Scum Thread Cluedo Mafia Private chat
- Thread starter Android Sophia
- Start date
Hahahahahaa
Also this Fran thing seems a bit random. How did they get here?
That was insane. There was so much switching. Do you think Fran's last voted counted? I doubt it
If there's a tie, D4 will be a riot for the first few hours
Android Sophia
Miss Congeniality
You have no idea how nervewracking deciding that was.
Man Sophia I'm sorry. It was the best call though.
Also I think the rope will be brilliant. It will cause the most confusion. Just gotta make sure our victim doesn't get lynched in the meantime.
I AM TOTALLY EXCITED FOR THE ROPE
Also I think the rope will be brilliant. It will cause the most confusion. Just gotta make sure our victim doesn't get lynched in the meantime.
I AM TOTALLY EXCITED FOR THE ROPE
People are starting to grow wary of Alexem and I think he has a PR. But Rats has mostly kept his head down. I think I'd be good either way
So do we rope or no rope???
He also thinks we're the Charlie's Angels of Town
Alexem is shaping up to be a wee scamp. I can't work out whether he is the cop or is vying for the cop to pop up and claim. Leaving him alive will give everyone else the chance to pick at him
Rats seems a possibility. But I don't know. Deva pushed him pretty hard. Feels like if he was gonnae crack and blab it would have been then. I could be wrong though
Rats seems a possibility. But I don't know. Deva pushed him pretty hard. Feels like if he was gonnae crack and blab it would have been then. I could be wrong though
take your frustration out on the flavor, @Android Sophia
Bugger it, yeah, maybe Rats would be good. Plus I think he'll easily dodge a lynch tomorrow
Android Sophia
Miss Congeniality
I may just do that after dinner, when I no longer have a headache. :P
Sawneeks
little green dog
so my class got cancelled tonight so I keep keep being unproductive. \o/
Also, the biggest downside to the Rope ( besides possibility of being seen ) is that it will essentially clear Muffin from the lynch pool tomorrow. He never said if he would get notified if his BP is gone or not, but the instant assumption would be Scum tried to kill him and failed and that's why there is no kill. That would go away once two people flipped as it would be clear that's where Scum's kill went, but at the start that may keep in clean.
Rats claimed Vanilla when Deva claimed against him on Day 2 but later on said something REALLY vague about how Deva's claim makes no sense 'according to the wording of his role PM' and that he was frustarted that he had to claim so much about his role.
he either is vanilla and baiting us or actually has something and just never believed Deva.
Also, the biggest downside to the Rope ( besides possibility of being seen ) is that it will essentially clear Muffin from the lynch pool tomorrow. He never said if he would get notified if his BP is gone or not, but the instant assumption would be Scum tried to kill him and failed and that's why there is no kill. That would go away once two people flipped as it would be clear that's where Scum's kill went, but at the start that may keep in clean.
Rats claimed Vanilla when Deva claimed against him on Day 2 but later on said something REALLY vague about how Deva's claim makes no sense 'according to the wording of his role PM' and that he was frustarted that he had to claim so much about his role.
he either is vanilla and baiting us or actually has something and just never believed Deva.
Sawneeks
little green dog
This is kinda why I suggest the Rope. it's not clear at the start what could happen but killing Rats out-right would semi-clear LP since scum would have to be #bold to openly discuss their kills. So making the kill delayed would make it easier.
oh right sorry I am a dumb
ooh, then we're double covered
Blarg called LP town in 1801 but it may have been sarcasm. He says he stands by his last four naming of scum so we need to grab that.
Sawneeks
little green dog
thank you monkey <3
also I think so, he kept updating it at odd times but I think that was the last one.
i asked about Blarg/LP because i had a random thought that they are Masons. It would kinda explain Grizzly just going after LP out of nowhere on Day 1 but not really pushing it and Blarg seems to poke a lot of people but not LP. don't know how much stock i'd put into that idea but it was a thought.
also I think so, he kept updating it at odd times but I think that was the last one.
i asked about Blarg/LP because i had a random thought that they are Masons. It would kinda explain Grizzly just going after LP out of nowhere on Day 1 but not really pushing it and Blarg seems to poke a lot of people but not LP. don't know how much stock i'd put into that idea but it was a thought.
