Scooby Doo 2: Mafia Unleashed - This time there are costumes!

[San Franpsycho]

BooBeard sure knows a lot of mafia terminology for a new player, like prod vote.

 

[Cat Creature]

yeah, dont vote for boobeard, that vote sucks

anthos seems like a good one though, who would vote for me?

Vote: Anthos

 

[Neon Phantom]

@Baba Yaga Hi, haven't seen you for a while.
As someone with a less believable shit-is-new-to-me post on record how do you feel about Boo?

 

[Lightning Strikes]

UNVOTE

need to think about this.

 

[BooBeard]

I read through the mafia scum wiki in anticipation of this game, that's how I know the terminology.

 

[Gnome]

Okay, any thoughts on boobear?

I haven't read back, but based on what he's done recently. I don't think he's scum.

 

[Alien]

For the record, I have reason to believe there is at least one new player in this game. So Boobeard could absolutely be telling the truth

 

[Gnome]

He just reads more like a frustrated townie than a scum to me.

 

[Snow Ghost]

this snow monster is very lost

"who do you think is scum" and the typical responses AAAAH hit me baddies

 

[Anthos]

Just seems a tad weird to jump over his post about being new after wanting to understand them and jumping back to me.

 

[Captain Skunkbeard]

My gut still tells me it’s Anthos.

 

[San Franpsycho]

@Baba Yaga Hi, haven't seen you for a while.
As someone with a less believable shit-is-new-to-me post on record how do you feel about Boo?

This is a good post.

 

[San Franpsycho]

For the record, I have reason to believe there is at least one new player in this game. So Boobeard could absolutely be telling the truth

lmao this has big Hawthorn in Risk energy

 

[Lightning Strikes]

@BooBeard You still have not Voted or pushed anyone.

You say you want to push a more inactive player but have not gotten more specific than that.

 

[Lightning Strikes]

For the record, I have reason to believe there is at least one new player in this game. So Boobeard could absolutely be telling the truth

lmao this has big Hawthorn in Risk energy

Are you implying Alien is scum and a scum mate is New?

Vote: Alien

Thats the type of indirect Connection I can Vibe with.

 

[Lightning Strikes]

Going to be busy watching Ubisoft Direct but that should Wrap up before End of Day hopefully.

 

[BooBeard]

Baba Yaga hasn't posted much, and has been repeatedly called out. I would like to hear from them as well.

I'm suspicious of Char Gar but I don't want to vote them out today. They're kinda on their own.

If I had to slap down a vote right now it would Anthos.

VOTE: Anthos

 

[Snow Ghost]

I'm just tired of this Day 1 no vote discussion every game, sorry.

An educated newbie, a pleasure for sure. Not a fan of this style of deflection but feel free to counter by saying that you are "new" in the sense that you've played on other sites before, that will help.

VOTE: BooBeard

 

[Pazzo the Ghost Clown]

Hmm, I never vote newbies out D1 but this could just be a play at pity points. Bleh gonna think on it and look back over their posts later

 

[Anthos]

Hmm, lets try it

vote: boobeard

 

[Scooby Snack Monster]

anyone got a current vote count on the two leaders?

 

[Anthos]

anyone got a current vote count on the two leaders?

boobeard - 6
anthos - 5

 

[Aeleus]

anyone got a current vote count on the two leaders?

my sheet should be up to date

 

[BooBeard]

I played Mafia on Starmen.net forums idk, 11 years ago? Haven't played since. I don't think playing Among Us, Trouble in Terrorist Town and Gnosia counts as playing forum-based Mafia.

The "I'm just tired of this Day 1 no vote discussion every game, sorry." jab was a reference to past games I read through like Fate/Mafia and was a deflection to try and make myself appear more experienced. That backfired spectacularly.

 

[Alien]

Are you implying Alien is scum and a scum mate is New?

Vote: Alien

Thats the type of indirect Connection I can Vibe with.

Vote me out first at least.

