Game Thread Grand Mini Mafia V - Game Thread

I got to jam for a while so I'm gonna hit these up real quick and then I should be back with time to get caught up before end of day.
I definitely understand the cons behind it, but truly, what's the alternative? I backspaced out a few times on my original post above that started this whole line of reasoning. Thought about it, re-typed, backspaced again. But I then came to the conclusion that more is better when it comes to hashing our thoughts out, and what we discuss has just as much opportunity to throw scum off as much as it does to lead them in a better direction? Maybe.
I had a whole long ass post about this but I think it would hurt more than it would help so I'm gonna point you to WIFOM if you don't know it and say that if we start speculating on who scum should kill it could easily result in giving someone a pass they ain't earned. As town we have one job: find scum. We need to find town too but we can't do that today. It's too damn early. All we have is feelings. So we have one job.

Actually, unless you feel like that could have some negative repercussions... Any chance you could point out which weird behaviors you would tie to newbies? Cause I have a couple of ideas, but there's only 2 new people in here so that's already more than what's possible.

As said before, I feel like Ken's fishing is either a really weak attempt or a big error. Would it make sense for a newbie to do it though?

(Don't want to interrupt the rest of the discussion though, so keep that going too)
gut response: not with you I can't. But that ain't helpful so Tommy's thing, the idea we should no lynch, some things like that. Ken's fish is whatever; what really matters is how Ken reacted to the fish and I don't think that falls in this category but why don't you tell me how you feel about it.

See, now this I can answer. I had the problem you had with me with your ???wtf??? post, had no idea if that was arrogant deflection or you just being hecking dumbfounded about what I said. Calling it arrogant deflection was more likelier an option to get a more juicy reaction out of you. Consider the arrogance bit dropped for now.

Don't think I am accusing you of that much, yet. Just felt that you were attaching yourself onto the solving crowd in a weird way. Trevor and Asuka were doing things and you were being the weird orbiter, trying to get into the cool kid's club. At this point though the hugbox of two has fallen apart, what for yours truly means looking at the individuals and where they went. Ugh.
I have 230952039959 more posts that Asuka and have so far all game so I think that's where I was indeed hecking dumbfounded as to why you thought I was trying to attach myself to someone else's tail rather than just weighing in on discussion that was happening. I didn't understand how you got there at all but I'm glad you explained. It felt like a damned-no-matter-what-you-do situation for me which added to the ???? reaction.

Peace out, sit hard on Michael, don't believe any lies, and all that.
 
I have 230952039959 more posts that Asuka and have so far all game

Oh how you tempt me so. I don't think equating quantity and quality is that wise a thing to do. But past is past, I'll get to your present in a bit and see what the situation is right now.
 
Trevor has evolved into the typical million-posts-a-minute tentacle monster that has a tentacle or two for every single little topic on hand. On tentacle? Perhaps. It feels genuine-ish to me but really, shouldn't call it before reflecting him on some other lesser monsters.
 
gut response: not with you I can't. But that ain't helpful so Tommy's thing, the idea we should no lynch, some things like that. Ken's fish is whatever; what really matters is how Ken reacted to the fish and I don't think that falls in this category but why don't you tell me how you feel about it.

Thank you.

I already went through my feelings about Ken lightly in a previous post. Let me look at this through the lenses of paranoia though. Disclaimer: I'm not sure we should do it, but let's see where this takes us.

About Ken: the fish itself felt a little weak and I can't see why scum would have tried it. On the other hand, the reactions to being called out are highly suspicious for different reasons. It could be due to inexperience, but it would be weird; also, if it was inexperience and he were mafia I think someone would've helped him correct his course later on in the scum forum. So... I don't know, but it feels weird. It could be inexperience, it could be scum, I can hardly believe it's both. It sure doesn't make me feel confident about him in general.

About Tommy, I feel like it would be very weird for a newb to ask that kind of play related questions in-game, especially if they're being mentored. I checked on ResetEra, and out of the 2 new guys, one explicitly asked for mentorship while the other didn't, but I'd expect him to need it given he said this was going to be his first game of Mafia ever. So... I don't know, asking that kind of questions in here sounds more like a cover-up to try and pass as a new player than honest questions.

In the end... I feel like their behavior sounds suspicious even without resorting to paranoia, so I'll keep these thoughts in a corner of my mind for now.
 
Since it already got hit while I was gone I won't quote the different posts on it but @TommyV , my point is that I don't see why we need to plan who scum is going to kill. It simply isn't a conversation we need to have at all. It opens avenues of pointing out some things scum may not have noticed as the biggest thing. Sure, Trevor is very clearly the top poster so whatever but they aren't an all-seeing eye. Someone on town may have noticed something that wasn't as obvious to scum and we gain nothing by planning who they are going to kill considering most or all, depending on the set-up, of us can't do anything about it anyway.
 
Oh man. Did not expect this to still be this slow 5 hours from the end of the day.

I did go through the thread again, so here's my updated thoughts.

Lance and Trevor: both very active, both asking a lot of question. Lance is more aggressive and shifts focus pretty quickly.
High post count and leading conversations could be tied to both town and scum, so it's not necessarily telling.

