Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This
- Thread starter Sorian
- Start date
Here you go, my scum PM compilation post:
https://www.outermafia.com/index.php?posts/35381/
(Doesn't include Kalor or CoolestSpot, but I'm sure everyone remembers how their roles work.)
Ah word couldn’t remember when this was posted either. Thanks for the refresher link
It's a question as to why Ynnek7 has been left alive throughout this entire game at all. But, with Nights 4 & 5 only having one kill, it's possible that one of those nights was an attempted (and failed) kill onto him. If I had to venture a guess, I think the other night may have been an attempted (and also failed) kill onto Blarg as well, since he never gave out the specific name for his role nor the amount of times he could use it. It would explain my confusion as to why scum took so long to kill Blarg, at least.
The day kills from Day 5 onwards targeted NeckToChicken, Geno, and Brazil, all players who were strongly considered to be town and either had a good PR or very active. I can see killing Ynnek7 being less of a kill priority as the game dragged on due to his low activity.
OK, with less than 4 hours to go, we need to come to a consensus soon. A tie would obviously be very bad here.
OK... OK... here I go. Deep breaths...
Vote: rac
If rac is lynched, is not scum, and the day kill still doesn't happen, I'm willing to shift my ranking between Fandorin and Ynnek7 for tomorrow since no one seems to agree with me thinking Ynnek7 is possibly more scum. Remember, we need to be in this thread precisely when the next day starts and immediately hammer the vote. That's literally the only way we can potentially win this tomorrow.
OK... OK... here I go. Deep breaths...
Vote: rac
If rac is lynched, is not scum, and the day kill still doesn't happen, I'm willing to shift my ranking between Fandorin and Ynnek7 for tomorrow since no one seems to agree with me thinking Ynnek7 is possibly more scum. Remember, we need to be in this thread precisely when the next day starts and immediately hammer the vote. That's literally the only way we can potentially win this tomorrow.
By the way, I never want to be in a LYLO situation again. Someone just kill me early next game please. I'm getting gray hairs.
rac
whatever
i used my power to vote include and shoot natiko
i shot at extreme put him as my top scum and he folded
while i was questioning coolest he called me an asshole, look at that exchange and try and tell me that was scum/scum
Page 72 (100 ppp) for the CoolestSpot thing, dunno about the ET thing.
I agree, but we also need to have a backup plan in case things don't go our way. We can't head into tomorrow thinking we'll have time to discuss things when we actually won't. I'm not willing to lose this one without a fight after coming this far.
I do find it a little interesting that you put ET as top scum but that was the day you self voted and threatened to self ita the day after. But looking st the vote break down that day fandorin did come in and help seal the deal on ET during the day end fuckery but I imagine that could simply have been not wanting to stack 3 scum on the same train to save one this late. Scum would want to split votes and fandorin is the only unknown that voted ET that day in my eyes.
That exchange between you and coolest does read genuine.
I think it’s fandorin guys.
For archiving purposes, here are all the Lone Stranger posts (I had to manually find these because you can't search for him):
Something bothers me about the Lone Stranger bit. I think this was the catalyst to Blarg's role claim. Lone Stranger's vote on Blarg made everyone immediately suspect Blarg as the Lone Stranger, which ultimately led to that debacle of a lynch between him and Alexem and Blarg claiming being the BP giver.
rac, why did you allow a situation like that to happen?
rac, why did you allow a situation like that to happen?
Lol at rac just leaving.
EoD are always a fun ride, I guess.
ET was always a scum read for me and I backed that up since the beginning. I was at the start of the vote and shot at him twice before that. Scum also needed him alive that day since they’d get another kill that night with his ability. I can’t see scum splitting votes in a situation like this, especially since it was a close lynch even so.
I do read Coolest interaction with rac as sincere, I doubt he’d get pretend to be that upset. Point is that doesn’t say much about his alignment. CS is already known for doing his own thing whatever the team thinks about it, point being his sucidial run at ITA during D6.
EoD are always a fun ride, I guess.
ET was always a scum read for me and I backed that up since the beginning. I was at the start of the vote and shot at him twice before that. Scum also needed him alive that day since they’d get another kill that night with his ability. I can’t see scum splitting votes in a situation like this, especially since it was a close lynch even so.
I do read Coolest interaction with rac as sincere, I doubt he’d get pretend to be that upset. Point is that doesn’t say much about his alignment. CS is already known for doing his own thing whatever the team thinks about it, point being his sucidial run at ITA during D6.
