Heh heh. When he thought you were scum. Good times, good times.
Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This
- Thread starter Sorian
- Start date
Heh heh. When he thought you were scum. Good times, good times.
How can you know how much lurking I have done? Are you in my room? I don't see you.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
Sawneeks
little green dog
Because I see little reason to claim this as scum on Day 1. Kawl is a smart guy and knows how flimsy our lynches are on D1 so I find it unlikely he'd do this as a scum player. Not to mention it causes way more havok by staying quiet and just thunderdome people every phase.
To answer splinter I have little to say there. Kinda feel like it falls into mixing with irl reasons given kawl says he has been busy. I can see a reasoning behind melon as it gets hard stances on her but I'll admit that reasoning is flimsy as fuck and I'm not a fan of it.
Still feel town esque, but would be willing to admit maybe a neutral right now.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
Ynnek7
OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
This is probably the last chance I'll have to post before day end since I'm going to be on the road, so:
Vote: Grizzly
I don't really have much of an opinion other than this train seemed to come out of nowhere in the past hour, but with how close the other two options are, I'd rather help avoid a tie.
I'm thinking Rynam will end up being neutral or town. He popped in for the event to see if he could get anything useful from it, then popped out once that ended. If he had a team backing him up, they'd have gotten him to post a bit more.
Not sure where I stand on Kawl right now. Definitely seems like a scummy move to set up the thunderdome, then only bring it up now.
Vote: Grizzly
I don't really have much of an opinion other than this train seemed to come out of nowhere in the past hour, but with how close the other two options are, I'd rather help avoid a tie.
I'm thinking Rynam will end up being neutral or town. He popped in for the event to see if he could get anything useful from it, then popped out once that ended. If he had a team backing him up, they'd have gotten him to post a bit more.
Not sure where I stand on Kawl right now. Definitely seems like a scummy move to set up the thunderdome, then only bring it up now.
Hecht
Like dubstep for my bootyhole
you love it
That would actually be a dumb reason to seriously resort to that. No true argument, just saying "nah you've always said this thing so you gotta be scum," even though it's a rather rudimentary connection I've made regardless of my alignment. I hope you're just trolling right now. Like of all things to try to grasp and link as being scummy, this is your sole argument. Just what...
Just the way he is in life, really. He's another one I suspect will be a target of an ITA regardless. I think we will lose a lot of town that way, tbh. :/
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Hecht
Like dubstep for my bootyhole
Nah, no one would target me during the day. I'm too adorable.
Grizzly just die you bastard and stop making me almost die of laughter asshole like man just die bro
I don't think he said if it was one shot or not...
Sawneeks
little green dog
This post, especially that last line, stinks to high heavens. Vote kawl if you feel grizz isn't a strong lead.
You went from "It's not the case" to "It's a dumb reason". I see you are afraid of death. Don't worry fam.
Mazre
Traitor of Humanity
Kawl, could use some info, is your ability a one shot?
To reiterate from this morning:
Scum Kawl - well we made the right choice in not lynching
Town Kawl - high probability that we'd be deciding between 2 townies, no lynch isn't a terrible thing here
Kawl using his power to fish for reads and generating talk can certainly be construed as towny, but it's also an easy excuse should he be scum
Scum Kawl could also be completely talking out of his ass and may have had nothing to do with this TD setup.
I find it somewhat suspicious that Kawl waited so close to day end to drop this info on us.
Agree with zeke that a Kawl flip would be useful at this point
VOTE: Kawl
To reiterate from this morning:
Scum Kawl - well we made the right choice in not lynching
Town Kawl - high probability that we'd be deciding between 2 townies, no lynch isn't a terrible thing here
Kawl using his power to fish for reads and generating talk can certainly be construed as towny, but it's also an easy excuse should he be scum
Scum Kawl could also be completely talking out of his ass and may have had nothing to do with this TD setup.
I find it somewhat suspicious that Kawl waited so close to day end to drop this info on us.
Agree with zeke that a Kawl flip would be useful at this point
VOTE: Kawl
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
That said, if I had an important power, I wouldn't act like this most likely, so take that as you will.
Since grizzly gonna die can we just talk marvel movies with time left?
Sawneeks
little green dog
He posted saying he'd do it again. Give me a sec to grab it.
