Search results

In his defense he's not calling it a stupid power use, he's saying it's a lie to cover for the power being random. I don't think random is likely to be a thing, but I guess he wouldn't know that. I think some people have been arguing "stupid and therefore scum" though, and yeah those people...

Gog could just as easily have been protected though. I don't think melon's action should be enough to lynch her.

Yeah completely pointless and increasingly bitter

Yeah I can remember being pretty irate with Faddy in a previous game. I dunno if you can blame him for other people not keeping their cool though.

Faddy did move on mind, he just didn't acknowledge. With the way Fantomas reacted it would be respectful to at least allay those concerns.

Faddy just needs to acknowledge Fanto's explanation and move on. I can see how it might look to Fantomas, but noone is actually attacking him for having a mentor or "playing too well", it was just an observation that it seems like he has some other outlet on the thread (which turns out to be...

I think I would be scumreading

I don't think this scum-Zeusy theory makes much sense. If he's the coasting scum, why would scum help town find him? If you look at those targets, Zeusy is the "obvious" lynch for the day, so if you thought this was a scum power you shouldn't be lynching there. And from his claim, you could...

I see it's Zeusy's turn to be called a dumb idiot who sabotaged town, this time for using his power role.

Yeah but there's "quite annoyed" and then there's this.

Maybe neither, I don't think they would have seen it as an intentional strategy, but they also can't be that annoyed by something that massively benefitted them. They're guessing how annoyed they should be, and overdoing it. Just compare them to the more vocal townies. Only

Not defending it, but 90% of that noise and doubt came from scum players. Town didn't have to go along with it.

I feel for Faddy, scum are playing really rough this phase, and town are all either afk or completely buying into scum's narrative.

I think we're allowed to reference but not quote past games? Or maybe we dropped it (it was a silly rule)

He's comparing her D1 vote in this game to her usual voting behaviour

Faddy: "Monkey usually votes on wagon" Monkey: "No I don't, look at game X" Faddy: "Here is the only counter example in game X and the situation was different because Y" Seems fair enough to me. I don't remember what game they're talking about but I can follow the arguments they're making.

This comment has absolutely no place in the game. Feel free to raise whatever you want post game, there's no need to foreshadow here except to make someone feel like shit. It was a bad play. We do not respond to bad play with bullying.

Again, applies to every lynch. If anything a policy lynch is easier to hide in than a regular one

That's not what I'm saying. The tactic is bad because it massively hurts town on average, and we generally policy lynch to discourage it. I agree on all of that.