Sawneeks
little green dog
@Android Sophia for the purposes of the game, is the Rope considered a NK or a lynch?
As in, could it potentially bypass a BP.
As in, could it potentially bypass a BP.
Sawneeks
little green dog
Also, if we do decide to Rope Kill Rats I would recommend not shying away from his lynch. It'll be really really tempting to not lynch him and watch two deaths happen at once but once that second kill goes through at Day End it'll be really really clear that's where our NK went. Any Townie worth their townie points will look to see if anyone tried to keep Rats around or danced around him that Day Phase as opposed to the previous one, so that is something we should be aware of.
Sawneeks
little green dog
Sawneeks
little green dog
I really want us to make it out of this is a group too, but we have to be willing to throw each other under the bus if it came down to it. If push comes to shove it's better to bus a teammate than save them for a Day Phase only for two of you to be caught and lynched instead of just losing one. That's why I'm doing my best to shade you guys when i see something, it's not enough to drive a lynch but if I ever get lynched ( and i still think that's the most likely out of the 3 of us ) then the connection isn't there anymore and it becomes that much harder to find you guys.
i kinda feel like i'm coming across as a bit callous when saying that but i hope you gals know that this is quickly becoming one of my favorite Scum Teams i've ever been in. your enthusiasm for this rivals my first ( and favorite ) Scum Team in Pokemon Mafia and I really want us to walk away from this with a win, especially for you both since this is your first rodeo as scum. <3
i kinda feel like i'm coming across as a bit callous when saying that but i hope you gals know that this is quickly becoming one of my favorite Scum Teams i've ever been in. your enthusiasm for this rivals my first ( and favorite ) Scum Team in Pokemon Mafia and I really want us to walk away from this with a win, especially for you both since this is your first rodeo as scum. <3
it's not callous, dude, it's mafia. it's all good!
also I would kill you with impunity just because so I'd do it double to win. it does not mitigate my love for you. <3
It's exhilarating because it's like playing two roles. I FEEL town out there. Like I'm really hunting. But in here we are crafty, cackling witches.
also I would kill you with impunity just because so I'd do it double to win. it does not mitigate my love for you. <3
It's exhilarating because it's like playing two roles. I FEEL town out there. Like I'm really hunting. But in here we are crafty, cackling witches.
Just caught up and yes to everything. Rope kill Rats then strong kill Muffin. They will lose their shit when there's no kill tomorrow and it will be glorious.
I understand that one of us may end up dying but happy to fall on my sword if it helps us win. sawneeks I will throw shade if you need me to but I'd rather you not die!!!
Also yes...GIRL GANG FTW. Thank you both for making my first terrifying game so awesome.
I understand that one of us may end up dying but happy to fall on my sword if it helps us win. sawneeks I will throw shade if you need me to but I'd rather you not die!!!
Also yes...GIRL GANG FTW. Thank you both for making my first terrifying game so awesome.
thank you for being here in MY first scum game! girl gang girl gang rah rah rah
So let's plan. What do we do if someone sees the visit to Rats? I can't do anything at all. Should this time be you, Neeks? Should we stick with gogkiller?
So what can they see? This is the bit I'm getting lost with. I know this is because it's my first game. What might happen?
If there's a tracker who happens to follow the person who does the action, they'll see you visit them. They won't see what you do, just that you visit - so you'd have to be able to explain it.
The chances are low. I wish I could take the action. I'd do it. I'm sure I wouldn't be tracked.
The chances are low. I wish I could take the action. I'd do it. I'm sure I wouldn't be tracked.
Sawneeks
little green dog
hmmmmmmmmmmmmm
who does the kill really depends on who we think will gather more attention. Gotham has been pretty good since she's low on everyone's radar so I'm fine if we want her to keep doing the kills. I think it's almost 50/50 at this point since both her and I kinda stayed out of that end of day shenanigans so we both have an equal chance of being watched without taking scum reads into account.
