Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

Natiko

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Geno said:
Like I said I was missing people for sure, can't remember everyone. But the list as is still stands. All of these players plus the ones you mentioned can safely be ITA'd.
Click to expand...
More just curious as to why those ones were named but not the others. You said you forgot the ones I named, but what caused you to remember the ones that you named?

Verelios said:
Sorry if you've already answered them, but I do have some questions for when you get back.
-Why did you go for a no lynch? Votes were already pushed for Splinter.
-Why Splinter? I get the hate, but I'm confused at why, and on day 1. It initially seemed like you were interested in lynching him but lost interest halfway.

What was this about?

Zubz did show up for a post though, to ask why you're so down on him.
Click to expand...
I didn't say none of them post, I said they're all posting very little. When they do post most of them do not show many (if any) signs of trying to solve. They either show up to:

1. Defend themselves
2. Parrot someone else
3. Talk about how they don't have anything to say

Do you town read any of the players named?
 
melonrabbit

melonrabbit

The only good kind of melon
BladeSymphony said:
Shoot: faircure, his back and forth and failure to really commit in the previous posts I mentioned on Grizzly make me think he's just saving face
Vote: Ynnek, his behavior is iffy, and he's playing really close to the chest, his posts seem to be just buying time instead of providing input
Protect: Stuart444 or Xbro, town reads on both of you right now.
Click to expand...

How are you getting any reading off of Xbro?
 
Geno

Geno

Natiko said:
More just curious as to why those ones were named but not the others. You said you forgot the ones I named, but what caused you to remember the ones that you named?
Click to expand...
Because that's how memory works haha. I have no real answer here.
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
Natiko said:
More just curious as to why those ones were named but not the others. You said you forgot the ones I named, but what caused you to remember the ones that you named?


I didn't say none of them post, I said they're all posting very little. When they do post most of them do not show many (if any) signs of trying to solve. They either show up to:

1. Defend themselves
2. Parrot someone else
3. Talk about how they don't have anything to say

Do you town read any of the players named?
Click to expand...
No, not particularly. They're mostly null to me given their inactivity.
 
BladeSymphony

BladeSymphony

melonrabbit said:
How are you getting any reading off of Xbro?
Click to expand...

Rynam's flip.

Xbro said:
Okay, so I'm not able to locate the exact posts by Grizzly I was looking for. Just the general feeling that was going on during the discussion. Basically I wasn't going after Grizzly because he was acting like Monopoly, I was going after him because I was catching him on the same things that I caught him on in Monopoly. It all hinged on whether or not Vere flipped if it was the same situation. Grizzly's posts leading up to his Vere vote felt like he knew something else and was just waiting for an opportunity to jump on it. At least this was my thoughts at the time. I had already gotten a bad vibe from Vere, so I figured if he flipped, then it was pretty much guaranteed that Grizzly was scum. Now we've been put into the reverse situation and I still think my initial analysis is correct. I find that the observations I make while reading the thread tend to be correct when I initially make them. I'm not sure if I can rally anyone on this but I trust my gut completely and I'm willing to take responsibility if I'm wrong.

For my shoot Lynch protect, I would shoot Vere, lynch Rynam and protect melon.

If Rynam really does have an ITA protection I would rather just Lynch him.

Melon seemed, to me, to use the Thunderdome as a means of Investigation on splinter. So I honestly think that is a town thing to do
Click to expand...
 
Geno

Geno

Why do you guys care how and why she picked Splinter, the result is what matters. Splinter flipped scum, she is either town or some 3rd party gladiator. End of story, move on.
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
I can’t believe what melon is responding wit. You had to use it? At that time? When most ppl were sleep?

You couldn’t claim it was you day one?
That’s convenient especially if we look at day 1 and don’t see any posts of you mentioning gladiator.

Geno her play hasn’t made her seem very town and if she is neutral, then they don’t have our interest at heart anyway.
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
Geno said:
Why do you guys care how and why she picked Splinter, the result is what matters. Splinter flipped scum, she is either town or some 3rd party gladiator. End of story, move on.
Click to expand...
The result would matter if Splinter was killed during the TD, but he wasn't and the TD ended up being wasted. So it's pretty damning for you to try and shout down any opposition when we're asking questions.
 
Geno

Geno

Verelios said:
The result would matter if Splinter was killed during the TD, but he wasn't and the TD ended up being wasted. So it's pretty damning for you to try and shout down any opposition when we're asking questions.
Click to expand...
No? What difference does it make when he was killed? The TD was wasted because this town is a bunch of chickens, only me and Faddy wanted to lynch people no matter what.
 
Blargonaut

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
DCPAT said:
Glad you think it's a good guess.
Click to expand...
oh, I simply couldn't bear to stand witnessing my fellow Town being slaughtered without me

melonrabbit said:
Blarg I miss you.

I even watched Gravity Falls hoping it would summon you.
Click to expand...
3JWOJn1.gif
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Geno said:
No? What difference does it make when he was killed? The TD was wasted because this town is a bunch of chickens, only me and Faddy wanted to lynch people no matter what.
Click to expand...

tbf, I think Faddy just wanted to turn things around because of the whole no lynch discussion from the start of the day when he was the first no lynch vote.
 
melonrabbit

melonrabbit

The only good kind of melon
EzekelRAGE said:
I can’t believe what melon is responding wit. You had to use it? At that time? When most ppl were sleep?

You couldn’t claim it was you day one?
That’s convenient especially if we look at day 1 and don’t see any posts of you mentioning gladiator.

Geno her play hasn’t made her seem very town and if she is neutral, then they don’t have our interest at heart anyway.
Click to expand...

Answering the timing stuff gets into real life and this an iffy question to push. And yes, you won't see any breadcrumbs. I've already said that.

Are you ever asking my other questions or no...
 
Geno

Geno

Stuart444 said:
tbf, I think Faddy just wanted to turn things around because of the whole no lynch discussion from the start of the day when he was the first no lynch vote.
Click to expand...
Maybe, but still he still had the right idea in the gladiatorial match and he ended up being town.
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
Stuart444 said:
Asking questions or trying to seem busy with an easy thing to question.

Pick on something easy, look busy, be thought of better.

Zeke feels legit but you to me feels forced with this.
Click to expand...
This doesn't make sense. So you're telling me there wasn't another utility for the TD? Like lynching another person?
 
Geno

Geno

Blargonaut said:
What do you think, Geno
Click to expand...
Now that Sorian has made posts after it makes it seem it wasn't a mistake on his part. But I don't see how the 2 are connected, they weren't lovers and I don't know a poisoner role that kills in the middle of the day. I guess we just need more info before we can solve what happened there.
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Verelios said:
This doesn't make sense. So you're telling me there wasn't another utility for the TD? Like lynching another person?
Click to expand...

I'm saying you feel like your forcing yourself into this with lack of things to talk about compared to Zeke who feels legit with his discussion with Melon.
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Also there is only one Utility for a TD, lynching someone. People chose no lynch though.

Asking if there is another utility for TD is like lol to me.
 
Geno

Geno

Blargonaut said:
nin was a Doctor and Kyan was Vanilla?

nin was killed while Kyan died?

Seems to me that nin died protecting Kyan, which is fucked since it's daylight out rn

so what is this
Click to expand...
Nin was roleblocked due to the event so even if Nin can somehow do that he still wouldn't be able to. The whole situation is a mess.
 
melonrabbit

melonrabbit

The only good kind of melon
EzekelRAGE said:
Will do when I get home, but to the why risks joat?
Not a risk if you planned to no lynch. Especially if you set up a time with scummstes to be on at midnight. We learned nothing from the td.
Click to expand...

You're saying we/I as scum coordinated the no lynch win?

Okay. That's one theory.
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
Stuart444 said:
I'm saying you feel like your forcing yourself into this with lack of things to talk about compared to Zeke who feels legit with his discussion with Melon.
Click to expand...
I'm pretty sure you're biased. That, or trying to police what I talk about.
Stuart444 said:
Also there is only one Utility for a TD, lynching someone. People chose no lynch though.

Asking if there is another utility for TD is like lol to me.
Click to expand...
That's the utility I mean, give town a second lynch opportunity.
 
Ferg

Ferg

melonrabbit said:
Pick some people that stand out to you for whatever reason and stick with them and try develop some reads on them. In my first game I followed people who's usernames sounded the coolest to me.

Trying to keep up with everyone will get you lost quickly.

A lot of us have played many, many, many time together and therefore tend to bullshit our reads with meta. So don't feel discouraged.
Click to expand...


Alright thanks :D
 
Zippedpinhead

Zippedpinhead

Zip it!
Why would Grizzly sacrifice himself... only if he thought that the other two mafia roles up for voting were more valuable. He basically started picking up steam right when Rynam and Verelios (and myself) were nearing a decent amount of votes.

Rynam's role is pretty unique and plays into the rest of the game. Grizzly's role is powerful, but all of these scum roles have been powerful.

Verelios, do you have something to tell us? are you an ability mirror?
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
Zippedpinhead said:
Why would Grizzly sacrifice himself... only if he thought that the other two mafia roles up for voting were more valuable. He basically started picking up steam right when Rynam and Verelios (and myself) were nearing a decent amount of votes.

Rynam's role is pretty unique and plays into the rest of the game. Grizzly's role is powerful, but all of these scum roles have been powerful.

Verelios, do you have something to tell us? are you an ability mirror?
Click to expand...
No, I was just told to stop posting my busy work.
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Zippedpinhead said:
Why would Grizzly sacrifice himself... only if he thought that the other two mafia roles up for voting were more valuable. He basically started picking up steam right when Rynam and Verelios (and myself) were nearing a decent amount of votes.
Click to expand...

I can see why Rynam's role might be more important since it gives an extra 'chance' to kill per night. In a large game like this it could be considered more important.

Kawl was also up for running and he's not been of much use recently and just been... not helpful.

Splinter even though he wasn't up for running had a very powerful role.

Considering this, I wouldn't be surprised if Vere was Mafia and had a stronger role.

Not ruling you out either though.
 
faircure

faircure

DCPAT said:
But what do you think of the point made?
Click to expand...
Talked abt it to Sawneeks earlier
faircure said:
Yeah, all I can say in defense of my behavior is that I can be pretty unconfident and easy to sway sometimes. D1 especially. Example that comes first to mind is when scum splinter said my vote for him in hvv was the weirdest he'd seen all game or something, and I immediately jumped off and kinda flailed the rest of the phase.

Flipped back and forth on Grizzly bc I didn't initially like how he was staying on Stuart for the no lynch discussion when a lot had happened in the meantime. But he really dug his heels in and expanded more on why so it gave me pause. Didn't agree with his reasoning but I was townreading his behavior otherwise so I let it pass as a stubborn townie read. Eventually voted because I don't trust neutral claims and my current vote was a bit of stretch but better than the Rynam/Verelios alternative.

Also worth saying that I was going to respond to Monkey and say I agree that Stuart's behavior was probably NAI but the first event happened and I deleted my response and then forgot. Never imagined it'd be so important :(
Click to expand...
 
Natiko

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Hey @Blargonaut are you scum? Because I feel like anytime you play without a new posting style you're usually scum. You can tell me if so, I won't be mad.

I will lynch/shoot you though.
 
Zippedpinhead

Zippedpinhead

Zip it!
oh believe me, after seeing the sacrifice, and then the recent flip I'm SURE that something is up with what I did and what I saw last night. and Verelios is at the heart of it.
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Zippedpinhead said:
oh believe me, after seeing the sacrifice, and then the recent flip I'm SURE that something is up with what I did and what I saw last night. and Verelios is at the heart of it.
Click to expand...

Do you want to tell us now? Or later in the day.

Because if we're talking now, might as well tell us now.
 
Blargonaut

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Zippedpinhead said:
Why would Grizzly sacrifice himself... only if he thought that the other two mafia roles up for voting were more valuable. He basically started picking up steam right when Rynam and Verelios (and myself) were nearing a decent amount of votes.

Rynam's role is pretty unique and plays into the rest of the game. Grizzly's role is powerful, but all of these scum roles have been powerful.

Verelios, do you have something to tell us? are you an ability mirror?
Click to expand...
Reading this post, only a Mafia would bring up the subject of a dead Mafia by framing their loss as a sacrifice that in turn severs players' ties from the deceased in a clear attempt to clean up a potential liability in social link reads for your team. You must be Mafia.
 
Natiko

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Zippedpinhead said:
oh believe me, after seeing the sacrifice, and then the recent flip I'm SURE that something is up with what I did and what I saw last night. and Verelios is at the heart of it.
Click to expand...
Can't wait to hear what sort of shenanigans this is since he was roleblocked.
 
Zippedpinhead

Zippedpinhead

Zip it!
vere, Either we have the exact same role, or you have something that reflects a role back at the user.

and I have been debating for the last two hours to pop up and figure out how to do it, but with the recent flip, that is what i see your role in scum's hands helps them, probably more than grizzly's role.
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Zippedpinhead said:
vere, Either we have the exact same role, or you have something that reflects a role back at the user.

and I have been debating for the last two hours to pop up and figure out how to do it, but with the recent flip, that is what i see your role in scum's hands helps them, probably more than grizzly's role.
Click to expand...

So you checked his role? Does that mean you're claiming role cop?
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
Zippedpinhead said:
vere, Either we have the exact same role, or you have something that reflects a role back at the user.

and I have been debating for the last two hours to pop up and figure out how to do it, but with the recent flip, that is what i see your role in scum's hands helps them, probably more than grizzly's role.
Click to expand...
This makes no sense.
 
Natiko

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Verelios said:
God damn, I was waiting to catch him out. Had a gif and everything
Click to expand...

Kawl said:
People need to learn to keep their real shut until enough rope has been spun out. Smh
Click to expand...

Geno said:
Agreed, Natiko wtf
Click to expand...
He'd already committed, don't be daft and act like he has some chance to just back out now.

Zippedpinhead said:
vere, Either we have the exact same role, or you have something that reflects a role back at the user.

and I have been debating for the last two hours to pop up and figure out how to do it, but with the recent flip, that is what i see your role in scum's hands helps them, probably more than grizzly's role.
Click to expand...
What does that even mean lol
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

What about watcher or tracker? I think those were mentioned in a previous game but never used so I don't know if they would work.

Basically, wtf
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Stuart444 said:
What about watcher or tracker? I think those were mentioned in a previous game but never used so I don't know if they would work.
Click to expand...

(I have no experience with these roles but I'm not a fan of this softing and baiting that's going on right now. just get on with it basically)
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Natiko said:
He'd already committed, don't be daft and act like he has some chance to just back out now.


What does that even mean lol
Click to expand...
Pointing out he’s ducked up while still expanding on his tale just gives him a chance to try to damage control sooner. There’s no point in jumping on this shit until he’s done claiming what he had seen. Don’t be daft and act like this doesn’t give him more wiggle room.
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Geno said:
Fun fact if he is an ability reflector the roleblock means nothing.
Click to expand...
Eh we don’t know that especially since this was a mod given punishment versus a user action. Interaction between role block and passive a can be murky even normally
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom