Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

Do you already know who you want to lynch today? Is there somebody who you absolutely don't want to lynch?
I don't want to lynch Geno, Natiko, Kawl, Ynnek, Zipped, Zeke because I feel pretty firmly they're town. Monkey has fallen down my town list a little since learning that Grizzly wasn't the only scum train d1, but I'm still reading her Grizzly push as very town. Wouldn't want to lynch her today. I also find myself mostly liking and agreeing with Sawneeks' logic, adding Include's arguing w/ her/suspicions of her I'm leaning town there as well.

Blarg has mostly just been asking questions, I don't mind his lynch. His Geno vote a while back also bothers me, but it kinda bothered me just in general that people were still going hard at Geno when at least to me the first event's resulting stuff pointed strongly to him being town. Looks even worse in retrospect since Include was pushing there as well. Nzjubjub's defense of Include and going after Geno is also notable to me, I'm not against his lynch. I was suspicious of Blade but the claim gives me pause, I'd rather give him another day to see how that plays out. I also had some suspicion of Extreme and Lux, but Lux's claim and Extreme being more open and engaged is giving me townie feels.

Just made a full read list since I was already halfway there:
Town: Geno, Natiko, Kawl, Ynnek, Zeke, Zipped
Town leaning: Sawneeks, Monkey, Lux, Gorlak, Extreme, Melon, Stan, Alexem, Brazil, Poltergust, Fandorin
Not sure: briefs_cat, rac, Blade, DC, Muffin, LP, Coolest, oreo, Kalor, Swamped
Scum leaning: NZjubjub, Zubz, Blarg, Chicken

Some of those aren't the researched the best besides just agreeing with cases made against or just my #feels since there are so many players though.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Potentially getting another kill from Splinters shot could have been helpful for scum but there's something to be said for being the first person to post a shot and it hitting town. If Zeke was scum and wanted to gain town cred, I feel like it looks better if you're the first person to post and also removes this line of thinking but in reverse (Zeke being scum but waiting until Splinter shot to maybe get another town kill).
Have you looked at the TD event and how it unfolded?
 
I was going by Muffin's line of thought myself at the start of this day, but someone pointed out how easy it would be to track back this power.
Nerfing scum shots to miss (Apollo could self-target, he missed Vere) could be possible as well. Or the boosted one didn't shoot at all. There are possibilities.

To be absolutely clear, we had 4 hits during D2.

Zeke hit Splinter
Mazre hit Zipped (he already had 100% accuracy)
Terra hit Trigger (dead, flipped town)
ET hit Vere

We had Hecht who could've boosted someone during N1 to 100% as well - he left no crumbs.

I've come around on ET, I do not believe he is scum. He's looking for advice and easily following it. He could be pocketing me, but I think he'd rather go into the scum chat instead of displaying it here.

@Fandorin

I'd say if Zeke was scum and this was a setup, they'd still let Splinter shoot first and try to get another townie (even if it's only 15%). Zeke already claimed being shot this night. I'm willing to wait it out in this case.

I'm not opposed to testing ET, we killed enough scum to have some leverage. But my opinion is that he's not scum and I'd not actively pursue this lead.

Didn't think about the self nerf for town cred.... might be coming around on this use.

Seems scum had 4 kills at N1, which is a damn lot, and no one really knew how messy the ITA events would have been. Could be Apollo went conservative and chose the nerf instead. Hard to say at this point.

Not really a lead worth following to me. ET remains scummy in his own merit to me.
 

Muffin

Born with a heart full of neutrality
I don't want to lynch Geno, Natiko, Kawl, Ynnek, Zipped, Zeke because I feel pretty firmly they're town. Monkey has fallen down my town list a little since learning that Grizzly wasn't the only scum train d1, but I'm still reading her Grizzly push as very town. Wouldn't want to lynch her today. I also find myself mostly liking and agreeing with Sawneeks' logic, adding Include's arguing w/ her/suspicions of her I'm leaning town there as well.

Blarg has mostly just been asking questions, I don't mind his lynch. His Geno vote a while back also bothers me, but it kinda bothered me just in general that people were still going hard at Geno when at least to me the first event's resulting stuff pointed strongly to him being town. Looks even worse in retrospect since Include was pushing there as well. Nzjubjub's defense of Include and going after Geno is also notable to me, I'm not against his lynch. I was suspicious of Blade but the claim gives me pause, I'd rather give him another day to see how that plays out. I also had some suspicion of Extreme and Lux, but Lux's claim and Extreme being more open and engaged is giving me townie feels.