And, well, this is probably less serious, but that "Howdy Partner" for the ITA shot is so ridiculously on-the-nose I'm questioning whether it's a serious call-out to Natiko being a scum partner. I don't think something like that is worth mulling over, though.
He explained that already this phase. I think he said that he wanted to create some distance between him and the Lone Stranger.
Eh I don’t think getting one additional kill is worth selling the whole farm on a town v scum lynch especially when he for sure would have gotten ita’d and flipped the next day. Too much egg one basket
Yeah, but he put our BP Giver under the bus by doing so. I understand that no one knew what Blarg's role was at the time but it still bothers me.
He also pretty much gave up on keeping his role a secret almost immediately the next day once the Lone Stranger died. The question I want answered is why he kept it secret to begin with if he was going to just give away his role like that so easily. It's not like we were given new information off of it; we already knew there was a jailer based off of what Lux told us. Maybe it was a way to avoid a potential counterclaim since NeckToChicken can confirm what happened, but baiting a counterclaim would have greatly benefited town at that point.
Kawl, can you read my post going over Xbro's stuff and post what you think of it?
rac
whatever
i didnt think that blarg being scumread was because of being thought as the lone stranger
Point me to it?
rac
whatever
i also was threatening to tie the vote, on this day i had given up completely
It’s almost too good ya know
?????
Oh no, it's gonna be Kawl, isn't it? Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
wtf
Um... OK. Guess that does indeed narrow my choices.
Um... OK. Guess that does indeed narrow my choices.
Also, my plan for tomorrow is now kaput. We have no choice but to hammer today.
Is that "no" supposed to be a "now"?
==== DAY 8 VOTES ====
Day Start
fandorin (1 votes)
kawl - #8489
rac (1 votes)
kawl - #8470 #8489
poltergust - #8509
kawl (0 votes)
rac - #8479 #8512
poltergust (0 votes)
rac - #8467 #8479
Post Counts:
poltergust: 48 kawl: 35 fandorin: 29 rac: 28 ynnek7: 8 sorian: 2 stuart444: 1
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day Start
fandorin (1 votes)
kawl - #8489
rac (1 votes)
poltergust - #8509
kawl (0 votes)
poltergust (0 votes)
Post Counts:
poltergust: 48 kawl: 35 fandorin: 29 rac: 28 ynnek7: 8 sorian: 2 stuart444: 1
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
rac
whatever
also i highly doubt this considering this is the only reason why i was townread for awhile
That was a backup plan. We absolutely shouldn't make that our main way of doing this. ._.
We have ~2 hours to find the last scum. We should use this time wisely.
You’re the only dude I’m going to listen to here. Which way you leaning. Need to know what you’re thinking
I’m completely against it at this point. I even though it was a bad backup plan then.
OK, it's definitely not you, so there's that.
Let's go over Fandorin again. The thought of him playing too well did cross my mind. A lot of things he/Xbro talked about we so accurate to the point of it being weirdly coincidental. He also has the best voting/ITA record out of all of us. The day killing ability, if not a factional thing, could also only reasonably fall onto him.
...But this is just WIFOM at this point. He's been so consistent at being town this entire game that I just find it hard to believe he's scum. I'd seriously be completely flabbergasted if he does turn out to be the last scum and I wouldn't even be mad if he wins because of it.
*were so accurate
I guess another point against Fandorin is that he did try to take the strong shot in the Greed event. Brazil took that in order to make sure scum didn't get it. Maybe Fandorin thought the same but it could also mean that Brazil protected us from a Fandorin strong shot.
I’m really packed here at work, but I think my contributions this game are backed with previous reads and interactions I’ve had with everyone. I took shots at Nomad and faircure and I also mislynched along the way, but I think I did pretty good for a sub in trying to keep up with the rhythm of the game.
I wouldn't say it was a bad plan at all. After all, we got another day kill, meaning scum was not willing to risk taking that chance tomorrow. I dunno if my plan caused it or not, but I'd like to think it influenced them.
CoolestSpot gave up his power for the event.
I think this was before the whole "I am Groot" thing.
It was. That happened the other day phase.
Which is completey bonkers considering he left that event with a lot of town creed.
...Huh, that's a really good point! CoolestSpot giving up his permanent, disruptive ability for a chance at a one-time use item makes no sense unless more than one scum entered along with him.
Let me look over CoolestSpot's PM again.
Let me look over CoolestSpot's PM again.
