Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This
- Thread starter Sorian
- Start date
Muffin
is being held hostage by Sammi
It's also easy to get a train deliberately rolling and take over all discussion by making that pressure a bit bigger than needed with a few extra votes on there. Also pretty basic imo.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Willing to go with Nat. Been pretty vocal and has lasted this long. Gorlak just became vocal yesterday and proactive. Dead. (Could be I missed him D1/d2, but yesterday he seemed to be leading very well. )
Monkey I dont get a scum read on and Kawl is greencked.
I just read back through that thread. The only people who still didn't receive the antidote once DCPat received his were you, Geno, Kawl, and Apollo. Apollo is dead scum, while Kawl is almost certainly town at this point.
I wonder if there is scum between you and Geno...
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I’ll wait here while you go collect the list of everyone that’s voted for two town players this game. Let me know how it goes.
If mine's been incredibly weak, yours is deep in the gutter right now.
A melon/natiko/heymonkey flip is what I'd be most interested in seeing right now.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
But it didn’t take over all discussion. Blarg was still pretty handily the vote leader. I feel like I could see your point more if you at least thought Blarg was scum, but you don’t even believe that. What would the purpose of scum pushing Alex in that moment be if Blarg is town? What would they be derailing?
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Honestly at this point I can't read much into the Alex vote atm.
I know I voted him cuz I figured it would be me vs him.
What screwed us is everything happened sorta quick then we just got an influx of information within an hour or so of deadline. With Blarg claiming to being a blacksmith and kawl/melon confirming it.
I know I voted him cuz I figured it would be me vs him.
What screwed us is everything happened sorta quick then we just got an influx of information within an hour or so of deadline. With Blarg claiming to being a blacksmith and kawl/melon confirming it.
Muffin
is being held hostage by Sammi
Having a fallback is always nice, cmon. If Blarg is scum, what I don't think, it makes more sense yeah, but even with town Blarg it perfectly serves scums interest to make the other obvious lynch option another townie, before people start exploring different options.
^^now this intrigues me - keep digging
I feel like there's more reason to clear Geno based on behavior and not much on faircure, but I also get really hung up on how Terra was convinced Geno was scum. And Geno acted really odd around the whole Include thing. It means he's probably more likely to be clear but I'm not certain.
Do you think melon/natiko/me are teamed up?
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
But I was already voting JubJub who was sitting at five votes and due to Lux we know was town now. After Alex became suspicious and received pressure he was also sitting at five votes. What exactly was my motivation in that moment if I’m scum?
Oh, correct again, rac did still have an active vote on Blargonaut yesterday. He was just at the top; I didn't see.
So:
rac
BladeSymphony
Zubz
ExtremeTactician
StanleyPalmtree
Geno
Kalor
What do you all think of Blarg still being alive/would you have kept your vote on him at EoD if you'd been here (for those that weren't)?
this is not a call for anyone who may have protected Blarg to claim, though - but I'm curious if anyone received a BP last night since it's possible that may be connected to happenings last night.
So:
rac
BladeSymphony
Zubz
ExtremeTactician
StanleyPalmtree
Geno
Kalor
What do you all think of Blarg still being alive/would you have kept your vote on him at EoD if you'd been here (for those that weren't)?
this is not a call for anyone who may have protected Blarg to claim, though - but I'm curious if anyone received a BP last night since it's possible that may be connected to happenings last night.
Muffin
is being held hostage by Sammi
This is simply a matter of what might scum prefer that you're asking me here. Might be that scum saw Alexem coming out of that event and wanting to get rid of him quickly in case he got an item, while putting JubJub off for the NK.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
rac
whatever
because i was invited to jailor chat where i was given read only access and they killed me in there
So this is all predicated on:
scum wanting to kill Alexem for reasons (why tho? How was he a threat?)
and putting JubJub off for an NK (why tho? How was he a threat?)
And so you're also saying Lux is actually scum?
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
But why not push on Ezekiel in that case? He was under flak and could’ve had an item too, plus is a much more active player. Unless you think he’s scum too I suppose.
oreomunsta
Crumbles under pressure *for now*
What was the deal with AlexEm at the end of the last day phase? Don't understand much about what happened there apart from him not doing well to some pressure questions (?)
rac
whatever
what do you want to know?
Alexem came out of the event and half-claimed role but didn't tell what he asked for/got, threw some shade on Fando/Brazil, then disappeared, which was out of character to my eye, at least (I'm not sure others talked about that).
When he came back he was weird-possibly sincere (obviously he was but reporting in-the-moment feels) but also he claimed a reflect so the only way he could be confirmed was via lynch.
Muffin
is being held hostage by Sammi
What? How do you come to this? No.
And Alexem came out of the event where items couls be won and acted the most suspicious. Good target for a town lynch. Gets rid of a potential threatening item too.
Ezekiel ITAed a powerful scum role iirc, he got a bit too much towncred to be easily pushable.
oreomunsta
Crumbles under pressure *for now*
Sounds good, and thanks monkey for that. Odd how the vote didn't change off him after he voted himself, but I didn't check to see how much more time was left in that day
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
Illogical, but whatever
rac
whatever
voted include for red check, shot at natiko cause i figured it was safer to flip him based on the claims
voted myself and blarg, switched to alexem cause again it felt safer because of the claims
by the time i was actually able to get back into the account and vote because i accidentally got it locked i didn't need to switch my vote on my main account
It was pretty late but there was some time. There wasn't really another wagon that was viable so it's a double-edged sword there. Too many active people jumping would have lynched Blarg and I don't think there were enough people/enough agreement to move someone else up and not enough time for that.
Though I dunno if not lynch Blarg was a good thing. Time will tell there.
He claimed the kill on JubJub so I was just wondering if you were wrapping him into this theory but I guess we'll talk about it tomorrow.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
For the record, I believe blarg about the bp role. As to why scum didnt kill him. idk
Also, know that we know the jailer decided to jail rac. We know why Zipped died.
T_T
Also, know that we know the jailer decided to jail rac. We know why Zipped died.
T_T
rac
whatever
yeah i saw the command i was only given read only access because lone ranger can only vote and ita
if i were to die first lone stranger would've lived
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
As for why he is alive, im not that surprised, its odd by not all that suspicious considering how many kills happened yesterday and how little we know about all the kills that happened yesterday.
About my vote, Nah, i believe the confirmations on his armorer role from Kawl and Melon, and while i dont think it necessarily makes him town i dont particularly mind if he's a neutral. Im still wary about him but not so much i wanna see him lynched.
And Saw was the person who gave DCPat the antidote.
Poltergust seems sketchy when it comes to his ITA shots. Monkey called out in her readlist (#4906) his unused shots, despite town reading him. He then took a very safe shot at Nomad (#5030) that didn't hit and then made a weird post about it (#5039).
This talk about shooting Blarg is especially uncharacteristic with this in mind.
This talk about shooting Blarg is especially uncharacteristic with this in mind.
Are you seriously trying to bait a possible new town BP into claiming?
oreomunsta
Crumbles under pressure *for now*
Fair enough. I'll concede, though, that it's way easier for me to make these statements in hindsight than it would have been if I was in that day end mess :D
If Blarg is indeed town, he's a great distraction to keep town from scumhunting
It doesn't matter now because we know Blarg wasn't jailed. It's also not bait if I ask outright. Are you not curious why Blarg is alive if his claim is legit? Look at who else died. Why any of them over a legit-Blarg?
So the Jailer can actually roleblock + protect + private chat with his identity hidden + kill at night?
That's pretty OP actually, so much so that I wouldn't be surprised if it's not town aligned.
rac, can you explain more about the Lone Stranger mechanics? He joined in pretty late in the game if I'm remembering it right. Did the Jailer choose to kill you or your "NPC"?
That's pretty OP actually, so much so that I wouldn't be surprised if it's not town aligned.
rac, can you explain more about the Lone Stranger mechanics? He joined in pretty late in the game if I'm remembering it right. Did the Jailer choose to kill you or your "NPC"?
I don't see anything strange at all with shooting Gorlak and a role cop over a Blarg that was moments away from being lynched in the previous day phase.
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Why wouldn’t they have killed Zipped then? Unless you’re implying neutral. Lux even saw a kill attempt on Zipped the night he was jailed.
Maybe because a lot of players were actively suggesting to wait for Blarg's NK to decide whether he was telling the truth or not.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
I've seen a town jailkeeper role exactly like the one rac is describing somewhere. I don't remember where, though. Probably while researching for my own game.
I wouldn't be surprised if it did end up being a neutral role.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Yea I noticed that. Wanted to look at those ppl too.
