Costume Party |OT| The Mafia Mash

Rey

Costume Account
Dracula isn't really dracula in my eyes

more like some brit with a top hat and rose coloured glasses and black cape
 

Minecraft Steve

Costume Account
Dracula isn't really dracula in my eyes

more like some brit with a top hat and rose coloured glasses and black cape
See with the accent I was thinking more A Brit person Pretending to be French standing on top of a castle taunting King Arthur
 

Jack Sparrow

Costume Account
I should have clarified what I meant by early game antics: I meant meme votes that don’t mean much. Their reasoning sounded like a meme
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
I had a vision that Dracula has a pure mind.

It was hard to see clearly what was going on, but for now I trust my visions and do not want to vote for him.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Vote Count:

Cereal Killer - 2
Spider-Man - Post #76
Dracula - Post #81

Dracula - 2
Cereal Killer - Post #93
Banana - Post #115
 

Spider-Man

Costume Account

"no" it's not obvious why cereal killer is scum, or "no" to cereal longer being scum?

Just to explain, everyone here is a character of some sort but I've never heard of Cereal Killer. It's that like Count Chocula or something? If CK ends up being an actual serial killer you'll all thank me later.

(I'm only half joking lol)

I think they think you’re scum. Are you?
I take it that means you trust this Spider-Man.

I'm liking this healthy paranoia in Dany.
I like Dracula too, being the second vote after the first vote on D1 takes balls that not all action would have.

Lolz aside, this is as good as any for a day 1 day start vote.

You going to vote with us then?
 

Bob Ross

Costume Account
"no" it's not obvious why cereal killer is scum, or "no" to cereal longer being scum?

Just to explain, everyone here is a character of some sort but I've never heard of Cereal Killer. It's that like Count Chocula or something? If CK ends up being an actual serial killer you'll all thank me later.

(I'm only half joking lol)




I'm liking this healthy paranoia in Dany.
I like Dracula too, being the second vote after the first vote on D1 takes balls that not all action would have.



You going to vote with us then?
Game Specific Rule no.2
 

Prisoner

Costume Account
"no" it's not obvious why cereal killer is scum, or "no" to cereal longer being scum?

Just to explain, everyone here is a character of some sort but I've never heard of Cereal Killer. It's that like Count Chocula or something? If CK ends up being an actual serial killer you'll all thank me later.

(I'm only half joking lol)
Flavor is just Flavor, so I'm not sure where you're going with that reasoning.
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
If there’s something bad about Dracula it’s his absence after receiving pressure, but that could have many reasons. The responses he did give didn’t have a layer of dishonesty you’d expect from the evils.
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
Didn't realize we had already started.
Since you have just read them, what do you think of the first battles and votes?
I'm just trying to vote out the serial/cereal killer. Cereal is meant to be enjoyed.
I find that a little premature when we don’t even have any evidence about the existence of a serial killer. The only reason I could see to believe that is because there are 18 of us and parties work best with an odd number of guests so that might mean someone snuck in.
 

Spider-Man

Costume Account
Since you have just read them, what do you think of the first battles and votes?

I find that a little premature when we don’t even have any evidence about the existence of a serial killer. The only reason I could see to believe that is because there are 18 of us and parties work best with an odd number of guests so that might mean someone snuck in.

If there were a party guest dressed as a mafioso or as a werewolf would you vote them out? Because I would, I'd totally go for the low hanging fruit.
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
If there were a party guest dressed as a mafioso or as a werewolf would you vote them out? Because I would, I'd totally go for the low hanging fruit.
It depends, I would go where I sense evil. If that’s where I sense it the most or if I sense good from the rest I would go there.
 

Witch

Costume Account
Spider-Man is just trying to get the ball rolling. Dracula is more sus, but the vote doesn’t seem to have much thought behind it, either. I think folks holding Dracula accountable are justified, even though I think it’s probably nothing.
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
Spider-Man is just trying to get the ball rolling. Dracula is more sus, but the vote doesn’t seem to have much thought behind it, either. I think folks holding Dracula accountable are justified, even though I think it’s probably nothing.
This is from a relaxed mind. You can join my good vision along with Spider.
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
I don't understand what you're saying here.
There are some people who are just messing around and some who are way on the other end and treating this like there's a lot of stuff going on. They're asking questions and digging in. And some in the middle I guess but my guess is one of the more serious people would probably be scum trying to start early on town cred. It is a good time to do it because a lot of people will not be very active yet because it is the weekend and already late at night for some players.
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
There are some people who are just messing around and some who are way on the other end and treating this like there's a lot of stuff going on. They're asking questions and digging in. And some in the middle I guess but my guess is one of the more serious people would probably be scum trying to start early on town cred. It is a good time to do it because a lot of people will not be very active yet because it is the weekend and already late at night for some players.
There’s a feeling of evil here trying to cast doubt on those helping us and with the widest net possible so anyone can be caught.
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
The way I see it Daenerys is following up on real things and also making comments on them so people will see where she stands. A few others are only asking questions but not really commenting so we don't get the same sense of where they stand. Questions are easy especially if you never follow up with anything.
 

Witch

Costume Account
The way I see it Daenerys is following up on real things and also making comments on them so people will see where she stands. A few others are only asking questions but not really commenting so we don't get the same sense of where they stand. Questions are easy especially if you never follow up with anything.

I agree. I’d implore town to engage as much as possible. We’re not going to get someone doing an obvious slip on day 1, so sitting back and watching to see how this whole thing spins out won’t help us. Holding conversations will help build your character to others and hopefully your towniness shines through.
 

Rey

Costume Account
Just for the sake of this argument and to push this conversation along the lines

@Daenerys Targaryen If Dracula is a pure spirit, then whom amongst us should be lunched on day one?

just for the sake a read
 

Rey

Costume Account
as much as I would love to lunch at least one low posting partcipant, this is kinda is a costume party

and I really want to see this whether this psychic gambit ends great or nah
 

Witch

Costume Account
as much as I would love to lunch at least one low posting partcipant, this is kinda is a costume party

I understand going after low contributors, but I don’t follow your full reasoning for not wanting to lunch one. Can you explain?
 

Dracula

Costume Account (He/Him)
To be honest Spidy insisting on voting Cereal makes me think they might be Town.
Because Scum wouldn't lock themselves in so early.
There iz about a 0% chance zat your page 1 vote will lock you in on voting zomeone. I don't underztand your logic.

How about Cereal'z rezponze to the two vote wagon? Did you find zat zcummy or towny, and did that impact your read on Zpiderman azzociatively?
 

Dracula

Costume Account (He/Him)
There are some people who are just messing around and some who are way on the other end and treating this like there's a lot of stuff going on. They're asking questions and digging in. And some in the middle I guess but my guess is one of the more serious people would probably be scum trying to start early on town cred. It is a good time to do it because a lot of people will not be very active yet because it is the weekend and already late at night for some players.
Not interezted in deep wolvez until we lynch the more obviouz onez firzt. More efficient. But yez, thiz iz how a game uzually panz out.
 

Dracula

Costume Account (He/Him)
The way he popped in just to place that vote didn’t feel great.
On ze two day time frame thiz fixation you've had on the activity of a few playerz doezn't zeem to be too...

This is getting annoying.

Anyway. On the two day time frame we have, this fixation on the activity of players/pop outs between their posts is like, the last thing I'm looking at. Working from home is real at the moment, popping in and out is probably going to be more common than in your standard mafia game.
 

Dracula

Costume Account (He/Him)
If it becomes a major pattern that coincides with the game in a consistent way that's different but for now it seems pointless
 

Banana

Costume Account
as much as I would love to lunch at least one low posting partcipant, this is kinda is a costume party

and I really want to see this whether this psychic gambit ends great or nah

I mean going after low participant players when the game as been open for *checks watch* 5 hours seems a little extreme to me. To me that just screams not willing to put yourself out there on any sort of meaningful vote later and just hide behind someone who isn't as active.
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
Not interezted in deep wolvez until we lynch the more obviouz onez firzt. More efficient. But yez, thiz iz how a game uzually panz out.
It's not about deep wolves. It's about how people usually gravitate toward nitpicking people who post more and I'm saying probably people who are talking more right now are more likely to be town. I don't think you actually read anything I said lol. I said not more than one would be a wolf.
 

Rey

Costume Account
Something's a bit off

the computer reads a pattern but I'm not sure it's a pattern I can recognize
 

Rey

Costume Account
I have you know cereal killers have been known to play games with the cops so......
 

Banana

Costume Account
It's not about deep wolves. It's about how people usually gravitate toward nitpicking people who post more and I'm saying probably people who are talking more right now are more likely to be town. I don't think you actually read anything I said lol. I said not more than one would be a wolf.

Ehhhh....I don't really buy this at all. I have seen plenty of scum be some of the most talkative people in the game while others don't say any more than they have to. I try not to view activity as a sign one way or another (especially in a costume game) because that way lies misdirection and madness.
 

Witch

Costume Account
I don’t have a solid mafia/town read on anyone yet, but I think Cereal Killer has been talking the most sense and is worth keeping around on that basis alone.

A few players seem to be trying to be helpful, but are just causing more issues. Sorry, Rey and Daenerys, I do mean you. I don’t think that means lunch, but it’s like... cool your jets y’all.

Orherwise, just a handful of folks trying to contribute and not really knowing where to go (myself included) since this is just day 1. I’m open to suggestions, but I’d spinning a wheel deciding who to vote for right now. In lieu of anything else by end of day, I would not target low activity players; I’d push someone I feel is actively harming town with their rhetoric.
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
Ehhhh....I don't really buy this at all. I have seen plenty of scum be some of the most talkative people in the game while others don't say any more than they have to. I try not to view activity as a sign one way or another (especially in a costume game) because that way lies misdirection and madness.
It’s a day one take. Do with it what you want lol
 

Dracula

Costume Account (He/Him)
It's not about deep wolves. It's about how people usually gravitate toward nitpicking people who post more and I'm saying probably people who are talking more right now are more likely to be town. I don't think you actually read anything I said lol. I said not more than one would be a wolf.
I got the message exactly as you intended, you're claiming that probabilistically there's going to be one wolf in the early game more active posters, right? If I'm correct in that rephrasing then I just repeat my previous post.
 

Banana

Costume Account
It probably is a coincidence because if they were around they should be putting out something about it to try to stop speculation in its tracks. Still it's not a good look even if it was an innocent comment.
 

Zombie

Costume Account
Oh didn't realize we were starting. I'm seeing the usual day 1 of joke votes followed by people taking those joke votes seriously is going full steam.

Only one scum left for you to find

This is a hell of a bad post though. Further investigation is required.
 
Top Bottom