Just made a full read list since I was already halfway there:
Town: Geno, Natiko, Kawl, Ynnek, Zeke, Zipped
Town leaning: Sawneeks, Monkey, Lux, Gorlak, Extreme, Melon, Stan, Alexem, Brazil, Poltergust, Fandorin
Not sure: briefs_cat, rac, Blade, DC, Muffin, LP, Coolest, oreo, Kalor, Swamped
Scum leaning: NZjubjub, Zubz, Blarg, Chicken

Some of those aren't the researched the best besides just agreeing with cases made against or just my #feels since there are so many players though.
Hm, interesting. What makes you town read Zeke in particular? I have a blind spot there.

And I see people scumread Blarg, what's the reason for that? I did notice that Blarg is more passive than the last time I played with him, but besides that Blarg seems normal.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I'll start with Natiko's post on me since its the biggest and so will probably encompass a few of the others too.

I can't expect people to remember me given how little impact I've had on the games I've played, but I have and will always feel that a player should be allowed some leeway in order to give them the opportunity to play. So if anyone subs in or is having trouble finding the time to play then I want to give them the benefit of the doubt for a few days to give them the opportunity to get stuck in and start playing the game in earnest.

Responding to this because it'd be weird to just leave out one of the sections: Not much to say apart from that I didn't intend to end up in a tunnel, that was just how it played out.

You're right in that I'd typed that before Verelios' flip was posted. The reason I said "I don't think I'll be taking that shot" was that it was my first time being present for an ITA phase and I couldn't remember if flips came during or after the phase. I assumed after and was wrong.

Geno had come onto my radar as a result of his freaking out over Terraforce on day 1, I decided not to pursue that read as he was high-profile enough that he'd certainly be getting looked at by a number of other players. I felt safe shelving any reads on him to start limiting the number of players I was actively reading to try stop myself from being overwhelmed by the size of the game. Include's shot reminded me that I wasn't entirely without a scumread after Zipped turned out to be a bad read. Fair enough if you think I'm making that shit up though.

The reason is valid and I will not apologise for finding it. Also, there was no way I was going to stay up until 9 or 10 AM doing for Geno what I'd done for Zipped.

On day 2 my Zipped tunnel became a crutch for me, when that was kicked out from under me I fell back on an old Geno feeling and Include being in my Town pile. Having that fall through as well left me seriously disoriented.

I'll go back through the thread and answer each of the other posts directed at me.
Your explanations are okay, not great though. I find it interesting that you admit to being disoriented on where your thoughts lie, yet you prioritize trying to defend yourself over solidifying more reads. I'd still peg you as my largest scum read.

So why is he not scum? I'd argue this is pretty scummy behaviour?

On another note most of us agree Monkey isn't scummy? Where does this come from? I don't even see her on any of your read lists?
My general impression of Monkey is that she hasn't done anything that overtly pings my radar as scum, so she's probably town. She has waffled and hedged, but I would bet there isn't a single game she's played that don't feature those same things.

That is Blarg throwing opinions out there and see what sticks. This is actually one thing he does as town as well. But he's not following up on it at all. You can only be sure that he scumreads someone, when he's further interrogating, which is completely missing so far.
I do see the case on Blarg. I feel like town Blarg tends to push harder against people than I've seen this game. My only hesitation is the long disappearing act to start the game. I could do with an ISO of him too, but right now I'll be hard pressed to get out one today let alone multiple. From memory though while I could scum lean him I feel the case on JubJub is better.
 
@melonrabbit and @EzekelRAGE I feel like you'll be starting to clutter the thread. Nothing has changed from the previous arguments. The stances are clear and you won't convince the other in any way. Please use your energy in another way to help us find scum.
 
You know, if people are suspicious of me, I'll just let them be. I'll just use my futute actions as proof I ain't scum.

Anyway, good night! I have to wake up early to do grocery shopping, so I might make it to the end of the day phase.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Hm, interesting. What makes you town read Zeke in particular? I have a blind spot there.
Why would any scum do what he's doing? Note Grizzly only got focused in on Stu that hard after he was a lynch candidate. Ezekel is not.
It puts a huge amount of attention on him and it requires a ton of work to trace these connections.

Not to mention he actually did shoot Splinter, who was not a lynch candidate at the time, so it wasn't just getting cred from the inevitable.

So let me turn this on you: what reason do you have to scumread him? Or what's causing your blindspot?
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
And it's semi-backed by Zipped getting no result on his action.
@EzekelRAGE - LuxCommander claimed to have heard Zipped being jailed:

As for the bolded, I gave my opinion on that yesterday.

