Spectator Thread Chain of Sleep Dream Drop Re:Coded Over Two Days Union Fragmentary Deep Dive Point Final Mix HD
- Thread starter The Bear
- Start date
Zeke is too stubborn. x.x
Ok, stu is rather sad irl now :(
Zeke and Coolest are going to such an earful from me after this game. Fuck it is infuriating watching these two play.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I don't think he was insulting Muffin anywhere in the thread, so I hope he doesn't really think he was going too far there.
I don't think he was either but you see his latest post. Stu doesn't like upsetting people.
fucking do it zeke
This is great lol.
I'm so disappointed in CS. What a waste of a confirmed town player.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Oh wait yeah lol nvm. I was thinking differently.
Thank you for doing the work coolest ;-; /salute
Zeke JFC
CS you at least did your job in the end
CS you at least did your job in the end
he should
zeke has to be the dumbest player I have seen in mafia so far
like christ he has his moment and he fucks it up so bad
zeke has to be the dumbest player I have seen in mafia so far
like christ he has his moment and he fucks it up so bad
I like Zekes stubbornness (Hi Marvel Mafia Zeke) I admit but sometimes watching him is frustrating. Especially this time.
So:
5-1, stu dies, 4-1.
Stu has set everything up so town can win. please town.
5-1, stu dies, 4-1.
Stu has set everything up so town can win. please town.
urgh, messed that up.
it'd be 3-1 after the NK
Town should win. it's officially mylo
it'd be 3-1 after the NK
Town should win. it's officially mylo
I'm happy the day starts tomorrow and not the day after.
I wonder if they will turbo? Zeke is confirmed now so it's down to Gry and Nat to convince Zeke of Muffin over Nat.
Shouldn't be too difficult I hope
(I'm assuming Stu will die as he is the cause of scums current predicament)
I wonder if they will turbo? Zeke is confirmed now so it's down to Gry and Nat to convince Zeke of Muffin over Nat.
Shouldn't be too difficult I hope
(I'm assuming Stu will die as he is the cause of scums current predicament)
Also welcome Coolest ^-^ sorry you had to die though :( (just for whenever he arrives here)
it will be natiko, gryvan and zeke vs muffin; with zeke being confirmed by the brazil flip
the question will be if zeke will still insist on natiko being the 2nd scum even though he said muffin was 100% scum
Since he was so convinced on Muffin being scum, I'm hoping. If not, it will be a tie and someone else will die at night making it 2-1 the next day. I think? (I'm trusting Gry to believe in Stu)
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Yeah, I assume Stu is dead tonight as well.
I think they'll just hammer Muffin. Zeke already wanted to kill Muffin today. If I were him, I would probably feel really bad about Brazil being the bomb and just trust in Stuart's world and vote for Muffin. I doubt Nat or Gry will disagree.
I think they'll just hammer Muffin. Zeke already wanted to kill Muffin today. If I were him, I would probably feel really bad about Brazil being the bomb and just trust in Stuart's world and vote for Muffin. I doubt Nat or Gry will disagree.
Nat wanted Zeke so with Brazil being the bomb, Nat won't go after Zeke. I mean I'd be shocked if he did.
Though I'm sure Zeke isn't looking forward to day start.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Seriously lol I don't even have words for it.
Yeah, Nat will be on board for Muffin I think.
Really my hope is that seeing the Brazil flip will make everyone just go back and believe in Stuart's world that he spent all day giving to them.
I fucked up a lot this game thanks to be my blindness of following Brazil and unable to fully commiet on certain days.
I learned a fuck ton though, I was honestly surpised by the Brazil flip.
Hope town pulls through despite me.
I learned a fuck ton though, I was honestly surpised by the Brazil flip.
Hope town pulls through despite me.
This broke my heart. I'm gonna read the thread but any feedback you have would be great.
Let's hope so
Hopefully with the case Stu set up, people will trust that Zeke just played badly and is not scum.
Did you just hammer to stop the conversation? Either way, you sacrificed yourself for the greater good! My 100% record.
Hope everyone stays on point with Muffin
Stu still feels sad though. :( about Muffin thinking Stu insulted him. I'm giving him hugs every so often while he reads Era/Reddit.