 

[Alien]

My flip will prove you're all morons

 

[Scooby Snack Monster]

VOTE: Anthos

 

[Scooby Snack Monster]

i don’t think alien hints at anything if they are scum. i know sans is a hawthorn fan but might be overestimating alienhere

 

[Pazzo the Ghost Clown]

I played Mafia on Starmen.net forums idk, 11 years ago? Haven't played since. I don't think playing Among Us, Trouble in Terrorist Town and Gnosia counts as playing forum-based Mafia.

The "I'm just tired of this Day 1 no vote discussion every game, sorry." jab was a reference to past games I read through like Fate/Mafia and was a deflection to try and make myself appear more experienced. That backfired spectacularly.

I don’t know, I read back and it’s a really hard pill to swallow. You adapt extremely well to a new community and your first mafia game in a decade if you’re new. Using terms like scum, NAI, meta, prod vote, wagon, etc. Clueing into Jman’s linguistics. Being adept enough to know to use no vote instead of the old word, the one you probably would’ve been using 11 years ago.

 

[BooBeard]

I don’t know, I read back and it’s a really hard pill to swallow. You adapt extremely well to a new community and your first mafia game in a decade if you’re new. Using terms like scum, NAI, meta, prod vote, wagon, etc. Clueing into Jman’s linguistics. Being adept enough to know to use no vote instead of the old word, the one you probably would’ve been using 11 years ago.

I don't remember anything about playing Mafia 11 years ago, I was a literal child. What is the old word, kill? Or is it l*nch?

Thanks for the compliment that I adapted well, it will ease the pain when I get voted out of my first game Day 1.

 

[Alien]

I'll put it in no uncertain terms. I'm one of the FGO Era bunch. I know someone new has signed up from there.

 

[Anthos]

I'll put it in no uncertain terms. I'm one of the FGO Era bunch. I know someone new has signed up from there.

Eh

 

[Alien]

Whether it's boo or not I obviously don't know. I suspect it is though and I'd rather you vote me out and give them another day then kill someone day 1 that's very possibly new to the community.

 

[BooBeard]

That's kind of you Alien but don't worry about it. I played terribly. I'll do better next game I get in.

 

[Snow Ghost]

a deflection to try and make myself appear more experienced

What is the point of this, why was it necessary? Doesn't seem like you did it for fun, as you haven't mentioned anything of the sorts. Why can't you just say that you haven't played in ages and go from there? Cuz I see you faking experience and doing nothing with it and that is odd.

 

[Technicolor Phantom]

So we got Boo who says he's new but posts like he isn't.

And Alien who's willing to martyr himself to make us look dumb.

And finally Anthos who doesn't care what we think about him.

Great choices today.

 

[Alien]

Nah it ain't about that now

 

[Alien]

I'm looking out for an obviously new player

 

[BooBeard]

What is the point of this, why was it necessary? Doesn't seem like you did it for fun, as you haven't mentioned anything of the sorts. Why can't you just say that you haven't played in ages and go from there? Cuz I see you faking experience and doing nothing with it and that is odd.

I guess I didn't think it through? Another bad move on my part. I was trying to get people to stop talking about Day 1 no votes and instead I sucked all the oxygen out of the room. Oops!

 

[Frankenstein]

Vote: BooBeard

Just not buying it.

 

[San Franpsycho]

So if Boo is telling the truth, what’s mafia doing during this discussion?

 

[Frankenstein]

Fairplay if you are new, it was an extremely ballsy approach, much more so than my first ever day 1.

 

[Technicolor Phantom]

Hmmm, why do you wanna know what Waxy knows?

Think they're scummy?

Is this what people found suspect from Anthos? Seems like a giant nothing burger.

 

[BooBeard]

I am telling the truth and scum are probably just dogpiling on me because I'm an easy out. Oh well, sorry fellow townies.

 

[San Franpsycho]

Vote me out first at least.

My flip will prove you're all morons

How does your d1 flip prove anything but your alignment? Why do you want to die?

 

[Alien]

How does your d1 flip prove anything but your alignment? Why do you want to die?

Lightning and San implied myself and Boo are teammates. My flip will prove that isn't the case.

 

[Spooky Space Kook]

I dunno, this whole thing feels weird. It feels like it's being layed on a little thick but scum pretending to be a brand new player this much feels like a bit of a 'cheap' shot

 

[Alien]

I don't want to die but as I already said I'd rather take the bullet than someone who is new.

 

[Spooky Space Kook]

I don't want to die but as I already said I'd rather take the bullet than someone who is new.

What if they aren't who you think they are?

 

[San Franpsycho]

Is this what people found suspect from Anthos? Seems like a giant nothing burger.

Can you remember anything about Anthos? There’s at least 4-5 others like that too but I’m too lazy to look back at the player list.

At least Alien has now taken a position on something, even if it’s a bad one.

 

[Technicolor Phantom]

There's no post count tracker is there? I want to see who's RPing LP.

 

[San Franpsycho]

Lightning and San implied myself and Boo are teammates. My flip will prove that isn't the case.

I’m San and no I didn’t.

 

[Alien]

What if they aren't who you think they are?

I'll take the L for making a bad call

 

[Alien]

I’m San and no I didn’t.

Oh my bad, I guess I misunderstood your Hawthorn Risk post

 

[San Franpsycho]

Oh my bad, I guess I misunderstood your Hawthorn Risk post

Hawthorn showed everyone up in Risk by just saying don’t worry about it. You tried that but caved and I don’t how you made that a teammate thing anyway lmao. Paranoia much?

 

[Baba Yaga]

Why is Anthos getting votes?

I see the case for Boo who is borderline guilt tripping the whole game with a potential lie. Reading mafia scum wiki is a tad too much for me. Would be okay with voting him.

CCG seems interesting, not voting there today, if he's scum, we'll find out.

Woodsman looks okay so far. That's all I can recall.

 

[Alien]

Hawthorn showed everyone up in Risk by just saying don’t worry about it. You tried that but caved and I don’t how you made that a teammate thing anyway lmao. Paranoia much?

If you say so

 

[Cat Creature]

i still think this boo vote sucks

anthos is meh

wheres the spicy vote?

we need a new one to swap to...

Vote: Char Gar Gothakon

 

[San Franpsycho]

Whatever, this is boring now, just get rid of people who are blending. It’s hard enough to keep up with a costume roster. There are no d1 gotchas, we don’t lynch all liars in this scenario, and there’s an obvious correct play here. Narrow it down, see who acts weird, and move on.

 

[Baba Yaga]

Ah, Jman/Lightning is getting a dislike for outing himself and insinuating nothing bad could happen with identity reveals.

 

[Anthos]

anthos seems like a good one though, who would vote for me?

Vote: Anthos

anthos is meh

So that vote was just a joke?

 

[San Franpsycho]

Why is reading a wiki weird? Because you can’t imagine someone putting effort in? Boo lied but it’s just another dumb cosplay lie. Who cares? See what happens from it. The lie itself doesn’t mean mafia.

 

[Cat Creature]

So that vote was just a joke?

my votes are always very serious

very

serious

Spoiler

meow

 

[Cat Creature]

Why is reading a wiki weird? Because you can’t imagine someone putting effort in? Boo lied but it’s just another dumb cosplay lie. Who cares? See what happens from it. The lie itself doesn’t mean mafia.

this

 

[San Franpsycho]

lmao Anthos out here on ctrl-f self watch

 

[Technicolor Phantom]

Can you remember anything about Anthos? There’s at least 4-5 others like that too but I’m too lazy to look back at the player list.

At least Alien has now taken a position on something, even if it’s a bad one.

When he came back he did a subtle fish of CC but that just seemed accidental and not malicious. I wouldn't vote there today.

Honestly I don't like either of the 3 votes but I won't blame anyone for voting Boo because of his newbie claim. It's bad faith at best.

 

[Alien]

If the newbie claim is fake im gonna be genuinely pissed off.

 

[Technicolor Phantom]

Vote: Anthos

So far I’ve got good gut feelings about San, Gnome and SSM

I can’t believe that Wax Phantom is trying to imitate me. Shame on you.

Yawn

My wagon is still looking for a hearty crew.

