Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

I'm back and compiled a list of the day kills:

@nin1000 has been killed



@Kyanrute has died



Game Continues

@Stuart444 has been killed

Before ITA phase begins and independent of the ITA he attempted to make:

@EzekelRAGE and @heymonkey have been killed





Now ITA Phase Starts

@Kalor Do you still want to do the same command? Sorry for interrupting




I think this accounts for everyone? I'll see what I can gleam from these kills.

One quick thing, though: I don't know why both nin1000 and Kyanrute died at the same time. It makes no sense for that to have been the cause of one action unless the ability has something like "you can kill two people at once with your first shot" or something, but they are still listed under the same post (which implies a singular action), so... I dunno. I looked through the other scum PMs and the only one that could possibly have done the other kill was Splinter, but he died before those two did, so that can't be it.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Huh,

I'm bothered that I didn't highlight one of those. That was unintentional before someone starts trying to divine something weird from that.
 
Huh,

I'm bothered that I didn't highlight one of those. That was unintentional before someone starts trying to divine something weird from that.
I was about to say... =P

Anyways, I've looked through Kyanrute's posts and can't find any reason as to why scum would kill him. I mean, look at this:
Not gonna have a good answer for that but that in itself is a good answer, is it not?

Shoot Splinter for memes, Sawneeks for trusting me too much.
Vote I dunno, don't think my D1 Vere case has legs now though I'll give myself a disclaimer that I haven't parsed much of D2 through yet.
Protect, ehh, boring if I can give it to myself so Apollo I guess. #D1feels
Thinks Apollo is town at this point and only jokes about shooting Splinter (this happened before Splinter died).

nin1000 makes more sense because everyone was town-reading him. Plus, he was an active player.

Stuart's death is pretty self-explanatory. Declaring himself to be 1/2 of an alignment cop put a humongous target on his back.
 

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
I'm out of work now and here. So is our best bet right now to wait for the day kill and figure out where to go from there?

I had forgotten about that first double kill in regards to the day kill. It's weird that the reason for that hasn't shown up yet, and a stipulation like "you get to kill two with your first shot" sounds unlikely.
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Hey sorry. Been busy. Good news is I went 6-0 at my Galatic qualifier and won a worlds seat for next year and played good at softball.

My Bp is indeed gone, so fuck you scum.

Will do a read over and provide some thoughts here in the next few hours tonight. Sorry for being absent.
 
I'm out of work now and here. So is our best bet right now to wait for the day kill and figure out where to go from there?

I had forgotten about that first double kill in regards to the day kill. It's weird that the reason for that hasn't shown up yet, and a stipulation like "you get to kill two with your first shot" sounds unlikely.
The day kill may not even happen, as I speculated earlier.

Where on earth is Kawl, by the way? He should be free from whatever he was doing this weekend. We need him here. I do not want to lose due to inactivity. That'd be the absolute worst way to end this.
 
If I had to guess which one of the BP Lovers pair got shot, it was probably heymonkey. Ezekel was barking up the wrong tree (melonrabbit) almost the entire time he was alive, despite getting that clutch kill onto Splinter. heymonkey was mostly being seen as town. I'm not sure when their shared BP was used up, though.
 
NeckToChicken, Geno, and Brazil's deaths don't seem to reveal much to me either. They all seem like super obvious kills considering they were all seen as town during those days, but... that's it. I guess Brazil's death is sorta questionable because it was possible to argue for a gambit play involving Kalor's shot at him, but that's obviously not a thing anymore.

*sigh*

I really don't know what to make of all of this. The only person I can see myself voting for is fandorin, but it still doesn't feel right. Whoever the remaining scum is, you've blended yourself in very well.
 
(Reminder: Fandorin replaced Xbro)

Funny that you should mention this. I was getting the same feeling. Not only that but the interactions between him and Vere are very similar to him and Stuart in Monopoly. If Vere flips scum, which there is a good chance of happening, then Grizzly's chances of being scum skyrocket.

Right now I'm 60/40 scum/town on Grizzly. If Vere is scum that goes up to 80-85/20-15.

As far as Vere is concerned I genuinely believe he was confused about the rules of the game. That's not what I'm suspicious of him. I mentioned before that his vote on the monkey was flimsy at best enough so that he completely disregarded it without making it official by the vote tracker. The problems with the current argument stem not from him being mistaken in the event but how panicked he is about the whole thing.

vote: verelios

Let's see how this pans out.

Well that was an interesting night. Going to reinstate my vote on Verelios because to me it's still worth it to see a flip.

vote: verelios

Recent posts have given a much better vibe on him, but I'm going to go with my initial gut read until I see more. And strengthening my read on Grizzly would be great.