On Trevor's case, I can't help but trust him right now. The only thing I kind of disagree with him on is voting Ken, but more on that later.
I can't say the same about Lance, but it's a gut feeling that comes 90% from having been a target of his accusations. I do understand how that kind of play works through, so I guess I'll wait a bit more before I form an opinion.

About Ken, that was a really weak attempt at fishing. So weak, that I can't really believe it's been purposefully done by scum on their first post.
On the other hand, what came after is more suspicious. He's kind of shying away without a convincing explanation of what he was doing. I'd argue that even just saying "I was joking" would have worked better that what he came up with.
So... I wouldn't actively decide to vote for him, but I'm open to being convinced.

I'm still annoyed by Niko's roleplaying. Glad to see it toned down.

I got more going on but this post is getting too long, and I've seen 15ish new posts pop up in the meantime, so I'll be back after I read them.

To finish what I started...

I get some weird feelings from TommyV and Ken. Either they're inexperienced, or scum, definitely not both. So I don't know what to think right now; not going to argue with the fact that they're high in vote count.
I also would want some opinion on the current situation from @Ken, since he's still under the 10 posts count and we're getting close to end of day.

Claude and Huang, despite being coasting low key, don't give me any scum vibes from their posts as of now.

Catalina and Asuka feel very logical and experienced, and do have towny vibes. A lot of people said the same thing, and the more people say that, the more I'm suspicious lol. Still not enough to actually doubt them though.

Last but not least, I need more posts from both @Franklin, @Carl and @Roman . I get the issues with vacation/weekend and the late entrance, but again, the night is drawing near. What do you think of the current standing? I know not much of interest happened, but what are your feelings regarding everyone else?
 
Asuka falls a bit to the background as the game progresses. Some of that could be explained by others picking up the slack and me giving too much influence to the bright stars of the slow start, but even with all those disclaimers there is a odd feeling of comfort there. Like Asuka has done the needed and hunkered down for the day.
 
Thank you.

I already went through my feelings about Ken lightly in a previous post. Let me look at this through the lenses of paranoia though. Disclaimer: I'm not sure we should do it, but let's see where this takes us.

About Ken: the fish itself felt a little weak and I can't see why scum would have tried it. On the other hand, the reactions to being called out are highly suspicious for different reasons. It could be due to inexperience, but it would be weird; also, if it was inexperience and he were mafia I think someone would've helped him correct his course later on in the scum forum. So... I don't know, but it feels weird. It could be inexperience, it could be scum, I can hardly believe it's both. It sure doesn't make me feel confident about him in general.

About Tommy, I feel like it would be very weird for a newb to ask that kind of play related questions in-game, especially if they're being mentored. I checked on ResetEra, and out of the 2 new guys, one explicitly asked for mentorship while the other didn't, but I'd expect him to need it given he said this was going to be his first game of Mafia ever. So... I don't know, asking that kind of questions in here sounds more like a cover-up to try and pass as a new player than honest questions.

In the end... I feel like their behavior sounds suspicious even without resorting to paranoia, so I'll keep these thoughts in a corner of my mind for now.
To finish what I started...

I get some weird feelings from TommyV and Ken. Either they're inexperienced, or scum, definitely not both. So I don't know what to think right now; not going to argue with the fact that they're high in vote count.
I also would want some opinion on the current situation from @Ken, since he's still under the 10 posts count and we're getting close to end of day.

Claude and Huang, despite being coasting low key, don't give me any scum vibes from their posts as of now.

Catalina and Asuka feel very logical and experienced, and do have towny vibes. A lot of people said the same thing, and the more people say that, the more I'm suspicious lol. Still not enough to actually doubt them though.

Last but not least, I need more posts from both @Franklin, @Carl and @Roman . I get the issues with vacation/weekend and the late entrance, but again, the night is drawing near. What do you think of the current standing? I know not much of interest happened, but what are your feelings regarding everyone else?
So Mikey, you seem to agree with the general thoughts on Ken. You have the take that it could be the sign of an inexperienced player though, which is something I somewhat disagree with (the whole "would scum help their scummate" thing is a "meh" from me) but I can see the angle at least.

Your thoughts on Tommy are similar, you seem to be wavering between scum reading and newbie reading him, which is fair because that's basically where I am on Tommy as well.

I don't agree with the take that one (or even both) of them couldn't be both inexperienced and Scum here, that's entirely possible in my eyes.

-------

With all that in mind, if you were to try to look for someone outside of the "they could be a newbie" realm, who would you be looking at here as a possible Scum player? You mention some light suspicions on other players, but nothing too concrete. It feels like you are leaning to a Tommy/Ken vote here, but you are making some decent cases for why they might not be Scum as well.
 
Asuka falls a bit to the background as the game progresses. Some of that could be explained by others picking up the slack and me giving too much influence to the bright stars of the slow start, but even with all those disclaimers there is a odd feeling of comfort there. Like Asuka has done the needed and hunkered down for the day.
I agree with this, I had asked a question to Roman about that last night but I don't think he ever responded. My feeling was that Asuka, when present, feels like a strong voice with logical opinions, they've made some pretty good posts I think, but then they kind of stick to the shadows after things seem to be going their way... which makes me worry it might be a scummy way...
 
