Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
thereitis.gif

So D1 was all scum primarily up for a lynch. Need to go back and read again to see if anyone pushed really hard at day end to make a different wagon happen. Also need to think on what scum would do with two scum wagons happening.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
wait if this account is Rynam's ability is this confirmation that Zipped is scum
cause unless i read his pm wrong i thought it could only shoot at scum
You read it wrong. Mafia have a different chance of hitting town in the ita. Ryan's ability lowers that chance by 5%.

So it could very well be used as a way to make scum look more like town.
 
Anti-town lean

Geno 99% Check my D1 post https://www.outermafia.com/index.php?posts/24707/, he never got back to me, voted late on Grizzly, spend an unhealthy amount of time arguing about the numbers of scums instead of hunting them, speculate about how many anti town teams there are and so on? Seems very empty, just noise to keep us from focusing on the real thing which actual scum hunting.

Want to “clean up afk” instead of going for scums, no sir, afk will be dealt with in time, they are obvious and can’t escape us, but you are creating noise and trying to distract us. Also, afk being subbed out gives others who wanted to play a chance to do so: brazil, fando and rac comes to my mind.

Saw 75% Wanted to kill a newbie D1? Town Sawneeks would never do that! I know this and everybody who paid attention should as well, check my post about her on D1 https://www.outermafia.com/index.php?posts/24753/, her behavior was hypocritical. You also using Geno’s multiple scums’ team theory and create noise with it? I don’t care if there are different teams, anti town are anti town no matter if they are called A or B, at the end of the day it won’t change anything, minus trying to make noise and confuse us.

And now, Kyan shoot you and then he suddenly dies.What coincidence!


g'night, good luck with the ITAs, etc. etc.
please dont kill me

Why so afraid? Just say it, are you a scum or neutral?


what the fuck @melonrabbit and Kyan ? Can't really ask Kyan but why on earth did you try and shoot me, Melon?

also feel for the scum team with that Ry flip. Having an inactive member is the worst but....at least we got him.

I bet you do feel for them, are you sad we are winning? You either scum or neutral Saw, there is no way you are town!


kawl 60% Why are you BSing us and then backtracking? It’s confusing and tiring and frankly not helpful in the least. You’re stalling the game instead of helping us going forward and I can’t see a townie doing that.

Also PEW PEW: GENO

DIE SCUM, JUST DIE!

My read list isn't finished yet, coming up the rest.
 
Y'know I was gonna take the whatever shot at Nomad, but Geno has been weird and Include is pretty cool so:

Uchuu Senkan YAAAMAATO: Geno
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Verelios' Role PM:

Welcome Verelios,

You are Scarlet Witch. True Identity Wanda Maximoff.

Your role is Mafia Role Cop. You may use the command CHECK:<playername> once per night phase. You will learn the role name of the player.

You may also use the command KILL:<playername> once per night to execute the mafia factional kill. Your target will be killed assuming they have no form of protection. You may use both your individual ability and the factional ability in the same night, if applicable.

You win when the mafia team outnumbers all other players.
yNNBO0P.jpg
 
WTF Vere, just when I thought you may have been set up, you just go and do this? Is that why you gave me the cold shoulder day1? I almost felt like I was too narcissistic and refused to suspect you because of it and you played the victim role so well, I felt for you when you said that people have been attacking you for two days and you are tired of it because I know how it feels. This is BS, honestly.

Has your opinion of Geno changed with Vere's flip? Geno starting the train on him d1 makes me think he's town.

No way, did you read my posts? Did you ISO him? He either bussed him or is a neutral, there is no way Geno is town, no way.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Geno is the Hulk. Nothing to do with roles, claims or flavour, you just wouldn't like him when he's angry.
 
WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU DOING? I HAVE VOTED FOR 100% OF THE SCUMS AND YOU TRY TO SHOOT ME? GET REAL.
You voted Grizzly when he started trolling like everyone else, you get no credit for that. Also what did you do the entire game minus creating noise about game balance and you being upset about the event? Answer my arguments and then get back to me.
 