Okay, so I'm not able to locate the exact posts by Grizzly I was looking for. Just the general feeling that was going on during the discussion. Basically I wasn't going after Grizzly because he was acting like Monopoly, I was going after him because I was catching him on the same things that I caught him on in Monopoly. It all hinged on whether or not Vere flipped if it was the same situation. Grizzly's posts leading up to his Vere vote felt like he knew something else and was just waiting for an opportunity to jump on it. At least this was my thoughts at the time. I had already gotten a bad vibe from Vere, so I figured if he flipped, then it was pretty much guaranteed that Grizzly was scum. Now we've been put into the reverse situation and I still think my initial analysis is correct. I find that the observations I make while reading the thread tend to be correct when I initially make them. I'm not sure if I can rally anyone on this but I trust my gut completely and I'm willing to take responsibility if I'm wrong.

For my shoot Lynch protect, I would shoot Vere, lynch Rynam and protect melon.

If Rynam really does have an ITA protection I would rather just Lynch him.

Melon seemed, to me, to use the Thunderdome as a means of Investigation on splinter. So I honestly think that is a town thing to do

Ugh, this all feels so... right. Xbro has already presented himself as a strong town contender well before Fandorin replaced him.
 
If I had to guess which one of the BP Lovers pair got shot, it was probably heymonkey. Ezekel was barking up the wrong tree (melonrabbit) almost the entire time he was alive, despite getting that clutch kill onto Splinter. heymonkey was mostly being seen as town. I'm not sure when their shared BP was used up, though.

Ezekel said he was shot N2 I think, before I subbed in and that really gave him some town points. heymonkey kept in the shadows and didn't say anything about being shot obviously. At that point Ezekel had already shot Splinter and was really town read across the board.

I guess I can see scum shotting Ezekel again since he was already out of his claimed BP.
 
I want to hear what Yneek and Kawl think of the situation. I don't think we should expect the day kill at this point, like Polter said.

I had some suspicious on Polter coming into the day, but he's really putting in some work now. Even though most of it seems like a bit of "catch up" on some topics.
 
Hey sorry. Been busy. Good news is I went 6-0 at my Galatic qualifier and won a worlds seat for next year and played good at softball.

My Bp is indeed gone, so fuck you scum.

Will do a read over and provide some thoughts here in the next few hours tonight. Sorry for being absent.
Wait, what? Congratulations Kawl! That seems like a really big achievement man haha.
 
I'm back and compiled a list of the day kills:













I think this accounts for everyone? I'll see what I can gleam from these kills.

One quick thing, though: I don't know why both nin1000 and Kyanrute died at the same time. It makes no sense for that to have been the cause of one action unless the ability has something like "you can kill two people at once with your first shot" or something, but they are still listed under the same post (which implies a singular action), so... I dunno. I looked through the other scum PMs and the only one that could possibly have done the other kill was Splinter, but he died before those two did, so that can't be it.

I'm out of work now and here. So is our best bet right now to wait for the day kill and figure out where to go from there?

I had forgotten about that first double kill in regards to the day kill. It's weird that the reason for that hasn't shown up yet, and a stipulation like "you get to kill two with your first shot" sounds unlikely.

Humm, don't think anyone pointed this out till now. The "first kill comes double" wouldn't make sense, but I don't see any other scum role that could do that.
 
Everyone, we need you to put your best foot forward here if we want town to win. I can't do this on my own, and I'm getting a headache seeing how literally every option to vote for is bad.

@rac , @Ynnek7 , @Kawl , it's do or die time.
 
I don't know if this is enough to build a case off of, but I could see this being a slip where you planned for your shot to not kill.
The game is making me so stressed and I kept overthinking things that something obvious like mafia getting a kill off during the night completely slipped my mind.

Besides, if I was scum, how could I kill Lux if I was dead? We know now that there is only one scum left since Kalor died since the game would already be over if there were more than one. Yes, it wasn't a "real", permanent death, but everything about the game treated it like it was a real death besides revealing the role PM, from it being publicly announced that I died to even my name being crossed out in the OP. And being dead, I was not allowed to interact with the game in any capacity until I got revived the following day.

Honestly, scum should have taken the opportunity to try to kill Kawl that night to arouse suspicion on my end, but they seem to be a day too late on that and maybe keeping Lux alive was too dangerous for them.

I mean, I get I'm not the best town player (a problem that has stuck with me throughout all of these Mafia games), but the reason I used my ability in such a matter was to make it so that I don't become a lynch candidate in case we ever got into a situation like this. It's the closest thing to a confirmation on my towniness that I could possibly provide, given the circumstances.
 
*sigh*

It's not enough for me to just defend myself, I know. I'm having trouble justifying a vote on anyone now, though. Everyone still alive has a ton of town points, yet one of them has to be scum. I'm just... not seeing anything.
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
I don’t think you can be scum polt unless we got some ascetic serial killer cop or some shit happening here. I don’t think the cop check would be split between two players of different factions so I think ynennk checks out. I think it’s either rac or fandorin.

We lynch one and if that’s wrong you turbo the other the next day especially if they manage to not whiff on the kill again.

As for which of fandorin and rac is more likely to be it....the vanilla claim points towards fandorin but my gut from everything else says that rac is scummy and the only reason I wouldn’t go on him is because he created the lone stranger. But hell we’ve seen numerous scum with wildly varying abilities, he could very well be telling the truth about doing that as well as other shit going on.

But I need to review the shit a little more before committing.
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
My gut says rac. I think that’s what I’m going with in the morning unless something changes. If there’s an extra scum kill out there then oh well. But i think we lynch rac and fandorin and get the hell out of dodge.
 
It... can't be Fandorin. After reading through his entire post history I'll seriously trust anyone again if he turns out to be scum. There are way too many posts of his trying to scum read people, and hitting the mark quite a few times to boot. Bringing up behaviors from past games, trying to confirm his reads by pressuring votes... I just can't fathom a scum player playing like that, and so consistently too.
 

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
Yeah, I think it really just has to come down to either Fandorin or rac at this point.

If we had seen even one more godfather show up in all those scum kills, I would be willing to believe in Kawl being a third, but with just one I'm pretty sure of him being town. (Congrats on doing so well in the tournament, by the way!)

There was some of rac's play towards the end of the game that wasn't sitting right to me, but I think I chalked that up to just plain frustration at the time.
 
I still wouldn't count out Ynnek7, by the way. The situation with him just feels too convenient, despite his partnership with a townsperson. We already had a pair of town-aligned Lovers in the game, too.

I feel like I'm left with no options here. A vote on either Kawl or Fandorin aren't even remotely justifiable for me now, Ynnek7 has been considered town for nearly the whole game due to his role, and rac shares a similar role to scum, so that redundancy gives points in his favor.

Maybe it's time for me to read the post histories of rac and Ynnek7 now...
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
I mean if your scum as Ynnek7 I think your play is to just say green check on everyone. Especially with only two results showing. That reveal ended up costing scum two dudes. If they just sit and stall it’s easy to nullify the cop checks. I can’t buy a world in which Ynnek7 is scum.
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
And thanks for the congratulations. It was pretty awesome to take it home. Still riding that high tbh
 

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
I still wouldn't count out Ynnek7, by the way. The situation with him just feels too convenient, despite his partnership with a townsperson. We already had a pair of town-aligned Lovers in the game, too.

I feel like I'm left with no options here. A vote on either Kawl or Fandorin aren't even remotely justifiable for me now, Ynnek7 has been considered town for nearly the whole game due to his role, and rac shares a similar role to scum, so that redundancy gives points in his favor.

Maybe it's time for me to read the post histories of rac and Ynnek7 now...

A little more in my defense, I did take out CoolestSpot with my ITA, who had been taking shots at Fandorin.
 
I mean if your scum as Ynnek7 I think your play is to just say green check on everyone. Especially with only two results showing. That reveal ended up costing scum two dudes. If they just sit and stall it’s easy to nullify the cop checks. I can’t buy a world in which Ynnek7 is scum.
Yeah, it's also possible they were relying on Kalor's ability to pick off Ynnek7 as well on Night 4 or 5, but since he never fully claimed the shot failed.
 
Anyways, I looked through Ynnek7's posts right now and can't find anything particularly wrong about them outside of his activity dropping pretty harshly after Day 3.
 

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
Problem is, I could see CoolestSpot taking those shots at Fandorin regardless of whether or not Fan was scum, too, lol.
 

rac

whatever
eh i voted include shot at natiko and extreme

put extreme as my top scum and then he just sort of fell apart

if my power was scum why would i use it to vote and shoot at other scum?
 

rac

whatever
crazy that im gonna be lynched when it actually matters

not like i was trying to get itad/voted out days ago
 
Looking at rac's history, his scum reads are all over the place. He picked out Geno, Brazil, and Fandorin as scum early on, but got a bit better as the game went on. Like me, he also trusted Kalor up until his flip. Him voting for himself Day 4 is... odd, though. But I guess oreomunsta did the same thing...?

eh i voted include shot at natiko and extreme

put extreme as my top scum and then he just sort of fell apart

if my power was scum why would i use it to vote and shoot at other scum?
?

I'm looking at the ITA chart and don't see you shooting Natiko. It said you shot at Blarg Day 3.

crazy that im gonna be lynched when it actually matters

not like i was trying to get itad/voted out days ago
OK, who do you think is the last scum? I don't believe we've heard your thoughts on this yet.
 
Ugh, what is going on. The game got really tense this phase out of nowhere. I just dreamed with the game and this is making me nuts.

I think I need to organize my thoughts on everyone.

One thing is for certain, I can't see Ynnek as scum. His role claim back then was exactly what we needed, Stuart's interactions also made complete sense, plus Coolest nonsense post on him and his own pot shot on Coolest last phase that got him. His activity had a big drop after the claim, but whenever he came up he offered his most on point reads and helped us move forward with the discussion, without fluffling or adding in filler like a "confirmed town" scum would do in his position.

My biggest fear after watching Sneakers Mafia is to just ignore the possibility of a godfather until the end and lose because of that, so I confess I've been sorta wary about Kawl throughout the game. But thing is, I don't really see how he could be scum. Besides the green check, Kawl shot Verelios, Kalor and Include, killing her at D3. He also confirmed the Extreme Tactician lynch at a crucial moment of the game, and also pushed really hard for Kalor's lynch last phase. What remaining doubts I had were gone when the day started with no kill; if Kawl was the last scum he wouldn't need to leave 5 players alive like we have right now, he could completely cripple the discussion by shooting Ynnek, the other confirmed town that didn't have a BP, and just sit back while we town lynched me, rac or Polter.