I’m literally in Vegas right now, just checking out of my hotel. Sorry I haven’t been more present. I’m going to read through what I’ve missed now.
 
So Mikey, you seem to agree with the general thoughts on Ken. You have the take that it could be the sign of an inexperienced player though, which is something I somewhat disagree with (the whole "would scum help their scummate" thing is a "meh" from me) but I can see the angle at least.

Your thoughts on Tommy are similar, you seem to be wavering between scum reading and newbie reading him, which is fair because that's basically where I am on Tommy as well.

I don't agree with the take that one (or even both) of them couldn't be both inexperienced and Scum here, that's entirely possible in my eyes.

-------

With all that in mind, if you were to try to look for someone outside of the "they could be a newbie" realm, who would you be looking at here as a possible Scum player? You mention some light suspicions on other players, but nothing too concrete. It feels like you are leaning to a Tommy/Ken vote here, but you are making some decent cases for why they might not be Scum as well.

What I know for certain is that they can't both be newbs. There's a meta way to prove my point (that I won't explain). This still doesn't drive anything home though, aside from the fact that if either of them is non-newbie they would be highly suspicious.

If I were to only use my readings to cast a vote, yeah I'd be leaning towards Ken/Tommy.
My biggest thought against that vote, though, is that it doesn't really give us a lot to go by in terms of information for tomorrow. I mean, there doesn't seem to be anyone actively defending either of them, so that can't be used to gather new info... unless you want to be veery subtle? Or I missed something?

Let me go through the thread once more to see if I can catch something I missed.
 
What I know for certain is that they can't both be newbs. There's a meta way to prove my point (that I won't explain). This still doesn't drive anything home though, aside from the fact that if either of them is non-newbie they would be highly suspicious.

Nah, son. Only way you could know is if you're scum and you know the real identities of the other scum players. Meta can't prove because you don't know if someone is purposely screwing with meta.

Asuka falls a bit to the background as the game progresses. Some of that could be explained by others picking up the slack and me giving too much influence to the bright stars of the slow start, but even with all those disclaimers there is a odd feeling of comfort there. Like Asuka has done the needed and hunkered down for the day.

I agree with this, I had asked a question to Roman about that last night but I don't think he ever responded. My feeling was that Asuka, when present, feels like a strong voice with logical opinions, they've made some pretty good posts I think, but then they kind of stick to the shadows after things seem to be going their way... which makes me worry it might be a scummy way...

Y'all got this concern but not enough to push there to see what happens?
 
When someone is NK'd or eliminated, they should message the gamerunners if they want spec access to preserve their identities. Thanks
 
Nah, son. Only way you could know is if you're scum and you know the real identities of the other scum players. Meta can't prove because you don't know if someone is purposely screwing with meta

Definitely not the only way. Also, jumping to conclusions much?
 
My biggest thought against that vote, though, is that it doesn't really give us a lot to go by in terms of information for tomorrow. I mean, there doesn't seem to be anyone actively defending either of them, so that can't be used to gather new info... unless you want to be veery subtle? Or I missed something?
To be fair, I've somewhat soft defended Tommy just in that I was starting to get some new-player vibes at some point and it felt like he was a bit easy to latch on to.

Ken, there have been a few comments that seemed to push back on the idea of him being a target here on D1, Carl sticks out in my mind as one of them.
Y'all got this concern but not enough to push there to see what happens?
What are your thoughts on Asuka?
 
Anyone else sticking out to you here? I saw you mentioned Tommy earlier since he's one of the vote leaders, what do you think of Ken though?
Pretty much a non-entity to me, not sure.

Thoughts on other people, I like Asukas posts so far, seems like genuine scumhunting to me.
 
I’m having trouble sorting personalities out due to the avatars all being so similar in style. Feels like people blend together more.

Anyway, my first instinct here is Carl.

vote: carl

He seemed to want to stifle discussion early on. Some examples below.

I'm back. Doesn't seem like I missed anything major at least.

Not a Carl post but this gave me weird vibe on claude as well. There’s definitely stuff that was going on.

There isn’t much to discuss other than if we should or shouldn’t drink the punch, which is dumb considering there’s a dead body on the floor.

Voting for someone just because of not saying much on a weekend is pretty dumb.

We’re trying to deduce who’s scum and who’s not, and just throwing out names indiscriminately just benefits scum.

Just don’t like these. Throwing out votes is too dismissive.

It seems to me voting for anyone day 1 is most likely to benefit scum. It'd have to be a damn lucky shot to not hit an innocent.

Come on, let’s not do this every game.

Otherwise, gonna look at vote leaders soon.
 
What are your thoughts on Asuka?
There's some potential merit in what you two are saying but I lean more toward folks not really engaging Asuka more than Asuka not being a presence. He's out here posting but not a lot of people are trying to draw him out. So I'm gonna say that I find it curious that y'all wanna talk about him but not to him.
 
There's some potential merit in what you two are saying but I lean more toward folks not really engaging Asuka more than Asuka not being a presence. He's out here posting but not a lot of people are trying to draw him out. So I'm gonna say that I find it curious that y'all wanna talk about him but not to him.
I suppose to go back to why I haven't voted for Asuka, it's because I largely agree that he seems pretty Town here. I'm not interested in voting him out today. It's just something to keep in mind for the future is all depending on what info we end up getting.
 
Also, like I had said, I asked Roman about Asuka earlier and never got a response, so it was interesting to see someone else bring up a similar line of thought there.
 
For everyone giving Ken a hard time for that comment, it’s really Michael the one fishing for noobs.

@Franklin I’ve seen it in previous games, wanting to vote out the people with a few posts because they appear to be coasting or hiding. I agree that sometimes that’s the case, but the weekend start kinda changes that a bit. I don’t think that’s a good indicator right now.

And as for trying to stifle discussion, that comment was early on in the day, if I remember correctly, when there wasn’t much to discuss. I was just adding a bit of flavor. Nothing more than that.
 
I'm getting low-key scum vibes from Catalina. Seems like somebody engaging the bare minimum to stay just shy of being labeled a coaster. Like mostly obvious takes or asking people to make it easier for her so she doesn't have to read too much.

VOTE: Catalina
 
I don’t really agee with the reasoning for the ken votes. I actually think scum would be guessing roles in their own thread, not publically. Additionally, the lack of a push towards another vote make me think scum is okay with it.

Unfortunately, ken isn’t giving us much to work with otherwise.

Checking TommyV next. Did he give any reason for ken vote or is it a survival vote?
 
when there wasn’t much to discuss
There has been plenty to discuss for a while, those comments came in at the halfway point of the day phase. If there is any point to start a discussion, it is when there is less than 24 hours left in the day.
 
My biggest town read right now is Asuka.
Who's your biggest scum read?

I'm not feeling the Ken votes as much as I still am the Michael vote unless both do something as we ramp up to day end. I don't agree that scum wouldn't try to guess in thread and Ken's reaction was meh but I'm not sure how to take the disappearance after even if it was announced.
 
... At this point though the hugbox of two has fallen apart, what for yours truly means looking at the individuals and where they went. Ugh.

Are you complaining that you’re going to have to put in effort of your own? I hate sheep d1. It’s such a cop out.
 
Who's your biggest scum read?

I'm not feeling the Ken votes as much as I still am the Michael vote unless both do something as we ramp up to day end. I don't agree that scum wouldn't try to guess in thread and Ken's reaction was meh but I'm not sure how to take the disappearance after even if it was announced.
The person I voted for, Carl. He did respond which I’m going to double check, though.

A lot going on IRL still with air travel, so I’m slower than I’d prefer.
 
I don’t really agee with the reasoning for the ken votes. I actually think scum would be guessing roles in their own thread, not publically. Additionally, the lack of a push towards another vote make me think scum is okay with it.

Unfortunately, ken isn’t giving us much to work with otherwise.

Checking TommyV next. Did he give any reason for ken vote or is it a survival vote?
I'm not set on Ken, but I am tired of doing nothing, so I at least wanted to put a vote out there. Honestly, my reason has nothing to do with the fishing. It was the defensiveness that came out after that made me raise an eyebrow. I am second-guessing based on your comment, "...the lack of a push towards another vote make me think scum is okay with it." I agree.
 
There has been plenty to discuss for a while, those comments came in at the halfway point of the day phase. If there is any point to start a discussion, it is when there is less than 24 hours left in the day.
Didn’t go back and look for my own post, so I’m just misremembering then. Still, didn’t mean anything other than what I explained.

I don’t feel like voting for Ken or Tommy. I agree with what Franklin just posted - scum is probably okay with any of those two, so I’m gonna vote elsewhere.

Within the next 35 minutes, I guess.
 
Who's your biggest scum read?

I'm not feeling the Ken votes as much as I still am the Michael vote unless both do something as we ramp up to day end. I don't agree that scum wouldn't try to guess in thread and Ken's reaction was meh but I'm not sure how to take the disappearance after even if it was announced.
How are you feeling about Carl and Claude right now?
 
I snap out of my daze, and catch up with the dialog that had passed when I wasn't around. I was somewhere else. My flashback had utterly consumed me. I was remembering my very first girlfriend. It hadn't lasted long. Because she was done in by an opposing gang. A very opportune thing to remember, given the pressures I now found myself under.

"Asuka's reluctance to place a vote seems fishy. It feels like they've been trying to direct the game without calling too much attention to themselves. At this point, mere hours before our life or death decision, I'm eyeing those who have not placed a vote into the ring, even a temporary one, designed to push other players, with some ammount of suspicion."

I lean back, taking another swig of my overly sugary beverage. It wasn't a good look for a gangster. I should have been fine with having some booze and smoking a cigar. But I was trying to find a better me, in the bleak wreckage of my soul.

"Those with little to no posts concern me as well, but given how early we are in the process of elimination I think that should be a concern saved for tomorrow. Everyone needs a chance to tap in to the rhythm of the game."

For it was a game we were all playing. A dark, twisted nightmare that playes on the innermost longings of our soul. An instinctual screeching, that for some had been dulled to a point of a low thrum, but for others rang as loud as a siren. A call to murder. A call to revenge.

"Trevor seems the most trustworthy to me due to sheer presence. But that isn't a metric I'm willing to go to bat for if the chips fall badly for him down the line."
 
