The Malt Shop

Status
Not open for further replies.
Aeleus

Aeleus

Mystery Incorporated is still the best scooby doo show and all other answers are wrong

For this game though why don't we (well actually just I as noone requested spec) chill out and enjoy the beverages served at this fine establishment.

g6vOFWN.jpeg
 
Hobohodo

Hobohodo

Say it five times fast
Having never spectated one before I’ve got some costume related questions that I’m curious about.

Any ModKill penalties for revealing who you are?
Are mafia all in costume or do they know who is who?
Does the costume come off when the player dies or do we have to wait to the end of the game?
 
Aeleus

Aeleus

Hobohodo said:
Having never spectated one before I’ve got some costume related questions that I’m curious about.

Any ModKill penalties for revealing who you are?
Are mafia all in costume or do they know who is who?
Does the costume come off when the player dies or do we have to wait to the end of the game?
Click to expand...
There's no rule for revealing who you are (though it probably goes slightly against the spirit of the game)

The mafia are all in costume but they've already told eachother who they really are.

Who is who will only be revealed at the end of the game
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
#HowareyougonnadoBooBeardlikedat

I have a good idea of who some players are, but I'm just categorizing others into their group semantic tics.
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
Aeleus said:
Can't just tease us like that, give us the deets!
Click to expand...
Says person with all of the deets.
gaGgMia_d.webp


I'll say that one person shares a lot of Chugg's posting habits, but they also have some of Fate's colloquialisms. I'm pretty sure Blarg is here, just absent his sprawling gif montages. And another player has some of the...semantic trappings I expect from Nat or Maol.
 
Last edited:
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
San Franpsycho said:
Just so this doesn't continue to spread, Boo lied. Boo even admitted to lying. We don't have to guess about this, Boo lied. He pretended to be not new and then new, so there's a lie. But anyone can lie. Town lies, mafia lies, neutrals lie, lying by itself is not proof of anything.
Click to expand...
EoGECnL.png
 
Frankenstein

Frankenstein

Costume Account (He/Him)
Also there is a possibility wax actually is sparks, unless he didn't sign up for the game, no one else giving sparks energy.
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
Frankenstein said:
Somehow I'm more interested in trying to guess who is who than actually who is mafia.
Click to expand...
That's the magic of costumafia. I narrowed down San to two people, and then one because only one person uses --- hyphen lines to break her thoughts in posts. But those =p make me unsure...
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
San Franpsycho said:
I don't care about gambits or emotional plays. Town does that. Scum does that. It's meaningless. You have to read past the easy stuff. Keep trying, maybe you'll get there.
Click to expand...
Pazzo the Ghost Clown said:
Then hopefully he drops it. My issue with Wax isn't that he chose to roleplay, it's that he has dropped the allusion just enough at times to make it clear he CAN play mafia, yet he's choosing not to. I can't get any real gauge on him because they're purposefully choosing to roleplay as a person that generally is not productive. I need the guise to fall to even start to get a real read on the slot.
Click to expand...
1a90c7fd-a247-4c78-9900-cf2cd5af01bb_text.gif

gif-do-michael-jackson-comendo-pipoca-3.gif
 
Frankenstein

Frankenstein

Costume Account (He/Him)
Verelios said:
That's the magic of costumafia. I narrowed down San to two people, and then one because only one person uses --- hyphen lines to break her thoughts in posts. But those =p make me unsure...
Click to expand...

I have one idea who san fran might be but I hope I'm wrong, san fran legit hurt my feelings lol
 
Aeleus

Aeleus

You are free to reveal your identities if you want, also your actual accounts might just have access to spec as well, not sure
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
Frankenstein said:
Is garbo a purple tell? Or you thought that was someone else?
Click to expand...
Not many people I know use garbo fluidly so it was a purple tell =D. There's you, Nat, I think Splinter, maybe Sorian (but I doubt it for a costume game) who would use it offhand when posting, but Nat's posting style isn't similar.

