Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

[LuxCommander]

So, now that Natiko is confirmed scum, I want to look deeply into his post history. I found this gem here:

Appears it's time for my claim - it can be partially verified today, not tomorrow (how convenient) as well. I am an Event Gambler. At night I submit three names and if one of them wins an item then I get a copy of it and become vanilla - I don't get to submit names anymore and have no chances at winning a second item. I put in Splinter, Melon, and Geno N1. I went with my top two town reads and Geno just seemed the type to try hard to get an item based on HVV lol

We all know how Splinter turned out. I think I'm gonna shift my vote over now. Might even go in for the kill during the next round of ITAs.

VOTE: melonrabbit

 

[melonrabbit]

Yes, LP saying hi after days of nothing is certainly putting in more effort than same.

Shameful.

 

[melonrabbit]

So, now that Natiko is confirmed scum, I want to look deeply into his post history. I found this gem here:



We all know how Splinter turned out. I think I'm gonna shift my vote over now. Might even go in for the kill during the next round of ITAs.

VOTE: melonrabbit

I'm not sure how that's a gem.

Given we don't know the amount of scum left it is in our best interest to deal with these inactives.

Lylo is coming.

 

[melonrabbit]

LP. The way you worded that post made it seem like that was all LP had said.

Confused you with LP. Get an avatar plz.

 

[LuxCommander]

I'm not sure how that's a gem.

Given we don't know the amount of scum left it is in our best interest to deal with these inactives.

Lylo is coming.

I don't have a problem chewing through inactives, but what difference does the order actually make? If those inactives are town, then we get closer to LYLO anyways.

 

[melonrabbit]

I don't have a problem chewing through inactives, but what difference does the order actually make? If those inactives are town, then we get closer to LYLO anyways.

Okay. If you think it is cool that they are essentially holding a spot in a game they don't feel like playing ever.

My mislynch is far more interesting anyway.

 

[Kawl]

Wait melon got Bp not muffin. I hate all the m names

@Blargonaut why did you choose melon?

 

[melonrabbit]

Also, in general your turnover from briefs to me is a little abrupt. @LuxCommander
You were on board with Kalor for minutes before getting bored.

Who are you supposed to be again, Red?

@Kawl how dare you not remember me.

 

[melonrabbit]

You are just jelly of mine and Blarg's friendship.

 

[LuxCommander]

I just felt it was necessary to go back and check the records. Your post count has increased. Almost as if your heart started beating faster.

 

[melonrabbit]

I just felt it was necessary to go back and check the records. Your post count has increased. Almost as if your heart started beating faster.

Citation needed.

 

[Kawl]

You are just jelly of mine and Blarg's friendship.

You’ll never be a part of hydro cannon no matter how hard you try.

 

[Blargonaut]

Vote: Melonrabbit

Goin to sleep. Will be back for ITAs, then back to bed.

 

[BladeSymphony]

@BladeSymphony can you please answer what Monkey asked earlier about what made you switch on your Natiko read? it's especially relevant now that Natiko has flipped and it's kinda weird that you just ignored that post.

He knew I went to Stuart. It made me think he may have been the town tracker, even with my already mafia suspicions. His votes yesterday just confirmed I was wrong.

 

[Blargonaut]

You’ll never be a part of hydro cannon no matter how hard you try.

Keep that in mind, we designed that rhyme

 

[Blargonaut]

WAIT IS IT ITA TIME??

 

[Muffin]

WAIT IS IT ITA TIME??

No, five and a half hours till the next phase I think

 

[Muffin]

Nvm, it's four and a half.

 

[Muffin]

Second ITA Phase In:

Third ITA Phase in:

Day 4 Ends in:

 

[Blargonaut]

What the fuck is happening

 

[Blargonaut]

Before ITA phase begins and independent of the ITA he attempted to make:

@EzekelRAGE and @heymonkey have been killed





Now ITA Phase Starts

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

 

[Blargonaut]

WHO DID THIS

 

[Blargonaut]

I'LL EAT YOU ALIVE

 

[Lone_Prodigy]

Given that I've read a fraction of this thread, this is your chance to sway me towards your biggest scum read with selective quoting and eloquent analysis.