For sure. I doubt I'd vote him today, but eh, I didn't vote him yesterday. I'm just a big boggled by the NK choices.
Why?
They've killed a role cop and Gorlak, who is probably one of the most dangerous townies in this entire community.
An event is starting
This event has space for 9 players. The first 9 to join are in, sign ups cut off after that. The time commitment should be about 30-45 minutes and the activity requirement is very high (players will be playing multiple games in quick succession that may involve discussion or voting). Please use the JOIN command to join the event.
This event has space for 9 players. The first 9 to join are in, sign ups cut off after that. The time commitment should be about 30-45 minutes and the activity requirement is very high (players will be playing multiple games in quick succession that may involve discussion or voting). Please use the JOIN command to join the event.
Sorry, I was implying neutral yeah. But this is actually interesting, could Lux have seen the Jailer try to kill Zipped too?
Guess not since Zipped had Stockholm syndrome and was also surprised by Lux's knowledge.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Join
anyway, here's update - sheet 2 has current living players. Since I have to go for a bit I turned on commenting in case I fucked anything up. I'll fix it in a bit
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1M-WtLIvzXF48M-OxTaUpc1zuAnFv2rw2SBMasRXdICQ/edit?usp=sharing
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1M-WtLIvzXF48M-OxTaUpc1zuAnFv2rw2SBMasRXdICQ/edit?usp=sharing
I've seen those too; in the incredibly famous known for it's balance Mafia community of Starcraft 2 lol
LuxCommander
Bro.
I can do this!
JOIN
JOIN
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
sweet i can finally get in on one of these
join
join
rac
whatever
i could recruit on day 2 to create a new account, created after i started posting in the thread since ferg never used it
i couldn't talk but i could vote and ita, if i died i could play on through my account
the jailer chose to kill the npc
I find it surprising, & as stated before, I think there was a concerned effort to sway the vote off of Blarg, hence the sudden swing towards Alexem & suspicion on everyone that voted Alexem near the end (I have a town read on you, but you were the first person to vote or Alexem yesterday...). Based on all the Town Kills, I think most of the Night Kills were Scum. DCPat was an exception, but that could have been someone who just wanted a flip on a quiet player.
oreomunsta
Crumbles under pressure *for now*
JOIN
My first one!! :D
My first one!! :D
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
you have 2,
make it snappy beanie boi
make it snappy beanie boi
melonrabbit
The only good kind of melon
Would've but drunk.
The drunker I get the more I trust, Stanley.
The drunker I get the more I trust, Stanley.
oreomunsta
Crumbles under pressure *for now*
Thanos's fist, be nice to Thanos. You need him, and he needs you.
You are like two parts of a whole
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Are you scum?
@Brazil
@EzekelRAGE
@Fandorin
@LuxCommander
@rac
@StanleyPalmtree
@faircure
@oreomunsta
@Zubz
A new thread has appeared in the Galactic Arena titled "Lone Survivor" Please make your way over there now. These players will not be posting here during the event.
@EzekelRAGE
@Fandorin
@LuxCommander
@rac
@StanleyPalmtree
@faircure
@oreomunsta
@Zubz
A new thread has appeared in the Galactic Arena titled "Lone Survivor" Please make your way over there now. These players will not be posting here during the event.
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
was that comma meant to be more, like are you telling me that you trust people more in general, or you specifically trust me more?
Also you totes should have joined, Tanked is always the best way to play.
melonrabbit
The only good kind of melon
Stark, I'm more town than you.
melonrabbit
The only good kind of melon
I think you are def town. And I trust you with my impaired judgement and all.
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Got pretty quiet with most of the awake players in that event lol What are people thinking for their ITAs today? I’m leaning towards LP or briefs. I doubt they’ll ever post enough to get a fully developed read on at this rate. Oreo and Neck are bad too, but at least Oreo has shown up today. Hopefully that continues going forward.
I missed the event! Dratini!
You really did huh? Good job man!
That'a inherently unfair. Why would that happen?
I am Steve Rogers.
I wouldn't have kept my vote on him, but I wouldn't have voted on Alexem either. He seemed to be overwhelmed by responses, and just gave up.
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
Yall missed a fun event i tells ya what
Thank you my dude
oreomunsta
Crumbles under pressure *for now*
Damn, events are the best thing ever :]
rac
whatever
how is it anymore inherently unfair than scum just having a straight up day kill?
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
going by the comics, i think this means sorian is in love with you?