My gut still tells me it’s Anthos.

Everything from Captain Skunkbeard after his vote on Anthos. Seems content to just let it ride.

Vote: Captain Skunkbeard

 

[Cat Creature]

i like it

Vote: Captain Skunkbeard

 

[Technicolor Phantom]

Going to be busy watching Ubisoft Direct but that should Wrap up before End of Day hopefully.

Missing EoD because of Ubisoft is a giant scum tell.

Spoiler

/s

 

[Baba Yaga]

Why is reading a wiki weird? Because you can’t imagine someone putting effort in? Boo lied but it’s just another dumb cosplay lie. Who cares? See what happens from it. The lie itself doesn’t mean mafia.

You ask why it's weird and acknowledge it's a lie? It was done with the intention to create a bad conscience among (potential) voters, like with most of his woe is me posts.

 

[Baba Yaga]

Vote: Captain Skunkbeard

Let's see.

 

[Snow Ghost]

I feel that Boo is doing an appeal to emotion Hail Mary. Was this weird narrative necessary? No, but people make mistakes and staying quiet under pressure is a hard thing to do. Once a narrative was chosen and posted there was nothing but sticking to it. #639 feels like an admission of guilt to me.

Alien jumping in front of the gun is cool, brave if scum. Anthos is...detached? Yeah, that's what he feels like. Not a bad secondary I guess.

I have this meta read on Char that is ringing scum bells but I'd need to be right about the person behind the mask and I am not yet fully sold on that.

I feel that I really should know who Phantom is LOL and it bothers me

 

[Baba Yaga]

I have this meta read on Char

You think he's going to lick you, don't cha?

 

[Cat Creature]

I feel that I really should know who Phantom is LOL and it bothers me

i know who both you and phantom are lol

 

[San Franpsycho]

You ask why it's weird and acknowledge it's a lie? It was done with the intention to create a bad conscience among (potential) voters, like with most of his woe is me posts.

he says and then votes Skunkbeard instead lmao

Boo said two contradictory things so yes one of them is going to be a lie. That Boo lied is fact. Also fact is that I don't care, people gambit, gambits don't prove alignment, just that people make choices about how to play.

 

[Snow Ghost]

Oh, my identity is not that hard to guess. It is I-

Spoiler

naaah

 

[Snow Creature]

I'm willing to give Boo the benefit of the doubt for today, on the off-chance they are new. I can believe it for now.

Unvote

 

[San Franpsycho]

Also, update, I'm still not moving off of Anthos at this time. We've done this too often lately in every game that I've been in where we look at really obvious dumb things and ignore the people who are trying to hide. I am sticking with a blending poster unless something compelling happens, Anthos is just one of the more blatent examples of showing up, offering nothing, and disappearing again without much of a word. Everything he posts is about Anthos. Baba Yaga is another good one. Someone look at the player list and do the math to find the rest. Wagon them and see how many suddenly show up.

 

[Baba Yaga]

So Boo lied and you don't care, Sans, I get it.

But what about the Boo that is desperately clinging to life? Nothing in his demeamor striking you as over the top?

Why do you vote Anthos by the way?

 

[San Franpsycho]

So Boo lied and you don't care, Sans, I get it.

But what about the Boo that is desperately clinging to life? Nothing in his demeamor striking you as over the top?

Why do you vote Anthos by the way?

I literally explained it several times. As for your Skunkbeard vote, at least they started a wagon. What did you do besides not read the thread?

 

[Pazzo the Ghost Clown]

Unvote

Idk maybe I’m dumb but I think I’m buying it. Either it’s true or Alien and Boo are scummates or masons or something. It feels like too specific of a lie, and no one is out here going “but wait Alien, it’s actually I that am the newbie!” Sure, Boo being a newbie wouldn’t actually clear Alien, but he seems really heavy handed in calling for his own immolation which if he’s scum helping out a out of game buddy I think his scummates would be super pissed. Meh. Need to think and get a new vote down - I might miss day end

 

[The Ghost of Stealin Stan]

i think i know who snow ghost is, but that's it besides lightningman.

sticking with boo beard. alien's attempt to defend him is just based on thinking there's probably a new player in the game, no good reason to assume it's boo imo.

