Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

Include spent a crazy amount of effort to paint Geno as scum yesterday. #3409 #3455
This whole going at each other does not seem construed to me (yeah, yeah you never know)
In the first post she also included Sawneeks and Kawl. She refers to a D1 post about Saw too.
Here she is #3528 Townreading Ezekel, monkey and melon.

This is another longer interaction between Saw and Include #3593. I don't want to underestimate these two, but I don't think they would've argued all this time when they are in the same team.

Yet this is Saw's read afterwards:
Include (she/her; CEST) - Seein' good ol' Include here. She isn't afraid to call people out on their shit and follow it with very tunnely, somewhat aggressive posting. Town Lean.
Ambivalent.
---
Stuart, Geno, Sawneeks, Kawl
Ezekel, Monkey, Melon

Out of these reads I'd argue there is at least on partner of her either in Geno/Saw or Monkey/Melon. I'm leaning Saw over Geno and Melon over Monkey. Because of the length of arguments I'd suspect her townreads to be more likely to be partners.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
In the ITA. In the TD Melon and Splint pushed for a no lynch.
I think you know exactly what I meant by my question. No matter, allow me to put it more bluntly.

Throughout the game, you've been pushing Melon as scum for that thunderdome. You've alleged that she was willing to bus Splinter for town credibility. A big mitigating factor that people had against your idea was that bussing a JOAT wasn't a likely tactic. Now, though, we know that scum had two JOATs. What's more, you have acknowledged, through the medium of Morgan Freeman, that Splinter wouldn't have been a bad candidate for a bus if scum knew they had another. So, would you not say that shooting Splinter in that first ITA could look just as much of a move to gain credibility as Melon putting him at risk in the thunderdome - perhaps even more so by virtue of actually getting the kill?

Right now, I think the two of you look as bad as each other.
 
Anyways Geno seems to have scent of town so for now:

Vote: Natiko

From my skimming his reasoning did seem iffy and others are starting to question him. Consider this not a vote to kill, though his behavior makes me think we may get answer from that, but just a prod.
 
Comparing melon's to monkey's reaction regarding the claims:

Melon had a meltdown because of TD talk.
She then revealed Stanley didn't move while Ynnek and Stu reveal the red check on Include.
Melon leaves with a vote on Include and no comment regarding the whole issue.

Monkey comments on the people reacting to the claim. (specifically finds Brazil odd) In #4202 she sides with Include.

After Natiko claimes Melonrabbit sides with Natiko #4324

And Monkey attacks that stance in #4419 because she saw a fiery attitude in Include which melon did not see. But Monkey also agrees with Natiko about the slow info drop by Include.

Monkey shifts to believing Nat, but not automatically seeing Include as scum.

#4449is an interesting thought about scum team composition if Include is scum. But why did it came to her mind at this point?

And afterwards ITA's begin Monkey shoots Include (no further explanation, did I miss her saying Include is the best choice forward or did she never take a position until that shot?)

Melon comes in late and shoots Include after she died.

I... don't see something condemning in these events. Melon was more absent, was Monkey trying to feel if Include could be left alive and realised it was too late?
 
luxcommander... can you write things in code so I can understand what you said some pages ago about what happened to me last night?

I feel like

You're reading too much into it... Or maybe not enough. It was a flavor choice. I recommend brushing up on your Marvel Writers. Some of them have some strange quirks.
 
Looking at the ITAs of course @hom3land looks really bad. He comes in and shoots confirmed town Kawl. Wifom. We can deal with a mislynch because of that.

Geno shooting Natiko seems to follow his logic he described before. But it also looks like he never bothered to look at how Include continued to defend herself.

And @NeckToChicken first post of the day was concerning Lone Stranger, then he only appears for the ITA. Getting scummy vibes.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Natiko, now what
Well, when I have free time I plan on looking over the lower activity players that are left. I feel like there's probably at least a couple scum blending in with that pile, and it would be nice to have a stronger feeling on which may be the best to bounce sooner rather than later. Especially with our hit rate in ITAs.

Currently my strongest scum reads are probably Muffin and Zubz. Them plus a couple more lower activity players would be my guess for remaining scum. It just feels like this scum team is flailing and doesn't really have much leadership which leads me to think people like Monkey, Saw, Brazil, etc. aren't scum. That or they're playing super mind games and Ezekiel has been right all along with his elaborate bussing theories.

