Search results

I would ok this too. It is a hard game to judge since it is quite different, so the best way is probably just to run it and then learn from how it goes!

I agree with Burb that the game as is now is probably fine IF advertised as an experimental, smaller game. This being quite different will probably mean we will just have to run it to see how it goes.

Pretty sure no screenshots of private chats (and for all intents and purpose these chats will basically be private chats between the players) is already an official rule in the community. So no need to make a separate rule for this game.

1. agree, chats should be separate. 2. I think they shouldn't be able to look back at the other threads, this forces them to explain to the other group what happened when they were split up which creates an interesting dynamic. 3. Night chat is definitely needed, way to hard to coordinate...

I think you misunderstood my point. I am not saying the design is like ONUW, but with the type of game I mean how both this and ONUW are very different from normal mafia games and time wise are smaller in scope. Thus, both this game and ONUW games should not be part of the main season games and...

I agree with burb that this really is a ONUW style game and not a "normal" mafia game. It should run fully on outer mafia and probably should not be a part of a main season and more be an "in between" snack game. I do like the idea a lot though, especially the part of groups having their own...

@Franconp any update on the new roles you wanted to add?

Ok, looking over it, I honestly think it is pretty well balanced already. Love the neutral idea, I am always a fan of neutrals that have to side with the team that is currently losing to extend the game as long as possible. Free on the fly balancing! One thing I am wondering though: how would...

I seriously doubt this will be an issue. If we call this bastard we wouldn't have normal games left.

Looked at the role pm's, some remarks: - the win condition sentence on vanilla towny is slightly different then the other town roles. - Don't forget to highlight/make red the target commands in the pm's - The jailor should specify that it prevents any powers from being used on their target...

https://www.resetera.com/threads/buck-bumble-mafia-lets-rock.22251/page-22#post-4703359 So what faddy did here is insinuating that Fire complained to the mods when Faddy was pushing for Fire, thus basically saying that Fire was misusing the rules as part of gameplaying strategy. It's not ok...

Yep, the hider would become targetable that night, and if the tracker is on them they would see them visiting the jailed player in their attempt to hide behind them.

Ugh, priorities, always fun (no its not). A switcher can't switch a hider around (hider goes first), but they CAN influence where the hider ends up. (so priority would be: hider leaves his spot - switch - hider arrives at his target). Also, I would say the jailer goes before the switcher...

A tracker sees the players his targeted visited, which is not necessarily the same as the one they targeted. So yes, a tracker would track the killer to B. Likewise, the tracker would see the switcher visit 2 players.

I'm back with fresh things to complain about! Jay! - Odd/even night would weaken the switcher enough that I would be ok with it. - Is the weak hider forced to go out there each night? With them dying when hiding behind scum or someone that dies during the night, and with the chance of a lovers...

Curious about the best mafia game ever run, eh? Understandable.

This day was a good example why gambits where the goal is to point town to certain directions are almost never a good idea. Town rarily actually goes into those directions the next day.

Deva's gambit has been horrible for town, basically forcing them to lynch him and wasting a day not scum hunting. He has been a great asset.... for scum.

Did he even said that? It came over to me more like our quality of play is lower than he is used to, not that he really minds that. He said it in a way that made it sound way worse than it probably was meant to sound though.