Costume Party |OT| The Mafia Mash

[Rey]

yeah course you all disappear when i get here.

fuckin skeeeeeeeeeeeeeeed

 

[Barney]

wait, why is Barney trying to even use me not posting in the neighbour chat against me when i couldnt have even had my costume stolen then?
if anything thats just consistency.

Read that again.

 

[Barney]

yeah course you all disappear when i get here.

fuckin skeeeeeeeeeeeeeeed

I'm here, just got home.

 

[Rey]

So that leaves Rey (That didn't say anything the whole night) and Kool-Aid Man.

What really bothers me is that Rey said nothing in the neighbor chat and now has said nothing here now.

i read it again and unless im missing another post this is it, not sure how else im supposed to take this.

 

[Barney]

i read it again and unless im missing another post this is it, not sure how else im supposed to take this.

I don't want to make your work for you, so I'll wait a bit to expose my theory on you.

For now, what do you have to say in the whole situation?

 

[Rey]

I don't want to make your work for you, so I'll wait a bit to expose my theory on you.

For now, what do you have to say in the whole situation?

mostly just that how you came right out the gate with both unfounded excuses for how it couldn't possibly be you, and some real stretches for why its both me and KAM makes me more suspicious of you than the others.

 

[Rey]

But then KAM has hardly handled this gracefully so it aint like hes in the clear.

 

[Barney]

mostly just that how you came right out the gate with both unfounded excuses for how it couldn't possibly be you, and some real stretches for why its both me and KAM makes me more suspicious of you than the others.

I'm scum-hunting, I have to if we want to win. Isn't it convenient how you just stayed away for...

yeah i think its a bit too late on that front,
like i dont think we should say tomorrows lunch will 100% be the other but its already clear that thats how its heading.

A literal day and a half?

 

[Rey]

I'm scum-hunting, I have to if we want to win. Isn't it convenient how you just stayed away for...


A literal day and a half?

honesly i wasn't thinking about the game much yesterday thanks to personal things (that i suppose i could say but it would help give away who i am under the costume), and even then its not like the day was up for long.
but either way i wouldnt call a conspicuous absence convenient, not to mention again if im bob ross then the supposed original town rey was still most of that absence.

 

[Barney]

honesly i wasn't thinking about the game much yesterday thanks to personal things (that i suppose i could say but it would help give away who i am under the costume), and even then its not like the day was up for long.
but either way i wouldnt call a conspicuous absence convenient, not to mention again if im bob ross then the supposed original town rey was still most of that absence.

I get that, I am also avoiding mentioning personal stuff because it goes against the spirit of the game.

Moving on, you should have access to the neighborizer thread, I really want you to make a full summary of what happened in the last day and what you feel about it.

 

[Rey]

I get that, I am also avoiding mentioning personal stuff because it goes against the spirit of the game.

Moving on, you should have access to the neighborizer thread, I really want you to make a full summary of what happened in the last day and what you feel about it.

right thats actually bugging me a bit.

So basically it was BobRoss being all dejected that he miscalculated on an impending scum victory and giving himself away, but otherwise taking it in good humour and joking with yall a bunch about it.
Which is kinda throwing me since he really looks like hes resigned to losing, like it all reads pretty genuine, which doesn't fit with him apparently having this hail mary play today with stealing another players identity.
It doesnt quite fit for me but i cant think of any other reasons beyond Bob just being a real good actor and luring yall into a false sense of victory

 

[Barney]

right thats actually bugging me a bit.

So basically it was BobRoss being all dejected that he miscalculated on an impending scum victory and giving himself away, but otherwise taking it in good humour and joking with yall a bunch about it.
Which is kinda throwing me since he really looks like hes resigned to losing, like it all reads pretty genuine, which doesn't fit with him apparently having this hail mary play today with stealing another players identity.
It doesnt quite fit for me but i cant think of any other reasons beyond Bob just being a real good actor and luring yall into a false sense of victory

It was a brilliant move and it actually worked because I would have liked to see your reaction on the whole thing, but since we:

1) Where so sure Obama had to be the last one and.

2) Natiko for some reason decided to make it 4 hours instead of "Until everyone submits their kills"

It is pretty obvious now that this was a move by Bob Ross so, as you said, fool us all.

Honestly, wouldn't you fall for it yourself? As you said, it did read pretty genuine.

 

[Rey]

It was a brilliant move and it actually worked because I would have liked to see your reaction on the whole thing, but since we:

1) Where so sure Obama had to be the last one and.

2) Natiko for some reason decided to make it 4 hours instead of "Until everyone submits their kills"

It is pretty obvious now that this was a move by Bob Ross so, as you said, fool us all.

Honestly, wouldn't you fall for it yourself? As you said, it did read pretty genuine.

well now my big question about you is if BobRoss would be so shamelessly self congratulatory.

 

[Barney]

well now my big question about you is if BobRoss would be so shamelessly self congratulatory.

I can appreciate the hustle.

I also think we are in deep shit.

But don't avoid the question. You've been doing that for a bit now.

 

[Rey]

I can appreciate the hustle.

I also think we are in deep shit.

But don't avoid the question. You've been doing that for a bit now.

uhh, which question? i thought id responded to everything?

 

[Barney]

uhh, which question? i thought id responded to everything?

I'll be more direct, then.

How would you have reacted to Bob Ross "Slippin", and joining the chat.

 

[Rey]

I'll be more direct, then.

How would you have reacted to Bob Ross "Slippin", and joining the chat.

The same as everyone, i would have thought it was a genuine slip and that we would be lunching Bob and sailing along to victory right now, which means i probably would have just been joking about it along with the rest of you.

 

[Barney]

The same as everyone, i would have thought it was a genuine slip and that we would be lunching Bob and sailing along to victory right now, which means i probably would have just been joking about it along with the rest of you.

Ok... ok...

So what do you think would happen if we don't lunch today, and wait until the final three?

 

[Rey]

Ok... ok...

So what do you think would happen if we don't lunch today, and wait until the final three?

that actually might not be a bad idea.
the worst thing i can think of is the possibility that the scum formerly known as bob ross might be able to use that same ability again, which would make figuring it out harder still, but that seems pretty unlikely just from a role balancing standpoint, no to mention it still being an easier choice.

 

[Rey]

wait actually no i dont think it really would help.
We can be pretty certain that Cinderella is town and not the new Bob right?
That would just mean scum would kill them tonight, leaving things in pretty much the exact same circumstances as today, except with it being even easier for them to hammer if anyone places a hasty vote.

 

[Barney]

wait actually no i dont think it really would help.
We can be pretty certain that Cinderella is town and not the new Bob right?
That would just mean scum would kill them tonight, leaving things in pretty much the exact same circumstances as today, except with it being even easier for them to hammer if anyone places a hasty vote.

Yeeep, I pointed that out earlier.

We need to figure this out now so we can give Cinderella the hammer.

 

[Barney]

I need all 4 of us to be here to really get the ball rolling, but my time for sleep is rapidly approachng and I'm not sure I'll be here.

 

[Cinderella]

Well I woke up with a cold, so won’t be going into work. Anyway I think I caught a slip a couple of hours back that’s good enough for me to pull the trigger. @Barney , the second KAM and I all share one thing in common, we use the world lunch (feel free to look back). Then ‘KAM’ comes in today and uses and lynch instead, without being forced.

I don't know why but I think you're trying to push some agenda here, if we no lynch why would scum kill? They will probably leave it as is I think

I think this is the best evidence we’re gonna have all day and I dont think anyone can begrudge me for voting based off this.

Vote: Kool-Aid Man

 

[Rey]

Yeeep, I pointed that out earlier.

We need to figure this out now so we can give Cinderella the hammer.

...as you can see im being as diligent as ever today.

Well I woke up with a cold, so won’t be going into work. Anyway I think I caught a slip a couple of hours back that’s good enough for me to pull the trigger. @Barney , the second KAM and I all share one thing in common, we use the world lunch (feel free to look back). Then ‘KAM’ comes in today and uses and lynch instead, without being forced.



I think this is the best evidence we’re gonna have all day and I dont think anyone can begrudge me for voting based off this.

Vote: Kool-Aid Man

it aint much, but i guess its the best we can really do given this challenge.

 

[Barney]

...as you can see im being as diligent as ever today.

it aint much, but i guess its the best we can really do given this challenge.

Yeah I'm 100% convinced now you are not DeepRoss. You didn't hammer instantly. We know it's not Cinderella.

It has to be either me or KAM.

Well I woke up with a cold, so won’t be going into work. Anyway I think I caught a slip a couple of hours back that’s good enough for me to pull the trigger. @Barney , the second KAM and I all share one thing in common, we use the world lunch (feel free to look back). Then ‘KAM’ comes in today and uses and lynch instead, without being forced.



I think this is the best evidence we’re gonna have all day and I dont think anyone can begrudge me for voting based off this.

Vote: Kool-Aid Man

It's a lot of small thing but they add up:
-Bad answers to my questions.
-No recollection of the flavour thing, that was made a big deal by blue KAM himself when it happened.
-Quick unvoting on me and jump to Rey when he felt that was not going to fly.
-lynch over lunch.

I think we got him.

Well, now it's on you Rey, what do you think? I really should go to sleep now. This is it.

 

[Cinderella]

Yeah I'm 100% convinced now you are not DeepRoss. You didn't hammer instantly. We know it's not Cinderella.

It has to be either me or KAM.

It's a lot of small thing but they add up:
-Bad answers to my questions.
-No recollection of the flavour thing, that was made a big deal by blue KAM himself when it happened.
-Quick unvoting on me and jump to Rey when he felt that was not going to fly.
-lynch over lunch.

I think we got him.

Well, now it's on you Rey, what do you think? I really should go to sleep now. This is it.

Yeah I think there’s enough here. Let’s end this, if it’s you or Rey than well played

 

[Rey]

yeah fuck it im down.

Its just waiting on my vote right? We wanna end it now?

 

[Cinderella]

yeah fuck it im down.

Its just waiting on my vote right? We wanna end it now?

Yeah might as well, don’t think there’ll be a major revelation or anything that cracks this wide open. If it’s you or Barney then well done

 

[Rey]

yeah imma end it now, i cant see KAM coming back with anything that would really swerve it.

Vote: Kool-Aid Man

 

[Kool-Aid Man]

GG, sorry team.

 

[Natiko]

DAY 8 ENDS

Rest will take a bit.

 

[Natiko]

Vote Count:

Kool-Aid Man - 3
Barney
Cinderella
Rey

 

[Natiko]

Very Small Crowd: Okay, look, I know we kind of sleep walked through the last couple days, but it's put up or shut up time.

Very Small Crowd: Aha! The answer, of course, is Kool-Aid Man because just like Bob Ross every third post contains a gerund phrase.

Kool-Aid Man has died!

Welcome to Costume Party Mafia!

You are dressed as Kool-Aid Man, a Vanilla Townie.

You have no special abilities, but you do have the ability to vote.

You are aligned with Town and win when all threats to Town have been eliminated.

Game thread is HERE

But wait... by god, that's off brand Bob Ross's music!

Bob Ross has died!

Welcome to Costume Party Mafia!

You are dressed as Bob Ross, a Costume Thief.

As a Mafia team you share a faction kill you may perform once per night with the command Kill: <PLAYER NAME>.

Once per game, when you perform the faction kill and remove your target from the game, you will take control of their account and lose control of yours.

On the following day, it will be announced that your target's real identity has been removed from the game and that their account has been taken over by the Mafia. The account you have left behind will be revealed as well.

You will gain your target's role but your alignment will remain the same under that new account.
If you are removed from the game under the new account, your role PM and target's original role PM will be flipped. Players will be aware it was the account that was robbed.

You also have the ability to vote.

You are aligned with Mafia and win when the Mafia team has a majority of the votes at the start of the day phase..

Your fellow Mafia members are Dracula, Prisoner, and Zombie.

The Mafia chat can be found HERE.

Game thread is HERE

And with that, this shitty costume party in the middle of the summer has concluded.

Town has won!

Your remaining stars are...

Cinderella has won!

Cinderella was played by... Kopite!

Welcome to Costume Party Mafia!

You are dressed as Cinderella, an Odd-Night Commuter.

During odd-numbered nights (Night 1, Night 3, etc.), you cannot be targeted by any player. You also have the ability to vote.

You are aligned with Town and win when all threats to Town have been eliminated.

Game thread is HERE

Barney has won!

Barney was played by... SalvaPot!

Welcome to Costume Party Mafia!

You are dressed as Barney, a Neighborizer.

During the night, you can target a player using the command Invite: <PLAYER NAME> to invite them to a secret chat. This chat will only be open for discussion at night. All targets from previous nights remain in this chat. The chat will be closed if you are removed from the game. You also have the ability to vote.

You are aligned with Town and win when all threats to Town have been eliminated.

Game thread is HERE

Rey has won!

Rey was played by... Stantastic! (Who replaced Funky Dude Sparks)

Welcome to Costume Party Mafia!

You are dressed as Rey, a Vanilla Townie.

You have no special abilities, but you do have the ability to vote.

You are aligned with Town and win when all threats to Town have been eliminated.

Game thread is HERE

Additional Cast & Credits:

Executive Producer was Fran as the original designer!

Clown was played by Kyanrute
Baby was played by Ketkat
Spider-Man was played by Swamped
Witch was played by LaunchpadMcQ
Daenerys Targaryen was played by Ty4on
Barack Obama was played by Benghis Khan
Cereal Killer was played by Dr. Monkey
Banana was played by MrHedin
Kool-Aid Man was played by Razmos (Who replaced nin)
Jack Sparrow was played by Red_V2
Bob Ross was played by Geno
Dracula was played by fowl playa
Prisoner was played by malus
Zombie was played by TheChuggernaut
Minecraft Steve was played by Zippedpinhead

 

[Geno]

Damn chuggs rolled scum again wow.

 

[Cinderella]

Damn chuggs rolled scum again wow.

I thought you were Chugg lol

 

[Natiko]

Boards should all be visible and accessible. I forgot we did something different on the back end now, so I was flying blind on how to open everything up. If anyone sees any issues let me know lol

 

[nin1000]

Thanks for hosting the game!
It was a ton of fun! i am pissed that something came in between an i was replaced.
But Raz did a great job as me.

 

[Razmos]

Thanks for hosting the game!
It was a ton of fun! i am pissed that something came in between an i was replaced.
But Raz did a great job as me.

I hope I did you proud nin!

 

[Natiko]

Kool-Aid Man was a highlight the whole way through - from nin's antics, Razmos' twist on it, and ultimately the unfurling at the end.

 

[nin1000]

I hope I did you proud nin!

You certanly did :*

 

[Barney]

I knew that was Monkey, somehow I always manage to annoy you.

 

[Natiko]

I would like to thank everyone that played. It wasn’t always super active, but it seemed like people had fun. Tried to put a few different twists on costume games in here. Sorry for it being hectic on my end with some late starts and getting to day end being delayed some. Hopefully you all enjoyed the game.

 

[nin1000]

Salva knew it was me. His hermano. Ofc he could not kill me, as soon as he saw that I was replaced he pulled the trigger.

 

[Geno]

Great game, thanks for running Natiko!

 

[SalvaPot]

Geno is the master of disguise, completely had me fooled the whole game, if he had chosen anyone other tha KAM I would have really struggles to put pressure on him becuae KAM was pretty much the onla player I was paying attention to the whole game.

I had a feeling that was you, Nin, you always make me laugh. Razmos did a great job too.

 

[Zippedpinhead]

I want to thank both the scum team and the town team.

without both of your teams hard work (scum for the banana NK and town for the cereal Killer flip day 2 and believing me on Prisoner) I could not have won.

Cheers everyone!

 

[LaunchpadMcQ]

I had a lot of fun, Natiko. Thanks for running the game!

 

[SalvaPot]

Major props to Kopite for figuring out that last Geno slip, and Stan for pulling that trigger.

We somehow waddled our way to victory!

 

[Chuggernaut]

Damn chuggs rolled scum again wow.

can’t stop won’t stop

 

[Swamped]

I would like to thank everyone that played. It wasn’t always super active, but it seemed like people had fun. Tried to put a few different twists on costume games in here. Sorry for it being hectic on my end with some late starts and getting to day end being delayed some. Hopefully you all enjoyed the game.

Thank you for hosting! And thanks to all the players for being awesome! This game was really fun to play. I enjoyed being a PR who was actually useful for once. I loved the costume idea too, it was a bit disorienting at first but it was so refreshing to not metagame.

 

[Kopite]

Major props to Kopite for figuring out that last Geno slip, and Stan for pulling that trigger.

We somehow waddled our way to victory!

You answering with your reaction to the GIF so quickly was amazing as well lol

 

[SalvaPot]

You answering with your reaction to the GIF so quickly was amazing as well lol

You can thank Dr.Monkey for that. We'll always find each other.

 

[Natiko]

I greatly enjoyed your opening to the day as well Salva, got a good laugh out of me.

 

[SalvaPot]

I greatly enjoyed your opening to the day as well Salva, got a good laugh out of me.

I had other more disturbing options but that one was too perfect.

All I could imagine was how smug Geno had to feel at the moment, controlling the narrative.

 

[heymonkey]

Kopite really crushed it at the end with that lunch v lynch pickup. Legend. SO good.

Nat, I love the game end post. :D

 

[Natiko]

Kopite really crushed it at the end with that lunch v lynch pickup. Legend. SO good.

Nat, I love the game end post. :D

I'm glad! Took a little longer, but I thought it would be nice to end it with a bit more style.

 

[Swamped]

I'm glad! Took a little longer, but I thought it would be nice to end it with a bit more style.

I also enjoyed the short and sweet flavor, I cracked up multiple times

 

[Ketkat]

Heyy, we won! That was a pretty incredible last day and I love that scum role for a costume game like this.

Thanks for setting up the game for us Natiko, I had a lot of fun!

 

[turmoil7]

It was a fun game to spectate, thanks to everyone involved. Congrats to town and zipped.

100% authentic scumslips

 

[lokiduck]

Damn chuggs rolled scum again wow.

And a Scum JOAT as well. Must be fun having the same role back to back. XD

Fabulous game btw the Geno. You almost had it. c:

 

[Stantastic]

Yes, i completely deserve this victory.

 

[Chuggernaut]

And a Scum JOAT as well. Must be fun having the same role back to back. XD

Fabulous game btw the Geno. You almost had it. c:

i want to roll town for the love of god

 

[lokiduck]

i want to roll town for the love of god

Clearly Random.org hates you :< I'm sorry.

 

[Cereal Killer]

You answering with your reaction to the GIF so quickly was amazing as well lol

Listen, me being an asshole has to be good for something.