Scum Thread Cluedo Mafia Private chat
- Thread starter Android Sophia
- Start date
Yeah. He has had eyes on us a few times. Plus I'm really worried he is a PR so a lynching works out better.
I'm at a family party right now so trying to keep up posting but my crazy gran is hasselling me
I'm at a family party right now so trying to keep up posting but my crazy gran is hasselling me
Sawneeks
little green dog
also just a heads up for you both, not sure if I'll be posting anything in the thread yet. wanted to come in and check on how things were going but I've still got to get ready for my day and possibly leave pretty soon.
if anything i'll be back in like 40-ish minutes and I'll be around for the last hour but we'll see.
if anything i'll be back in like 40-ish minutes and I'll be around for the last hour but we'll see.
He voted for himself
Nuff said
Nuff said
Monkey, he's now now decided that you, me, Rats and Alexem are his winged monkeys. (Bad reference, sorry)
I don't even have a sassy response for this
I don't even have a sassy response for this
Oh god, he just told someone to "vote with me and GoG". He just talked like we're chums.
HE HAS JUST TAKEN ME HOSTAGE.
HE HAS JUST TAKEN ME HOSTAGE.
There's no way I can respond to it without looking bad
He's telling Rats and I to move our votes to consolidate but I scrutinised someone for moving vote so I wouldn't be shifting anyway. Plus I did a stubborn little "I won't shift my vote because I've been told to" post earlier so I actually can't or I'll be called out. Seems like I'll be just keeping my head down
Fuck fuck fuck. How awful do we look if I switch to him to save you?
Ah Fran. I could hug you
Holy shit that was intense. And now immensely satisfying that he's gone.
Going to fun to see Muffin's response to untying a tie that wasn't actually a tie.
Also I'm sitting at a family party as my aunt's fiancé does an impromptu saxophone solo and I'm yelling "YEEESSSS THE FUCKER IS GONE"
Wee brother turns to me and just goes "Neeeeeeerrrrrd"
Going to fun to see Muffin's response to untying a tie that wasn't actually a tie.
Also I'm sitting at a family party as my aunt's fiancé does an impromptu saxophone solo and I'm yelling "YEEESSSS THE FUCKER IS GONE"
Wee brother turns to me and just goes "Neeeeeeerrrrrd"
No powers.
What a bullshit merchant he was
What a bullshit merchant he was
Hahahahahahahahaha
Arrested Development gifs are the bests
I'M ALSO GLAD
In all fairness, we are all nerrrrrrrds, but they don't get to say it. Also yes, Muffin is going to be VERY exploitable.
Sawneeks
little green dog
<3
alright, i'm going to go eat too much food and fall into a coma. i'll catch up and give some more thoughts but top of my head now that Deva is dead we should kill: Rats, Grizzly, or Wizard.
aka Top Townies. Rats/Grizzly possible PR, I'm leaning that way. Mostly Rats since I doubt people Scum Read him after Deva flipped Town.
alright, i'm going to go eat too much food and fall into a coma. i'll catch up and give some more thoughts but top of my head now that Deva is dead we should kill: Rats, Grizzly, or Wizard.
aka Top Townies. Rats/Grizzly possible PR, I'm leaning that way. Mostly Rats since I doubt people Scum Read him after Deva flipped Town.
Go enjoy your Thanksgiving folks. I am all for a Wizard kill too. Think that's a good way to go.
Android Sophia
Miss Congeniality
Happy Thanksgiving. I'm stuffing my face too. >.>
Sawneeks
little green dog
Anyway, aaallll caught up now with the shenanigans that happened.
Good news is, you two did an absolutely fantastic job at the end of the Day there. Most people really like your insightful posts Gotham and aren't worried about you at all. Monkey ran in and started kicking chairs over and picking a fight with Deva AND looked calm and Townie while doing it. You're both in perfect spots right now and, barring anything crazy happening, I doubt either of you get much flak in the coming Day phases and can go on without much worry.
BAD news is, I could see myself getting lynched because of all of this. Muffin, Fran, and even Zook/LP are likely to bite it before I do but I have a feeling with Deva flipping Town there's going to be more scrutiny against those he scumread for a while and the other lynch candidate. With Thanksgiving out of the way I'm free to devote time to this and hopefully argue out any accusations, but there's just enough people who are willing to kill me based on Meta ( Muffin, LP, Alexem ) that I worry.
but i also tend to over-worry as scum so take that as you will
i do think though that Gotham needs to do the kill again. I doubt Town has a Jailer, but a Roleblock is always possible and I have a feeling something may be on me tonight. We can use the Ninja if we feel it's necessary but I do like Doggo's plan of using a different weapon so we don't give Town hints that they break until we absolutely HAVE to.