I do however disagree with that Natiko quote. He wouldn't put two scum buddies in a list of three.

 

[Blargonaut]

WHO WILL DO ALL THE SCUMHUNTING WORK NOW

DO YOU EVEN REALISE HOW MUCH PAPERWORK YOU'VE SHOVED ONTO ME

 

[Lone_Prodigy]

Or he might, just to mess with us.

 

[Blargonaut]

UGH

 

[Blargonaut]

Assuming it wasn't a Daystrong, whoever did this must've targeted heymonkey

I gave Ezekel a vest last Night

 

[briefs_cat]

I've no issue with this. @briefs_cat, where have ya been?

VOTE: briefs_cat

Yeah sorry, I got distracted by other things and kinda forgot about this. I'm catching up now

 

[Blargonaut]

And if you're wondering, "Why Ezekel?" It 's because he was as good as Town for shooting Rynam I mean *Splinter

 

[Blargonaut]

I'm catching up now

really

 

[Blargonaut]

boy am I pissed

This is a workload

 

[Blargonaut]

well at least someone got Natiko and was correct about it

 

[Blargonaut]

where do we even start

 

[Blargonaut]

wow I really, really hate under-the-table kills

wow

 

[Blargonaut]

Geno what do you think about this situation

 

[briefs_cat]

Why you spamming?

 

[Blargonaut]

Who scumread monkey

 

[Blargonaut]

Why you spamming?

I'm spamming? So you understand Coolest?

 

[Kawl]

Assuming it wasn't a Daystrong, whoever did this must've targeted heymonkey

I gave Ezekel a vest last Night

Back down to 60% on trusting blarg

 

[Sawneeks]

fuckfuckfuck we just lost essentially all of our stronger Town Players in one go.

fuck this really sucks

 

[Sawneeks]

Natiko's Role PM:

also

i'm back to trusting my gut because it's apparently much, much better at this game than the rest of me

Vote: Melonrabbit

 

[Sawneeks]

Why you spamming?

holy shit, you're alive.

have you been reading the thread?

 

[Sawneeks]

@rac This was all I could find with ET talking about Nat in a very brief ISO

Waittt you can switch roles?

But...
Why would he switch with Nat?

I mean why would he use his power to switch on Nat?

But didn't Include finger Nat like a bit after someone mentioned him?

I mean I think he just knew there was an ITA and shot.

 

[Sawneeks]

Gonna try and also take the chance this phase to go over the remaining living Players. We likely still have a sizeable Scum Team left outside of potential Neutral(s) and with confirmation that we have nearly 4 kills per Night Phase + some mystery in-thread kill this game is going to become very small, very fast.

 

[Muffin]

Gonna try and also take the chance this phase to go over the remaining living Players. We likely still have a sizeable Scum Team left outside of potential Neutral(s) and with confirmation that we have nearly 4 kills per Night Phase + some mystery in-thread kill this game is going to become very small, very fast.

Two ITA phases left too today

 

[Sawneeks]

Two ITA phases left too today

True, but given how little we seem to hit those we may get 1 or 2 more deaths. :x

also muffin you gotta help me out here. gimme them scum reads

 

[Muffin]

also muffin you gotta help me out here. gimme them scum reads

It's hard, ET is still a possible person who could have got boosted on D2 by scum, but I'm more and more not feeling it. Not acting scummy.

And monkey and Natiko flipped before I could shoot or vote them today, so I'm kinda out of options I set up at day start. Kalor is left in that pile of early Alexem vote. I'll go through his posts.

Besides that, at this point I just want to get LP out. The showing up and asking others to do the work for him is getting old.

 

[Sawneeks]

I dedicate this shot to the lovers.

Conjure Ceiling Pizza: melonrabbit

Question; why?

Not counting the fact that Melon is supposed to be BP thanks to Blarg I'd love to know why you picked her.

Swamped

samesies here

 

[Muffin]

Swamped still needs to explain the vote and the shot on me.

 

[Sawneeks]

It's hard, ET is still a possible person who could have got boosted on D2 by scum, but I'm more and more not feeling it. Not acting scummy.