Geno is the Hulk. Nothing to do with roles, claims or flavour, you just wouldn't like him when he's angry.
I don't like him now and anyone who take a little effort to actual read his posts would know it too. Check my arguments about him and legit let me know what you think of him, because he sure as hell ain't town.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
I don't like him now and anyone who take a little effort to actual read his posts would know it too. Check my arguments about him and legit let me know what you think of him, because he sure as hell ain't town.
I find Geno a tricky one to read, as he tends to get very defensive when questioned. I recall watching him in Bill and Ted where he was scum - after enough pressure, he folded and took himself out.
 
You voted Grizzly when he started trolling like everyone else, you get no credit for that. Also what did you do the entire game minus creating noise about game balance and you being upset about the event? Answer my arguments and then get back to me.
I won't bother answering absurd arguments. Like how I didn't answer Verelios' and how I won't answer Terra's.
 
You voted Grizzly when he started trolling like everyone else, you get no credit for that. Also what did you do the entire game minus creating noise about game balance and you being upset about the event? Answer my arguments and then get back to me.

He went after Verelios first on D1, 1.5 he was on Splinter, 1.8 on Grizzly (and on Verelios before he moved his vote), on Rynam and Verelios today

Ignoring his arguments, he has a flawless voting record that I don't think he's Scum. If he is scum, he must be really bold or doesn't care about his team mates at all.
 
No way, did you read my posts? Did you ISO him? He either bussed him or is a neutral, there is no way Geno is town, no way.
Yeah, I read it and haven't iso'ed him but I don't remember his behavior being out of the ordinary for how I've seen him playing d1 in other games I've spectated. I'd have to go back and read his back and forth with Verelios more indepth but iirc he was really indignant that Vere said he should've voted Geno in the event. I'm not sure he would've acted like that if they were teammates?

It's possible Geno is neutral, esp cause he did seem to be valuing his life over the other four set to be penalized but I don't get how he's scum. And Grizzly voted Geno in the event. If the names matched that person would be penalized, so I feel like Grizzly wouldn't pick his teammate when it was unclear what the penalty was. Multiple people had the thought the penalty was death.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Geno as scum given Vere and Grizzly flipped scum? Seems unlikely. Would scum Vere in event 1 name Geno as who he should’ve named if they’re both scum? Does Grizzly vote for scum Geno as his pick? WIFOM to an extent, but given how cautious scum have seemed I just don’t see it. What sticks out to me more now is who Vere did pick..and who he wanted to make a point to “regret” picking. In hindsight I think Vere was confused about what was happening, but I think his reasoning for why he picked Blade was the portion he lied about.

@BladeSymphony

VOTE: BladeSymphony
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
If you were voting for Verelios then your vote has been reset. I don't have an easy way to do that so here is the current vote. The toll will still show Vere votes until you actually unvote.

==== DAY 2 VOTES ====
Day Start

ynnek7 (3 votes)
sawneeks - #1734 #1739
sawneeks - #1739
heymonkey - #1882 #2445
heymonkey - #3095 #3243
terraforce - #3162
luxcommander - #3163

melonrabbit (2 votes)
ezekelrage - #2286
swamped - #2465 #3246
zubz - #3341

bladesymphony (1 votes)
natiko - #3449

geno (1 votes)
blargonaut - #3433

zippedpinhead (1 votes)
nzjubjub - #2307

kyanrute (1 votes)
apollo - #2047

luxcommander (1 votes)
heymonkey - #3243

mazre (1 votes)
dcpat - #3394

alexem (0 votes)
heymonkey - #2445 #2719

kawl (0 votes)
muffin - #1767 #2727
stuart444 - #2024 #2622
blargonaut - #2453 #3161

rynam (0 votes)
geno - #2245 #3019

ynnek (0 votes)
terraforce - #3107 #3162

gorlak (0 votes)
blargonaut - #3161 #3187

Post Counts:
stuart444: 209 heymonkey: 136 verelios: 122 melonrabbit: 112 blargonaut: 104 geno: 88 sorian: 77 ezekelrage: 75 natiko: 68 sawneeks: 63 terraforce: 59 kawl: 52 muffin: 51 alexem: 44 extreme tactician: 41 nomad sparkster: 40 zippedpinhead: 35 ynnek7: 30 faircure: 27 gorlak: 25 dcpat: 24 mazre: 21 poltergust: 20 brazil: 20 xbro: 18 swamped: 17 kyanrute: 16 stanleypalmtree: 16 zubz: 16 apollo: 15 splinter: 14 include: 14 nzjubjub: 11 rynam: 11 bladesymphony: 10 hom3land: 10 luxcommander: 10 necktochicken: 9 nin1000: 8 coolestspot: 6 oreomunsta: 4 ferg: 4 lone_prodigy: 3 briefs_cat: 2 hecht: 1 mysterious entity: 1 fireblend: 1

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Now that the ITAs have closed, I'm going back to my initial vote

Vote: Kawl

His behaviour, his admitted low effort posting, his trolling in D1 with the TD stuff, etc. All of it makes me feel either he's either not town or very unhelpful town and I'm leaning heavily towards Not Town.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Geno as scum given Vere and Grizzly flipped scum? Seems unlikely. Would scum Vere in event 1 name Geno as who he should’ve named if they’re both scum? Does Grizzly vote for scum Geno as his pick? WIFOM to an extent, but given how cautious scum have seemed I just don’t see it.
Examples?
 
WOW so Vere was scum. I read all of his responses to me as frustrated townie rather than rolling over scum. Really didn't see this coming.
 
He went after Verelios first on D1, 1.5 he was on Splinter, 1.8 on Grizzly (and on Verelios before he moved his vote), on Rynam and Verelios today

Ignoring his arguments, he has a flawless voting record that I don't think he's Scum. If he is scum, he must be really bold or doesn't care about his team mates at all.

You are only considering him a scum, he can be neutral too. Also scums weren't lucky today, he is smart enough to would have taken a gambit with his teammates not expecting what happened today.

Let's go chronological order though and correct me if I am wrong:

He only went after Vere because Vere considered giving him the penalty instead of the 4 others and he thought he could have been dead. So he valued his life more than 4 others. He was on Splinter? You mean the TD that never happened? Point me to actual content? Did he push him? No I just read that he wanted the lynch of TD to happen, so he didn't care for Melon or Splinter to die, coz he doesn't give a shit if either are town or not.

He only voted Grizzly when he started trolling like everyone else too. Ry was gonna get killed too and everyone was OK with it.

He refuses to engage in any arguments, so even if you assume he cannot be possible scum, it doesn't clear him from being a neutral. Also, I remember Zippenhead busing scummates and winning the entire game by himself coz nobody thought he would go that far.

Geno is crazy, just look at his HvV game, you are underestimating him if you think he can't do it.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Now that the ITAs have closed, I'm going back to my initial vote

Vote: Kawl

His behaviour, his admitted low effort posting, his trolling in D1 with the TD stuff, etc. All of it makes me feel either he's either not town or very unhelpful town and I'm leaning heavily towards Not Town.
I'm inclined to agree. I still don't like the timing of his fake gladiator claim - after going back over D1, it looked to me like an attempt to split the Grizzly vote. I also found the thinly veiled threat about not ITAing him dubious - which, as I mentioned before, is exactly why I used my shot on him.
VOTE: Kawl
 
I won't bother answering absurd arguments. Like how I didn't answer Verelios' and how I won't answer Terra's.
It's absurd to ask for a reason why you think I'm scum other than saying I've said something once before as scum? Get freaking real man. If that's your only logic, then that's some kind of trash, and it makes entirely no sense to call questioning such flimsy logic "absurd." Especially when as you have still yet to prove, it's not even accurate.

If you're town, get over yourself man. This is the same shitty reason you helped the scum team win in Berserk. You'd think you would have learned your lesson by now.
 
You are only considering him a scum, he can be neutral too.

Yeah, I should have said not town rather than not scum.

He refuses to engage in any arguments, so even if you assume he cannot be possible scum, it doesn't clear him from being a neutral.

I agree with this. But he also just seems to be the generally defensive type. It's pretty NAI to me because of that.

Geno is crazy, just look at his HvV game, you are underestimating him if you think he can't do it.

gdi, I need to read this HvV game at some point, the amount of references to it or people bringing it up. *notes down for later to do*
 
I'm inclined to agree. I still don't like the timing of his fake gladiator claim - after going back over D1, it looked to me like an attempt to split the Grizzly vote. I also found the thinly veiled threat about not ITAing him dubious - which, as I mentioned before, is exactly why I used my shot on him.
VOTE: Kawl
Split how? You think one scum player would attempt to split the vote between another scum player? I don't see it at all. Garners unnecessary attention, and it's not like Bear had a great role to begin with (especially being roleblocked and all).
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Split how? You think one scum player would attempt to split the vote between another scum player? I don't see it at all. Garners unnecessary attention, and it's not like Bear had a great role to begin with (especially being roleblocked and all).
Let's say - and this is all hypothetical, mind - that a number of players who were thinking of voting for Grizzly saw Kawl's play as a scum move and voted for him instead. That would reduce the total vote count on Grizzly. If there were to be enough traction on a town player at that point, then scum could have assisted with a train for them instead of one of their own, with Grizzly and Kawl's vote counts being low enough to overtake.

I'll concede that there's a fair amount of assuming in this idea, but I still don't like how Kawl acted then.
 
That day 1 shenanigans wasn't to the towns benefit. It served no other purpose then to confuse the .... out of everyone.


vote:Kawl
 
Let's say - and this is all hypothetical, mind - that a number of players who were thinking of voting for Grizzly saw Kawl's play as a scum move and voted for him instead. That would reduce the total vote count on Grizzly. If there were to be enough traction on a town player at that point, then scum could have assisted with a train for them instead of one of their own, with Grizzly and Kawl's vote counts being low enough to overtake.

I'll concede that there's a fair amount of assuming in this idea, but I still don't like how Kawl acted then.
The only other main votes at the time were Rynam and Vere (who we now know were both scum)... So you're saying a scum player would take away attention from three other scum players to also put himself up for bat as well. I just don't see it. Your hypothetical situation ignores what actually happened at the end of day 1.

And like I said, suspicion isn't going to magically drop from Bear even if he did survive. There's just too many holes to that line of logic considering what we now know about day 1.
 
Geno as scum given Vere and Grizzly flipped scum? Seems unlikely. Would scum Vere in event 1 name Geno as who he should’ve named if they’re both scum? Does Grizzly vote for scum Geno as his pick? WIFOM to an extent, but given how cautious scum have seemed I just don’t see it. What sticks out to me more now is who Vere did pick..and who he wanted to make a point to “regret” picking. In hindsight I think Vere was confused about what was happening, but I think his reasoning for why he picked Blade was the portion he lied about.

@BladeSymphony

VOTE: BladeSymphony
Vere is the only one that gives me pause, so I'll have to reread those interactions. The others would be easy busses I know I sure as hell would have been on if I were mafia.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
The only other main votes at the time were Rynam and Vere (who we now know were both scum)... So you're saying a scum player would take away attention from three other scum players to also put himself up for bat as well. I just don't see it. Your hypothetical situation ignores what actually happened at the end of day 1.

And like I said, suspicion isn't going to magically drop from Bear even if he did survive. There's just too many holes to that line of logic considering what we now know about day 1.
I may be right, I may be wrong, but it's still the way that I feel about the situation.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Examples?
We’re already not going to agree because we vastly disagree on Melon. Coming from my perspective of Melon being one of my higher town reads though, scum punt on the chance (or have too many MIA) to get a bonus lynch on Melon and instead go for no lynch. Scum don’t just super bus Vere or Rynam and because of that a third scum in Grizzly is lynched which could’ve been avoided by them being proactive. And in no way removes suspicion on the first two. I suspect the scum team has quite a few inactives/low activity players on it which is why their efforts have been lackluster.

I have to give Geno a second read it seems. He started the vote on Vere. Mhm
But the grizzly vote is as much lemming as it gets.
It’s not just who he voted for in my opinion though. I just don’t see the series of events that occurred in event 1 happening if Geno is also scum. Vere never makes that post if he is.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Mornin'

Gonna catch up but I saw Vere flipped Scum. Good work guys! Kinda crazy how our working shots have hit scum a majority of the time so far. :x
 
Who should I vote for now?

Kawl! I mean, he admitted he was going low effort and even said (iirc) he wouldn't be much help for town as an unhelpful townie. I think he's probably scum (or that one who's mission is to die, tanner? but that's unlikely as I feels he would have posted more if he was) but might as well get him out of the way anyway.

D1 stuff combined with his self admitted low effortness makes me feel he is scum.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
If you’re so unsold by a Vere lynch, why would you potentially invalidate the one counter wagon by casting shade on it and moving your vote? A counter wagon for someone you do scumread even.
OH I misread I’m on mobile, sorry. I really don’t like the way Lux jumped on that and it makes me wonder about Ynnek. Now I’m sitting through ITA to see where I want to finish the day. But I do like to leave vote data behind me on my suspects since no one lives forever.
 

Muffin

Born with a heart full of neutrality
Oh so we resolved the Vere situation. My read of him during the second ITA phase was accurate, nice. Good job town.

Back to my earlier lynch then.

VOTE: Kawl
 
Geno being outraged at completely reasonable suspicions being tossed his way is a pretty good fit with what got me thinking Zipped was scummy, its as good a place as any to move my vote to. Time to get stuck in and sort out a fully realised opinion of him.
 

Muffin

Born with a heart full of neutrality
Mysterious Entity shouldn't show up anymore, right people? Rynam created it D2, and Scum could still use it for the rest of the day, but without Rynam they can't create a new one at D3.
 
I may be right, I may be wrong, but it's still the way that I feel about the situation.
But you're flat out ignoring the actual events that transpired. Your explanation literally contradicts what happened since there was no other "town player" to jump to. If Kawl knocked off attention from Bear, Vere or Ry would have died instead. So save a roleblocked scum player who will still look bad day two, and sacrifice a role cop or whatever Rynam was...that's your standing? And Kawl did a VERY poor job by that logic for him to jump onto the role cop (Vere) in order to protect Bear for some reason...?

Just feels like you're not putting much thought into your vote at all.
 
Mysterious Entity shouldn't show up anymore, right people? Rynam created it D2, and Scum could still use it for the rest of the day, but without Rynam they can't create a new one at D3.

Probably, Sorian just said he left the game so unless there is another NPC creator, I think that's it for that.
 

Muffin

Born with a heart full of neutrality
Probably, Sorian just said he left the game so unless there is another NPC creator, I think that's it for that.
The entity missed right? How did it work again, it has the ITA probability of the whole scum team or something? Can't find Rynams description right now.

If so there aren't that many scummies anymore probably, unless they had real bad luck with that shot.
 
Glad someone offed Rynam! Good choice.
You've convinced me.
VOTE: melonrabbit

What in the world?

Seems like base ITA chance is 15%. Maybe if a group of us target a particular person, we'll have a better chance of killing them as opposed to all of us randomly shooting.

Anyone want to join my gang? Target to ve decided!

Join your gang?! How about no? And you only want us to focus on one person and not who we suspect to be scums? How about no freaking way.

I really don't like what I have seen from you thus far, you seem to just go with the flow.
 
The entity missed right? How did it work again, it has the ITA probability of the whole scum team or something? Can't find Rynams description right now.

If so there aren't that many scummies anymore probably, unless they had real bad luck with that shot.

It's whatever the Mafia's current chance is

what I take it to mean is, all scum have a base % to hit, So Mysterious Entity has that same base chance. Not the total of the scum team.
 

Muffin

Born with a heart full of neutrality
It's whatever the Mafia's current chance is

what I take it to mean is, all scum have a base % to hit, So Mysterious Entity has that same base chance. Not the total of the scum team.
Oh well then I remembered that wrong. Never mind.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Just feels like you're not putting much thought into your vote at all.
Maybe so, but let's have a look at the reasoning for your current vote:
Anyway, REALLY want to hop on Extreme Tactician for reasons I said before, but it'll only do so much if I go it alone. So I'll join the train on Mr. Runner-up.

VOTE: Ynnek
'Joining the train on Mr. Runner-up' doesn't exactly convey a great deal of thought either now, does it? At least I've made my reasons clear enough.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
OH I misread I’m on mobile, sorry. I really don’t like the way Lux jumped on that and it makes me wonder about Ynnek. Now I’m sitting through ITA to see where I want to finish the day. But I do like to leave vote data behind me on my suspects since no one lives forever.
Just was curious if your perception on Ynnek has changed or if you scumread Lux more than Ynnek.

I’m pretty busy today, but I do want to go back and look at who all took ITAs and at who today or during the next night phase if I run out of time.

I’m also mulling over if it’s scummy to have been present today but never have shot or if it’s townie to be too indecisive/meek to shoot or if it’s complete WIFOM.
 
Top Bottom