I started nagging my mind about Polter the moment oreo flipped town. His activity really picked up these last few phases and he's really putting out content, retreading old discussions and poking others for reads on the last stretch. Initially I thought that this was a huge scum tell; changing your playstyle mid-game so much is normally something scum do when they start to get interested in the game, but fact is that he reads so sincere to me that it's making me paranoid. His mix up on how players we would have left last phase and the overall weird theories like the day kill limitations or Ynnek's scum case are little town slips that make complete sense at this point. I'd be very surprised if scum could just completely fake their participation like this so far into a game as big as this one. Finally, he did also kill LP with a ITA shot at D4, which can never be ignored.

rac has been a soft town read for me the whole game. Feel like he plays so straightforward all the time that it can't be anything else other than town, he's been upfront about his reads the whole time, despite not putting out much reasoning to it, which is the way he always plays. I hadn't read Rynam's flip this whole time and I was kinda surprised at how different both roles play out, since they seem to be the exact opposite of each other; Lone Stranger could apparently vote and shoot at anyone, while still being targetable during the ITA events and the night, like we found out after Neck executed him, while Rynam's NPC could only shoot at others in ITAs while being invulnerable throughout the game. rac has been pretty public with his relation to the Lone Stranger since he died, and has reminded repeatedly of how scum flipped with a NPC creator so he can't be it. I always felt like the Lone Stranger didn't add much to the discussion along the game, example being how Neck thought it would be best to kill him during his jail time. Still, rac pushed pretty hard for Extreme's lynch too, while also shooting at him together with me at D4, before the rest of town joined us in his lynch train at D5.
 
Forgot to add that I'm not sure how to read rac's self depreciation during the middle of the game, including his self vote and calls for his lynch. It came out of nowhere to me, and despite kinda asking him about it, I'm still unsure what caused that.
 
Hey Fandorin, did you ever tell us what you won with the Lone Survivor event?

I did, way back at D5. I think Brazil is the only player that commented on that then. I kept the fact that I would be notified who targeted me at night. Despite the fact that no one did target me then, I could bait someone into fake claiming something with me. Didn't happen though.

Anyway, I was Deathproof yesterday as a reward from the Survivor event. Couldn’t be killed or even lynched during the entirety of D4 and N4. Completely wasted on me; would’ve been much better if Ezekel got it instead.

I’m glad you’ve opened up about that reward being pressured to.
 
Thanks for your input, Fandorin. I think rac's the last one to not give us his full thoughts on this final vote yet.

OK, I'm going to be going to sleep soon, but before I do that, I have a proposal to make. As I speculated before, it's possible that a day kill won't happen today in order for a mislynch to be more likely, leading to an immediate day kill going into tomorrow and giving scum the win. This is bad; we're playing to the rhythm of the remaining scum player and giving them the advantage while we run around like headless chickens trying to find the last scum player.

So here's what I suggest: in addition to today's lynch, we need to decide today who we will lynch tomorrow. We won't have time to discuss anything tomorrow, but we may have enough time to get a vote in before the day kill command is processed. It needs to happen the moment the next day phase begins.

Of course, we have no idea who will live to tomorrow, so what we should do is rank players. If your top-ranked player ends up dead tomorrow, move one spot down and vote for them instead. We should adjust our rankings to try to match up with other players as best as possible to avoid a stalemate going into tomorrow.

If we follow through with this plan, we have a better chance. Scum will need to either chance their day kill command not going through on time tomorrow, or they will have to day kill someone today to stop this plan in its tracks, giving us a better shot at identifying the remaining scum. We may also be able to get some information based on how people react to the rankings.

So now, with all of that said, this is my current ranking:

1. rac
2. Ynnek7
3. Fandorin
4. Kawl

(It was extremely hard to decide between Ynnek7 and Fandorin; they are basically neck-and-neck.)
 
Thanks for your input, Fandorin. I think rac's the last one to not give us his full thoughts on this final vote yet.

OK, I'm going to be going to sleep soon, but before I do that, I have a proposal to make. As I speculated before, it's possible that a day kill won't happen today in order for a mislynch to be more likely, leading to an immediate day kill going into tomorrow and giving scum the win. This is bad; we're playing to the rhythm of the remaining scum player and giving them the advantage while we run around like headless chickens trying to find the last scum player.

So here's what I suggest: in addition to today's lynch, we need to decide today who we will lynch tomorrow. We won't have time to discuss anything tomorrow, but we may have enough time to get a vote in before the day kill command is processed. It needs to happen the moment the next day phase begins.

Of course, we have no idea who will live to tomorrow, so what we should do is rank players. If your top-ranked player ends up dead tomorrow, move one spot down and vote for them instead. We should adjust our rankings to try to match up with other players as best as possible to avoid a stalemate going into tomorrow.