I did think there were much less fucks thrown around for it to be Stan though.
 
Frankenstein

Frankenstein

Costume Account (He/Him)
Verelios said:
Not many people I know use garbo fluidly so it was a purple tell =D. There's you, Nat, I think Splinter, maybe Sorian (but I doubt it for a costume game) who would use it offhand when posting, but Nat's posting style isn't similar.

I did think there were much less fucks thrown around for it to be Stan though.
Click to expand...

Haha

I definitely wanted to kind of take on a different persona/approach but I let san fran get under my skin to easily to really stay in character lol

I was sad I was the night kill though, I had this plan to publicly replace out after an argument with san fran and use my power to change costume to dracula lol
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
Frankenstein said:
Haha

I definitely wanted to kind of take on a different persona/approach but I let san fran get under my skin to easily to really stay in character lol

I was sad I was the night kill though, I had this plan to publicly replace out after an argument with san fran and use my power to change costume to dracula lol
Click to expand...
It definitely is a shame. You had a really cool PR and seeing Dracula pop up when Frankenstein went missing would have made for a good time.
 
Frankenstein

Frankenstein

Costume Account (He/Him)
Zippedpinhead said:
I was indeed! Ghost bear, though I really had thought it was obvious through the use of gifs, second on the posting a truffle shuffle gif (and it wasn’t exactly the right size as Zeke’s), being busy on the weekend (I really was) and Lowish posting.
Click to expand...

I didn't pick up on that at all lol are you known as the gif guy? I dont really have that association in my mind. To me you are like lp with more words, an evolved lp of you will lol

Everyone saying its so obvious who everyone is and I'm like.. I have no idea who anyone is.
 
Technicolor Phantom

Technicolor Phantom

Costume Account (He/Him)
I said a lot about not knowing or caring who everyone was and then said I might know who San Fran is. It's a pretty weak crumb but I figured since I didn't mention many people it would stick out.
 
Zippedpinhead

Zippedpinhead

Zip it!
Frankenstein said:
I didn't pick up on that at all lol are you known as the gif guy? I dont really have that association in my mind. To me you are like lp with more words, an evolved lp of you will lol

Everyone saying its so obvious who everyone is and I'm like.. I have no idea who anyone is.
Click to expand...
Last few games have been VERY gif heavy for me + low posting. as opposed to other gif people like Blarg & Zeke who do so but are also high posters.

But really though, my biggest issue is that until the game gets whittled down I have severe trouble following it, so I settle in on something and generally just try to avoid death, but bad luck with this day 2.

really fun though, I think I have been in most costume games with some success and some failures. Really interested in seeing who else is who.
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
TheChuggernaut said:
You got to kill the people who don’t fall in line behind the town leads we prop up, and you do not fall in line much. Someone on our team picked up on the “Garbo” thing and then everything I read from you after that was clearly you.
Click to expand...
Lol, I was 80% sure it was you when you were shooting the shit D2, and 20% thought it might have been Fate.
 
Chuggernaut

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Someone thought you were Snow Creature. We actually do have a role where we can guess peoples identity, so we've been just doing that in the background this whole game lmao.
 
Chuggernaut

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
My scum team was overthinking it and thought you were like Vere or someone. Leaving off the obvious ones my current guesses are Snack is Launch, Neon is Ephi, Kook is Thorny, and Captain is Ambulance. I may or may not have some of my scum mates listed there. We'll have to find out together!
 
Technicolor Phantom

Technicolor Phantom

Costume Account (He/Him)
I wonder if someone like Fate is in this game because that guy is not the best speller. So he'd have to really try to not be obvious.
 
Scooby Snack Monster

Scooby Snack Monster

Costume Account (He/Him)
also because ael was kind enough to give me my check from last night I threw a check at skunbeard due to being paranoid about him and it came back vanilla, even though I incorrectly guessed their identity as ATP
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom