Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
My only hesitation is if Grizzly's claim is correct, it's a nearly data-free lynch, but I have a feeling tomorrow is gonna be wild, so I'm willing to take it.
 
Wait, wait @Grizzly you're an executioner and have to look for what? A certain person? Flavour? Fluff killings? In a game in which Sorian especially ruled out such a mechanic? What are you doing?

This claim makes no sense, unless you have to get a player lynched?

If Grizzly wanted to be lynched he wouldn't even need to claim anything as he was on his way to be lynched anyway. I'm puzzled.
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Can we just vote kawl just for causing all this confusing?

All my theories about vere and splinter are back on
LOL.

Either way, kawl gives us the most answers. Him doing this at the end of the day doesn't help town AT ALL.
oh boo hoo things happened and for an hour we got to see some reactions about shit instead of just blindly all voting for sad ass bear to get lynched.
 
Wow Grizzly is tanner/miller now? @Grizzly are you not of the mind that miller should be claimed early? I probably don't have the time to look, but I swore that was a general unspoken policy here like it is in a few other circles I've played mafia. Nothing I recall from you even remotely hinted at such a claim.

possibly
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Wait, wait @Grizzly you're an executioner and have to look for what? A certain person? Flavour? Fluff killings? In a game in which Sorian especially ruled out such a mechanic? What are you doing?

This claim makes no sense, unless you have to get a player lynched?

If Grizzly wanted to be lynched he wouldn't even need to claim anything as he was on his way to be lynched anyway. I'm puzzled.

I was given a specific player to go for. Think of how it works in Town of Salem, basically.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Well I was going through and quoting shit, but so much has happened since I last checked in that half of what I was going to respond to is old news at this point. Instead I’ll just do it off the dome:

Grizzly - What the fuck at most of his posts recently. Claim is meh, claiming neutral means it’s at least a 50/50 shot he’s scum.

Kawl - Interesting gambit, but I need more time to examine what all those that either rushed to defend you or lynch you were pushing. May have revealed some interesting tidbits.
 

Hecht

Like dubstep for my bootyhole
oh boo hoo things happened and for an hour we got to see some reactions about shit instead of just blindly all voting for sad ass bear to get lynched.
for the record, i knew it wasn't you

no one would ever give splinter that satisfaction willingly
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
==== DAY 1.8 VOTES ====
Day Start
grizzly (13 votes)
faddy - #1390
gorlak - #1399 #1523
coolestspot - #1402
natiko - #1409
stuart444 - #1417
empressdonna - #1424
nin1000 - #1431
verelios - #1474
heymonkey - #1506
ynnek7 - #1509
geno - #1513
hecht - #1515
faircure - #1586
apollo - #1589
rynam (5 votes)
terraforce - #1044 #1482
poltergust - #1166
stuart444 - #1174 #1417
alexem - #1206
empressdonna - #1294 #1424
muffin - #1307
luxcommander - #1334
hom3land - #1445
verelios (4 votes)
geno - #1001 #1513
xbro - #1050
kyanrute - #1128
grizzly - #1185
luxcommander - #1193 #1334
ezekelrage - #1337 #1484
zippedpinhead - #1364
kawl (3 votes)
gorlak - #1264 #1399
splinter - #1278
ezekelrage - #1484
mazre - #1522
geno (2 votes)
faddy - #1013 #1390
include - #1167
verelios - #1183 #1474
terraforce - #1482
zippedpinhead (2 votes)
natiko - #1038 #1132
bladesymphony - #1043
nzjubjub - #1169
natiko - #1268 #1409
faircure - #1315 #1586
blargonaut (0 votes)
melonrabbit - #1039 #1175
apollo (0 votes)
natiko - #1132 #1268
natiko (0 votes)
hecht - #1073 #1515
gorlak - #1241 #1264
stuart444 (0 votes)
nin1000 - #1359 #1431
gorlak (0 votes)
heymonkey - #1051 #1506
terraforce (0 votes)
faddy - #1004 #1013
ryanm (0 votes)
hom3land - #1321 #1437
Post Counts:
stuart444: 60 grizzly: 52 heymonkey: 41 geno: 40 faddy: 34 coolestspot: 33 gorlak: 28 verelios: 28 kyanrute: 26 hecht: 26 splinter: 24 terraforce: 21 natiko: 19 muffin: 15 melonrabbit: 15 ezekelrage: 13 poltergust: 12 alexem: 12 sawneeks: 11 nin1000: 10 kawl: 10 sorian: 9 dcpat: 9 include: 7 crimsonfist: 7 hom3land: 6 zippedpinhead: 4 faircure: 4 nzjubjub: 4 empressdonna: 4 nomad sparkster: 3 bladesymphony: 3 ynnek7: 3 luxcommander: 3 xbro: 3 mazre: 3 ferg: 2 apollo: 2 necktochicken: 2 fireblend: 1 extreme tactician: 1
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 

Apollo

Apollo will wreck your goddamn face
Wait, wait @Grizzly you're an executioner and have to look for what? A certain person? Flavour? Fluff killings? In a game in which Sorian especially ruled out such a mechanic? What are you doing?

This claim makes no sense, unless you have to get a player lynched?

If Grizzly wanted to be lynched he wouldn't even need to claim anything as he was on his way to be lynched anyway. I'm puzzled.

In Cthulhu mafia, i had basically this role, idk how the mechanics are here but there I had a night action to find the player (I was given flavor) I was supposed to lynch.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Generally agree and it's total WIFOM, but really hate that sentiment of "Must be town, scum would never do _______ "
Yeah, scum does all sorts of crazy shit. Next someone will say scum wouldn't stomping his feet like Kawl right now, 'cause scum is agreeable, blah blah blah blah

meh, says I

He claimed it...……..then just a few moments said he didn't do it. So just messing around it seems. Wasting time/discussion. Not very townie.
It is at that but I don't think it's the biggest risk to the game right now.
 
@Geno @Terraforce @CoolestSpot

You are not allowed to quote from previous games (or anything other than this game actually?). Just a fair warning.

It looks like you have your own little shenanigans ongoing. I don't know how to feel about you two ganging up on Geno just now. Geno did exactly this lurking in Berserk the day he go lynched after you were already dead Terra, especially around day end. You two know he's a hothead and push him right now, but why. Do you need him to be lynched today?


I backed off and said I'm not lynching him. Me and geno go back to the start and every and since, so more at play then you ever know. And we can reference past games just not quite them
 
there's no way he goes all out in the way he was posting about it if he knew he was wrong, can't believe that.
go look at this one mini mafia, I can't remember which one 1.1 maybe. people talking about "if splinter is scum he deserves the win", he starts posting pics of getting an erection and other self-celebrating things - and yes he was scum and won the game later
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
I assume I was given the specific name from the start to make it slightly easier for me, seeking for a player from pool of 50 would be a pain.
 

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
go look at this one mini mafia, I can't remember which one 1.1 maybe. people talking about "if splinter is scum he deserves the win", he starts posting pics of getting an erection and other self-celebrating things - and yes he was scum and won the game later
eh thats different, gloating in people saying you are playing like a stud and gloating about an absolutely stupid guess on whats happening being 'right' aren't even in the same realm
 
Well you have just under 20 minutes to post your target and make a case for them I guess. Up to you if you want to do that or just wait and see if it's posted with your role pm.
 
He claimed it...……..then just a few moments said he didn't do it. So just messing around it seems. Wasting time/discussion. Not very townie.

Yeah posts are flying in so I was still backed up a bit. He's definitely on the chopping block, but part of me wonders if we could get more info from another lynch now that cat's out of the bag.
 

Hecht

Like dubstep for my bootyhole
Roles have nothing to do with powers in this game.

That's why him saying that he needs to get a player and not a role lynched also makes his claim more believable.
i'm picking random names and hoping one of them is marvel
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
I guess I have nothing to lose with revealing.

My target is Stuart - I went after him earlier in the day since I figured that my best shot is at early days, before all the ITAs and whatever else there might start colliding.
 

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
That seems too easy, start of day 2 you claim a red check on them, free win.
It's the only possibility. I asked Sorian at the start of the thread remember? There are no PR that have to search for specific roles in this game. Doing this by player name is the only option for such a role.
 
In Cthulhu mafia, i had basically this role, idk how the mechanics are here but there I had a night action to find the player (I was given flavor) I was supposed to lynch.
yeah, I remember the infamous blarg hunt, it was the thing that got me into this community!! @Blargonaut <3

but Sorian said Flavour is NOTHING in this game.
And Grizzly just said he got a specific player, so there's that.
 

Mazre

Traitor of Humanity
That seems too easy, start of day 2 you claim a red check on them, free win.

Well to be fair, in this game that would most likely just get the person hit with multiple ITAs, which would then make him a survivor, and be awkward if his target wasn't scum.
 

Splinter

Lord of Volcano Island
go look at this one mini mafia, I can't remember which one 1.1 maybe. people talking about "if splinter is scum he deserves the win", he starts posting pics of getting an erection and other self-celebrating things - and yes he was scum and won the game later
Wow Gor, way to make it sound way worse than it was.
 
I guess I have nothing to lose with revealing.

My target is Stuart - I went after him earlier in the day since I figured that my best shot is at early days, before all the ITAs and whatever else there might start colliding.

I...

I have been thinking since you claimed that it was me.

Guess I was right XD
 

Hecht

Like dubstep for my bootyhole
ok, so if grizz is telling the truth, after we lynch him, i'm comfortable giving Stuart "as close to confirmed as possible" townie status.

Still gotta kill the bear though
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I guess I have nothing to lose with revealing.

My target is Stuart - I went after him earlier in the day since I figured that my best shot is at early days, before all the ITAs and whatever else there might start colliding.
I dunno if I believe you but if you're telling the truth, I'm gonna relax on my luxurious divan labeled "I was right about that bullshit."
 
Vote: Grizzly
So is the game pitched against scum (get scum lynched) or is the neutral here to help scum (get town lynched) or is Stuart neutral? :o
 
ok, so if grizz is telling the truth, after we lynch him, i'm comfortable giving Stuart "as close to confirmed as possible" townie status.

Still gotta kill the bear though
Potentially, but this wouldn't be the first time I've seen that type of role target scum either, since it's often randomized.
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
I don't know what Stuart's alignment is. Although his post "I thought it was me" is interesting response.
 
Potentially, but this wouldn't be the first time I've seen that type of role target scum either, since it's often randomized.

Yeah, I'm gonna say while this doesn't clear me (I am town), if we assume targets for roles like that are randomized, we can't assume the target is town or scum. Could even be a second neutral considering the size of the game, who knows. All it would tell us is that he is a neutral and he wants me lynched.
 

CrimsonFist

Neutral Vanilla
Potentially, but this wouldn't be the first time I've seen that type of role target scum either, since it's often randomized.

Since it's specifically a lynch, if the target was scum it would make Grizzly an extra cop, entirely pro town. Neutrals that have to night kill a target could go after town or scum, in this case, Stuart being town or neutral makes more sense.
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
84bd02cbaa164966aedf171e1f1a7183.jpg
 
Stuart isn't even close to confirmed town. Executioner can just as likely have a scum target. With near like 15 scum in the game I don't see why not.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Back for day end
Since it's specifically a lynch, if the target was scum it would make Grizzly an extra cop, entirely pro town. Neutrals that have to night kill a target could go after town or scum, in this case, Stuart being town or neutral makes more sense.
Why would that be exactly? I didn't really follow your logic here.
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Stuart isn't even close to confirmed town. Executioner can just as likely have a scum target. With near like 15 scum in the game I don't see why not.

Will you lynch Stuart with me Geno <3. Pretty please, I don't want to get another lost game to my repertoire.
 
Well, now that that info is out, might as well keep the vote on Grizzly for stability's sake. I don't want any last-minute surprises for Day 1.

Vote: Grizzly
 
Since it's specifically a lynch, if the target was scum it would make Grizzly an extra cop, entirely pro town. Neutrals that have to night kill a target could go after town or scum, in this case, Stuart being town or neutral makes more sense.
That's assuming we don't lynch the neutral first and assume we know the target's alignment...as we are doing now. I'm not saying it's likely because if I had to put money down I'd definitely bet on Stu being town in this scenario. But it's not something we should just take as a given either.

"Lynching" is exactly what I've seen this worded targeting scum (in fact in one game it was stated if they died by anything other than a lynch the role loses), as I said before, so that definitely does not negate the possibility.
 

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
Back for day end

Why would that be exactly? I didn't really follow your logic here.
A neutral who needs to NK somebody specific can still miss and accidentally kill town. Crimsons logic checks out there.

With that, Stuart doesn't seem like a good lynch.

VOTE: Grizzly
 
Since it's specifically a lynch, if the target was scum it would make Grizzly an extra cop, entirely pro town. Neutrals that have to night kill a target could go after town or scum, in this case, Stuart being town or neutral makes more sense.
Except Grizzly doesn't know what his target is so this isn't true.
 

CrimsonFist

Neutral Vanilla
Back for day end

Why would that be exactly? I didn't really follow your logic here.

The optimum play for his role would be to claim a red check on Stuart, free lynch (ITA's aside, so would need to be near the end of day) then win.

Scum lynch for town, win for him, nice and easy, everyone benefits except scum.
 

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
A neutral who needs to NK somebody specific can still miss and accidentally kill town. Crimsons logic checks out there.

With that, Stuart doesn't seem like a good lynch.

VOTE: Grizzly
Specific in this case would of course not be a player name, but something relating to flavor like a role name.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
The optimum play for his role would be to claim a red check on Stuart, free lynch (ITA's aside, so would need to be near the end of day) then win.

Scum lynch for town, win for him, nice and easy, everyone benefits except scum.
I guess that makes sense. Wouldn't it not matter either way though, since his win depends on the lynch?
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Oh wow, I thought this day ended in an hour from now.

Did Grizzly ever actually vote Stuart?

he did but his pushes were never getting Stuart close to lynched. So I'm not sure if I believe what Grizzly is saying.
 

CrimsonFist

Neutral Vanilla
I guess that makes sense. Wouldn't it not matter either way though, since his win depends on the lynch?

Claiming a red check on town can end up being a lot more disruptive, even if the target should usually end up lynched. Not really much scum can do against one.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Final vote count

==== DAY 1.8 VOTES ====
Day Start - Day End
grizzly (16 votes)
faddy - #1390
gorlak - #1399 #1523
coolestspot - #1402
natiko - #1409
stuart444 - #1417
empressdonna - #1424
nin1000 - #1431
verelios - #1474
heymonkey - #1506
ynnek7 - #1509
geno - #1513
hecht - #1515
faircure - #1586
apollo - #1589
gorlak - #1644
poltergust - #1656
muffin - #1661
verelios (4 votes)
geno - #1001 #1513
xbro - #1050
kyanrute - #1128
grizzly - #1185 #1647
luxcommander - #1193 #1334
ezekelrage - #1337 #1484
zippedpinhead - #1364
kawl - #1616
kawl (3 votes)
gorlak - #1264 #1399
splinter - #1278
ezekelrage - #1484
mazre - #1522
rynam (3 votes)
terraforce - #1044 #1482
poltergust - #1166 #1656
stuart444 - #1174 #1417
alexem - #1206
empressdonna - #1294 #1424
muffin - #1307 #1661
luxcommander - #1334
hom3land - #1445
geno (2 votes)
faddy - #1013 #1390
include - #1167
verelios - #1183 #1474
terraforce - #1482
zippedpinhead (2 votes)
natiko - #1038 #1132
bladesymphony - #1043
nzjubjub - #1169
natiko - #1268 #1409
faircure - #1315 #1586
stuart444 (1 votes)
nin1000 - #1359 #1431
grizzly - #1647
blargonaut (0 votes)
melonrabbit - #1039 #1175
apollo (0 votes)
natiko - #1132 #1268
natiko (0 votes)
hecht - #1073 #1515
gorlak - #1241 #1264
gorlak (0 votes)
heymonkey - #1051 #1506
terraforce (0 votes)
faddy - #1004 #1013
ryanm (0 votes)
hom3land - #1321 #1437
Post Counts:
stuart444: 64 grizzly: 63 heymonkey: 48 geno: 45 coolestspot: 35 faddy: 35 verelios: 33 hecht: 32 gorlak: 31 splinter: 26 kyanrute: 26 terraforce: 26 muffin: 20 natiko: 19 melonrabbit: 15 poltergust: 13 ezekelrage: 13 kawl: 13 crimsonfist: 12 alexem: 12 sawneeks: 11 sorian: 11 nin1000: 10 dcpat: 10 include: 7 hom3land: 7 mazre: 5 apollo: 4 zippedpinhead: 4 xbro: 4 faircure: 4 nzjubjub: 4 empressdonna: 4 bladesymphony: 3 nomad sparkster: 3 ynnek7: 3 luxcommander: 3 ferg: 2 necktochicken: 2 fireblend: 1 extreme tactician: 1
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Back in his throne room, Thanos pounded his fist on the arm of his chair.

“If they won’t begin the killing, then I will. They don’t seem to understand the situation they’ve found themselves in.”

As the heroes fought against one another, it was clear that they were holding back. Trying to injure and incapacitate instead of kill. The one taking the biggest beating among them all was War Machine. Unable to keep up without Tony’s new tech, even the weakest among them were able to land pot shots. Just as his consciousness was about to fade, a shockwave blew everyone away from his body.

As the dust cleared a giant shadow loomed over the hunched figure of War Machine. Thanos slowly picked up Rhodes by the skull and swiftly slammed his spine down over his knee. With no effort he tossed the body down into the void.

“No more games or I’ll kill all of you”

Grizzly has died!

Welcome Grizzly,

You are War Machine. True Identity Jim Rhodes.

Your role is Mafia Roleblocker. You may use the command BLOCK:<playername> once per night phase. Your target will be unable to execute any actions during the current night phase. In addition to being a roleblocker, you also function as a Godfather and will appear as “Town” in any alignment investigations.

You may also use the command KILL:<playername> once per night to execute the mafia factional kill. Your target will be killed assuming they have no form of protection. You may use both your individual ability and the factional ability in the same night, if applicable.

You win when the mafia team outnumbers all other players.

All night actions are due to me ONE HOUR before the night ends. PM them to me through OM NOT resetera.

Night 1 Ends in:
pur_1530226800.png
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Gamora wanted silence.

Most of the other heroes were reeling from the loss of the War Machine. Some felt betrayed that he had been working against them. Others were shocked and saddened by the loss of a friend. Gamora had no such bond with the man, but their pain was plain to see. And it hadn’t taken long for that pain to turn into hypocrisy.

“Thanos was the one who killed him!”

An increasingly common sentiment among the group. And an increasingly disgusting one to Gamora. Make no mistake, there was little love lost between Gamora and her father. But Thanos had merely pulled the trigger. The ones who'd put Rhodes in his weakened state? That was all them. And yet the justifications continued to pile on.

And so Gamora wanted silence.

Sadly, the absurdly large number of heroes present made silence quite unlikely. And so it was that Gamora turned to her last resort: a so-called “mixtape” lent to her by Quill. And so it was that, lost in the music, she wandered away from the group. And so it was that she ended up somewhere she should not have been, distracted by music that she should not have been listening to. Had it not been for the music, she might have noticed a set of voices. Familiar voices.

But not even the music could dull the sensation of a blade finding its mark. Struggling to keep herself standing, Gamora turned to face her assailant.

“What… the hell?”

“Close. I think you mean…. What the Hecht?”

And so Gamora had at last achieved the silence she had so longed for.


Hecht has died


Meanwhile, Cable knew that the best way to fix this situation was to prevent it from happening. He had noticed that Thor and Spider-Man still appeared to be in their right minds and the extra help would be appreciated. Together, the three of them traveled back days before the cosmic cube had been completed. Their plan was to stop Richards by any means necessary.

Unfortunately, a special surprise was waiting for them outside of the lab. Thanos had sensed the change coming in the timeline and using the power of the cube, he was able to pull and control other versions of Thor, Spider-Man, and Cable from alternate timelines to meet them outside of the lab.

“Hey! You shouldn’t be here!”


In the next room, Reed heard the muffled fighting and shouts of pain but the mind control was already total and absolute. No one would be coming to save the heroes and no one would stop the cube from being completed.

CrimsonFist, empressdona, and Faddy have died

Welcome empressdonna,

You are Spider-Man. True Identity Miles Morales.

Your role is Town Vanilla. You do not have any abilities but you may still vote and participate in ITA sessions.

You win when all threats to town are eliminated.

Welcome CrimsonFist,

You are Cable. True Identity Nathan Summers.

Your role is Town Mad Scientist. Each night phase, you may send an item to another player using the command SEND: <itemname>: <playername>. These items are all amazing in your hands but you have no way of knowing how the receiving player will use them. Though you do not know what any of these items do, the receiving player will receive any applicable information on what the item does once they receive it. Each item can only be sent once.

The items are: Techno-Organic Body Armor, Belle A.I. Program, Cybernetic Eye, Psi-Mitar, Forge Enhanced Brace

You win when all threats to town are eliminated.

Welcome Faddy,

You are Thor. True Identity Thor Odinson.

Your role is Town 4-shot Gunsmith. Each night you may use the command GIVE: <playername> to imbue the player with a killing ability. The player may use their kill during the day or night phase. When shot, the gun has a 50% chance to reveal the shooter.

You win when all threats to town are eliminated.

Welcome Hecht,

You are Gamora. True Identity Gamora Zen Whoberi Ben Titan.

Your role is Town ITA Booster. During the night phase, you may use the command BOOST: <playername> to change another player’s base chance to hit during an ITA to 100%. You may not self-target or target the same player on consecutive nights.

You win when all threats to town are eliminated.

ITAs will begin today

Every player will have one public command shot that they can make throughout the course of today. These shots can only be done during designated times. Below are three counters to the designated times. Please note that these counters are rough estimates but the ITA phase will begin within an hour of the timers ending. Once a phase begins, it will last for a half hour. During which time anyone may take a shot as long as they have not already tried shooting once today.

First ITA:
pur_1530266400.png



Second ITA:
pur_1530309600.png



Third ITA:
pur_1530374400.png



Day 2 Ends In:
pur_1530399600.png



DAY 2 BEGINS
 
Okay so first off:

Mafia Roleblocker + Godfather. good win for us

4 Town deaths: Bad for us ;_;

ITAs soon, Won't be around for the first one probably but will be for the second at least. :D
 

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
That was a good first lynch. Mafia straight from the bat.

Four kills last night, yikes. Wonder if Hecht and the other three being mentioned seperately means anything.
 
That was a good first lynch. Mafia straight from the bat.

Four kills last night, yikes. Wonder if Hecht and the other three being mentioned seperately means anything.

Speculation but I'm thinking the first one was the NK, the rest were through another method of killing.

No way to know for sure though but it's my only guess.
 

Splinter

Lord of Volcano Island
Ouch

I guess multiple deaths shouldn't be too surprising in a 50 player game. That's quite a rough night though.
 
Some of those kills seem kind of random? But four of them, that's interesting.

Thing that stuck out to me most from last phase was Grizzly's claim. Like I really don't understand why that specific claim and if he was just trolling or if there was some motive there.
 

nin1000

Chilean German Madman
Yay.
Lynching the Godfather right of the bat was a good thing to see. ( did not expect that thought)
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
holy shit, that's a loss. Wonder why Donna and Crimson were picked though as they weren't super active....

also let's try this again so

hi everyone
 
Top Bottom