Hecht
Like dubstep for my bootyhole
fixed your typo
Yeah it's a rather extreme grasp, and an incredibly poor reason to be the sole cause for wasting an ITA on someone you haven't indicated as being a straight scum read for several reasons. The whole "I'll prove it later" backtrack is rather funny though, since in my experience that's a basic scum tactic that often end with an "oops I forgot..."
So you have a claim to make then?
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Channeling my inner Blarg since he isn't here :(.
I'm struggling to see why you would push "flimsy as fuck" reasoning when you recognize it. Why wouldn't scum Kawl do exactly what he said and use his power early to wipe out a townie rather than risk getting killed before he could wipe out a townie?
Don't bring up the no lynch; I highly doubt anyone anticipated we'd do that.
Actually, his weirdness is making me wonder but I don't think we're gonna get anything out of him without a vote push, so I'm pushing.
Sawneeks
little green dog
Stuart , I took the first line to be he would do it again.
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Everyone has a role, right? So technically everyone always has a claim no matter what.
I assumed that meant "I'd do it again if I had the chance" - I mean it's a type of phrase you see people say often.
Mazre
Traitor of Humanity
I read that as if he had to do it again he would
==== DAY 1.8 VOTES ====
Day Start
grizzly (11 votes)
faddy - #1390
gorlak - #1399 #1523
coolestspot - #1402
natiko - #1409
stuart444 - #1417
empressdonna - #1424
nin1000 - #1431
verelios - #1474
heymonkey - #1506
ynnek7 - #1509
geno - #1513
hecht - #1515
rynam (5 votes)
terraforce - #1044 #1482
poltergust - #1166
stuart444 - #1174 #1417
alexem - #1206
empressdonna - #1294 #1424
muffin - #1307
luxcommander - #1334
hom3land - #1445
verelios (4 votes)
geno - #1001 #1513
xbro - #1050
kyanrute - #1128
grizzly - #1185
luxcommander - #1193 #1334
ezekelrage - #1337 #1484
zippedpinhead - #1364
kawl (3 votes)
gorlak - #1264 #1399
splinter - #1278
ezekelrage - #1484
mazre - #1522
zippedpinhead (3 votes)
natiko - #1038 #1132
bladesymphony - #1043
nzjubjub - #1169
natiko - #1268 #1409
faircure - #1315
geno (2 votes)
faddy - #1013 #1390
include - #1167
verelios - #1183 #1474
terraforce - #1482
blargonaut (0 votes)
melonrabbit - #1039 #1175
apollo (0 votes)
natiko - #1132 #1268
natiko (0 votes)
hecht - #1073 #1515
gorlak - #1241 #1264
stuart444 (0 votes)
nin1000 - #1359 #1431
gorlak (0 votes)
heymonkey - #1051 #1506
terraforce (0 votes)
faddy - #1004 #1013
ryanm (0 votes)
hom3land - #1321 #1437
Post Counts:
stuart444: 56 grizzly: 43 geno: 38 heymonkey: 33 coolestspot: 33 faddy: 32 kyanrute: 26 verelios: 26 gorlak: 25 hecht: 21 splinter: 20 terraforce: 19 natiko: 18 melonrabbit: 15 muffin: 13 nin1000: 10 alexem: 10 poltergust: 9 dcpat: 9 ezekelrage: 8 sorian: 8 include: 7 sawneeks: 7 hom3land: 6 zippedpinhead: 4 nzjubjub: 4 kawl: 4 empressdonna: 4 nomad sparkster: 3 faircure: 3 bladesymphony: 3 ynnek7: 3 luxcommander: 3 xbro: 3 ferg: 2 necktochicken: 2 mazre: 2 apollo: 1 crimsonfist: 1 fireblend: 1 extreme tactician: 1
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day 1 Ends in:
Day Start
grizzly (11 votes)
faddy - #1390
coolestspot - #1402
natiko - #1409
stuart444 - #1417
empressdonna - #1424
nin1000 - #1431
verelios - #1474
heymonkey - #1506
ynnek7 - #1509
geno - #1513
hecht - #1515
rynam (5 votes)
poltergust - #1166
alexem - #1206
muffin - #1307
luxcommander - #1334
hom3land - #1445
verelios (4 votes)
xbro - #1050
kyanrute - #1128
grizzly - #1185
zippedpinhead - #1364
kawl (3 votes)
splinter - #1278
ezekelrage - #1484
mazre - #1522
zippedpinhead (3 votes)
bladesymphony - #1043
nzjubjub - #1169
faircure - #1315
geno (2 votes)
include - #1167
terraforce - #1482
blargonaut (0 votes)
apollo (0 votes)
natiko (0 votes)
stuart444 (0 votes)
gorlak (0 votes)
terraforce (0 votes)
ryanm (0 votes)
Post Counts:
stuart444: 56 grizzly: 43 geno: 38 heymonkey: 33 coolestspot: 33 faddy: 32 kyanrute: 26 verelios: 26 gorlak: 25 hecht: 21 splinter: 20 terraforce: 19 natiko: 18 melonrabbit: 15 muffin: 13 nin1000: 10 alexem: 10 poltergust: 9 dcpat: 9 ezekelrage: 8 sorian: 8 include: 7 sawneeks: 7 hom3land: 6 zippedpinhead: 4 nzjubjub: 4 kawl: 4 empressdonna: 4 nomad sparkster: 3 faircure: 3 bladesymphony: 3 ynnek7: 3 luxcommander: 3 xbro: 3 ferg: 2 necktochicken: 2 mazre: 2 apollo: 1 crimsonfist: 1 fireblend: 1 extreme tactician: 1
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day 1 Ends in:
doesn't matter if your logic is godtier if it doesn't make it into the thread
Fair point, I usually take a role claim to be "I have a power role that I'll only reveal if I have to" or something like that. Saying you'll wait and see how things play out means you're at least not vanilla townie I'd have thought
No. The only reason I said I'll prove it later is because I want to go to sleep and don't have time before day end to collect and give you the proof. If we had more time maybe I would've searched for it.
Hecht
Like dubstep for my bootyhole
Grizzly's behavior is starting to become too much of an issue for me to ignore, but at the same time I'm not sure what lynching him would accomplish since I don't know why people started voting for him in the first place.
This is not a bastard game.
Verelios
Were-elios
Hecht
Like dubstep for my bootyhole
shit he's a tanner
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
Yeah I've got to admit the claim makes no sense. I do wonder if he fake claimed it just to troll me.
It seems Grizzly is probably scum anyway, so this is all moot for now.
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
congrats fam u got it
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
That's "I would", not "I will"
Sawneeks
little green dog
Okay but the no lyn- damn it.
I'm still catching up so I read that page I posted on by skimming it. I saw kawl saying he created the thunderdome and skimmed much of the rest, including splinters post you asked me to read. Going back and reading it over I still feel like kawl can easily be townie for stated reasons but I will agree his melon reasoning kinda feels desperate and made up. BUT, and a heavy but, I can also see it as weak town logic for wanting to get hard reads on a loud player.
So the question becomes why would a town Grizzly just roll over like this. ScumGriz maybe hoping we all wait for a claim and then leap off last minute, which is why he's holding back info. Town Griz may just think well, I'm here, no great scumreads, so why not, especially if busy in the coming days.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Yea grizzly flip tonight doesn't give us much I think. We can ita kill him next day phase.
Kawl waiting to claim he did it and the timing of the TD both read as scum. Couldve saved time in discussion. There is also the small chance he isn't the one that did it. Which would make him scum as well.
Would answer the question whether this power is scum or town. For the ppl who were so sure this was a scum power not voting him, is weird.
I guess what I don't understand is why you're doing gymnastics to read it as town while your arguments say "probs scum."
Alexem
Yeah, I'm town
I'm turning in for the night now. Still not feeling the push for Grizzly at this point, but I get the feeling that debating the first flip in this game is a moot point - whoever goes today, I wouldn't be surprised if the other leading candidates end up in the crosshairs for the early ITAs.
Assuming nothing happens between now and then, I'll see you crazy kids for D2.
Assuming nothing happens between now and then, I'll see you crazy kids for D2.
CrimsonFist
Neutral Vanilla
From what I can see the votes didn't even start piling on until he started shitposting, there was every chance it could have swung in another direction. I don't get this as a scum play, unless he has a role that activates on lynch.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
why not give a heads up b4 you sent the command in?
Hecht
Like dubstep for my bootyhole
^ scum
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
I was holding off my claim because once I reveal it becomes pretty much impossible for me to win.
I'm a neutral executioner, who needs to get their target lynched. If my target is night killed or killed by other means than lynch, I turn into a neutral survivor. I dislike this role, but what are you going to do.
I won't reveal my target because that would ruin all of my chances of winning.
I'm a neutral executioner, who needs to get their target lynched. If my target is night killed or killed by other means than lynch, I turn into a neutral survivor. I dislike this role, but what are you going to do.
I won't reveal my target because that would ruin all of my chances of winning.
But also, you guys have to be outside your mind if you think there is any way that the thunderdome power would be town aligned, I barely even buy the chance that its non scum aligned, unless it was just a random generated event by sorian.
going off of that there is no way that splinter is scum. there's no way he has to balls to go all in on celebrating his stupid ass wrong claim if he knew it was wrong. only way he responds like that is if he actually believes me, aka he isn't part of the scum team who used that power.
gorlak is suspicious for immediately both a) believing i was doing this to fish, and b) saying that. everyone knows that you let a day 1 gambit run its course before you call it out. otherwise it dilutes the reactions to it. shame on ya gorlak
going off of that there is no way that splinter is scum. there's no way he has to balls to go all in on celebrating his stupid ass wrong claim if he knew it was wrong. only way he responds like that is if he actually believes me, aka he isn't part of the scum team who used that power.
gorlak is suspicious for immediately both a) believing i was doing this to fish, and b) saying that. everyone knows that you let a day 1 gambit run its course before you call it out. otherwise it dilutes the reactions to it. shame on ya gorlak
CrimsonFist
Neutral Vanilla
This is impossible just keeping up with new posts v_v
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
If Grizzly is town. Either he has a role and should claim well in advance of EOD or he should keep quiet about his role and argue for someone else.
Now he has half put out a role claim. He needs to actually full claim if he has any desire to live.
Sawneeks
little green dog
To everyone that replied: yes, now I realize my reading my comprehension is bad and I shouldn't skim threads and multi task....
For the record I'm not against grizz given the current situation. Either he just doesn't care as a townie or is scary/neutral and got caught.
For the record I'm not against grizz given the current situation. Either he just doesn't care as a townie or is scary/neutral and got caught.
CrimsonFist
Neutral Vanilla
oh, lol
Vote Grizzly
Vote Grizzly
@Geno @Terraforce @CoolestSpot
You are not allowed to quote from previous games (or anything other than this game actually?). Just a fair warning.
It looks like you have your own little shenanigans ongoing. I don't know how to feel about you two ganging up on Geno just now. Geno did exactly this lurking in Berserk the day he go lynched after you were already dead Terra, especially around day end. You two know he's a hothead and push him right now, but why. Do you need him to be lynched today?
You are not allowed to quote from previous games (or anything other than this game actually?). Just a fair warning.
It looks like you have your own little shenanigans ongoing. I don't know how to feel about you two ganging up on Geno just now. Geno did exactly this lurking in Berserk the day he go lynched after you were already dead Terra, especially around day end. You two know he's a hothead and push him right now, but why. Do you need him to be lynched today?
Hecht
Like dubstep for my bootyhole
ok cool so nothing of value will be lost
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
From town POV, no. I don't like this role.
What? Are you now saying you didn't activate the event? I'm confused now.
Sawneeks
little green dog
It's almost like I'm uncertain about it. :U
There are thunderdome powers that are town-aligned. Gladiator can be any alignment.
CrimsonFist
Neutral Vanilla
hmm, how about you reveal your target Grizzly, if they're someone who looks scummy anyway we can lynch them and then shoot you tomorrow if you don't leave?
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Wait...………….didn't you just say you didn't the TD?
So you are saying you are Neutral at best and scum at worst?
Are you saying you were trolling with td claim?
okay but you admit you deserve me ribbing you like this in this moment, yes? <3
If we lynch Grizzly, would we find out who his target is?
and use it day 1 on those particular people? come on now.
whats the vote count, i buy that trash role claim from bear would like to have a shot at hitting scum and not 3rd party day 1
Sawneeks
little green dog
Okay, this is almost impossible. I really apologize but I didn't realize the day ending was this soon and I'm out and on mobile and have barely even caught up. I'm gonna be out for the rest of this phase since I can't keep up with what's happening. Hopefully if I'm still around next phase I'll be more on track. Again, I'm really sorry.
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
I don't know. The name is revealed in my role PM, but that could be potentially rescinded.
CrimsonFist
Neutral Vanilla
Kawl is town, scum doesn't draw attention to themselves at the end of day 1 like that.
Verelios
Were-elios
This sounds weird and kind of restrictive.
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Fair assessment. I would do the same if I was you. I blame Sorian :P.
Me too! Let's do it together. <3
that's how you should have known it wasn't true.
besides claiming i know enough about meta to realize you and melon have history? lol only inside jokes i've retained across my absence is a drunk who isn't even in this game
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Hmm..
Wait, I missed Kawl claiming to be the cause of the Gladiate? Wow haha. His reasoning isn't great either. I would not be opposed to that lynch either considering his rather lacking track record in this game.
Muffin
Born with a heart full of neutrality
I'd be down for this tbh. Lynching third party who leaves if we lynch somebody else seems wasted.
Apollo
Apollo will wreck your goddamn face
I just skimmed (and when I say skimmed I mean SKIMMED) through hundreds of posts to try to get a feel for the lynch candidates and I guess it’s basically decided by the time I’m done. Neat. I was going to vote Grizzly out of the leaders though so it’s fine I guess?
This stood out to me during my catch up.
In particular the part about what a “calm townie” would do rubs me the wrong way. Considering Verelios just got out of an event that he had to decide the outcome of, one he didn’t apparently understand the rules of, and was shortly after facing a ton of pressure from the likes of Geno and Kyan, I think not being entirely calm (or at least being prone to a “‘mistake”, if you want to call it that) is understandable. And of course a few posts after this post Verelios points out that the drip feed was only because of the questions he continually received. Grizzlys post just feels opportunistic to me.
VOTE: Grizzly
I don’t really have much to say about Rynam because he’s been kind of a non-factor. He said it was a coincidence he joined the event with his debut, maybe that’s true, maybe he was lurking, I’m not lynching for either at this point. Verelios I was feeling his event situation was NAI, but I at least think if he is town scum would try to take advantage of it.
Fake edit: okay and now he’s claimed neutral. idfk anymore but like it could be a fake claim? lol I think I’m caught up and I miss stuff while typing this
This stood out to me during my catch up.
In particular the part about what a “calm townie” would do rubs me the wrong way. Considering Verelios just got out of an event that he had to decide the outcome of, one he didn’t apparently understand the rules of, and was shortly after facing a ton of pressure from the likes of Geno and Kyan, I think not being entirely calm (or at least being prone to a “‘mistake”, if you want to call it that) is understandable. And of course a few posts after this post Verelios points out that the drip feed was only because of the questions he continually received. Grizzlys post just feels opportunistic to me.
VOTE: Grizzly
I don’t really have much to say about Rynam because he’s been kind of a non-factor. He said it was a coincidence he joined the event with his debut, maybe that’s true, maybe he was lurking, I’m not lynching for either at this point. Verelios I was feeling his event situation was NAI, but I at least think if he is town scum would try to take advantage of it.
Fake edit: okay and now he’s claimed neutral. idfk anymore but like it could be a fake claim? lol I think I’m caught up and I miss stuff while typing this
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Can we just vote kawl just for causing all this confusing?
All my theories about vere and splinter are back on
LOL.
Either way, kawl gives us the most answers. Him doing this at the end of the day doesn't help town AT ALL.
All my theories about vere and splinter are back on
LOL.
Either way, kawl gives us the most answers. Him doing this at the end of the day doesn't help town AT ALL.
He then backtracked just a few posts ago (or at least that's the implication I took from it)
Muffin
Born with a heart full of neutrality
he said that happens if his target gets killed through other methods.
ONLY if he is killed by other means. If it's a lynch, Grizzly leaves he said.
Mazre
Traitor of Humanity
Generally agree and it's total WIFOM, but really hate that sentiment of "Must be town, scum would never do _______ "
there's no way he goes all out in the way he was posting about it if he knew he was wrong, can't believe that.
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
I become survivor if my target dies from other source than a lynch. I leave if my target is lynched.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
He claimed it...……..then just a few moments said he didn't do it. So just messing around it seems. Wasting time/discussion. Not very townie.