Search results

  1. O

    Spectator Thread Observing a Story as it Unfolds

    Well tbf, role names shouldn't have to make sense
  2. O

    Spectator Thread Observing a Story as it Unfolds

    I think I spent way too much time thinking about the roleblock when reviewing, so of course it's gone before it's used lol. This night phase should be quite fun
  3. O

    Spectator Thread Observing a Story as it Unfolds

    For as long as this game was on my mind, I barely remember the roles lol. Should be fun from what I remember though.
  4. O

    Nier Role PMs

    https://giphy.com/gifs/mrw-nintendo-switch-fBicdJRegLYiI Um, maybe make the princess say if killed by non-town instead of outright scum since that could lead to assumptions of non deadly neutrals but other than that it looks good to go! And again, sorry all for the extended time it took for...
  5. O

    Mistery Game

    Would you allow the neutral to be a recruiter (or a neutral ascetic bulletproof serial killer cop lol)? I think the neutral might be interesting in how they choose their role. But yeah, I can't really think of anything else to add, it should be fine to go. It's largely gonna breakdown to what...
  6. O

    Mistery Game

    Are you going to look at all roles as a whole beforehand or as they come in?
  7. O

    Mistery Game

    Lmfao, this should be amazing What's the practical difference between conjurers and specialists? They both seem to have a ton of leeway in what roles they can choose. Also, what sort of roles would fall under support?
  8. O

    Nier Role PMs

    How will nier find out how to acquire more abilities? What is the sleepwalker finding out? I'm assuming it is just extra flavor. Hammerer should just hammer if they are off the wagon and do nothing if they are already on it. Just make sure it isn't active on my/lylo And fish vendor, with an...
  9. O

    Current Nier Roster

    It doesn't make a difference in how you do it imo. Here, a Google sheet, whatever is fine with me!
  10. O

    Current Nier Roster

    Yeah, that last point would be good. Because you don't want people to be solving the game via the game's wiki instead of by playing Mafia. Would the cover names have credible paths to making a fake claim? Since a lot of these roles seem tightly intertwined with their names.
  11. O

    Current Nier Roster

    OK, I was looking at some other guidelines for what people would do for role madness games. And the main thing I saw was whether at the beginning of D1 if everyone decided to roleclaim would the game fall apart. So as long as there are some good fake claims especially character-wise then it...
  12. O

    Current Nier Roster

    Um, looking at it again, is there any use to the Miller? There is no alignment cop (unless we are talking about the the weak hider that is kinda coppish). I think not having a foil for them is one of those bastard type elements. I'd consider the Miller to be non-town for hiding purposes But...
  13. O

    Current Nier Roster

    Yeah, that's pretty much it. I think they know they are a sleepwalker, but they don't know/have no control their actions.
  14. O

    Current Nier Roster

    I'd prefer the second option too A sleepwalker and item vendor would be fun for maximum confusion. I'd be fine with that. could make her hated for her bad additude or something. I just don't want the game to be *too* predictable, especially if you might be running out of named characters...
  15. O

    Current Nier Roster

    Oh god, now I feel even worse to see that nothing else was done here. I wish I didn't put others in this situation because I've been on the other side (gamerunner went awol in review) along with the fact that it is a generally lousy thing to do. Please don't be afraid to bop me on discord/era...
  16. O

    Current Nier Roster

    I'm totally here because I'm a super responsible reviewer and not because I was (justifiably) called out in a vague manner in the review thread. But for real, I'm sorry about the delay y'all.
  17. O

    Current Nier Roster

    Are all of the abilities without numbers attached unlimited? But yeah, town seems very OP
  18. O

    Design & discussion

    Again, I've never really payed too much attention to that before so I'm not concerned if it is SOP. I don't think anything else needs to be done in that case!
  19. O

    Design & discussion

    Only other thing that I can think of is whether or not the sample PM is a carbon copy of the vanilla townie PM. Probably won't be a problem since discussing PMs are frowned upon, but I'll throw it out there. Aside from that, it gets a green light from me!
  20. O

    Design & discussion

    i meant more of how much time before day start during the night phase will everybody be allowed to post (i didn't care when they would actually post the command), but i assume it is until night actions are locked
Top Bottom