Good news is, you two did an absolutely fantastic job at the end of the Day there. Most people really like your insightful posts Gotham and aren't worried about you at all. Monkey ran in and started kicking chairs over and picking a fight with Deva AND looked calm and Townie while doing it. You're both in perfect spots right now and, barring anything crazy happening, I doubt either of you get much flak in the coming Day phases and can go on without much worry.
BAD news is, I could see myself getting lynched because of all of this. Muffin, Fran, and even Zook/LP are likely to bite it before I do but I have a feeling with Deva flipping Town there's going to be more scrutiny against those he scumread for a while and the other lynch candidate. With Thanksgiving out of the way I'm free to devote time to this and hopefully argue out any accusations, but there's just enough people who are willing to kill me based on Meta ( Muffin, LP, Alexem ) that I worry.
but i also tend to over-worry as scum so take that as you will
i do think though that Gotham needs to do the kill again. I doubt Town has a Jailer, but a Roleblock is always possible and I have a feeling something may be on me tonight. We can use the Ninja if we feel it's necessary but I do like Doggo's plan of using a different weapon so we don't give Town hints that they break until we absolutely HAVE to.
Sawneeks
little green dog
Having seen everything now I'm not against killing Wizard or Rats. Bear/Alexem as back ups.
Wizard seems to be the only one thinking into what the NKs mean so if we kill him we don't have to worry much about the meta-analysis of it. Also unlikely to be lynched and very very insightful. Does Town Read most of us though, sans Doggo/Monkey and that's only because of some leftover fear of Doggo.
It's more of a gut feeling, but I don't think Town will buy trying to kill Rats after Deva flips Town. They'll likely buy that it was a Town v Town fight after that and we'd have to take out Rats at some point. There's also the possibility he's a PR but I wonder if he's playing that up to attract a NK because he's Ordinary.
Bear is easily going to be mislynch fodder if he isn't replaced. Prey on Town's fear that him just dropping stuff and leaving is just Scummy or something. He's just one of those people I can see jumping in here and clearing things up if he gets active again. Also PR possible, though that's more based on Deva's analysis of him.
Alexem is in this 'middle of the pack' area and could still be lynched but isn't on the chopping block yet. He is in this weird spot where he REALLY wants Muffin or myself gone because he believes one of us influenced the other on Alfred ( he's kinda right, but I just wanted Muffin off of LP and not onto Alfred :p ) and will likely pursue that tomorrow.
I think if I had to rank the kill list it would be: Wizard > Rats >>>>>> Alexem > Bear
Wizard seems to be the only one thinking into what the NKs mean so if we kill him we don't have to worry much about the meta-analysis of it. Also unlikely to be lynched and very very insightful. Does Town Read most of us though, sans Doggo/Monkey and that's only because of some leftover fear of Doggo.
It's more of a gut feeling, but I don't think Town will buy trying to kill Rats after Deva flips Town. They'll likely buy that it was a Town v Town fight after that and we'd have to take out Rats at some point. There's also the possibility he's a PR but I wonder if he's playing that up to attract a NK because he's Ordinary.
Bear is easily going to be mislynch fodder if he isn't replaced. Prey on Town's fear that him just dropping stuff and leaving is just Scummy or something. He's just one of those people I can see jumping in here and clearing things up if he gets active again. Also PR possible, though that's more based on Deva's analysis of him.
Alexem is in this 'middle of the pack' area and could still be lynched but isn't on the chopping block yet. He is in this weird spot where he REALLY wants Muffin or myself gone because he believes one of us influenced the other on Alfred ( he's kinda right, but I just wanted Muffin off of LP and not onto Alfred :p ) and will likely pursue that tomorrow.
I think if I had to rank the kill list it would be: Wizard > Rats >>>>>> Alexem > Bear
Sounds good to me. My biggest concern is that you and I are now prime targets for investigation. You due to meta and almost being lynched and me as a loud replacement. I don't think a kill on the wizard would be tracked so I'm fine with not ninjaing that. Getting red checked is my greatest fear. I'm not a great liar in mafia!