Wouldn't it be hilarious if Lone Stranger was controlled by two people, one town and one mafia? Or maybe by a dead player.
I find both of these unlikely. I think a town player in command of it would just claim if they realized they didn't have full control. Letting a dead player do it feels too bastard since that would mean we didn't get their full flip.

Anyways Geno seems to have scent of town so for now:

Vote: Natiko

From my skimming his reasoning did seem iffy and others are starting to question him. Consider this not a vote to kill, though his behavior makes me think we may get answer from that, but just a prod.
This feels like you're just piggybacking off of what Brazil (iirc) just posted instead of putting in the work yourself. Which reasoning of mine seemed iffy?
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Zeke also claimed being shot last night. What's your opinion on that?


Can you either link to previous posts or explain why you scum read these two, especially Muffin?
Zubz I've talked about a few times. When I'm home tonight I can go grab them if you need. The read on Muffin came more into focus today. His reads list struck me as really off. I probed and accused him of potentially being a neutral. Unless I missed something he never even responded which makes me lean a bit towards scum after all. I feel like most neutrals love to talk about how they super totally aren't neutrals. I'm just not sure how a player has as many posts as Muffin while leaving such a little impression on me and apparently having so few reads of his own. You can probably find my poke at Muffin easily, I've only posted a little bit today.
 
I'm glad that you guys did not fall for Include's ruse. I guess this means @Ynnek7 is confirmed town since he didn't lie about the results he got from Stuart. It sucks to have lost a cop role like that so early, though. Guess scum must have used some sort of daytime kill ability to off him since there's no reason for anyone to ITA him and he'd likely be protected during the night.

I still have to wonder about Natiko, though. A bus after so many losses doesn't seem like a good idea, but maybe that's just what the scum team wants us to think?
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Your reads aren't the most elaborate stuff I've ever seen either.
I have actual scum reads though, and when I'm not at work I plan to dive deeper to try and get a better feel on several players. What are your reads currently then? Or is there a particular reason you don't have any besides a couple town reads?
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
You're reading too much into it... Or maybe not enough. It was a flavor choice. I recommend brushing up on your Marvel Writers. Some of them have some strange quirks.
READING IT FLAVOR CHOICE MARVEL WRITERS THEM QUIRKS.
7FV0TOg.gif


ScyGrTD.gif
 

Muffin

Born with a heart full of neutrality
I have actual scum reads though, and when I'm not at work I plan to dive deeper to try and get a better feel on several players. What are your reads currently then? Or is there a particular reason you don't have any besides a couple town reads?
I like how you're framing me saying that I find people who could have benefited from a 100% ITA boost in my earlier list as "having no scum reads".
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I like how you're framing me saying that I find people who could have benefited from a 100% ITA boost in my earlier list as "having no scum reads".
Maybe this is just a phrasing/semantics disagreement then? I don't interpret every suspicion as equating 1:1 with a scum read. I find myself suspicious of a lot of things when I play mafia, but that doesn't mean everyone that I question or get suspicious of are scum in my book.

Let me just try and resolve this:

Who do you scum read?
 

Muffin

Born with a heart full of neutrality
As for your question, I don't particular like the push Ezekel made against you earlier before we got into this whole situation between you and Include.

And Faircure is suspiciously quiet while showing up for ITAs to go with the crowd.
 

Muffin

Born with a heart full of neutrality
Maybe this is just a phrasing/semantics disagreement then? I don't interpret every suspicion as equating 1:1 with a scum read. I find myself suspicious of a lot of things when I play mafia, but that doesn't mean everyone that I question or get suspicious of are scum in my book.
The question before I posted my reads list earlier was specifically mentioning "who do you find suspicious" if i remember correctly, so yes, you can equate that with an anti-town read in my case.
 

Muffin

Born with a heart full of neutrality
Also Gorlak harping on melon earlier about the specifics of his role seemed weird to me. Not enough for an actual scumread though.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
As for your question, I don't particular like the push Ezekel made against you earlier before we got into this whole situation between you and Include.

And Faircure is suspiciously quiet while showing up for ITAs to go with the crowd.
As much as Ezekel has frustrated me, I simply can't find him scummy for the same reason I don't find Melon scummy. It just seems like such an unnecessary risk for scum. Thank you for answering my question.

The question before I posted my reads list earlier was specifically mentioning "who do you find suspicious" if i remember correctly, so yes, you can equate that with an anti-town read in my case.
Okay, I genuinely apologize then. I know how frustrating it can be to feel like your words are being taken out of context. That's my bad - hopefully you at least see why I would find it concerning given my misunderstanding. That being said I do feel you deserve at least a skim of your ISO because you really do feel like a blank spot for me mostly.