 

[Snow Ghost]

Now I might be stupid, what is true, but I was charmed by the simplicity of Captain Skunkbeard's "My wagon is still looking for a hearty crew." Succinct. Elegant. It just sounded good.

Not that any of this matters but now you know.

 

[The Ghost of Stealin Stan]

also alien's self sacrifice is NAI. he's not actually up for elimination today. as scum, gaining a reputation of "he doesn't care if he lives or dies as long as it helps town!" is what you want

 

[Baba Yaga]

I literally explained it several times. As for your Skunkbeard vote, at least they started a wagon. What did you do besides not read the thread?

Alright, keep ignoring Boo's desperate yet underhanded emotional appeal.

You should probably vote me now.

 

[Neon Phantom]

Unvote

Idk maybe I’m dumb but I think I’m buying it. Either it’s true or Alien and Boo are scummates or masons or something. It feels like too specific of a lie, and no one is out here going “but wait Alien, it’s actually I that am the newbie!” Sure, Boo being a newbie wouldn’t actually clear Alien, but he seems really heavy handed in calling for his own immolation which if he’s scum helping out a out of game buddy I think his scummates would be super pissed. Meh. Need to think and get a new vote down - I might miss day end

I'm not sold on Alien being town just for putting up a defense.
He's not really in contention as things stand so his apparent willingness to flip in Boo's place isn't necessarily anything.
From my perspective he's not offering alternatives or even voting himself, he's just letting it ride while potentially setting up an "I told you so"

 

[Snow Creature]

Why is Anthos getting votes?

I'd also be interested to know this. Is there an actual reason? At least as far as D1 goes?

I'm leaning away from the Alien and Boo votes.

 

[Pazzo the Ghost Clown]

also alien's self sacrifice is NAI. he's not actually up for elimination today. as scum, gaining a reputation of "he doesn't care if he lives or dies as long as it helps town!" is what you want

I'm not sold on Alien being town just for putting up a defense.
He's not really in contention as things stand so his apparent willingness to flip in Boo's place isn't necessarily anything.
From my perspective he's not offering alternatives or even voting himself, he's just letting it ride while potentially setting up an "I told you so"

I feel like it’s a bit strong to say he’s not in contention at all, it wouldn’t take much to put him in the lead or tied for it. Especially given there aren’t a ton of viable wagons currently.

 

[Pazzo the Ghost Clown]

I think if the votes stand where they are I guess I would go Anthos or Alien. Looking over the player list and glancing back on some of the players that haven’t made any impression on me though at this point I’d honestly rather go Hyde or Ghost Bear.

 

[Spooky Space Kook]

I think if the votes stand where they are I guess I would go Anthos or Alien. Looking over the player list and glancing back on some of the players that haven’t made any impression on me though at this point I’d honestly rather go Hyde or Ghost Bear.

You know, I've been feeling the same. Let's shake it up!

Vote: Ghost Bear

 

[Alien]

I'm gonna vote in a bot and then dip. If you wanna vote me I'm not gonna fight it. My role is boring so I really don't care. I am off all next week though so I can actually contribute for once.

 

[Frankenstein]

This eod is more of a mess than usual.

 

[San Franpsycho]

When is day end? I don't see it.

 

[Snow Ghost]

Ends in 53 minutes.

 

[Cat Creature]

When is day end? I don't see it.

about 50 minutes

 

[Alien]

Oh crap I didn't realise it was so soon

 

[San Franpsycho]

This eod is more of a mess than usual.

Yes this day end with relatively static wagons and an easy vote a bunch of people jumped on and are now arguing about is very different from every day end ever in some mystical way you didn't elaborate on

 

[San Franpsycho]

about 50 minutes

Thanks, you're a real one

 

[Frankenstein]

Yes this day end with relatively static wagons and an easy vote a bunch of people jumped on and are now arguing about is very different from every day end ever in some mystical way you didn't elaborate on

Yap yap yap. So much bullshit.