Good news is I said something about being worried if the vote cleared off of Muffin and lo they ALL moved. I can exploit that.
Good news is I said something about being worried if the vote cleared off of Muffin and lo they ALL moved. I can exploit that.
I think I'll really harp on two things: the combination of Neeks getting introduced as a last minute wagon and everyone flipping off Muffin, especially Fran. There could be a Neeks-Muffin-Fran team - Fran wouldn't vote for Neeks, but Muffin has, but not for any good reason - maybe they knew they'd all flip off Muffin or Neeks lynches to Deva and hope to gain town cred? Alternately it could be Muffin-Fran-Zook/maybe Griz? I think if I say it could be Neeks but then talk about the pushing of Neeks as an alternative with Deva, it was done to save people jumping to Zook. So I shade Neeks but then clear her.
I'm sorry ladies. I'm at a wedding just now so will have to catch up tonight or tomorrow morning.
Sawneeks
little green dog
No worries, Gotham! Enjoy the wedding and festivities. :>
On Red Checks, if I had to make a Gut Call I don't think there is a Cop or, if there is, it's not a traditional one. For the same reason I doubt a Vig or Extra Kill, we have 0 defense against those type of Roles. The most we have for a Defense is a Strong Kill for a Doc ( and Terra is dead ) and a Ninja for some sort of Watcher/Tracker and even then those are only 1-Shots whereas the Town Doc was infinite. We're both a strong Scum Team and not that Strong in relation to Town, it's a really nicely done balance. If Town does have extra roles I don't think it would be something incredibly strong against us. Also, I've never been red checked ( knock on wood ), but if you are I've seen that the best strategy is to NOT give up and to fight it. You are Town, so if someone Red Checks you there is a mistake and you don't want Town to mislynch you.
On Red Checks, if I had to make a Gut Call I don't think there is a Cop or, if there is, it's not a traditional one. For the same reason I doubt a Vig or Extra Kill, we have 0 defense against those type of Roles. The most we have for a Defense is a Strong Kill for a Doc ( and Terra is dead ) and a Ninja for some sort of Watcher/Tracker and even then those are only 1-Shots whereas the Town Doc was infinite. We're both a strong Scum Team and not that Strong in relation to Town, it's a really nicely done balance. If Town does have extra roles I don't think it would be something incredibly strong against us. Also, I've never been red checked ( knock on wood ), but if you are I've seen that the best strategy is to NOT give up and to fight it. You are Town, so if someone Red Checks you there is a mistake and you don't want Town to mislynch you.
Sawneeks
little green dog
Also, that sounds good. I was going to say that introducing a team of myself-Fran-Muffin means the likely first lynch there to confirm the Team is me. And while at this stage we'd be fine to bus, the longer all 3 of us live the better chances we have at winning sooner and not slipping up. Also I like this team and don't want to leave it yet. ; __ ;
BUT if you're jumping off of it that works too and mitigates that. I usually prefer to just see what happens then to try and plan every little thing out in Scum Chat when it comes to conversations so they don't seem pre-planned, but I may try and poke holes in your theory. :p
That's fine! hole-poking is more natural and we always argue so we should argue here, too. Also good analysis on cops and advice on role checks. I think you're right that there's probably not an investigator but I wouldn't bet my life on it.
I feel good about our chances right now. IT'S SO EXCITING
I feel good about our chances right now. IT'S SO EXCITING
Sawneeks
little green dog
I also owe a certain @Roytheone scum doggos. blood pact and all that
you'll get some every time we mislynch/NK a townie, Roy. doggos are for celebrations, not for sads.
you'll get some every time we mislynch/NK a townie, Roy. doggos are for celebrations, not for sads.
Sawneeks
little green dog
I am still mid-wedding so haven't had a proper read here. I am all for a wizard kill and happy to do it again. Are we suggesting using the other 2 shot weapon? I am still reading the red check chat because I am eating cake and dancing.
FYI Cabot is drunk on tequila. It's amazing
FYI Cabot is drunk on tequila. It's amazing
Let's spanner him in the face
He says you are the only reason he drank so much but I suspect he lies.
Hi folks. All caught up now. Yeah, I'm afraid about Sawneeks getting targeted but I think if we pick apart the logic of the folk that jumped on that, we have a better chance of making them seem bad and Sawneeks seem more like she's only being targeted for meta reasons.
I'm going to keep on about Muffin. That switching yesterday was hilarious and opens him up for a lot of scrutiny. Zook still seems like an easy target. He's said practically nothing. Bear's absence is making me v uneasy though. I feel like he's going to show up eventually and have something up his sleeve.
One of the things I've noticed about Muffin is that he's super suggestible. Like he claimed that Sawneeks swayed his Alfred vote and then I watched him ask Deva what he thinks about Sawneeks "because he feels iffy but can't put it into words". So he keeps putting his decisions onto other people. Almost so he can backtrack later by going "THEYTOLDMETODOIT" which is easy to pick apart.
I'll put the kill through today once we've confirmed. Are we good with The Wizard then? I'm thinking the spanner. It's another 2 shot kill so still nothing to leave behind or investigate I hope. I'm also thinking that doing 2 kills in a row that don't leave weapons behind might trick Town into not investigating further once we start using our one-shot weapons. The Wizard is a good shot because he's not around much but when he is the stuff he says is generally pretty good and people tend to listen to him.
Sorry for my absence yesterday. Def will be able to do more tonight. Staying with my Gran and she goes to bed at like 9 so I'll be super bored and will be able to kick around more.
I'm going to keep on about Muffin. That switching yesterday was hilarious and opens him up for a lot of scrutiny. Zook still seems like an easy target. He's said practically nothing. Bear's absence is making me v uneasy though. I feel like he's going to show up eventually and have something up his sleeve.
One of the things I've noticed about Muffin is that he's super suggestible. Like he claimed that Sawneeks swayed his Alfred vote and then I watched him ask Deva what he thinks about Sawneeks "because he feels iffy but can't put it into words". So he keeps putting his decisions onto other people. Almost so he can backtrack later by going "THEYTOLDMETODOIT" which is easy to pick apart.
I'll put the kill through today once we've confirmed. Are we good with The Wizard then? I'm thinking the spanner. It's another 2 shot kill so still nothing to leave behind or investigate I hope. I'm also thinking that doing 2 kills in a row that don't leave weapons behind might trick Town into not investigating further once we start using our one-shot weapons. The Wizard is a good shot because he's not around much but when he is the stuff he says is generally pretty good and people tend to listen to him.
Sorry for my absence yesterday. Def will be able to do more tonight. Staying with my Gran and she goes to bed at like 9 so I'll be super bored and will be able to kick around more.
2 hours before. Was just going to wait until sawneeks agreed as well but I can do now if needed?
Just realised that's Sophia said earlier we can always change if needed so I'll go for it now:
Kill: The Wizard with the spanner
Kill: The Wizard with the spanner
I'll be here all night folks so please let me know if you would rather a different weapon
Android Sophia
Miss Congeniality
Command received.
Android Sophia
Miss Congeniality
Two hours before day start, so as of this message you have an hour and a half left.
Thanks Sophia
Android Sophia
Miss Congeniality
You murderers.
Also good thing doggy was okay. D:
Also good thing doggy was okay. D:
Oh no, that must have been so stressful! Glad they're okay now
Damn.
So I have just spent the last hour tracking how the votes went and that was ridiculous at the end of D2. Lots we can now work with
So I have just spent the last hour tracking how the votes went and that was ridiculous at the end of D2. Lots we can now work with
Sawneeks
little green dog
@Roytheone
We lived and the NK went through, have your weird Raccoon Doggo who is silently judging you.
and yes, this is apparently a dog so it does count.
We lived and the NK went through, have your weird Raccoon Doggo who is silently judging you.
and yes, this is apparently a dog so it does count.
Welcome to Town Gotham: population me
Also Sawneeks, you rip those buggers to shreds *sassy finger snapping*
@Roytheone
We lived and the NK went through, have your weird Raccoon Doggo who is silently judging you.
and yes, this is apparently a dog so it does count.
That looks like a bearcoon
I don't know what this is but I love it
Who does that then leave us? Alexem? He falls apart whenever there's any pressure so that could be fairly easy
I think he might be. He gets too specific on roles from time to time
Is that good or bad?!?!
Weird. What usually happens in this situation?
Android Sophia
Miss Congeniality
He failed to mention that he was still playing in Berserk, and I only found out afterwords from Ynnny. I'm reaching out for another replacement now.
Also, I'm not very happy right about now. :p
Also, I'm not very happy right about now. :p
Damn. That's pretty sucky. Sorry for all the hassle