effort in that’s bound to be the outcome. I don’t think I have you on Steam, no.

"You win when you have killed 3 players, this must include at least one member of the mafia faction. If you have not achieved this condition when all mafia are dead you will instead win if you are the only player alive."

I'm sorry I didn't know the rules based on this wincon? Like, what?
Don’t get me wrong Boo - I’m not trying to disparage your play! I thought you did really well. I mean you turned around an almost D1 death and made it all the way to endgame. You deserve a ton of kudos. I’ve been in your shoes before as a neutral trying to navigate to the end, I was just mentioning it as something to consider should you face this scenario again in the future. At game end you opted to go with there just being 0-1 mafia left, but if you had stuck to thinking two you could’ve just open wolfed with us. Sorry if you thought I was being harsh. I thought you really did well.
 
To be completely clear @BooBeard was considered a threat to mafia so they couldn't win while he was alive.

However given there were two of them he could of killed one and won (thus leaving the game), leaving the remaining scum the last player and also winning.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Mafia scum wiki did not prepare me for this, and believe me I looked
To be very specific we didn’t need to exit the game. It was 1-2-1 at the end. We as mafia completely controlled the vote. Monkey and I were unkillable by day voting at that juncture. The three of us could have voted no kill, then you douse one of us while we shoot Wax, next day is 2-1 and we no vote again, you ignite and exit and one mafia remains to win for our faction.
 

Nomad Sparkster

This is some wild shit maynard
That’s a good first step, but that doesn’t mean next season you just go back to the status quo of joining games and then not playing. I’m sure getting criticized so harshly sucks, but when you put no effort in that’s bound to be the outcome. I don’t think I have you on Steam, no.

Put me on spec thread in definitely
 

BooBeard

Costume Account (He/Him)
To be completely clear @BooBeard was considered a threat to mafia so they couldn't win while he was alive.

However given there were two of them he could of killed one and won (thus leaving the game), leaving the remaining scum the last player and also winning.
Right this is exactly what I thought okay

I had no chance then as soon as I doused Skunkbeard. I should've doused Pazzo (Natiko) instead lol. No regrets then
 

BooBeard

Costume Account (He/Him)
Don’t get me wrong Boo - I’m not trying to disparage your play! I thought you did really well. I mean you turned around an almost D1 death and made it all the way to endgame. You deserve a ton of kudos. I’ve been in your shoes before as a neutral trying to navigate to the end, I was just mentioning it as something to consider should you face this scenario again in the future. At game end you opted to go with there just being 0-1 mafia left, but if you had stuck to thinking two you could’ve just open wolfed with us. Sorry if you thought I was being harsh. I thought you really did well.
Thanks, I will keep it in mind going forward. You did come off a little harsh :P
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
The most important thing is that now it won't just be me that votes for Monkey at the start of every game...

Congrats to Scum, even the ones who were meanie doodoo heads, they know who they are. Well played, twas a fun game!

Thank you to Aeleus for hosting, especially with the excruciating work of hand counting all the votes, not an easy or fun task at all, so major props to you, it was a very fun and well designed game and you ran it very smoothly! <3
 

BooBeard

Costume Account (He/Him)
I didn't know I counted as a threat to Mafia though, so that will be useful information going forward. Is that true of all neutrals or only ones with killing roles?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom