What's lame? You in the lead of the votes or the fact that you're one of the two that we must vote on?
Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This
- Thread starter Sorian
- Start date
What's lame? You in the lead of the votes or the fact that you're one of the two that we must vote on?
melonrabbit
The only good kind of melon
Please be excited.
melonrabbit
The only good kind of melon
You don't have a strong read on much, given this is your second post in the entire thread.
melonrabbit
The only good kind of melon
Considering this is your second post, do you have a read on much? Any gut feels? Or any thoughts about how things have been recently before the event started?
LuxCommander
Bro.
...
This seems dirty. I don't like it one bit. Need to sleep on it, give the situation some though. Will spare the club until morning.
This seems dirty. I don't like it one bit. Need to sleep on it, give the situation some though. Will spare the club until morning.
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
She's relaxed, involved, unafraid. It's still only gut level but she's the strongest town read I've got so far.
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
No clue but your vote is being counted now.
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
This ends in 5 hours, y'know...
melonrabbit
The only good kind of melon
Trigger pulled the trigger and left.
Hmm.
Vote: No Lynch
Haha, perfect image for the situation.
That said, I do find it kinda funny after all the no lynch discussion that an event started where we must vote between two people and no lynch is currently in the lead.
furthermore, discussing how splinter defused this, or at least attempted to - dunno what will happen between now and the deadline - is fodder. the votes that were cast is fodder. Splinter and melon townreading each other enough to refused to lynch (potentially) tells us something.
i'm too sleepy to argue this. good luck and godspeed, you two. i'll miss the deadline.
i'm too sleepy to argue this. good luck and godspeed, you two. i'll miss the deadline.
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
I don't expect I'll get an answer to this, and I need to go to work soon.
There's no way this was a town aligned power. If you were town and had this ability, who would you target?
Not melon and I, not then.
So who did it? I would blame Faddy, but he was almost certainly asleep.
There's been a few posts this game linking me with melon. They seemed silly at the time but a lot more sinister now. I don't remember who it was though
It may not even be a power and is just something cooked up by Sorian. If he doesn't say anything then it's just a guessing game about if it's a power or not.
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
Me/melon is too much of a coincidence to be rng, and Sorian wouldn't hand pick a thunderdome.
I assume it's a mechanic, and we'll see more thunder dome situations. Just my gut. I don't imagine a player just deciding to use their power randomly on Day 1.
I'm still not sure if I fully understand what happened in the earlier event, but I don't think Verelios comes off as scummy. Beyond that, much of the discussion hasn't left an impression on me yet. Sorting through the fluff and meaningful interactions has been a little overwhelming.
I'm still not sure if I fully understand what happened in the earlier event, but I don't think Verelios comes off as scummy. Beyond that, much of the discussion hasn't left an impression on me yet. Sorting through the fluff and meaningful interactions has been a little overwhelming.
Alexem
Yeah, I'm town
Someone's running Bartertown on D1? Madness, sheer madness. Can't say that I'm sold on the prospect of either candidate, in all honesty, so I'll hold off my vote for the moment. If I had to vote this very second, though, I'd probably lean a little more towards Splinter, but that's purely based on Melon's activity so far. It's not something I have much conviction for.
@Geno - I appreciate your point about lynching for more information on D1, but this event isn't the be-all and end-all for today. If the consensus is that neither of the candidates are worth lynching at this point, we still have the normal lynch for the rest of the day. Personally, I wouldn't say that a no lynch is quite such a bad idea in this situation.
@Geno - I appreciate your point about lynching for more information on D1, but this event isn't the be-all and end-all for today. If the consensus is that neither of the candidates are worth lynching at this point, we still have the normal lynch for the rest of the day. Personally, I wouldn't say that a no lynch is quite such a bad idea in this situation.
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
Gotta be honest, these melon votes are a bit weird
The votes for me at least have reasons, mostly that melon is more active. If I was a third party and felt forced to choose (ignoring no lynch), that's probably what I'd do too.
Yet we have no less than 5 unreasoned voted for melon. I'd wager that at least some of these are scum trying to split themselves between the two options.
There's more than I'd expect, and none of them give a reason. (I left out Gorlak who did give a reason, though none of these people commented on it.)
The votes for me at least have reasons, mostly that melon is more active. If I was a third party and felt forced to choose (ignoring no lynch), that's probably what I'd do too.
Yet we have no less than 5 unreasoned voted for melon. I'd wager that at least some of these are scum trying to split themselves between the two options.
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
OTOH, these are bad reasons for voting:
It's a common rookie mistake, to be fair.
I'm not sure I'm interpreting this one right, but Zubz seems concerned with melon's motives, yet votes me?
Trusting melon because she defended you? Does she have reason to defend you so early?
It's a common rookie mistake, to be fair.
I actually agree here apart from hom3land. I read their vote as "I want to put down a vote now and will think about it properly later before the end of the event" aka random nothingness considering the whole "Until then. Because her name was first and M comes before S"
But the rest I fully agree on and that it's weird.
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
What is this? WHAT EVEN IS THIS?!?
NO LYNCHS?!?
bah! COWARDS!!
NO LYNCHS?!?
bah! COWARDS!!
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
And what even i
And what even is this?
'I dont feel one way or the other, so let me very specifically lean one particular way."
ADMIT YOUR BLOODLUST OR STAND FIRM IN YOUR PARTISANSHIP.
INCONSISTANCY ONLY BEINGS SHAME UPON YOURSELF AND CONFUSION TO ALL WHO WOULD SEEK TO JUSDGE YOU
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
NIN.
Enetertain me.
Explain your votes on melon.
Also whos up for lynching Nomad as soon as we get our lynch back in the hands of the public?
Be honest, would anyone actually regret it etger way?
Enetertain me.
Explain your votes on melon.
Also whos up for lynching Nomad as soon as we get our lynch back in the hands of the public?
Be honest, would anyone actually regret it etger way?
nin1000
Chilean German Madman
nin1000
Chilean German Madman
To be honest it just sucks either way since i consider em both strong players if they decide to play.
Melon was strong and Splinter has seen how strong she is, thats why he has ulped his game ( even thought his one liners can get a bit boring).
My vote still sits on melon because i threw a coin.
The coin has spoken.
Swamped
Dazzling Mafia Queen
You made it seem like there were a ton of votes on Ferg but in reality there was only one, from Terra.
---
Don't like this thunderdome situation. I'm town reading both. It seems neither Splinter nor Melon chose this thunderdome. So another player probably did. But if town-aligned, why choose those too? For meta reasons? I would choose players that were more universally scum read. Only people who know the community would thunderdome those two players (because you would have to be familiar with their rivalry from previous games), and someone with that level of mafia experience wouldn't pick these two given how they've been playing this particular game.
So basically, I'm speculating that this is a scum power, and they chose two townies. But then, why two fairly vocal players? I'd have chosen two silent townies. But this way they get rid of a loud voice I suppose?
I'm inclined to no lynch as well.
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
Ahh
. Innocence by means of insanity. I path i know all to well.
Swamped
Dazzling Mafia Queen
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
The drink. She sings to me.
But her somgs do nothing against winters serrated chill.
But her somgs do nothing against winters serrated chill.
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
It's because Kawl knows I'm on to him.
Melon is one of the few players who would likely beat me in a thunderdome at this stage, and has the added benefit of our existing rivalry acting as a smokescreen.
It all fits, but I see you Kawlo. Conspicuous by your absence.
Swamped
Dazzling Mafia Queen
No Lynch is also an option...
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
It's summer Stan geez how much did you drink
melonrabbit
The only good kind of melon
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
Do we get our rehular day 1 lynch back? I thought this just was our d1 lynch now
Caught up with everything that has gone down and honestly, I agree that this situation feels like town vs town.
Vote: No Lynch
Vote: No Lynch
Based on the way the event post is worded, yes we do. Votes get reset after the event is over though so we'll need to vote again.
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
I was at cousins 21st surrounded by family i do not care for. Im fuckin rat arsed m8
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
3 fookin degrees
Kyanrute
kyan-rute
No murdererererings is of BORINGZ >:(
melonrabbit
The only good kind of melon
Thank you for defending my honor, @StanleyPalmtree. You're a true prince.
melonrabbit
The only good kind of melon
You still get to lynch someone once the thunderdome concludes.
Kyanrute
kyan-rute
As for melon and Splints, I know that I don't have enough info to be being all protect-y about either of the two (apart from the reasons already mentioned). Nothing to me about them speaks SUPER DUBER ULTIMATE TOWN so death it is. For info or something. What info, dunno. Possible info. Very abstract info that might not be info at all.
Kyanrute
kyan-rute
But two for the price of one! Great savings!
unless two are town in which case scum gets two for the price of one :(
Kyanrute
kyan-rute
Hmm. True! Peace and love it is! Enter the hugbox now! No more murders!
we have a plenty of spares / imma gonna be the arrogant voice this game yaaaay finally found my thing yaaaay
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
i mean thanks but i feel like im doing a terrible job.
Care to explain why
melonrabbit
The only good kind of melon
That's not the argument here. No one is saying no murders ever.
Quit being dense. Giving scum the potential to take out two town players isn't optimal play and you know it.
melonrabbit
The only good kind of melon
You could always switch to no lynch and shoot my slanderers tomorrow.
Kyanrute
kyan-rute
I already mentioned that I am not reading either of you as town. As for the #realcandidate, I don't personally plan to vote for a townie.
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
Also for the question of "Is this our Day 1 lynch or do we get the normal lynch" thing from earlier, here is the section that talks about that in the post :)
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
Oh damn thank. Id have flown right past it
Alexem
Yeah, I'm town
Given that the option's getting more traction, I'm going for
VOTE: No lynch
My gut feeling is that this is either a trap, a total stab in the dark, or someone's been forced to initiate a D1 thunderdome on pain of modkill. None of those are good enough reason for me to vote for Melon or Splinter at this point.
VOTE: No lynch
My gut feeling is that this is either a trap, a total stab in the dark, or someone's been forced to initiate a D1 thunderdome on pain of modkill. None of those are good enough reason for me to vote for Melon or Splinter at this point.
For cause, I think I remember Sorian said that some stuff in this game would be callbacks/community references and I could see this falling under that maybe. But otherwise I'd say it's caused by some neutral/maf role probably. Town role maybe, but I feel like it should've been used a lot better if it was.
Mazre
Traitor of Humanity
This is fun to wake up to.
VOTE: No Lynch
This seems a perfectly acceptable no lynch situation to me. We don't know if this is player or gm initiated. If player and scum, we don't want to lynch. If player and town, we probably don't want to lynch. If gm, who knows, the odds are still bad. At least there will be something to discuss the remainder of the day, which I will be mostly at work for, see you all in 10-11 hours.
VOTE: No Lynch
This seems a perfectly acceptable no lynch situation to me. We don't know if this is player or gm initiated. If player and scum, we don't want to lynch. If player and town, we probably don't want to lynch. If gm, who knows, the odds are still bad. At least there will be something to discuss the remainder of the day, which I will be mostly at work for, see you all in 10-11 hours.
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
*sigh*
fiiiiiiiiine, ill go along with your little compasions and patience's and not rushing to murder someone for little to no reason's
VOTE: No Lynch
fiiiiiiiiine, ill go along with your little compasions and patience's and not rushing to murder someone for little to no reason's
VOTE: No Lynch
Really? Why would scum put themselves in the spotlight day 1 for no reason and risk getting lynched?
we've had such a role in a previous game. Scum had to do it (until d/n3(?)) or be modkilled. So unlike what you're trying to say - it is very much possible for one of them to be scum.
That was a thing? Use X by a certain day or be killed? O.o
Zippedpinhead
Zip it!
What kind of insanity did I wake up to?
You are trying to add a super obscure role that's borderline bastard to a situation that's almost 99% not that. I will give you 1% though in case that role actually exists here.
Zippedpinhead
Zip it!
Almost every time something like this has happened in a game I played in, it was town V Town.
Except I think that one time like what gorlak said.
Except I think that one time like what gorlak said.
Yeah, nah I don't see anything that makes me reconsider.
I'm a vegetarian and these are both meatlovers.
Zippedpinhead
Zip it!
Eh
vote: no lynch
I don’t want either of you to die yet
vote: no lynch
I don’t want either of you to die yet
Someone, possibly our benevolent despot, has made an ultimatum.
I’m interested to see how the story of the two gladiators who throw down their weapons ends.
Alexem
Yeah, I'm town
Yep, it was a scum role in Brexit mafia. One before my time, but I remember reading it well.
BREEEEXIIIIIT!
She may have an item or something. She outed herself as Namor when I stated I personally want to kill Namor, & called me a cold-footed hypocrite for contemplating sitting this vote out. I feel she wants me to vote her out & I don’t know why.
That said, I don’t want to vote either of you out, but don’t want to have a No Kill staining my record, so I abstain.
Unvote: Splinter
nin1000
Chilean German Madman
We don’t know if this is Hero vs. Hero or not. At least we know someone is a Thanos goon out of everyone.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
We aren't finding out by no lynching
Stantastic
Our Badminton Stanpion
this is like a pineapple pizza (lynching melon) and one of those pizzas thats just basically only cheese, which isnt bad but not right now thanks (lynching Splinter).