If we follow through with this plan, we have a better chance. Scum will need to either chance their day kill command not going through on time tomorrow, or they will have to day kill someone today to stop this plan in its tracks, giving us a better shot at identifying the remaining scum. We may also be able to get some information based on how people react to the rankings.

So now, with all of that said, this is my current ranking:

1. rac
2. Ynnek7
3. Fandorin
4. Kawl

(It was extremely hard to decide between Ynnek7 and Fandorin; they are basically neck-and-neck.)
This post reeks of townie, but I don't think it's really the right mindset to have right now. We have the chance to end the game with this lynch right now. I have zero doubts that there is only one scum left with the lack of night kill + day kill this phase.

At this point scum can day kill either Kawl or Ynnek without much thought. They are not getting lynched. Besides, it would be a huge WIFOM to go through, whatever the kill is.

Of course, I think we should be open with our reads, this is the single most important moment in the game to do that. If we do end up mislynching and still get another shot at this, Sorian will most likely end the night phase right away so we can end the game. I think we will all be ready to vote quick if that happens.

I will do a reread on Polter and rac to decide this, but I'm not voting for either Ynnek or Kawl.
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
This post reeks of townie, but I don't think it's really the right mindset to have right now. We have the chance to end the game with this lynch right now. I have zero doubts that there is only one scum left with the lack of night kill + day kill this phase.

At this point scum can day kill either Kawl or Ynnek without much thought. They are not getting lynched. Besides, it would be a huge WIFOM to go through, whatever the kill is.

Of course, I think we should be open with our reads, this is the single most important moment in the game to do that. If we do end up mislynching and still get another shot at this, Sorian will most likely end the night phase right away so we can end the game. I think we will all be ready to vote quick if that happens.

I will do a reread on Polter and rac to decide this, but I'm not voting for either Ynnek or Kawl.
If polter was last scum game should have been ended when he was dead. He’s cleared in my eyes by the time frame and usage of his power imo. Unless Sorian made that role super savage against town.
 

rac

whatever
ok since i see my day 5 actions being brought up ill explain

i was called an asshole, being scumread by a person who ignored me the whole game and asked if i was even in the game

any one i guess i could've just dealt with but every time i looked at the thread i was getting more angry

as for lunch i have really no idea

1. polt=fand
2. kawl
3. ynnek
 
If polter was last scum game should have been ended when he was dead. He’s cleared in my eyes by the time frame and usage of his power imo. Unless Sorian made that role super savage against town.
But couldn't it just be a public announced commute? He was untargetable for the night. We haven't seen any of those in this game and with would be the second defensive role alongside the doctor scum had.
ok since i see my day 5 actions being brought up ill explain

i was called an asshole, being scumread by a person who ignored me the whole game and asked if i was even in the game

any one i guess i could've just dealt with but every time i looked at the thread i was getting more angry

as for lunch i have really no idea

1. polt=fand
2. kawl
3. ynnek

I completely missed this. Didn't catch any of that then.
 
But couldn't it just be a public announced commute? He was untargetable for the night. We haven't seen any of those in this game and with would be the second defensive role alongside the doctor scum had.
Ate a few words.

*We haven't seen any of those in this game and with it that would be the second defensive scum role, alongside the doctor scum had.*
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
But couldn't it just be a public announced commute? He was untargetable for the night. We haven't seen any of those in this game and with would be the second defensive role alongside the doctor scum had.


I completely missed this. Didn't catch any of that then.
Dead is dead. Like I said If it works otherwise I’ll take it up with Sorian but I’d be pretty bothered about it. I guess I can go back and see who was pushing for him to die. I think it was geno though. As long as it wasn’t scum pushing it I’m fine losing the game if he is actually a commuter and wasn’t dead, but rather dead
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
I’m basing it more on the fact he would have been last scum in the game but also ded. That should have triggered our win con imo.
 
interestingly enough it was coolest who called me an asshole
On my reread and saw that post now. Kinda baffled with CS's contributions this game.
Dead is dead. Like I said If it works otherwise I’ll take it up with Sorian but I’d be pretty bothered about it. I guess I can go back and see who was pushing for him to die. I think it was geno though. As long as it wasn’t scum pushing it I’m fine losing the game if he is actually a commuter and wasn’t dead, but rather dead
Brazil and you have the same idea then, that the announcement of his death in the thread means exactly that, and anything other than that would enter bastard territory which is something not present at the rest of the game.
 

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
Of course, I think we should be open with our reads, this is the single most important moment in the game to do that. If we do end up mislynching and still get another shot at this, Sorian will most likely end the night phase right away so we can end the game. I think we will all be ready to vote quick if that happens.

Only problem I see here is that, while I'm sure scum wants to get this over with just as much as we do, they really have no reason to work with us if it means we'd vote before they could get their day kill off.

Better for then to hold off on the night command until closer to day start, and hope that some of us aren't able to be here on time.
 
Did a read on Poltergust post history to get a better feel on his previous phases, especially on D1 and D2 since I didn't get the chance to interact with him then.

Something that caught my attention is that he pretty much made the leading case for Mazre's lynch based on his ITA hit and Apollo's flip with the possible boost. We found out with his flip that this was because of his own role; 100% hit rate for ITA shots. Surprisingly, Polter mentioned this exact role in a off hand comment after so many misses at ITA phases.

You know, I would not be surprised if someone here was Hawkeye or something whose power is to never miss an ITA. Basically a daytime vigilante.

Anyways, I’m going to bed. Looking forward to the last ITA results!

When he made his case for Mazre though there were no mentions of that, or later when he apologized to Mazre for being wrong on that.

I think that we should go over the possible ways Apollo would've used his power. I do agree with what was mentioned before in that he likely gave someone a 100% hit rate for today's ITA. This means that the people we should look into are the ones who got a hit:

-EzekelRAGE hit scum. A powerful scum role as well. Unlikely that he was given the guaranteed shot.
-Mazre hit Zipped, who at this point is almost certainly town.
-Terraforce hit Trigger. However, we just now learned Terraforce is town. Also, he ded.
-Finally, Extreme Tactician hit Verelios. While this may have been done to earn town points, it also feels unnecessary considering we were likely going to lynch Verelios at the end of the day.

And that's all the successful ITAs for today. Mazre is definitely the most suspicious of the bunch. Apollo made a mistake in killing off Terraforce because now there are only two real choices here. Terraforce would almost certainly be suspect if he was still alive. So, with all of that said:

Vote: Mazre

Also, I'm sorry Mazre. I guess the high of our "perfect" game had to end sometime. I guess we'll need to reevaluate how Apollo used his ability.

This other interaction with heymonkey over the Alexem train forming at the background at D3 also seemed interesting. He threw some shade at the Alexem train, but then got corrected by monkey that he wasn't the lynch leader. A bit later Blarg, the leading lynch then, claimed and the situation shifted. Polter then voted for Alexem anyway, doing a flip on his own assessment of him without much explanation. Albeit this was addressed a bit in his final post, I would like to hear more from Polter here.

If you want my flip you’ll need to lynch. Using ITAs on me is just wasting them

Twice bullet proof

I dunno, I don’t feel good about this Alexem train. I feel like we’re about to make a mistake.

As for Blarg/Lone Stranger, I don’t see a reason to lynch him since we haven’t really seen them do anything wrong. I doubt it’s a scum ability since we already got the scum who created the Mysterious Entity.

But at the same time, voting for anyone else at this point is pretty meaningless. =/

He's nowhere near the lynch leader; how is that a mistake?

It's an hour to go and votes shuffle. If you believe someone else is scum, vote them.

Oh whoops. I’m using mobile right now and only skimmed through the vote count. Sorry. ._.

If Blarg is able to pass on BPs to other players, I expect him to die in the night. Scum wouldn't want someone who can keep people alive to be in the game for long.

As such, I guess I have no choice but to go for Alexem. If Blarg survives the night then I’ll ITA him.

Vote: Alexem

Honestly, even though it didn't matter in the end I regret voting for him. I said earlier that this Alexem train felt like a mistake, but with so little time left and Blarg ceasing to become a good option for lynching that day, there wasn't any other choice.

We need to be more proactive in preventing such a situation from occurring again.

On these final days, I had that nitpick over his eagerness over his claim which I've already covered here.

... Well, fuck. I'm glad I have you here, bro.

Because I got a strange feeling from the post below, like Polter wanted to hurry us along into lynching someone, but brushed it off as no big deal because he had no reason to do so.


But you're absolutely right that we don't know whether he can or can't send night commands while fake dead.

Wouldn't him being the only scum alive after Kalor got lynched breach the "You can use it if it'll end the game" rule, however?
Maybe it doesn't because he wasn't the last scum alive when he activated it.

Welp, so much for the easy last lynch.

Remaining Players:
  1. rac
  2. Poltergust
  3. oreomunsta
  4. Fandorin
Last scum is here. Kawl and Ynnek have been confirmed since before I even subbed in, and Brazil has zero going for him and he was just shot in the face by Kalor.

I don't think there's anything more of note for me to read on oreo, so my ISO is still fresh. He's overall pretty scummy, but not as bad as Brazil makes him out I think. Most of the case is in the end based on his low activity and lurker post style.

However I really dislike that he didn't even bother to respond to my theory on his mix up on the delay on N3 that I made on his ISO. I was also looking forward for his results today since it would green or red check someone, but he didn't share that either. What's up with that?

I'll try and ISO rac and Polter tomorrow to confirm my feelings on them too. Feel pretty good about rac and only good about Polter I think. Would be really surprised if rac ended up being the last scum, he's been playing absurdly upfront the entire time. I think I wouldn't even be mad if he was last scum.

On Polter I get the feeling that he kinda showed up right now at the end. Maybe it's just me and maybe I've been sorta ignoring his earlier posts, but since last phase he started putting out a lot more content on his posts, but it's mostly filler? I don't think we've seen him actually scum hunt other players for instance. Well, I guess no one did much of that last phase besides Brazil, but still.