And monkey and Natiko flipped before I could shoot or vote them today, so I'm kinda out of options I set up at day start. Kalor is left in that pile of early Alexem vote. I'll go through his posts.

Besides that, at this point I just want to get LP out. The showing up and asking others to do the work for him is getting old.

Need more than this. We've got around...24 Players left? And likely 5 or so Scum so this isn't covering it. Give me gut reads, slight feelings, etc.

Also what do you think of rac calling out ET for that early celebration? how does this effect your read?

 

[Sawneeks]

Swamped still needs to explain the vote and the shot on me.

that too but you covered it already so I didn't quote it again.

 

[Geno]

Shoot Sawneeks in the ITA

 

[LuxCommander]

Shoot Sawneeks in the ITA

Why?

Not that you've given me any reason to doubt you so far, just the opposite, but why?

 

[Geno]

Why?

Not that you've given me any reason to doubt you so far, just the opposite, but why?

Think about it, what has she contributed in this game? The way I see it she has said a whole lot of nothing.

 

[Kalor]

Need more than this. We've got around...24 Players left? And likely 5 or so Scum so this isn't covering it. Give me gut reads, slight feelings, etc.

Also what do you think of rac calling out ET for that early celebration? how does this effect your read?

I assume you meant me and not rac? I don't think rac mentioned the early celebration, Fandorin did though

 

[Muffin]

Also what do you think of rac calling out ET for that early celebration?

When did this happen? I'm not finding it in racs post history

Shoot Sawneeks in the ITA

I mean you've been right so far, any specific reason?

 

[Muffin]

Nvm you answered already.

 

[Sawneeks]

Shoot Sawneeks in the ITA

Think about it, what has she contributed in this game? The way I see it she has said a whole lot of nothing.

I know I've been playing badly but I'd hardly say I've contributed nothing. :x

Also recommend you don't waste your shot on me and try to it actual scummy players.

 

[Muffin]

Jubjub was probably killed by a town or neutral role. Scum probably wouldn't kill someone with suspicion against them, unless they thought they had an important role.

This is curious. Scum would know that they didn't try to kill JubJub, and Kalor seems very sure of it here. Two or three posts later Lux admits to the kill. Luck, or something else?

 

[Sawneeks]

I assume you meant me and not rac? I don't think rac mentioned the early celebration, Fandorin did though

When did this happen? I'm not finding it in racs post history


I mean you've been right so far, any specific reason?

Was it Kalor? My bad. :<

and Muffin don't ignore my question.

 

[Muffin]

and Muffin don't ignore my question.

I didn't ignore it, you gave me the wrong person to go through lol

 

[Muffin]

I'm looking at the post and it could be a slip. Then again I found Natiko to be scummy also and can see myself reacting similar if I'm rather sure of it.

Rather NAI to me, maybe a slight direction into scummy territory.

 

[rac]

I'm looking at the post and it could be a slip. Then again I found Natiko to be scummy also and can see myself reacting similar if I'm rather sure of it.

Rather NAI to me, maybe a slight direction into scummy territory.

if extreme was so sure natiko was scum why would he post about wanting to ita briefs cat right before and then never even submitting one but be active enough to react to the hit before the flip even happens

 

[Geno]

I know I've been playing badly but I'd hardly say I've contributed nothing. :x

Also recommend you don't waste your shot on me and try to it actual scummy players.

I mean if not nothing then very little. I think it's worth it so we can eliminate veteran scum players like you and leave only the top town alive for the late game.

 

[Geno]

Like with Natiko, it made way too much sense for him to be scum so shooting him first leaves us more room to work with as town. Shooting Briefs cat gives us nothing even if he flips scum.

 

[Muffin]

if extreme was so sure natiko was scum why would he post about wanting to ita briefs cat right before and then never even submitting one but be active enough to react to the hit before the flip even happens

The former is a fair point. I don't see the problem with the latter. If he's indecisive about his shot, he can still take part in the thread. Nothing weird about that.

 

[Sawneeks]

I didn't ignore it, you gave me the wrong person to go through lol

I meant my other ques-

actually, it was more of a statement. my bad. but I meant this:

Need more than this. We've got around...24 Players left? And likely 5 or so Scum so this isn't covering it. Give me gut reads, slight feelings, etc.