To everyone - I plan on ISOing several people. If there's anyone in particular you want to hear from me on let me know. If they have a ton of posts though it's going to be a skim. I only have so much free time.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
sorta? I mean it feels like NZJubjub kinda faded into the shadows after vere and I had our thing yesterday.
Yeah, can’t tell if it’s just inactivity or scum there. Frustrating because I feel that way about a lot of people. Is it just the size of the game? Hiding scum? Who fucking knows?
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
So, would you not say that shooting Splinter in that first ITA could look just as much of a move to gain credibility as Melon putting him at risk in the thunderdome - perhaps even more so by virtue of actually getting the kill?
No i wouldnt compare that to melon's TD. And no it's not a move to gain credibility. Apollo attempting to shoot Vere would be a move to gain credibility. Or the scum bussing Grizz.
I am like the only one in the game who even thought the No lynch/ Splinter v Melon/TD situation even looked off.

Also can we kill the "Splinter was at risk in the TD" storyline? What risk was there with both he and melon pushing for a no lynch? He was under no pressure at all.

Right now, I think the two of you look as bad as each other.
In no way do I look as bad as melon has. Please provide examples to back up your theories/claims like I have on melon.

The only reason melon has been read as town thus far is because "it doesnt make sense for scum to risk that gambit".
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Maybe this is just a phrasing/semantics disagreement then? I don't interpret every suspicion as equating 1:1 with a scum read. I find myself suspicious of a lot of things when I play mafia, but that doesn't mean everyone that I question or get suspicious of are scum in my book.

Let me just try and resolve this:

Who do you scum read?
Man, I just want to say: THIS.

Town does all manner of suspicious shit.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I’m gonna take a nap now that all my stuff is done, since I also had a doctors appt and am generally over humans for a minute. When I get back tonight I will make a reads list but I didn’t really sleep last night so if I tried it now I think I’d make no sense.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
ITA 2 Begins in:
pur_1530568800.png


ITA 3 Begins in:
pur_1530612000.png


And day 3 ends in:
pur_1530658800.png


Will probably be like 20-25 minutes after that timer if I had to estimate for you.
 
Well, now that I'm present for this next ITA phase, I'm having trouble deciding who to shoot.

Maybe just one of the inactives like briefs_cat or oreomunsta? They are low-info kills, though. Maybe Natiko to confirm if Include was trying to bus him? Hm... <_>
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Zeke also claimed being shot last night. What's your opinion on that?
Possibly scum, possibly a vig who'd had enough of the Melon tunnelling - who's to say?
In no way do I look as bad as melon has. Please provide examples to back up your theories/claims like I have on melon.
Call it a bad feeling. I'll be honest, your committal to your idea sounds genuine - I can't really see scum sitting back and letting a team-mate tunnel someone so hard - but I can't help but feel that the more you push, the more forced it seems to me. That's my take, anyway, I can't speak for others.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Call it a bad feeling. I'll be honest, your committal to your idea sounds genuine - I can't really see scum sitting back and letting a team-mate tunnel someone so hard - but I can't help but feel that the more you push, the more forced it seems to me. That's my take, anyway, I can't speak for others.
I havent been pushing for it. After all the stuff I did last day phase that went on deaf ears, I decided i wasnt going to make it a real sticking point like last time. Only really been bringing up when others bring it up for the most part.

Scum sitting back and letting it happen - Maybe they havent.
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
Greetings. I have a lot to catch up on but send me any questions you might have and I'll answer them whenever I can.
 
@EzekelRAGE , I've read back on Melon x Ezekel x Gorlak and I did not find agreeable new insights on why to lynch Melon. For me it adds to my townread. She was questioned well and thorough and answered fine in my eyes.

Only thing I maybe find weird is that Gorlak seems to seek for a better pay-off to the roll. Which I can understand. It seems a rather useless role if there isn't a reward. But if there would be a reward for Melon I don't see her picking Splinter. Especially when she gives up the lynch rather quick. So maybe it's just more of a fun role (which I think it is) than a powerful one. But that's the only point of Gorlak I can find myself agreeing with.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
I might be way off base, but I think in this case I fall on the side of believe Include in this switch. I haven't been able to get a good fix on Natiko and earlier his talking about when he was here (and not) put me in mind of his evasiveness during HvV. I haven't slept (still finishing my now overdue second chapter) so I dunno, maybe I'm insane. But I've been trying to get a good read on Natiko specifically and I just couldn't.

I will hold off any voting until we get more details from Include, though.

something something i like to nitpick monkey

i dislike this post for multiple reasons. feels like stalling to vote a scummate to see how things go.

Appears it's time for my claim - it can be partially verified today, not tomorrow (how convenient) as well. I am an Event Gambler. At night I submit three names and if one of them wins an item then I get a copy of it and become vanilla - I don't get to submit names anymore and have no chances at winning a second item. I put in Splinter, Melon, and Geno N1. I went with my top two town reads and Geno just seemed the type to try hard to get an item based on HVV lol

Melon won a 1-shot track, which means I got my copy. Hence why I could confirm that was the item. I tracked @BladeSymphony to @Stuart444 last night. I was going to leave it alone since nothing bad has happened to Stu and drop my scumread on Blade so as to not draw attention to him. That being said, since scum is now trying to throw a hail mary I figured it was pertinent to just come out with it all.

Anyways, suffice it to say I'm vanilla now so if I need to die to string up Include so be it. We're miles ahead right now.

Hrmm.

With Stuart unexpectedly dying I want to say we should keep an eye on Blade. He claims a protective role but it's possible he may be a Poisoner/Delayed Kill of some sort. I don't want to push that now in the case I'm wrong but if he lives for a continued period of time I'd recommend being cautious.

Her role as claimed doesn't sound scum (but if she is, she's almost certainly making up aspects). But it doesn't particularly sound neutral, either. It's not a terrible claim - just the timing, and the choice of Natiko. It makes me wonder if she's scum who's left on the time since this would probably be a group effort. Something to possibly speculate on after flip. I think it would point to at least one more veteran player left on the scum team.

Any thoughts on this now, Monkey?

and i was even a 1-shot!
My oh my melon if you keep this up i may start to get the wrong impression here.

of course it can talk, it just doesnt have anything to say.

Is this a weird subtle hint saying that you made that NPC?

Wait you did where

I'm glad people are finally talking about me. Felt a bit lonely

I keep trying to talk to you and you keep ignoring me ;;;;

Include spent a crazy amount of effort to paint Geno as scum yesterday. #3409 #3455
This whole going at each other does not seem construed to me (yeah, yeah you never know)
In the first post she also included Sawneeks and Kawl. She refers to a D1 post about Saw too.
Here she is #3528 Townreading Ezekel, monkey and melon.

This is another longer interaction between Saw and Include #3593. I don't want to underestimate these two, but I don't think they would've argued all this time when they are in the same team.

Yet this is Saw's read afterwards:

Ambivalent.
---
Stuart, Geno, Sawneeks, Kawl
Ezekel, Monkey, Melon

Out of these reads I'd argue there is at least on partner of her either in Geno/Saw or Monkey/Melon. I'm leaning Saw over Geno and Melon over Monkey. Because of the length of arguments I'd suspect her townreads to be more likely to be partners.

Wait. Are you seriously scumreading me because the back-and-forth I had with Include lead me to Town read her? Just because I argue with someone doesn't mean I think they are Scum. :x
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Greetings. I have a lot to catch up on but send me any questions you might have and I'll answer them whenever I can.
Are you scum?

@EzekelRAGE , I've read back on Melon x Ezekel x Gorlak and I did not find agreeable new insights on why to lynch Melon. For me it adds to my townread. She was questioned well and thorough and answered fine in my eyes.

Only thing I maybe find weird is that Gorlak seems to seek for a better pay-off to the roll. Which I can understand. It seems a rather useless role if there isn't a reward. But if there would be a reward for Melon I don't see her picking Splinter. Especially when she gives up the lynch rather quick. So maybe it's just more of a fun role (which I think it is) than a powerful one. But that's the only point of Gorlak I can find myself agreeing with.

Alright.
 

Nomad Sparkster

This is some wild shit maynard
I have become one with the universe, rising like a fiery phoenix before your very eyes. I see everything and I know everything. I'AM THE SHITPOST
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
I would hope you know how to do it considering you've been around since the start of the game.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
For a moment, I thought the Lone Stranger had somehow got two shots there. Interesting time to slip a vote in.
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
This game sucks. Needs rebalancing. ITA hit percentage needs to be at least....3 times bigger
 
Top Bottom