Conclusion: Polter always telegraphed his reads and actions the entire game. He reacts openly and doesn't seem to keep anything that is on his mind for himself. A lot of times that makes it seem like he's just adding in filler, posting whatever despite being a retread or something already addressed by others previously. Which also leads to some mix ups, like the one we had yesterday with the "lack of kill" during the night or this phase with the "maybe there are 2 scum alive after all". But

He's nowhere near the lynch leader; how is that a mistake?

It's an hour to go and votes shuffle. If you believe someone else is scum, vote them.

Oh whoops. I’m using mobile right now and only skimmed through the vote count. Sorry. ._.

If Blarg is able to pass on BPs to other players, I expect him to die in the night. Scum wouldn't want someone who can keep people alive to be in the game for long.

As such, I guess I have no choice but to go for Alexem. If Blarg survives the night then I’ll ITA him.

Vote: Alexem

Honestly, even though it didn't matter in the end I regret voting for him. I said earlier that this Alexem train felt like a mistake, but with so little time left and Blarg ceasing to become a good option for lynching that day, there wasn't any other choice.

We need to be more proactive in preventing such a situation from occurring again.

On these final days, I had that nitpick over his eagerness over his claim which I've already covered here.

... Well, fuck. I'm glad I have you here, bro.

Because I got a strange feeling from the post below, like Polter wanted to hurry us along into lynching someone, but brushed it off as no big deal because he had no reason to do so.


But you're absolutely right that we don't know whether he can or can't send night commands while fake dead.

Wouldn't him being the only scum alive after Kalor got lynched breach the "You can use it if it'll end the game" rule, however?
Maybe it doesn't because he wasn't the last scum alive when he activated it.

Welp, so much for the easy last lynch.

Remaining Players:
  1. rac
  2. Poltergust
  3. oreomunsta
  4. Fandorin
Last scum is here. Kawl and Ynnek have been confirmed since before I even subbed in, and Brazil has zero going for him and he was just shot in the face by Kalor.

I don't think there's anything more of note for me to read on oreo, so my ISO is still fresh. He's overall pretty scummy, but not as bad as Brazil makes him out I think. Most of the case is in the end based on his low activity and lurker post style.

However I really dislike that he didn't even bother to respond to my theory on his mix up on the delay on N3 that I made on his ISO. I was also looking forward for his results today since it would green or red check someone, but he didn't share that either. What's up with that?

I'll try and ISO rac and Polter tomorrow to confirm my feelings on them too. Feel pretty good about rac and only good about Polter I think. Would be really surprised if rac ended up being the last scum, he's been playing absurdly upfront the entire time. I think I wouldn't even be mad if he was last scum.

On Polter I get the feeling that he kinda showed up right now at the end. Maybe it's just me and maybe I've been sorta ignoring his earlier posts, but since last phase he started putting out a lot more content on his posts, but it's mostly filler? I don't think we've seen him actually scum hunt other players for instance. Well, I guess no one did much of that last phase besides Brazil, but still.


Conclusion: Polter always telegraphed his reads and actions the entire game. He reacts openly and doesn't seem to keep anything that is on his mind for himself. A lot of times that makes it seem like he's just adding in filler, posting whatever despite being a retread or something already addressed by others previously. Which also leads to some mix ups, like the one we had yesterday with the "lack of kill" during the night or this phase with the "maybe there are 2 scum alive after all.
The main thing on my mind though is the complete change in gears he had here at the end game, posting a lot more and going through old posts to figure it out, adding in ideas (some not really good too) on how to deal with the day kill. That's not something scum can do so easily like that after playing a game this big. I just don't see scum doing that right now, and I'm really town reading him for it.

Gotta add that he did a 180º flip on his read on me since before EoD last phase he said, along with rac, that I'd be his lynch candidate if oreo flipped town. I'm wary because pocketing someone at this point could be enough to end the game with the day kill.
 
Only problem I see here is that, while I'm sure scum wants to get this over with just as much as we do, they really have no reason to work with us if it means we'd vote before they could get their day kill off.

Better for then to hold off on the night command until closer to day start, and hope that some of us aren't able to be here on time.
That would be really unsportsmanlike, really. Having us (and the whole community, really) wait almost 24 to settle this would make me really pissed.


Anyway, I thought I had much more time available today to get some reading done. Might not be able to read through rac's posts, but I'll be reading the thread the whole time. Right now, I'd rank the players like this:

rac > Polter > Kawl > Ynnek
 

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
With that vote being up for about half an hour, would scum have followed suit? Maybe saying something like "Poltergust isn't my first choice, but let's end this...." and then hoping for a tired town to agree and hammer?
 
If I had to say anything about that, I’d say the contrary. Hoping a tired town would waltz in for the hammer like that seems pretty far fetched.
 