The person I voted for, Carl. He did respond which I’m going to double check, though.

A lot going on IRL still with air travel, so I’m slower than I’d prefer.
lol that's fair. You unpacked him pretty well. Anyone else? Any particular reason you're good on Asuka? How you feel about those who aren't?
 
Y'all got this concern but not enough to push there to see what happens?

EOD. I want to go across the board and think more. I am bit concerned that my initial thought about declaring Asuka a solver was giving too much credit to him. That then would taint the whole line of thought, making the argument a massive misstep.
 
Ken---get your buns in here. I'm not confident in my vote for you. You're way too quiet though for someone leading votes.
 
Are you complaining that you’re going to have to put in effort of your own? I hate sheep d1. It’s such a cop out.

Alternative 1: Laying out what I planned to do next at the time.
Alternative 2: doing alternative 1 AND writing some filler to see if someone wants to take bite of some cheap bait.
 
Asuka falls a bit to the background as the game progresses. Some of that could be explained by others picking up the slack and me giving too much influence to the bright stars of the slow start, but even with all those disclaimers there is a odd feeling of comfort there. Like Asuka has done the needed and hunkered down for the day.

I agree with this, I had asked a question to Roman about that last night but I don't think he ever responded. My feeling was that Asuka, when present, feels like a strong voice with logical opinions, they've made some pretty good posts I think, but then they kind of stick to the shadows after things seem to be going their way... which makes me worry it might be a scummy way...

I didn’t really want to use real life as a crutch but this weekend has been particularly busy which is why you are getting bigger posts infrequently from me. The week should be easier since boredom at work will force me to play.

I snap out of my daze, and catch up with the dialog that had passed when I wasn't around. I was somewhere else. My flashback had utterly consumed me. I was remembering my very first girlfriend. It hadn't lasted long. Because she was done in by an opposing gang. A very opportune thing to remember, given the pressures I now found myself under.

"Asuka's reluctance to place a vote seems fishy. It feels like they've been trying to direct the game without calling too much attention to themselves. At this point, mere hours before our life or death decision, I'm eyeing those who have not placed a vote into the ring, even a temporary one, designed to push other players, with some ammount of suspicion."

I lean back, taking another swig of my overly sugary beverage. It wasn't a good look for a gangster. I should have been fine with having some booze and smoking a cigar. But I was trying to find a better me, in the bleak wreckage of my soul.

"Those with little to no posts concern me as well, but given how early we are in the process of elimination I think that should be a concern saved for tomorrow. Everyone needs a chance to tap in to the rhythm of the game."

For it was a game we were all playing. A dark, twisted nightmare that playes on the innermost longings of our soul. An instinctual screeching, that for some had been dulled to a point of a low thrum, but for others rang as loud as a siren. A call to murder. A call to revenge.

"Trevor seems the most trustworthy to me due to sheer presence. But that isn't a metric I'm willing to go to bat for if the chips fall badly for him down the line."


Asuka wonders if Niko is reading the game or just planning more RP considering he has had a vote down for half the day phase now.
 
Bout to run back out for a few so I'm gonna leave this post about how I'm feeling right now, pending what I assume will be a flurry of people realizing day is ending. I'll be mobile though.

Would not vote today: Trevor, Catalina, Niko, Roman, Carl

Would consider voting: Michael, Ken, TommyV

No real feelings or not today: Claude, Asuka, Huang

Feeling some feelings about Franklin. I know he's been out mostly because travel but I'm struggling with Asuka as top town and callouts on Carl which don't seem like anything to me but I'd rather let that develop more. (This works as answer to Carl too.)
 
So about an hour and a half left and Ken is just kind of cruising in the lead on the legs of Tommy voting for him as the next closest wagon.

I don’t like that but I’m also not going to save Ken if he isn’t going to save himself here.
 
Did he? How did he unpack me?
"Like a flimsy cardboard box from Jeff Amazon."

Ah. A joke about the current political climate. As much as I was brooding, some small sliver of humor remained in the cold blood flowing through my veins.

Asuka wonders if Niko is reading the game or just planning more RP considering he has had a vote down for half the day phase now.

"My thoughts on TommyV have not changed. But thank you for asking so nicely."
 
It's cool how I'm being called out for being too defensive when there's a ton of waffling going on elsewhere. I guess standing your ground is a bad look. I should listen to Asuka and just take the L for, what, a flippant first post? Is that it?
 
It's cool how I'm being called out for being too defensive when there's a ton of waffling going on elsewhere. I guess standing your ground is a bad look. I should listen to Asuka and just take the L for, what, a flippant first post? Is that it?

Care to present to the rest of us this so called a ton? And perhaps your thoughts about why this a ton is being ignored or why we should be concerned about this a ton instead of you?

The more constructive me would encourage you to take a more aggressive posture regarding your self-defense.
 
It's cool how I'm being called out for being too defensive when there's a ton of waffling going on elsewhere. I guess standing your ground is a bad look. I should listen to Asuka and just take the L for, what, a flippant first post? Is that it?
Back it up if you’re gonna say it. Otherwise it’s just air.

Who’s waffling.
How do you feel about it.
Where are you at.

You wanna talk pushback? I’m gonna push against your lack of substance. The best defense is doing any damn thing.
 
Tommy, do a hot take on who should we kill and why - make it a top three! Go!
Oh, god. Terrible time to be on mobile. Okay, here goes.

Actually, I took out my two others. My #1 is Ken. This is my hot take why...and it comes off making me sound like an asshole, but I truly don't mean it to be negative... If Ken is a townie, we can at least afford to lose him because he doesn't seem to argue/dissect much. At least not in a compelling way, as of yet. It isn't a mistake that will tear us down much, if it is a mistake to lynch him.
 
"I'm willing to switch my vote if something happens."

"No movement is concerning but I'm not doing anything about it."

"Yeah I could vote for the suspicious ones."
 
"Like a flimsy cardboard box from Jeff Amazon."

Ah. A joke about the current political climate. As much as I was brooding, some small sliver of humor remained in the cold blood flowing through my veins.



"My thoughts on TommyV have not changed. But thank you for asking so nicely."

Are you saying that you meant to say Tommy instead of me or...? This is still confusing me I guess.

It's cool how I'm being called out for being too defensive when there's a ton of waffling going on elsewhere. I guess standing your ground is a bad look. I should listen to Asuka and just take the L for, what, a flippant first post? Is that it?

Yeah. All you had to do was originally say that it was a flippant post and you didn’t actually care who was new. It’s that you instead went to blaming Huang instead and doubling down (twice if I remember).
 
Also, these two are something as wagon leaders. I’m on Len and described my read there and then we have Tommy doing what feels like bending over backwards to justify his Ken vote when this is really just him preserving himself. A lot of what you are saying Tommy applies to most of the low posters, it’s just a vote on Ken means you aren’t in first.
 
Yeah. All you had to do was originally say that it was a flippant post and you didn’t actually care who was new. It’s that you instead went to blaming Huang instead and doubling down (twice if I remember).

Because it was? It's not my fault you jump to your own conclusions and them double down on it when I explain.
 
Didn't someone say that Michael just rather is there? Being around? That is not a sign of a Mafia per se, but...

...and that is where my thoughts on Michael end up on.

Tommy, man, no. Not the loss minimization argument. No. This would be a really good act. I'll lean on it not being an act.

I've somewhat grown on Lance. Somewhat. I am now reminded of the original concern of mine and how he now seems to have gained substance. That is nice, but was that a natural change or not? Though a talented townie can change at will as well, that much is sure. Food for thought.

UNVOTE
 
Oh we have an hour left.

Let me go back and pick out something from this giant cluster duck of a day.
 
My #1 is Ken. This is my hot take why...and it comes off making me sound like an asshole, but I truly don't mean it to be negative... If Ken is a townie, we can at least afford to lose him because he doesn't seem to argue/dissect much.
With that alone you could list me or many other people as #1, whether they're being deliberate or just busy this weekend.
 
"Like a flimsy cardboard box from Jeff Amazon."

Ah. A joke about the current political climate. As much as I was brooding, some small sliver of humor remained in the cold blood flowing through my veins.



"My thoughts on TommyV have not changed. But thank you for asking so nicely."

Oh wait I see, no the “he” was me. I’ve had a vote down for half the day phase. I’m trying to figure out how you didn’t notice that.
 
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

Ken (3 votes)
Trevor - #38
Asuka - #115
TommyV - #200

TommyV (3 votes)
Lance - #33 #58
Niko - #52
Huang - #89
Ken - #258

Michael (1 votes)
Lance - #80

Carl (1 votes)
Franklin - #221

Catalina (1 votes)
Claude - #227

Franklin (0 votes)
Michael - #118 #193

Claude (0 votes)
Trevor - #7 #38

Lance (0 votes)
Catalina - #75 #260

Niko (0 votes)
Claude - #141 #172

Asuka (0 votes)
Lance - #58 #80

Not voting: Michael, Roman, Carl, Catalina

Post Counts:
Trevor: 52 Lance: 33 Michael: 22 TommyV: 21 Asuka: 20 Niko: 18 Catalina: 17 Claude: 14 Ken: 14 Carl: 13 Huang: 12 Franklin: 9 Roman: 6

Current Countdown:
9nhh2568xa



Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Are you saying that you meant to say Tommy instead of me or...?

The comment seemed innoccuous. But it didn't ring true. It rang a little hollow. Like there was something lingering beneath the surface. An attempt to deflect even the mildest of suspicion even if a giant truck could bore a hole through a singular aspect of it. With little thought as to what could be remaining in the aftermath, and what could stand on it's own.

"No. I still mean what I said about you. I did, however, miss your vote. Not because I didn't read, but because I merely didn't catch it on my readthrough. However, I think my point about you trying to direct the game stands independently from that. Maybe a little less in the shadows... Sure. But, however--"

I did not have time to finish my point. But that was the way of things sometimes.

Oh wait I see, no the “he” was me. I’ve had a vote down for half the day phase. I’m trying to figure out how you didn’t notice that.

"
How does anyone miss anything? By missing it. Lingering on it seems needless. But I have no idea what you're referring to with the "He" comment."

I stare at Ken throwing his vote down for TommyV. Smelled like self preservation. A reliable method of play, sure. The main goal of all of this was survival, after all.

"Depending on how the vote for TommyV pans out, I'll be watching Ken very closely."
 
With that alone you could list me or many other people as #1, whether they're being deliberate or just busy this weekend.
Yeah, but Ken didn't say he was busy this weekend, did he? And you're managing more posts than him still. That plus his defensiveness are what do it for me.
 
VOTE: Michael

I’ve had this vote down for the past hour, but every time I try to explain my reason, there’s always a “yeah, but....” in my head.

The reason for this vote is just because of your attempt to try and fish some information out of Lance regarding the new players. He placed his vote well before this so I think he has another reason for voting you, but mine is for that little interaction.
 
Yeah, but Ken didn't say he was busy this weekend, did he? And you're managing more posts than him still. That plus his defensiveness are what do it for me.

I wasn't aware that you needed to telegraph your activity in mafia /s
 
The day was winding down, with a tough decision on the horizon. Everyone had begun speaking up. The table's attendants were shouting at one another. Some seemed calm. Others did not. But there was a single fact that seemed important to mention, in among the chaos. I rose, and placed my palms on the table, giving everyone a most dire look.

"I would like to draw attention to the fact that we presently have a tie."
 
@Michael @Roman @Catalina do not currently have votes down.

We are 45 minutes away from EoD. Going to need to see where you're going here.

Michael, you just entered in as a contender here even after Carl's vote, so you should probably be here because I am tempted to vote there.
 
VOTE: Michael

I’ve had this vote down for the past hour, but every time I try to explain my reason, there’s always a “yeah, but....” in my head.

The reason for this vote is just because of your attempt to try and fish some information out of Lance regarding the new players. He placed his vote well before this so I think he has another reason for voting you, but mine is for that little interaction.

I'd argue that I didn't fish the information, since I actively asked for his opinion on the matter. Also, that was just paranoia discussion that I'm trying to keep off the plate.
But well, semantics.

"I would like to draw attention to the fact that we presently have a tie."

We need majority, right? So I guess the biggest issue is that either way, there's still 4/5 votes missing.
 
Michael, you just entered in as a contender here even after Carl's vote, so you should probably be here because I am tempted to vote there.
If I may ask, why are you considering voting there? Same as Carl because he tried to fish for info on newbies according to him, or something else?
 
If I may ask, why are you considering voting there? Same as Carl because he tried to fish for info on newbies according to him, or something else?
I was in agreement with most of Lance's takes earlier and he is one of my stronger town leans right now, even though I don't trust myself to town read people this early. I've felt a bit better about Mike's contributions here more recently, but not enough to make me think he couldn't be Scum or to erase those feelings from earlier.
 
Michael is the vote I’d move to if I just wanted to trust completely in gut. I don’t have anything real to point to but he’s been a non-presence for most of the day while still feeling like an active player.

The comment seemed innoccuous. But it didn't ring true. It rang a little hollow. Like there was something lingering beneath the surface. An attempt to deflect even the mildest of suspicion even if a giant truck could bore a hole through a singular aspect of it. With little thought as to what could be remaining in the aftermath, and what could stand on it's own.

"No. I still mean what I said about you. I did, however, miss your vote. Not because I didn't read, but because I merely didn't catch it on my readthrough. However, I think my point about you trying to direct the game stands independently from that. Maybe a little less in the shadows... Sure. But, however--"

I did not have time to finish my point. But that was the way of things sometimes.



"
How does anyone miss anything? By missing it. Lingering on it seems needless. But I have no idea what you're referring to with the "He" comment."

I stare at Ken throwing his vote down for TommyV. Smelled like self preservation. A reliable method of play, sure. The main goal of all of this was survival, after all.

"Depending on how the vote for TommyV pans out, I'll be watching Ken very closely."

You answered my question and it’s noted for later. There was a communication issue otherwise in how I asked my question before which isn’t important enough for me to try and fix on mobile with quotes so it’s fine.
 
@Michael @Roman @Catalina do not currently have votes down.

We are 45 minutes away from EoD. Going to need to see where you're going here.

Michael, you just entered in as a contender here even after Carl's vote, so you should probably be here because I am tempted to vote there.

I'm here.
I'm still not very convinced about putting down either Ken or Tommy. As much as they both have some fishy behavior in their history, I'm kind of doubtful regarding what we will get out of killing them.

But still... no kill is probably even worse in terms of info. So...

VOTE: Ken

Reasons: what I said before. Picking between Ken or Tommy was just gut feeling.
 
Votes all spread out here.

Not feeling the Tommy vote as much right now. Don’t love him but not sure on that vote. Not loving Carl coming to Michael with me either after I soft defended but he had an okay reason I guess.

Ken digging deeper over there. Hmm.
 
I was in agreement with most of Lance's takes earlier and he is one of my stronger town leans right now, even though I don't trust myself to town read people this early. I've felt a bit better about Mike's contributions here more recently, but not enough to make me think he couldn't be Scum or to erase those feelings from earlier.
I see, thanks. As somebody who missed a good part of the phase, this kind of explanation is helpful, and something for me to keep in mind for future phases, though it's currently not my preferred lynch.
 
Though I guess it's about time I weigh my options since the only one on my preferred lynch is me. And I do not like voting either Tommy or Ken. The former just seems newbie-ish to me, while I have barely any read on the latter.
 
We need majority, right? So I guess the biggest issue is that either way, there's still 4/5 votes missing.

Wrong, misread the first post.


Michael is the vote I’d move to if I just wanted to trust completely in gut. I don’t have anything real to point to but he’s been a non-presence for most of the day while still feeling like an active player.

I was here, expressed my stance and kept reading trying to figure out a better solution than voting Ken or Tommy. Didn't result in much.
I don't trust I'd be able to move votes to someone else even if I did have a feeling though, given my current reputation lol.
 
Vote: Ken

I slide my second vote of the day on the table. The cursive script gleamed with the red ink I'd written it in. It joined many others. Red. The blood of angry men. Red among a sea of black and white. Black and white, mingled with many shades of grey. The only colors I could see. The only colors I could feel.

"...Ken has been around more than TommyV. And I've liked nothing about their play. To avoid a possible tie, I'm going to be placing my vote here."
 
You answered my question and it’s noted for later. There was a communication issue otherwise in how I asked my question before which isn’t important enough for me to try and fix on mobile with quotes so it’s fine.

I need pay more attention to the vote tool to be honest, I keep forgetting that such a valulable thing exists.
 
I'm here.
I'm still not very convinced about putting down either Ken or Tommy. As much as they both have some fishy behavior in their history, I'm kind of doubtful regarding what we will get out of killing them.

But still... no kill is probably even worse in terms of info. So...

VOTE: Ken

Reasons: what I said before. Picking between Ken or Tommy was just gut feeling.

This tosses my head upside down. Why the no kill mention - why state the obvious? Why do the woe is me who is forced to pick between these two beautiful townies?

This does not fit. #91 "I've seen too many scums strategizing around defending newbs..." The implication being that he has played before, even multiple games. The spoilers have implications about prior game experience.

Why the fluff? Final note: no notable hunting what I can see.
 
There’s still a half hour left, I don’t see why we are sweating a tie

VOTE: Michael

That’s now a tie again btw.
 
I think there’s a chance here Ken could be a flailing townie. I think we’ve all seen it before. But there’s also hard avoidance there and if it turns out that he is scum we should look at everyone who didn’t address him during this time.

I’m willing to give Michael another day. Especially with the votes that are shifting to him now.

vote: Ken
 
It's a small player list and a slow weekend so people seem content to pad their post counts talking about a select group of people.

I voted for Michael because he spent an inordinate amount of time speculating on who's new and who's not. Frankly we don't know and it shouldn't matter in a costume game.

Tommy keeps defending his self-preservation vote like he has to. Spoiler: you don't.

What else... Catalina goes between one good post and one bad post. Like why comment on Trevor taking over the game? That comment about Asuka dropping his vote and then walking away is food for thought.

Carl and Claude are kind of just there.
 
This tosses my head upside down. Why the no kill mention - why state the obvious? Why do the woe is me who is forced to pick between these two beautiful townies?

This does not fit. #91 "I've seen too many scums strategizing around defending newbs..." The implication being that he has played before, even multiple games. The spoilers have implications about prior game experience.

Why the fluff? Final note: no notable hunting what I can see.
This is definitely some shit I want to see unpacked and spread out to dry.
 
VOTE: Michael
Yeah, just ISOd and read all his posts. The focus on newbies and trying to get information about it or discussing how such info could be used is really odd to me. Definitely preferable to Tommy or Ken for me.
 
I'm here.
I'm still not very convinced about putting down either Ken or Tommy. As much as they both have some fishy behavior in their history, I'm kind of doubtful regarding what we will get out of killing them.

But still... no kill is probably even worse in terms of info. So...

VOTE: Ken

Reasons: what I said before. Picking between Ken or Tommy was just gut feeling.

"I'm just going to waffle between the two until a clear favourite emerges."
 
I am torn between Ken and Michael right now. I am really looking weird at that last post from Michael.

Lance, why the sudden switch to Ken? You seemed pretty set on this just a few hours ago.
 
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

Ken (5 votes)
Trevor - #38
Asuka - #115 #290
TommyV - #200
Michael - #281
Niko - #287
Lance - #291

Michael (4 votes)
Lance - #80 #291
Carl - #270
Ken - #285
Asuka - #290
Claude - #295

TommyV (1 votes)
Lance - #33 #58
Niko - #52 #287
Huang - #89
Ken - #258 #285

Carl (1 votes)
Franklin - #221

Franklin (0 votes)
Michael - #118 #193

Claude (0 votes)
Trevor - #7 #38

Lance (0 votes)
Catalina - #75 #260

Niko (0 votes)
Claude - #141 #172

Catalina (0 votes)
Claude - #227 #295

Asuka (0 votes)
Lance - #58 #80

Not voting: Roman, Catalina

Post Counts:
Trevor: 55 Lance: 37 Michael: 25 TommyV: 24 Asuka: 24 Niko: 22 Claude: 21 Catalina: 19 Ken: 18 Carl: 14 Huang: 12 Franklin: 9 Roman: 6

Current Countdown:
9nhh2568xa

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Top Bottom