He gave up this for a chance at getting one item? That... doesn't make any sense to me. He still had at least 3 more commands to give out by the time the event happened on Day 3.
Huh, never really took a chance at reading his role PM before. I think that second command might be why nin died with kyan with the first day kill. It even explicitly says that it will start taking effect at the next day phase.
Well, that's the thing. It could be that gaining town cred was not the primary reason he did what he did for that event, which would make his actions afterwards less confusing.
I just can't believe he would intentionally nerf himself like that without a good chance at gaining something in return. If I was Coolest, I would have just let a townsperson give up their life/ability. Town cred is not enough of a reason, especially with the way he acted the days afterward. With him + another scum in the event, however, they stood a chance at gaining something.
But he did get town creed for what he did and then squandered it. No one was even pushing for his lynch later when he got shot, he just decided to implode then.
Also, revisiting the thread and the best reward for scum there, the strong kill, wasn’t even close to his role either way, since those are practically 5 situational strong kills.
He didn't aim for the strong kill, he blocked town from getting a 1-time cop item.
rac
whatever
OK, with an hour left, I think I feel justified enough to do this.
Vote: Fandorin
Scum, if you still win after all, then ggs.
Vote: Fandorin
Scum, if you still win after all, then ggs.
All of those are solid. I think it’s fandorin man
*crosses fingers*
Yeah...
rac, let's end this, one way or another.
rac, let's end this, one way or another.
Fandorin has died
As his last champion fell, Thanos looked on in silence.
"A good game. And as your reward, I'll keep you on as top lieutenants in the Endless Resurgence."
For the final time, Thanos held the cosmic cube above his head. It's light radiated like never before.
"It's time to take control of this universe and all the rest."
As the cube shined bright, once again, the center of the or it lacked any light of it's own and at the pivotal moment that all of the energy would have transferred into Thanos' body, he could feel that something was wrong. Unbeknownst to Thanos, Reed Richards hadn't fully succumbed to his control. There was one small piece of his will that remained intact and that piece of him was able to sabotage one small process in the re-creation of the cosmic cube. A "cut-out" was made that could be removed by another strong of will and that is what Dr. Strange had done what felt like an eternity ago. Distracted by fear of the Eye of Agamotto, Thanos didn't notice the simpler solution that had been employed. Before Strange died that day, he had transferred out the core of the cube. Not enough to stop its power completely, but enough to cause a misfire if its full power was harnessed.
As Wolverine, Gambit, and Storm looked on, the terror that had threatened to consume them, faded away into a thin dust, the cube having one final violent reaction before disappearing as well.
Earth would remain at peace that day but at a great cost.
Storm looked up, the most shaken of them all.
"The only way to fix this is with the infinity stones."
The three of them looked at each other. A heavy duty now thrust upon them and the world's villains waiting in the wings for just this opportunity.
Town has won the game!
As his last champion fell, Thanos looked on in silence.
"A good game. And as your reward, I'll keep you on as top lieutenants in the Endless Resurgence."
For the final time, Thanos held the cosmic cube above his head. It's light radiated like never before.
"It's time to take control of this universe and all the rest."
As the cube shined bright, once again, the center of the or it lacked any light of it's own and at the pivotal moment that all of the energy would have transferred into Thanos' body, he could feel that something was wrong. Unbeknownst to Thanos, Reed Richards hadn't fully succumbed to his control. There was one small piece of his will that remained intact and that piece of him was able to sabotage one small process in the re-creation of the cosmic cube. A "cut-out" was made that could be removed by another strong of will and that is what Dr. Strange had done what felt like an eternity ago. Distracted by fear of the Eye of Agamotto, Thanos didn't notice the simpler solution that had been employed. Before Strange died that day, he had transferred out the core of the cube. Not enough to stop its power completely, but enough to cause a misfire if its full power was harnessed.
As Wolverine, Gambit, and Storm looked on, the terror that had threatened to consume them, faded away into a thin dust, the cube having one final violent reaction before disappearing as well.
Earth would remain at peace that day but at a great cost.
Storm looked up, the most shaken of them all.
"The only way to fix this is with the infinity stones."
The three of them looked at each other. A heavy duty now thrust upon them and the world's villains waiting in the wings for just this opportunity.
Town has won the game!
Apollo
Apollo will wreck your goddamn face
Hell yeah
Xbro
Bags his own tea
Funny that you were caught on things not even having to do with you being scum.
