Spectator Thread Marvel Heroes Spec Thread - The Half That Hates Me

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Did he already use his shot on her?

He used his event reward to shoot her last night. As stated in the thread WHICH HE KNEW AND FELT LIKE GAMBLING AGAINST ANYWAY, she had a BP from Blarg

This tunnel has no end and I love it.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
*snicker*

Ezekel: "Blarg can someone else confirm your bulletproof gifting?"

Blarg is about to play mind games with an opponent who has no chance of understanding.
 
I don't think 2 town RC out of 50 is that unreasonable.

However, I think Vere's defense includes both "you're lying!" and "why yes I am a role cop, thank you for asking"

He's improved his defense recently but it looks like it's too late.
This right here is why I debated even mentioning my role check until I did.

Also can I get spoilers on who I checked last night? I want to know what their role is
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Thanks! Such a nice game runner!

Enjoyed the game thanks for the madness. Glad I decided to play instead of quit yesterday

I'm still astounded that you plucked out your mirror role out of a list of, what 47 at that point?
 

Verelios

Were-elios
I'm still astounded that you plucked out your mirror role out of a list of, what 47 at that point?
Had me like
9dbc88fa38aa373d63d9b3683d9c70bf.gif
 

CrimsonFist

Neutral Vanilla
Does anyone else have an issue where if you click the arrow in a quote in the game thread to jump to the quoted comment, it won't do anything?

It works fine for me in this thread, just not the game thread.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Does anyone else have an issue where if you click the arrow in a quote in the game thread to jump to the quoted comment, it won't do anything?

It works fine for me in this thread, just not the game thread.

I've gotten it as well, not sure what's caused it.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Something about the main games flow seems...off right now? As if they're actually trying to catch scum.
tumblr_o6ftbqx7xU1qij8uso4_540.gif


So weird.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
I would never put a speech altering mechanic in my games amateur hour over here.
 

Apollo

Apollo will wreck your goddamn face
“Lone Survivor”

If there aren’t 8 deaths by the end of this ill riot
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
“Lone Survivor”

If there aren’t 8 deaths by the end of this ill riot

I don't actually have another death minigame planned for awhile. The kill count in this game is back on track imo.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
These two duking it out for this specific prize is pretty good, I have to admit.
 

Apollo

Apollo will wreck your goddamn face
Looking forward to the argument that Fandorin must be scum for passing right before the BOOM on all 3 lol
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
The winner of this event is deathproof for one day and night phase. They can not be killed by any means including strong kills or lynches. If lynched, the person in second place will die instead
 
The winner of this event is deathproof for one day and night phase. They can not be killed by any means including strong kills or lynches. If lynched, the person in second place will die instead
And now they won't ever be shot or lynched all day and night today, wasting the deathproof. :D
 
I'm so happy that I insisted on letting Melon lives, now Zeke tunnel is creating so much noise that my dear scummies can take a break.

Sorry Melon, you are a tunnel magnet for those who never played with you before. Buy Hey look at the bright side, I tried to defend you from him in the game thread and so did many others which may or may not have enabled him further like it did for me on Buffy... Actually never mind my attempts at defending may be worse for you at this point :(

What happened to DC he got killed? Hmm gotta check day end and start. Man, I wish I can follow the game but I can't, and just hoping by isn't cutting it at all. How can someone people just jump in and catch up? it's impossible when busy.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
I'm so happy that I insisted on letting Melon lives, now Zeke tunnel is creating so much noise that my dear scummies can take a break.

Sorry Melon, you are a tunnel magnet for those who never played with you before. Buy Hey look at the bright side, I tried to defend you from him in the game thread and so did many others which may or may not have enabled him further like it did for me on Buffy... Actually never mind my attempts at defending may be worse for you at this point :(

What happened to DC he got killed? Hmm gotta check day end and start. Man, I wish I can follow the game but I can't, and just hoping by isn't cutting it at all. How can someone people just jump in and catch up? it's impossible when busy.
DC caught a bullet in the night from Blade =(
 
So from reading the thread here, these are the remaining scum:

Natiko, Lone_Prodigy, Fandorin, Coolest Spot, Extreme Tactician(?) - who are the other 2?

I knew something was up with Nat. That read vomit was strange, did he do that before? Huge posts, lot of quotes and nothing he'd follow up on? Also him not saying anything towards Blade when he supposedly watched him caught my attention over night.

Did Nat send in an action this night? My redirect was a coin flip between Saw and Nat. In the end I thought Nat was too hot after D3 and that he would keep his head down if scum.

I'll never play a game without post requirement ever again. LP is the absolute worst. That's a huge fuck you to everyone trying to play from him. I'm disappointed.

So ET really is scum? He's playing the newbie card well. But others were suspicious, they'll get to him. Don't know about Spot though.

And Hecht nailed scum D1, huh? Grizz, Nat and Xbro. I knew I should've followed up on that more.

I stand by my choice for Alexem. "I wanted to draw the nk, so I claimed vanilla..." @Stuart444 Monkey was insistent that Alex usually says bye, and in that I trusted her (one of the few times). Someone saying "I was on a train" is a running gag and gets you nowhere. Tell me where that obvious lynch was hanging D3 which town so obviously towned.

Actually for everyone are there any fatal flaws that town committed so far? Give me some spec hindsight, which scum was not looked at, yet deserved to be lynched long ago?
 
Re: rac and lone stranger

Rac posted and was completely ignored. That lone stranger vote OBVIOUSLY was made to bring attention to rac. I only went a step ahead and asked why that happened.
 

Apollo

Apollo will wreck your goddamn face
Also for @Gorlak

Natiko did not submit an action last night. And I find this amusing since you’re upset with L_P, but he’s actually the one who wrote the flavor for your death lol.
 

Splinter

Lord of Volcano Island
I'll never play a game without post requirement ever again. LP is the absolute worst. That's a huge fuck you to everyone trying to play from him. I'm disappointed.
Yeah it's bullshit, and not the first time he's been more active in the scum thread than game thread.
 
Someone saying "I was on a train" is a running gag and gets you nowhere. Tell me where that obvious lynch was hanging D3 which town so obviously towned.

I'll believe anyone who says there is an irl reason for them being gone.

As for lynches, there was plenty of scum options.

Could have gone with Extreme (who seems to have been forgotten about despite being a viable option earlier on), Nat (who I tried to make sure people know Includes flip would not clear him) or Coolest who is acting weird and ballsy at some points (including now imo XD)

Could have also pushed towards JubJub though they have now flipped Town, they seemed weird enough to me that I would have risked a lynch on them.

Regardless, Alexem seemed genuine enough to me so I would have quite happily defended them until the end if I didn't die ;_;
 
COME THE FUCK ON
this can't be true. ducking out after such a fatal mistake to increase scum chances is on the same shameful level as LP boycotting the game principle
wow

What do you mean here? I feel like I'm missing something o.o
 

Splinter

Lord of Volcano Island
COME THE FUCK ON
this can't be true. ducking out after such a fatal mistake to increase scum chances is on the same shameful level as LP boycotting the game principle
wow
Actually he was going to be busy the rest of the week. I don't remember what with.

IIRC he was talking about subbing out before the shot happened, and he didn't intentionally shoot at the green check.
 
AWW. Zeke died.

I really wanted to see Melon die first. :( (Sorry Melon but I wanted the reaction in the game thread from it)
 

Apollo

Apollo will wreck your goddamn face
Scum is sooo screwed. CS is 90% a dead man walking for this Groot thing gets called out, and Kalor LP and ET are all super ITAble if not lynchable.


scum calling out scum that tried to ita scum... *head spins*

lol
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Yeah, hom3land didn't do anything egregious. He was going to be busy all week and I told him to continue playing until I had a replacement. That shot on Kawl was 100% hadn't caught up on the thread.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Natiko did do great. I think more shots were heading his way if Geno had missed to be honest though.
 

Apollo

Apollo will wreck your goddamn face
i was going to say ITA shots are clearly biased against scum but then i remembered that we’ve used them all on ourselves
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
5 unboosted hits so far 3 scum, 2 town and one of those was scum shooting scum. Seems fair :P

Not counting Mazre or
Kawl
who had role related internal increases.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Also when the lovers get here, props to heymonkey for having so much patience with Zeke's tunnel on melon far after she had actually stopped scumreading melon lol
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
With Monkey-Zeke-Natiko dying at the same time, this game will become lot less active.
 