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
I'm not sure why rac would vote for Poltergust in the end over Fandorin. If we accept Pol's power at face value, it's unlikely that he's the final scum.
 

rac

whatever
why would i care about polts power and taking at face value when no one gives a shit about mine

all i know is im not scum
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
why would i care about polts power and taking at face value when no one gives a shit about mine

all i know is im not scum
Because there’s a world in which you are scum and can have the power of creating an npc along with other powers ala the 3+ scum we’ve seen with multiple powers? But the game states in which polts power exist and he’s scum involve this being a bastard game, which I have a harder time swallowing. That’s not hard to understand is it?
 

rac

whatever
Because there’s a world in which you are scum and can have the power of creating an npc along with other powers ala the 3+ scum we’ve seen with multiple powers? But the game states in which polts power exist and he’s scum involve this being a bastard game, which I have a harder time swallowing. That’s not hard to understand is it?

it would make absolutely no sense for me to have other powers, none
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
it would make absolutely no sense for me to have other powers, none
I disagree with the variety of powers we have seen scum have this game.

Regardless voting polt over fandorin is absolutely bizarre from you
 

rac

whatever
I disagree with the variety of powers we have seen scum have this game.

Regardless voting polt over fandorin is absolutely bizarre from you
yeah like rynams

hows this for votes
vote: kawl

show me my scummy shit
please
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Quit just lashing out and explain why you think polter is so much scummier than fandorin that you’ll believe Sorian is lying to us before you think fandorin is the last scum?
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
If your scum you likely need me to not be in final 3 with you to get the win since I’ve been clear on scum reading you heavily. So gotta chew through the Bp at some pint.
 

rac

whatever
If your scum you likely need me to not be in final 3 with you to get the win since I’ve been clear on scum reading you heavily. So gotta chew through the Bp at some pint.

then why would i kill brazil before trying to kill you?
brazil was townreading me the hardest, i wouldve needed him in the game
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
then why would i kill brazil before trying to kill you?
brazil was townreading me the hardest, i wouldve needed him in the game
Honestly because he was putting in the most effort and constantly reevaluating the game state. Taking him out and getting his voice out of the way is a strong move regardless of whether he was town reading you then. He had shown he would go back and reevaluate people.
 

rac

whatever
anyways your logic is faulty
you wanna use polter's power as a confirmation but just ignore mine in relation to rynam's power
while asking why i am not going for a fandorin lynch even though you aren't either
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
anyways your logic is faulty
you wanna use polter's power as a confirmation but just ignore mine in relation to rynam's power
while asking why i am not going for a fandorin lynch even though you aren't either
My ooo is you then fandorin. I think if we get both of you gone then we are home free. Polts power killed him dead. Unless you think Sorian was lying. And if he was last scum and dead we win game would have ended. The game has not ended. Therefore, I don’t think polt is scum. How is this fault logic? If you take contention on whether Sorian would lie to us with a role like that okay fine that’s a difference in opinion and I’ll agree it is what it is.

This game has been so wacky and shit with roles that I don’t think saying hey scum had a pretty similar role to this already you really think I would be scum with this? Doesn’t carry nearly as much weight to me.
 

rac

whatever
This game has been so wacky and shit with roles that I don’t think saying hey scum had a pretty similar role to this already you really think I would be scum with this? Doesn’t carry nearly as much weight to me.
and if we wanna go down this route you could just as easily be godfather as me being a second npc creator with an added day kill
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Why are you apprehensive about that? Is there anything specific that gives you pause when thinking about lynching oreo?

I'm still going to look over things, but the case against oreo makes itself when looking at it through a simple elimination process.

- You were dead last night and couldn't put in a command.
- rac has the same role as a flipped scum.
- Ynnek7 is confirmed.
- Kawl is green-checked and pushed us to lynch Kalor.
- Fandorin has scumhunted a lot, and doesn't really have anything going against him (that I've noticed). He was also targeted by Coolest's shots that ended up getting Coolest killed.

Meanwhile, off the top of my head I yesterday I could list multiple things going against oreo:

oreo didn't commit to a single ITA shot before this very phase (and he took one first at a townie).
oreo left a vote on Splinter during the TD - it's bizarre to me that we don't know of a single scum who left a vote there for easy town cred later out of a group of 12+.
oreo then skipped three phases-worth of voting to only show back up when over half the scum team had died.
oreo has a power with negative town utility.
oreo has admitted to using his power to the detriment of town twice.

If I'm really stretching it, the only real possibilities I can see for scum are rac, Fandorin and oreo. And I feel very good about the first two.

Also this dude is also going to pick you and fandorin to go once Oreo is gone. So idk if I’d say he wasn’t town reading you hard. That seems like a weird take away
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Also where the fuck is rynams flip? He just died day 2 but I dig through day start and through itas and shit and can’t find it. It’s a nightmare finding shit in this game on mobile
 
I'm back. I just woke up.

Thank you for ranking your votes in case we need to go to tomorrow. I just hope we can end this today.

Seems that things have gotten quite dangerous now, though.
yeah like rynams

hows this for votes
vote: kawl

show me my scummy shit
please
rac, stop being dumb with your votes, especially at this stage in the game. I thought the one thing everyone here agreed with is that Kawl is town.
 
Top Bottom