I mean if not nothing then very little. I think it's worth it so we can eliminate veteran scum players like you and leave only the top town alive for the late game.

Meh. Explain to me the logic of killing of someone who has contributed 'little' to someone who has contributed less? i.e. me over, say, LP or briefs?

Also ask why you would even want that? Natiko was highly Town Read by people before he died, as was Include. If anything purposefully keeping the Top Town alive for late game only for that reason opens you up to being deceived like that again.

 

[Sawneeks]

Like with Natiko, it made way too much sense for him to be scum so shooting him first leaves us more room to work with as town. Shooting Briefs cat gives us nothing even if he flips scum.

If you are so dead-set on this I'd recommend not shooting me then, you'd have better luck on a lynch.

 

[Muffin]

I agree with Geno that we should rather take care of possible competent scum players instead of inactives that won't give us much info.

Even though I really wanna shoot LP.

 

[Kawl]

If you are so dead-set on this I'd recommend not shooting me then, you'd have better luck on a lynch.

Spicy

 

[Sawneeks]

Like with Natiko, it made way too much sense for him to be scum so shooting him first leaves us more room to work with as town. Shooting Briefs cat gives us nothing even if he flips scum.

Please show me where you've gone back and looked over Natiko's and other scum flips posts to find more info. Because if you're arguing info kills you have to still do the work instead of just the talk.

 

[Muffin]

actually, it was more of a statement. my bad. but I meant this:

Pretty sure I named most of my reads. I might wanna add that I feel good about Brazil so far. Was sceptical when he joined, but he picked up till now.

Natiko was highly Town Read

Errrr, really?

 

[Geno]

If you are so dead-set on this I'd recommend not shooting me then, you'd have better luck on a lynch.

Hmm, might be a bait but I guess we can't kill you now.

 

[Muffin]

Pretty sure I named most of my reads. I might wanna add that I feel good about Brazil so far. Was sceptical when he joined, but he picked up till now.

That should say "newer reads". My opinion on people like Melon, Geno, Blarg, kawl etc. hasn't changed.

 

[Muffin]

@Sorian

Would it be possible to give us a list of players who still need to shoot?

If I missed it in the thread, if anybody else can quote it, that'd be nice.

 

[Sorian]

@Sorian

Would it be possible to give us a list of players who still need to shoot?

If I missed it in the thread, if anybody else can quote it, that'd be nice.

Blade, Blarg, briefs, Coolest, Fandorin, Kawl, L_P, Lux, Muffin, Oreo, rac, Sawneeks, Stanley, Ynnek, Zubz

I believe that’s right, playing with my spreadsheet on mobile can be hard.

 

[BladeSymphony]

I'll be traveling for work tomorrow and I'll be back fairly late so I apologize if I am late with any messages during that time. I'll try to be around for today's ITAs phase but I can't promise more than that. Will catch up when I return.

 

[Muffin]

Blade, Blarg, briefs, Coolest, Fandorin, Kawl, L_P, Lux, Muffin, Oreo, rac, Sawneeks, Stanley, Ynnek, Zubz

I believe that’s right, playing with my spreadsheet on mobile can be hard.

Thanks, Thanos.

@Blargonaut @Sawneeks @Ynnek7 who are you three thinking of shooting today?

 

[Geno]

I thought Ynnek was dead.

 

[Kalor]

Hmm, might be a bait but I guess we can't kill you now.

Is that all it takes for you to change your mind about killing someone?

 

[Geno]

Is that all it takes for you to change your mind about killing someone?

Where did you get that?

 

[Muffin]

I thought Ynnek was dead.

Stuart is dead, which makes Ynnek basically vanilla now. Confirmed vanilla though.

 

[Kalor]

Where did you get that?

It was just that you bring up the idea of killing Saw and then decide against it pretty quickly.

 

[Lone_Prodigy]

This is a work in progress.

Won't shoot
Geno

 

[Blargonaut]

I mean if not nothing then very little. I think it's worth it so we can eliminate veteran scum players like you and leave only the top town alive for the late game.

l o l

 

[Blargonaut]

Thanks, Thanos.