Last edited:

Splinter

Lord of Volcano Island
I think the whole ITA mechanic is a lot harder for scum to handle to be fair. If you only shoot town you risk destroying your chances in end game, but to shoot scum you have to either spend PRs or risk the 15%

Meanwhile you have to be townread by EVERYONE or you're always gonna be at risk of a stray ITA (see: me), but as scum you usually don't want to be totally townread or your survival becomes suspicious.

We had limited PRs that could protect us from the mechanic, and even using those reduced our killing potential.

I'm not saying the game was unbalanced (I think we played too badly to ever know that), just that this mechanic would always be difficult for scum and I'm not really sure how we should have handled it.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
I assume the mid range posters will now pick up slack. Brazil, Poltergust, Fandorin. Also, oreo seems more involved now
 
So from reading the thread here, these are the remaining scum:

Natiko, Lone_Prodigy, Fandorin, Coolest Spot, Extreme Tactician(?) - who are the other 2?

I knew something was up with Nat. That read vomit was strange, did he do that before? Huge posts, lot of quotes and nothing he'd follow up on? Also him not saying anything towards Blade when he supposedly watched him caught my attention over night.

Did Nat send in an action this night? My redirect was a coin flip between Saw and Nat. In the end I thought Nat was too hot after D3 and that he would keep his head down if scum.

I'll never play a game without post requirement ever again. LP is the absolute worst. That's a huge fuck you to everyone trying to play from him. I'm disappointed.

So ET really is scum? He's playing the newbie card well. But others were suspicious, they'll get to him. Don't know about Spot though.

And Hecht nailed scum D1, huh? Grizz, Nat and Xbro. I knew I should've followed up on that more.

I stand by my choice for Alexem. "I wanted to draw the nk, so I claimed vanilla..." @Stuart444 Monkey was insistent that Alex usually says bye, and in that I trusted her (one of the few times). Someone saying "I was on a train" is a running gag and gets you nowhere. Tell me where that obvious lynch was hanging D3 which town so obviously towned.

Actually for everyone are there any fatal flaws that town committed so far? Give me some spec hindsight, which scum was not looked at, yet deserved to be lynched long ago?

I told you guys about Nat but y'all did not trust me! I'm still hurt :(
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
I think the whole ITA mechanic is a lot harder for scum to handle to be fair. If you only shoot town you risk destroying your chances in end game, but to shoot scum you have to either spend PRs or risk the 15%

Meanwhile you have to be townread by EVERYONE or you're always gonna be at risk of a stray ITA (see: me), but as scum you usually don't want to be totally townread or your survival becomes suspicious.

We had limited PRs that could protect us from the mechanic, and even using those reduced our killing potential.

I'm not saying the game was unbalanced (I think we played too badly to ever know that), just that this mechanic would always be difficult for scum and I'm not really sure how we should have handled it.

I was talking somewhere else (mod chat for this game I think?) and was commenting on how when I watch these played elsewhere, scum usually has the advantage since they are a power block that can all shoot and plan together. The reason why I thought this would be good to bring to this community is because we are always so different from the norm and I figured our bussing culture would level that playing field a bit (and it ended up tipping it even more). As far as the right way to play, anecdotally, the best run I saw of one of these was where scum had one dedicated busser for the whole game and everyone else on the team played it straight. That busser went after town a few times too but the rest of the team only did town and they found success with that. So much is going on that bussing has very limited effect in a game this size.

That said, games this big are meant to be more spectacular affairs with oddities happening left and right (see your death immediately for no rhyme or reason). Trying to do a 50 player game of straight mafia probably isn't the commitment this community is looking for due to the time that would really take.

.....

All that to say that I hope people are at least having fun :V
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Oh @Gorlak I just noticed that question since Include quoted you

No Nat would have also been miss in terms of your item power
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
I've had fun. I don't like heavy RNG (which ITA is), but but the concept is worth trying.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Is our Mafia community much more bussier than others? o.o

Oh absolutely and I’ll take some blame for that since I found a lot of success with it early on in our meta but for awhile a lot of people who heavily bussed were able to coast to end game.
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Bussing has been really effective in the community. Maybe this game shifts that slightly.
 

Splinter

Lord of Volcano Island
So much is going on that bussing has very limited effect in a game this size.
I mostly agree. But when most of the game has flipped if you see a pattern of scum ONLY shooting town then chances are you can work out the remaining scum.

I guess that's why the strategy of having just one busser worked so well.
 
Top Bottom