Spectator Thread Marvel Heroes Spec Thread - The Half That Hates Me

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
I need town hooker explained to me

A hooker is exactly the same as a roleblocker. The difference is it insinuates that a Virgin is in the game (a virgin, if you dont know, is a role that if killed makes scum miss their next kill automatically) and if the hooker ever roleblocks the virgin then they aren't a virgin anymore.

Sawneeks and I were scum hookers in love boat 2 and I called an audible and decided that the truth is always the best lie so claimed as is and blamed Grizzly for bad balancing giving us a town hooker that could disable a town virigin.
 
Sawneeks and I were scum hookers in love boat 2 and I called an audible and decided that the truth is always the best lie so claimed as is and blamed Grizzly for bad balancing giving us a town hooker that could disable a town virigin.

The hilarious thing reading this is hearing that it actually worked haha.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Zeke may be dead but the tunnel lives on!

Zeke gonna come in here and start talking about how this spec chat is a work and we're still in the game.

894e390897670ebe3fd5984102549.gif


@Splinter and @EzekelRAGE sup?

Lololol. I still shot you even though I knew you had a vest. Was fun though.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
RIP melon

Soon, I think, RIP town. They started eating themselves at an accelerated rate.

I will ignore ALL town hooker discussion on the grounds of it incriminates but like it was my third game or something, I dunno.

I'm so terrible at sorting out fake claims.
 

Pedro

The Last Airbender is actually a great movie
This community should stop outright assuming that "X role has to be scum", or "X role has to function this way", like the designers can't tweak original concepts and create something new.
Almost every game this season brought something new to the table, and I don't think people notice that.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
This community should stop outright assuming that "X role has to be scum", or "X role has to function this way", like the designers can't tweak original concepts and create something new.
Almost every game this season brought something new to the table, and I don't think people notice that.

In a bubble, I agree. That said, I still will definitely use this line when I know of another role in the game and the one we are talking about is a direct counter.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I've always said you were the mvp of that game. Your tunnel was amazing.
I managed to loop back on that scum read of Sophia like three times and eventually bury us because I was SO SURE that I wanted to lynch them now so that when I died Sorian could be polished off. Kark and you played me like a fiddle.
 
This community should stop outright assuming that "X role has to be scum", or "X role has to function this way", like the designers can't tweak original concepts and create something new.
Almost every game this season brought something new to the table, and I don't think people notice that.

Sounds like something to announce once this season ends!

"Guys! STOP THIS! Love Pedro"
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
I promise to write us a new meta next season with some insane action. You all have my word.

We need fresh memes too.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
This community should stop outright assuming that "X role has to be scum", or "X role has to function this way", like the designers can't tweak original concepts and create something new.
Almost every game this season brought something new to the table, and I don't think people notice that.
let's talk about this instead because ACCURATE

also all games will now have ten JOATS. Everyone is a JOAT.
 
Btw what i wanted to ask a while ago about a mafia command a while ago @Sorian
Does the "Command D on Kawl" still be in effect after Coolest lost his Role powers?
 

Pedro

The Last Airbender is actually a great movie
No one called dibs on the IP either

make digimon mafia for us, stu

In a bubble, I agree. That said, I still will definitely use this line when I know of another role in the game and the one we are talking about is a direct counter.

Sure, but there weren't counters for Gladiator and now Adrenaline Junkie in those moments, and we rarely have the latter in our games to even have a "meta" about it.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Btw what i wanted to ask a while ago about a mafia command a while ago @Sorian
Does the "Command D on Kawl" still be in effect after Coolest lost his Role powers?

Yes and he was notified that it lasts forever
 
No one called dibs on the IP either

make digimon mafia for us, stu

(psst I don't have that type of time.... right now psst)

If you want to really stare into the abyss, go read Heroes vs. Villains mafia

I read up til half way through the first day and then closed the tab.

Considering going back to it when I actually have that type of time to read through it >_>
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
In keeping with tradition, I'll need Puppetmon again.

I already got Joker both times we did a batman game.
 

Xbro

Bags his own tea
Geno is saying there is no way that he's scum because he killed two major scums. That sounds so much like a bus it hurts.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
And you knew from day zero. Because I told you from the second I got the PM I'd TD Splinter.

How could you do this to me?

And yes, you PM'd me while I was still sending role PMs and was already trying to plan for how things would go if you killed scum's strongest killer like hour 1 into the day lol
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
I feel like they are going to eat briefs alive, I know he’s trying to prove and get a feel of the game but this late in, it looks so wishy washy
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
I can only assume that face applies to Monkey too whenever she reads any mafia thread.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
I find it hilarious whenever I see kids wearing giant shades. Monkey probably started yelling at the ice cream man at that moment
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
mfw yet another scum member gets ITAd
Because I hate myself and had to know, both town and scum are actually below the 15% hit rate. The difference is Town is a decent bit further below it than us currently.

Edit: That is being hit, not landing a hit.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I find it hilarious whenever I see kids wearing giant shades. Monkey probably started yelling at the ice cream man at that moment
She was actually totally happy; I just happened to snap pictures of her making weird faces. Timing + luck = best reaction shot

and those shades are pretty hilarious
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Because I hate myself and had to know, both town and scum are actually below the 15% hit rate. The difference is Town is a decent bit further below it than us currently.

Edit: That is being hit, not landing a hit.
There's more townies too and that would pull it down a bit, eh?
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
There's more townies too and that would pull it down a bit, eh?
Uhh, I dunno. All I did was look at the shots at scum that were attempted and that landed then did the same for town. I ignored who shot and if they survived due to BP I still counted it as a hit. The number of shots at scum compared to town isn’t that far off (just 9 less), but both groups have been hit by 4.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Taking out all the ITA increase roles within a day and a half lol
 

Nomad Sparkster

This is some wild shit maynard
This game has kinda reinvigorated my love for mafia and srsly being compared to blarg by Sorian is the highest compliment I will get from Sorian!
 

melonrabbit

The only good kind of melon
Fandorin, Kalor, LP, Extreme, and Coolest

Town is fuckkkked. GG, scum. Mostly.

**An aside, I strongly question some of the tactics being employed by some of the scum team. There's low activity and there's no activity and the latter of what isn't fun to play with regardless of where the alignments fall.

It manipulations the game in a way that makes it actually unfair to those that show up and want to be part of the game. I realize the review thread is probably a better place for this. But I'm honestly somewhat hurt that some have chosen this as a means to play.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Town is fuckkkked. GG, scum. Mostly.

**An aside, I strongly question some of the tactics being employed by some of the scum team. There's low activity and there's no activity and the latter of what isn't fun to play with regardless of where the alignments fall.

It manipulations the game in a way that makes it actually unfair to those that show up and want to be part of the game. I realize the review thread is probably a better place for this. But I'm honestly somewhat hurt that some have chosen this as a means to play.
I think it will be a topic of discussion in the review thread. At least Monkey indicated so. It’s tough - I too generally wish everyone would put in effort and be active. I also don’t want to alienate people just because they’re different in playstyle than me - especially since I basically never play anymore. Due to that it’s probably a conversation better had by others.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I come off town reading everyone still alive from the group more, that being Kawl, Brazil, Saw, faircure and Geno. The reactions seem legit and the progression of the event makes sense with what the players acted and said during and after it.

Sawneeks asking for a chance to share her reads list before death and Apollo and DCPat jumping in to throw shade at Brazil after he distrusts Stuart reinforces my town read on them too.

I don't think we had 3 scum in this event. Considering the passes, the only player who even has a chance at that would be faircure, but I don't buy it.
Translation:
I’m going to kill you all
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I think it will be a topic of discussion in the review thread. At least Monkey indicated so. It’s tough - I too generally wish everyone would put in effort and be active. I also don’t want to alienate people just because they’re different in playstyle than me - especially since I basically never play anymore. Due to that it’s probably a conversation better had by others.

first, you should play all the time. we love you. even when you're a scum-ass.

second
There's play style and then there's not participating in a way that allows people around you to function appropriately. I think it would be great if we designed some games for lower activity players. But in our standard meta, it really does start to feel like taking away a spot from people who want in and handicapping those in the game unnecessarily. Like I said before, I'm fine with just the minimum. But this is really extreme.

The solution needs to come on multiple fronts, I think; we as players need to be more punishing (and work together better); that's an ongoing issue. We need to learn the difference between actual wasted kills and utility kills, and when to operationalize abilities and lynches. We maybe need some ways to divide players up by activity throughout the season, too, to foster differences in playstyles. But we need people to play, too. That's a matter of trust the same as RL excuses. Without trust I fear for our community and there have been a few instances this season that erode some of that.
 
@Zubz happy birthday!

@melonrabbit seeing someone else tunnel on you really showed me how bad I was back in Buffy. You truly are a tunnel magnet.

In other news at the end game ET, Coolest and Lp are gonna get got sooner or later, but maybe Fando and Kalor can pull it off.

@heymonkey your daughter's reaction is gold! Nice timing there.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
first, you should play all the time. we love you. even when you're a scum-ass.

second
There's play style and then there's not participating in a way that allows people around you to function appropriately. I think it would be great if we designed some games for lower activity players. But in our standard meta, it really does start to feel like taking away a spot from people who want in and handicapping those in the game unnecessarily. Like I said before, I'm fine with just the minimum. But this is really extreme.

The solution needs to come on multiple fronts, I think; we as players need to be more punishing (and work together better); that's an ongoing issue. We need to learn the difference between actual wasted kills and utility kills, and when to operationalize abilities and lynches. We maybe need some ways to divide players up by activity throughout the season, too, to foster differences in playstyles. But we need people to play, too. That's a matter of trust the same as RL excuses. Without trust I fear for our community and there have been a few instances this season that erode some of that.
I dunno, we’ll see. I can accept being bad, I won’t accept ruining other’s enjoyment. It’s been awhile since then, but to this day I feel bad about the impact I had on Palmer and Sophia’s enjoyment.

I don’t disagree that this game has a couple really egregious examples. The hard part to me is no matter which route you take someone ends up alienated, and I worry that my perspective is biased because I know the type of activity and effort I like to see. How do you decide what constitutes abuse of the system? When you do identify it, how do you address it with someone guilty of doing so in a way that doesn’t alienate them? I wouldn’t want to see anyone leave that hasn’t done something legitimately awful.
 
If I have one thing that I wasn't so convinced about in the game is the ITA, it gives no way for scums to bullshit their way through accusations. Natiko is a good talker he could have managed to survive, I on the other hand had a red check and no way to be able to defend myself before I get home. Splinter is also damn unfortunate... And so on an do forth.

It kinda defy the purpose of lynch and hope to convince and deceive others.

The concept is fun and adrenaline inducing but perhaps it should have been limited to a handful of shot per day, not all the players at once on a single phase.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I do think scum has had worse luck with the ITAs than town, but realistically it’s a fine mechanic. We just kept having too many people in the limelight that soaked up a lot of shots. There shouldn’t be this many shots at scum realistically but due to our own hubris, some bad breaks with checks, and some of our team being MIA for chunks of time here we are.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
@Include Limiting ITA's is an interesting idea. It adds another layer of complexity when you can only have, say 3 shots per phase and the bullets are randomly assigned. Tones down on the clutter and allows analysis afterwards.
I dunno, we’ll see. I can accept being bad, I won’t accept ruining other’s enjoyment. It’s been awhile since then, but to this day I feel bad about the impact I had on Palmer and Sophia’s enjoyment.

I don’t disagree that this game has a couple really egregious examples. The hard part to me is no matter which route you take someone ends up alienated, and I worry that my perspective is biased because I know the type of activity and effort I like to see. How do you decide what constitutes abuse of the system? When you do identify it, how do you address it with someone guilty of doing so in a way that doesn’t alienate them? I wouldn’t want to see anyone leave that hasn’t done something legitimately awful.
I mostly agree with this. Differences in playstyle can sometimes be hard to gauge, for example when I initially started playing I did enjoy aggressive arguing but I could also understand that it's not for everyone. Striking a balance is a bitch and a half, even without considering real world complications.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Another idea would be to limit everyone’s bullets overall. So each person gets x shots. Also gives you room to make roles that play with that limit some too. I don’t think this mechanic works well without a large ass player count though so good luck to anyone brave enough outside of Sorian to run it lol
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I don’t disagree that this game has a couple really egregious examples. The hard part to me is no matter which route you take someone ends up alienated, and I worry that my perspective is biased because I know the type of activity and effort I like to see. How do you decide what constitutes abuse of the system? When you do identify it, how do you address it with someone guilty of doing so in a way that doesn’t alienate them? I wouldn’t want to see anyone leave that hasn’t done something legitimately awful.
I can agree with that. I'm certainly not gonna say I think it's an easy fix. :/
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I do like the notion of ITAs and I hope it comes back at some point with variations. Overall, I find the events and mechanics here to be much more within the gamespace than the events in HvV. I feel like players retained agency here, whereas in HvV things felt more arbitrary. I'm interested in seeing how we can evolved these more mechanics heavy games in the future.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Yeah, I definately agree that ITAs have made this game more memorable. I was expecting them to whittle players at a faster rate, actually, but combined with the muliple night kills, the pace has been kept rolling quite nicely.
 
On the ITA thing: I do like that there was ones for people in different timezones. Better chance of not wasting a shot :).

Random thought but a chance I would have made is maybe have ITAs on alternating day phases ie days 1, 3, 5 or 2, 4, etc and have multiple events (preferebly death events) on the days where there is no ITAs :P.

It's only a thought since events as we've seen with that pass the antidote event gives time for discussion and can even be used later rather than just random shots that the ITA gives you.
 
Top Bottom