Spectator Thread The Protagonist Penthouse
- Thread starter TearablePuns
- Start date
LaunchpadMcQ
...can I smell you?
I legit do not know if Maol sets up these dominoes (e.g. flip Geno then Hawthorn looks scummier) if he's playing town. The one time I played with him as town, he was basically quiet D1 and just all up on my case D2 before we killed him. But the dominoes thing was one of those things I watched when he was on my team like "man this is sketchy as hell".
I dont know what to think anymore. Now Gorlak is being super sus.
LaunchpadMcQ
...can I smell you?
lmao Gorlak please
LaunchpadMcQ
...can I smell you?
LETS FUCKING GOOOOOO
my boy has got this
my boy has got this
I'm so confused
LaunchpadMcQ
...can I smell you?
The monster was getting closer to the forefront of the picture
I'm so confused why gorlak temp banned himself.. because of the game?
I think so. Our games are usually less contentious.
I have not read everything closely, but what I have read indicates that the arguments have led to some blind spots.
If Geno turns out to be town I'm gonna freak..
Maol confirmed town
For the love of God can they flip geno now.
For the love of God can they flip geno now.
LaunchpadMcQ
...can I smell you?
I just want all of town to know I would’ve tanked this game just as hard lol
yeah, I am stumped on who the last scum is anyway
ehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh not always
I tried.
SalvaPot
YEAH
You did maol, Geno is always a really REALLY hard nut to crack, even when I caught him on a lie in Costume Party Mafia there was this voice telling me to believe him. He is just really good at adjusting.
And I was still looking at Zeke and Leo too, but like, this town was not doing shit unless you presented the entire scum team to them on a platter.
And yeah, this is exactly why I told Gorlak I wasn't pressuring Geno early on in the game. I knew if Geno was scum, it'd be a tremendous amount of bullshit to deal with the entire time. And I was really trying hard to hold off on it until there was a relatively good case against him.
SalvaPot
YEAH
I enjoy playing with Geno for the same reason, actually.
I’ll give you all 1 for now
Geno said:
Unlucky dude, though you were my early scum favourite, by d3 it was pretty clear to me geno was scum. If only he hadn't found out I was neutral I think we would have had him.
Despite him admitting he only gave the info because he was about to be lynched and would have preferred to keep me around, everyone seemed to weirdly think thst confirmed him as town.
SalvaPot
YEAH
He is gloating.
I'm not giving Geno shit until he's in this thread.
I don't trust remaining town to get this right.
I still can’t believe he got away with that Pinhead claim. That was one hell of a gambit, i gotta give him props for pulling that off up until now
I was toying with the idea of self voting if I got to 5 just to clear up my alignment for town, but held off when I realized that would leave town pretty much leaderless after Gorlak split, and there being a good chance Zeke was scum. (Which I feel more strongly about after that hammer) And I know Geno will continue to try to get another day.
Doesn't look great for town unless they really step up now and cut through the massive amounts of noise this game is bringing.
Which is really weird considering Stu is in the game, and he's been mostly absent and I can't tell if that's because he's scum being afk or just really not interested in this game.
Doesn't look great for town unless they really step up now and cut through the massive amounts of noise this game is bringing.
Which is really weird considering Stu is in the game, and he's been mostly absent and I can't tell if that's because he's scum being afk or just really not interested in this game.
"Yes, my role is an amalgamation of 13 different roles that fires randomly. Yes, this game also somehow balanced for that."
That should have killed him, and it's only because scum had ATP's role in their back pocket did he get out of that one. And then town collectively nodded along in agreement that a neutral was a bigger threat than scum.
I love how invested you are in town, despite your own role. :D
I tried to argue geno should have gone before I did.. but then when even gorlak seemed to think I was the right move I knew I was done. Which is why I hammered myself.
I was legit playing as trying to win with town lol.
Well until I body swapped. I was gonna take hawthorn or leo.
SalvaPot
YEAH
I know it can be frustrating, sometimes you might as well just get it over with, specially in your position. Next time you might realize there is something else you can do. Flip the script. But that can be taxing too xD.
Oh totally lol.
The amount of times I wrote out a reply then hesitated thought about how it might make me look scummy and then deleted it and said nothing lol
SalvaPot
YEAH
That is why I always just post as it goes, makes me hella scummy, but it's always out there.
LaunchpadMcQ
...can I smell you?
Based on what Puns said about Pooki before being replaced, I think Stu is role playing his character. I don’t know that he’d be so audacious about it if he were scum, but I haven’t seen him play like this on either team.
Yeah i could have handled it better. I could have really doubled down on that i already hid and thus couldn't use the body swap and was no longer a threat.
but to beat a dead horse.. i am.a newbie who didn't know whst he was doing :p
SalvaPot
YEAH
Again, you did really good! Like, I'm sure you actually made Geno sweat. Even vets have a really hard time taking down a desperate Geno.
Too bad he didn't roll Freddy Kruger if that's the case.
Policy lunch anyone that uses the word ‘amalgamation’ when describing their role from now on
Town has a veryyyyy uphill battle ahead of them.
It has to do with one of their powers, which they’ve planned accordingly to take advantage of Day 5.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
SalvaPot
YEAH
Ooh, sounds like classic Geno overplanning. That's how I got him at the end of Costume Party Mafia.
LaunchpadMcQ
...can I smell you?
As payment for doubting you, I will be playing in EZA
SalvaPot
YEAH
At that point I'm sure half of us were thinking the same thing.
Then again, you probably nailed the whole scum team on that other post.
I'm still bewildered by gorlak "breaking" does that sort of thing happen often?
SalvaPot
YEAH
To request a self-ban? First time, probably.
Usually they just ask for a replacement, join the spec chat and relax for a while.
Gorlak had some private matters come up.
Real life comes first, so let’s all wish him well.
Real life comes first, so let’s all wish him well.
Hope he's well.
I had a little concern I went too hard on him when I was trying to pinpoint a read and sucked all the fun out of it for him.
I had a little concern I went too hard on him when I was trying to pinpoint a read and sucked all the fun out of it for him.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
My final Scum Team guess is Geno, Leo, Zeke, Hawthorn. I don't see it being anyone else tbh. Leo we kind of learned about in here, and Hawthorn has seemed too aligned with Geno over the course of the game for me to give her any benefit of the doubt.
Zeke has a vote on Geno on D2, but it's a sly bus vote for sure. He voted Geno on D2 and D3, but then completely dropped it once Geno claimed and went to bat for him instead?
Now, MafiEra veterans, ask yourselves, would Town Zeke drop a tunnel on someone just because they gave a sketchy-ass claim that only gave Role Cop results on a non-Mafia player?
Zeke has a vote on Geno on D2, but it's a sly bus vote for sure. He voted Geno on D2 and D3, but then completely dropped it once Geno claimed and went to bat for him instead?
Now, MafiEra veterans, ask yourselves, would Town Zeke drop a tunnel on someone just because they gave a sketchy-ass claim that only gave Role Cop results on a non-Mafia player?
All the best to gorlak, hope things get better soon.
He was definitely someone I was leaning on those first two days.
He was definitely someone I was leaning on those first two days.
Alexem
Yeah, I'm town
First of all, best wishes to Gorlak.
Second, I can't believe they let Geno get away! Oh, wait - yes I can. If ever there was a time to turbo, the start of that last day was it - instead, the door was left wide open for scum to spread FUD.
Thirdly, this should really be setting off some alarm bells:
Second, I can't believe they let Geno get away! Oh, wait - yes I can. If ever there was a time to turbo, the start of that last day was it - instead, the door was left wide open for scum to spread FUD.
Thirdly, this should really be setting off some alarm bells:
Zeke letting somebody else drop the hammer? That's not right at all.EzekelRAGE said:
LaunchpadMcQ
...can I smell you?
I will echo support for Gorlak.
Also, I want to apologize. This is the second time I’ve interpreted a person legitimately stressed out as a gambit lol
Also, I want to apologize. This is the second time I’ve interpreted a person legitimately stressed out as a gambit lol
Sawneeks
little green dog
Hope all is well, Gorlak <3
how dare you accuse my innocent trainee. he is pure and has nothing to do with this mafia-ness going on
would this face LIE to you?
how dare you accuse my innocent trainee. he is pure and has nothing to do with this mafia-ness going on
would this face LIE to you?
Zippedpinhead
Zip it!
have we ever had a scum clean sweep of a game? I mean this is pretty crazy
SalvaPot
YEAH
I think we sweep Greed Island Mafia? Can't remember.
LaunchpadMcQ
...can I smell you?
From this season, Mario, Transistor, and I think Nier
SalvaPot
YEAH
Yeah last season scum steamrolled the games.
SalvaPot
YEAH
I take full credit for that one~
But goddamn if Geno didn't try that awesome gambit he would have won, he had me 100% fooled as Bob Ross.
LaunchpadMcQ
...can I smell you?
It was good work, though I’m not sure if we would’ve been so lucky if fowl and Chugg hadn’t tripped over themselves earlier in the game. For my part, they all had me totally fooled. :(
LaunchpadMcQ
...can I smell you?
What’s the forecast for today, Puns?
Our beloved newbie will be joining us soon
This could be a lightning round of a day phase btw lol depending on activity
I'll give you all another one:
Zeke is Mafia.
But if they don't lunch him until last, Town will lose.
Zeke is Mafia.
But if they don't lunch him until last, Town will lose.
Hi!
Well, that was fun!
Well, that was fun!
Well played pancakes. Unlucky, by the end there you were the only sane member of town left, which unfortunately led to your demise.
Sawneeks
little green dog
Alexem
Yeah, I'm town
They've got to suss him first... hoo, boy.
Lol @ Geno's first post of the day. If town keep swallowing his shit they deserve to lose.
Alexem
Yeah, I'm town
Yep, straight in with the trap. "No, he wouldn't have just tried to bus Zeke like that!"
Zeke is a Hunter variant. Starting N2, he got to choose one player to bind himself to. If Zeke ever gets lunched, that player will die.
If Zeke got NKd or day killed, his target wouldn't die. Zeke cant pick another target if his dies, too.
It's Stu lol
That was a hell of a ride!
When I received the PM from TearablePuns I was about to begin writing my opening post for the day, casting doubt about what Zeke did. lol!
So Zeke is Scum, huh? And Leo too according to what I read here?
I'm sure the remaining two are Geno and Hawthorn.
When I received the PM from TearablePuns I was about to begin writing my opening post for the day, casting doubt about what Zeke did. lol!
So Zeke is Scum, huh? And Leo too according to what I read here?
I'm sure the remaining two are Geno and Hawthorn.
Oh! And sorry @AllThingsPurple, couldn't save you :p
Glad you had fun. You did really good, you had great intuition with your reads. The hardest part of Mafia is getting other people to vote with you.
Even veteran players struggle in that department.
^^ truth
jman interpreted his role incorrectly and told malus that he was forever redirected to him... but he isn't.
So I told him, since the wording could be misconstrued in the PM, that it was only for that night but he never mentioned it in the thread.
So, malus never used his last track command :( Then again, since Zeke carried out the kill, it would've probably been bad for Town to see that givien the circumstances.
So I told him, since the wording could be misconstrued in the PM, that it was only for that night but he never mentioned it in the thread.
So, malus never used his last track command :( Then again, since Zeke carried out the kill, it would've probably been bad for Town to see that givien the circumstances.
LaunchpadMcQ
...can I smell you?
You played really well. Really well done. I'd guess they skipped over Ambulance and killed you instead because you were getting too close. lol
lmaoooo
LaunchpadMcQ
...can I smell you?
Has scum realized they win if Zeke gets lynched?
Slip on purpose to get himself launched so stu dies?