and if someone catches you, you're kinda dead once we hit the Day Phase after this one if they claim. Not all claims are a total bust though, even if someone claims they found out you're Scum because they're a Cop or something you still fight it. For all they know, you're Town and they got an incorrect check and you KNOW they are lying because you are Town. You fight enough to create doubt and then lynch the other person first you can at least take someone down with you. :p
who does the kill really depends on who we think will gather more attention. Gotham has been pretty good since she's low on everyone's radar so I'm fine if we want her to keep doing the kills. I think it's almost 50/50 at this point since both her and I kinda stayed out of that end of day shenanigans so we both have an equal chance of being watched without taking scum reads into account.
and if someone catches you, you're kinda dead once we hit the Day Phase after this one if they claim. Not all claims are a total bust though, even if someone claims they found out you're Scum because they're a Cop or something you still fight it. For all they know, you're Town and they got an incorrect check and you KNOW they are lying because you are Town. You fight enough to create doubt and then lynch the other person first you can at least take someone down with you. :p
Sophia - if someone does get tracked or otherwise seen using the rope, will it show up BEFORE the kill or AFTER? I assume if someone is watching tonight and happens to see they'll see it tonight and that's what worries me about gog in particular because she and Rats got tagged as perfect targets.
I think if we pull this off, we're golden and it doesn't matter.
I think if we pull this off, we're golden and it doesn't matter.
Argh this is so tricky. I think I'd be really shit at talking my way out of it. But I think the rope would be amazing for the beginning of the Day Phase because they would be so thrown for a loop when no one dies. It would cause utter chaos.
Thank you for the link. V v helpful.
Lol Cabot has mostly been helpful but I've been getting almost everything I've needed answered in this chat from both of you. Although last night he kept texting me "COULDNT KILL ANYONE IN A GAME ABOUT KILLING".
Thank you for the link. V v helpful.
Lol Cabot has mostly been helpful but I've been getting almost everything I've needed answered in this chat from both of you. Although last night he kept texting me "COULDNT KILL ANYONE IN A GAME ABOUT KILLING".
Fuck it. I think I could do it. I'll stand my ground if someone comes at me.
Sawneeks
little green dog
okay yeah, reading over the Day End again I think Gotham should submit the Rope Kill. There's enough worry/shade against me that I'd worry about a Tracker on me tonight. Monkey would be another good choice but she isn't allowed to get her hands bloody. :<
Rope Kill on Rats seems to be the best bet so far. Any other suggestions on a NK before we lock it in?
Rope Kill on Rats seems to be the best bet so far. Any other suggestions on a NK before we lock it in?
Sounds good. I'm happy to submit it in the morning and that way it give you two a few hours to decide for sure or change your mind if anyone else springs to mind.
Ppps I move at least 1 amiibo every time I'm at his flat and sometimes he goes days without noticing but then I get too ambitious and start hiding them around the flat and last week I added 2 Batman figures in amongst them. He's so easy to harass
Ppps I move at least 1 amiibo every time I'm at his flat and sometimes he goes days without noticing but then I get too ambitious and start hiding them around the flat and last week I added 2 Batman figures in amongst them. He's so easy to harass
Okay here we go and we've got plenty of time to change it:
Kill: Rats with the Rope
Kill: Rats with the Rope
Android Sophia
Miss Congeniality
It's considered a Mafia factional kill.
This I cannot answer.
Command received.
Thanks Sophia
Fingers crossed he's not
Nearly time to find out if this is going to blow up in our faces!
(I really really hope it's not)
(I really really hope it's not)
Terrified right now
Does Fran know something about the weapons???
Do you think there's a role that alerts him to the weapons??? He did mention the gun earlier
Okay before I get excited do we think it's definitely one-shot for Fran? And is it true?
Sawneeks
little green dog
Good god Fran nearly gave me a heart attack. I read the 'I'm an Investigator' part and saw my name underneath it and immediately got worried.
the only issue is I can't tell if that would catch our Ninja Kill or not. It SOUNDS like a Tracker, or a variant of it that shows if a person has a weapon ( which in clue does mean they are the killer ), so I'd assume it wouldn't catch the Knife. If that's the case, we don't have to worry about being Tracked but it's not clear.
the only issue is I can't tell if that would catch our Ninja Kill or not. It SOUNDS like a Tracker, or a variant of it that shows if a person has a weapon ( which in clue does mean they are the killer ), so I'd assume it wouldn't catch the Knife. If that's the case, we don't have to worry about being Tracked but it's not clear.