It's not to do with examples of behaviour - it's the fact that I could apply the bussing logic with regards to Splinter as much to Melon as I could to you in my eyes. That was my view of the situation, take it or leave it.

How do we know it was a jailer? I guess what im asking is how does @LuxCommander power work? I may have missed it. Is he a watcher?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Why would any scum do what he's doing? Note Grizzly only got focused in on Stu that hard after he was a lynch candidate. Ezekel is not.
It puts a huge amount of attention on him and it requires a ton of work to trace these connections.
(side note: I don't know that I agree on the whole melon conspiracy - but I don't think melon's doing much to push the game either so I'm ambivalent over the whole thing. I just don't read scum motivations on Zeke's actions at all.)
 
Blarg's wagon is pretty bad to me. Might be missing some of the more compelling posts on it, but from what I've seen the case against him is mostly meta based, which I'll be trying to avoid at my best after the ass whopping we had on Power Rangers Mafia.
 
I usually get an incredible feeling of earnestness in every town!faircure post. Even though I was scum in HvV, I think the way she posted there made it incredibly obvious that she was town, for example.

I'm not getting that strong feeling in this game. She seems more subdued in how she presents her arguments and prods (even though she's still prodding, which is a good sign), not really going at great lengths to explain her reasonings and all that.
Her somewhat weird vanilla claim fits with the way she usually presents information about herself as a townie, though.

I guess I'm leaning town on her, but also staying open to the possibility that this subdued faircure could be my first contact with scum!faircure.
If it helps I'm pretty sure I was just so earnest in the past because in Buffy I felt like I had something to prove as a brand new player coming in at the end of the game, and in HvV I was frustrated about the justified suspicion about my role that I couldn't dispel because none of my actions were panning out. So I just had to resort to "please please believe me I don't understand what's happening" lol
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
@melonrabbit and @EzekelRAGE I feel like you'll be starting to clutter the thread. Nothing has changed from the previous arguments. The stances are clear and you won't convince the other in any way. Please use your energy in another way to help us find scum.
1. Why would I try to convince her of anything if I think she is scum?
2. I didn't bring it up @Alexem and @melonrabbit did. Which I found odd.

I have repeatedly asked you to explain your theory. You have dodged my questions or say "scum won't" in response..
Melon even asks me to explain my theory again. Idk what they are getting at.

All I asked melon to do is post the questions she wanted me to answer.
 

Muffin

Born with a heart full of neutrality
Why would any scum do what he's doing? Note Grizzly only got focused in on Stu that hard after he was a lynch candidate. Ezekel is not.
It puts a huge amount of attention on him and it requires a ton of work to trace these connections.

Not to mention he actually did shoot Splinter, who was not a lynch candidate at the time, so it wasn't just getting cred from the inevitable.

So let me turn this on you: what reason do you have to scumread him? Or what's causing your blindspot?
I do not know how you manage to read so much into my posts that isn't there. I don't scumread him. I said I have a blindspot there. I know he was one of the shots, and a rather unlikely target for the scum boost, but I thought Faircures opinion maybe wasn't based on only that. Because besides the shot I don't have much on Zeke besides seeming to tunnel Natiko for a while.
 
Hm, interesting. What makes you town read Zeke in particular? I have a blind spot there.

And I see people scumread Blarg, what's the reason for that? I did notice that Blarg is more passive than the last time I played with him, but besides that Blarg seems normal.
Blarg shows up, makes some noise with shallow questions that he could find the answers to by reading the thread, and then goes away.
 

Realized midway that my read lists sucks and that big posts in this game make me lazy, but some reads.
Extreme - Hard gut feeling since before I joined the game. Posts are unsubstantial overall, and here and there we get this weird confusing post that doesn't make much sense. Fits what I expect from a new player playing scum (this is his second game right?). Didn't like his reactions to Include, especially in contrast to Gorlak's posts.
 

Muffin

Born with a heart full of neutrality
Blarg shows up, makes some noise with shallow questions that he could find the answers to by reading the thread, and then goes away.
I'll need to reread Blarg. In my memory this didn't happen as often as your post makes it sound.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
So I just had to resort to "please please believe me I don't understand what's happening" lol
this made me laugh and seems accurate to that crazy situation

I do not know how you manage to read so much into my posts that isn't there. I don't scumread him. I said I have a blindspot there. I know he was one of the shots, and a rather unlikely target for the scum boost, but I thought Faircures opinion maybe wasn't based on only that. Because besides the shot I don't have much on Zeke besides seeming to tunnel Natiko for a while.
(the bolded) Seems a bit disingenuous considering I didn't accuse you but instead asked why and gave either option. I find it odd that your biggest idea of Zeke is "seeming to tunnel on Natiko" for a while, though, unless you're not saying that's the only thing - because it's sure not the thing he's most concerned himself with.

So I can't figure if you're just being really defensive or unclear and it's resulting in these odd little "fights" wherein you have to clarify. You had one yesterday, too.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
That's the thing. With Include's flip and her ability to make someone get a no result for the rest of the game.

I guess the question is do we trust @LuxCommander
At this point in time, personally, I don't see any reason not to. It's simpler to believe Lux than to construct a chain based on chance that provides the link between Include and the person Zipped checked. Other factors may change this later.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
That's the thing. With Include's flip and her ability to make someone get a no result for the rest of the game.

I guess the question is do we trust @LuxCommander
That's a valid point, I hadn't considered that ability. But how would Lux know he was targeted by Zipped? Just a guess based on the result?
 
What's the benefit of Lux revealing anymore info _today_?

Even if it turns out that melon was invalidated, that tells us nothing about her alignment or anything.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
That's a valid point, I hadn't considered that ability. But how would Lux know he was targeted by Zipped? Just a guess based on the result?
Was just another theory I was thinking of.

Either way would need to how lux's power works. And Lux wouldnt have been the target btw.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
An event is starting

This event will only be taking 7 people and will not run until all spaces are filled. The activity requirement for this event is very low (players will not be directly interacting ). Please use the command JOIN to join this event.
 
I was specifically referring to melon's alignment because that's what Zeke wants to know.

There is no reason to distrust Lux (for now). Any worthwhile info he would've already shared. Revealing his power and how it works now only benefits scum.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I was specifically referring to melon's alignment because that's what Zeke wants to know.

There is no reason to distrust Lux (for now). Any worthwhile info he would've already shared. Revealing his power and how it works now only benefits scum.
oh, gotcha, sorry - looked like you were talking about Lux
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Looks like I'm late. Probably for the best since a meeting is starting.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
SIGN UPS CLOSED

Only took the first 7 so Muffin isn’t in.
 

rac

whatever
anyways

Might as well follow through.

Dogweld: Lone Stranger

people were getting shade for not using their shot, is this supposed to count?

reads as afraid to me

let me try and simplify chicken's actions in the game

chose to shoot at rynam when the choices were rynam v. vere

didn't vote rynam?

when we had to choose between a red check include or a naticko switch, questioned ynnek's alighnment while itas were popping off then quickly backed off that question
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
people were getting shade for not using their shot, is this supposed to count?

reads as afraid to me
Is town more likely to be afraid or is a rapidly dwindling scum team more likely to be cautious and not call attention? Not many safe targets during that ITA. Also why I'm salty at the people who shot Nomad over super low posters.
 
Is town more likely to be afraid or is a rapidly dwindling scum team more likely to be cautious and not call attention? Not many safe targets during that ITA. Also why I'm salty at the people who shot Nomad over super low posters.

I think second is more likely, after all, town is way ahead right? Doubt there could be more then one or two scums by prior calculations in this thread
 
Hm, interesting. What makes you town read Zeke in particular? I have a blind spot there.

And I see people scumread Blarg, what's the reason for that? I did notice that Blarg is more passive than the last time I played with him, but besides that Blarg seems normal.
The shot on Splinter, I guess it could be a desperate bus after three scum wagons D1 but he was a really important scum role in my eyes. Plus his general tunneling is taking a lot of work and engagement and reads townie to me.

I've only played with Blarg briefly as scum but I feel like he acted similarly to how he is here. Plus all the weird easy questions and all his votes have been on people I read as town: Kawl, Geno, Zeke, Gorlak
 
I've only played with Blarg briefly as scum but I feel like he acted similarly to how he is here. Plus all the weird easy questions and all his votes have been on people I read as town: Kawl, Geno, Zeke, Gorlak
Oops, Natiko too. Didn't scroll up far enough on the vote tool.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
I think second is more likely, after all, town is way ahead right? Doubt there could be more then one or two scums by prior calculations in this thread
I've been working with the idea that there could be anywhere between ten and fifteen anti-town players - scum or otherwise. Just an estimate.
 

melonrabbit

The only good kind of melon
@melonrabbit and @EzekelRAGE I feel like you'll be starting to clutter the thread. Nothing has changed from the previous arguments. The stances are clear and you won't convince the other in any way. Please use your energy in another way to help us find scum.

He was the one to re-reminded everyone that he hasn't forgotten me despite everything else far more pushing. I only responded because he @'d me but that was probably a mistake.

I am been trying me best to focus on others but considering Zeke and yourself continue the circles it is quite difficult.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
He was the one to re-reminded everyone that he hasn't forgotten me despite everything else far more pushing. I only responded because he @'d me but that was probably a mistake.

I am been trying me best to focus on others but considering Zeke and yourself continue the circles it is quite difficult.
So your goin to ignore the post?
 
thats what the last one was called right
The mysterious entity's soul purpose was ITA. Could not be voted or interacted with, if I recall correctly.

Lone Stranger can be voted, ITAed or talked to. I don't see them as the same.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
The Greed event has ended and is now publicly viewable in the galactic arena. Results will not be posted by me but there is no stipulation on what players wish to discuss.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
^ I've answered you enough for today.

And clearly others agree.
You accuse me of dodging quesitons and avoiding you. Then conveniently enough when I ask you to back it up with facts/posts you bail. Also you really havent answer me at all today. For the most part I've been ignoring you directly and letting Gorlak see what he can get from you.

@EzekelRAGE What do you think about ET currently?
Think we are hinging too much on the hit itas and connecting that to scum ita booster. Nothing has really stuck out to me so far this day phase. Wouldnt mind checking @Alexem @NZJubJub @LuxCommander out more.
 
All I know is out there; I've not been hiding anything from you all. My powers have their limits; ironically they suit the flavor far more than they were supposed to, which is even funnier when you consider that the name of character and power contradict themselves.

Reminds me, I still need to put a proper vote down. I'm not particularly concerned by Blarg being the lead, but I feel like @NZJubJub's posting behavior is setting off alarms to me. I'm strapped for time, so I can't crawl through and point out specific posts, but a quick glance through his post history will show what I'm getting at.

VOTE: NZJubJub

I'll be back to mostly quiet due to work, but I'll try to monitor and post brief messages if I can.
 
Re: Greed (Event 6)

I got an item and am willing to reveal it. I was expecting that no town would sacrifice, so I'm leaning towards scum being within this player group.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Now that it's over, can I just say that as soon as I saw the event was called Greed, the first thing that I thought of was the Addams Family pinball table. Nothing to do with the game, but I just didn't want to be the only one with that in my head.
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
Re: Greed (Event 6)

I got an item and am willing to reveal it. I was expecting that no town would sacrifice, so I'm leaning towards scum being within this player group.

I could see town sacrificing their role, depending on what it was. Maybe it was limited or outlived its usefulness. There's no guarantee that town would get the other items but a role cop, 100% ITA and reflect could be useful in town hands. I do agree with you that scum are probably more likely to sacrifice their role to get items, particularly 1 and 3.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
All I know is out there; I've not been hiding anything from you all. My powers have their limits; ironically they suit the flavor far more than they were supposed to, which is even funnier when you consider that the name of character and power contradict themselves.

Reminds me, I still need to put a proper vote down. I'm not particularly concerned by Blarg being the lead, but I feel like @NZJubJub's posting behavior is setting off alarms to me. I'm strapped for time, so I can't crawl through and point out specific posts, but a quick glance through his post history will show what I'm getting at.

VOTE: NZJubJub

I'll be back to mostly quiet due to work, but I'll try to monitor and post brief messages if I can.
I really wonder if you just have the worst case of APPEARS WILDLY SCUMMY disease. You had it in the mini too and here you have a fair claim on the board but literally everything else you've done has seemed SO entirely scummy that it pulls me all the way back around to assuming you're town because it's too blatant.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Re: Greed (Event 6)

I got an item and am willing to reveal it. I was expecting that no town would sacrifice, so I'm leaning towards scum being within this player group.
Why wouldn't a town player sacrifice? I would if I had a power. Unless it's like a really amazing power, powers only take town so far.

I asked for the cop check. Ironically, I wanted to use it on you.
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
Why wouldn't a town player sacrifice? I would if I had a power. Unless it's like a really amazing power, powers only take town so far.

I asked for the cop check. Ironically, I wanted to use it on you.

I assume you didn't get it then?
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
I'll say that I didn't sacrifice - if I had, I'd have been modkilled, so I didn't exactly have much choice on that one.
 
I'd argue the items aren't that great. I don't see the reason why as town you would sacrifice. There was much more to win for scum in these choices. 1 and 3 are extra kills and the obvious things scum would go for. 4 is the only truly useful for town and was also likely to be requested by scum to make sure it's unavailable.

I got the redirect since I wanted to disable scum going for a less obvious item - and I wanted to prevent fuckery with the known info roles so far.
 
Top Bottom