@Blargonaut @Sawneeks @Ynnek7 who are you three thinking of shooting today?

You or Geno

 

[Geno]

It was just that you bring up the idea of killing Saw and then decide against it pretty quickly.

No? I said we can't kill her because she claimed BP. Ita is useless.

 

[Kalor]

No? I said we can't kill her because she claimed BP. Ita is useless.

We already knew she was BP from Blargs vest. The wording of your post makes way more sense now if you didn't know that beforehand.

 

[Muffin]

You or Geno

You serious? I can't see any reason to shoot Geno and I don't know why you wanna shoot me, but that's at least a bit more understandable.

 

[Muffin]

Also @Swamped wanna explain a bit or nah

 

[Kawl]

We already knew she was BP from Blargs vest. The wording of your post makes way more sense now if you didn't know that beforehand.

Saw doesn’t have a blargovest...

 

[Kawl]

Also maaaaan this thread slowed way the fuck down with those three people dying

 

[Poltergust]

You serious? I can't see any reason to shoot Geno and I don't know why you wanna shoot me, but that's at least a bit more understandable.

I have to agree with Muffin here. Why shoot Geno who just killed scum in the last ITA phase? I wouldn't exactly consider someone like that a high-priority target.

 

[melonrabbit]

I meant my other ques-

actually, it was more of a statement. my bad. but I meant this:




Meh. Explain to me the logic of killing of someone who has contributed 'little' to someone who has contributed less? i.e. me over, say, LP or briefs?

Also ask why you would even want that? Natiko was highly Town Read by people before he died, as was Include. If anything purposefully keeping the Top Town alive for late game only for that reason opens you up to being deceived like that again.

Explain to me the logic of wanting to want a much more powerful vote on me over someone that has contributed very "little' like a briefs or LP.

I see when it is your ass on the line suddenly you care about this game. Honestly I hope you aren't scum because this is one of the poorest game I've seen you play.

Your reads are just piggybacked half the time and you constantly forgot there is a thread. Are you not remotely curious why suddedly briefs and LP picked now to hop back into the thread and participate. No? Still worried about yourself.

 

[Poltergust]

Also maaaaan this thread slowed way the fuck down with those three people dying

We're just going to need to pick up the slack. It sucks since I believed both heymonkey and Ezekel to be town, too. Now I have to be more wary of others. =/

 

[Fandorin]

At work and will be during the ITA, so I skimmed hardcore.

Anyways, I will shoot the hell out of Extreme.

 

[Fandorin]

Explain to me the logic of wanting to want a much more powerful vote on me over someone that has contributed very "little' like a briefs or LP.

I see when it is your ass on the line suddenly you care about this game. Honestly I hope you aren't scum because this is one of the poorest game I've seen you play.

Your reads are just piggybacked half the time and you constantly forgot there is a thread. Are you not remotely curious why suddedly briefs and LP picked now to hop back into the thread and participate. No? Still worried about yourself.

Wait, briefs actually turned up?!

 

[melonrabbit]

Wait, briefs actually turned up?!

Yup. just this page after being called out for days. And was like, "There was a game???? Oh lol"

 

[Poltergust]

At work and will be during the ITA, so I skimmed hardcore.

Anyways, I will shoot the hell out of Extreme.

Extreme has been bugging me, too. He's the last one alive who got a hit during Day 2 ITAs, so if Apollo used his 100% hitrate ITA ability then Extreme is the only candidate left for that. Him jumping the gun on reacting to Natiko's death also strikes me as odd, like he knew Natiko was scum before the role PM was posted.

And then there's this post:

So me, fellow Mafia is happy a mafia member died?

Dude what. Why would I be happy? I mean the Mafia is so outnumbered right now.

That last sentence bothers me, because he sounds so sure about how much scum is left. There could be as little as 2 left, or as many as 6. If scum are at 5 or 6 then town is in a lot of trouble. But, we have no way to know for sure, so making a claim like that with such certainty doesn't sit well with me.

Not to mention that he has basically been coasting along, not making any significant contributions. The biggest thing he's done was killing Verelios, but a whole lot of people wanted to do that Day 2 as well.

If Extreme is indeed town then I think he's not doing a good job at it.