I hammered cause Stu was right, we were deadlock and if someone should die it should be me since I had no proper reads. I didn't want to just jump on other train as I figured Brazil would give us at least something for next day.
You were entertaining CoolestGroot! (I'll always remember that)
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Like I said earlier man, you jumped on a bomb to do the right thing. I don't really have much feedback for the rest of your play since I'm still a newbie to this game, but I think trusting in Stu in the end was a good play. So I think you went out the best you could under those circumstances at least. Your breadcrumbs for your role were also pretty great haha.
You played a good game
Fanto
Confirmed Town
You had me bamboozled until Nicole pointed out some stuff the other day. I thought Fandorin was scum with Muffin. And before that I thought Nicole was scum with Fandorin. You were pretty much never on my radar until the end, so well played man!
- Don't do gambits that don't pay off. Off the top of my head, there was the chat thing, and then there was the recruiter thing. They're not really cute or funny, and they're more of a headache than anything. Gambits like that can backfire easily, and if you weren't confirmed, you could have gotten yourself lynched over it.
- Take things slow. Be slow to trust. I am very slow to put anyone in my town column. Once you develop a read on a player, always self-examine that read with new information provided. You might have been reading Brazil as town earlier, but you can always re-examine a read and change your mind. Admitting you were wrong on your own reads can be difficult, but being self-critical is key. If you have a blind spot on a player, try and do as much as you can to clear that blind spot.
- Posts like the below are bad:
Everyone had already claimed if you were paying attention.
Muffin already gave the information, and doing the legwork to find out when he claimed/what he said is the least you can do as a confirmed town player.
also you said this
then a few pages later said (of defending a non-brazil lynch)
Your job as a confirmed town isn't to coast. Your job as a confirmed town player is to examine everyone and everything. You shouldn't be tunneling on anyone. The rest of the town can look at you as a person to rally behind because they know you're confirmed. It is your job to ensure that you're providing reads and being critical of others since no one can dismiss your scum hunting against them easily thanks to you being confirmed.
Additionally, your logic here for Brazil is based on "feelings" instead of actually looking at the substance of his posts. I've posted this in the thread already, but there was enough information from day one and day two to piece together the entire scum team, if you were willing to put in the work to find it. Mafia is a game that takes work and commitment if you're town. You can't simply coast and let others do your work for you, even more so when you're confirmed town.
Thand you. Honestly this game has been a big "learn and take notes" game more then any other.
I hope we can play again together on the same team as you're a bomb ass player, and blow you away.
Next game I'm going to have a note book with post numbers and try to constantly update the player base.
<3
You played well for the first few days. I was fairly pleased with the way you handled yourself until the chat incident, although you got into tunnel mode quite a bit on Zeke. One of the things I think you should do is think of Mafia more like a puzzle. If Zeke was scum, who was his scum partner? Is there evidence to support this? Can I find that evidence or ask questions of them to create it? If I don't find the evidence, who else could it be?
Also, in general, you can be entertaining (I enjoyed your poem reads), but you shouldn't feel the need to try and force it. You're generally an entertaining person to play with, and you don't have to try to force the entertainment blarg style. Blarg is blarg; you are you. Be unique / yourself. :)
I think I want to bring you down any time you ever try to scum me again
Pooh is such a fitting role for you.
Okay gonna be honest
WHO THE FUCK IS BLARG and why am I constantly called a copy?
WHO THE FUCK IS BLARG and why am I constantly called a copy?
Blarg is a player who often shitposts and has a very unique playstyle. The thing is behind that exterior he's actually a wicked problem solver and one of the best mafia players on the site. The style in which you post is very, very blarg.
I don't think you're a copy of Blarg at all. You're completely different beasts. People just tend to pair you two together because you both like posting weird shit.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Blargonaut.
I played with him in my very first game, GoT.
Now I know I'm a newb and haven't played with many people or watched many people play yet, but I feel pretty safe in saying that Blargonaut is probably the best Mafia player I have ever seen.
Who's the kill choice? I can't imagine it's not Stu!
It's early though. Maybe he'll change his mind before tomorrow?
It's not Stu. He needs to do something weird to have a chance, however small they may be, haha.
since zeke was just confirmed, zeke would be the obvious target
but I think stuart will still rally the troops against muffin if so
That being said, I think stuart NK gives muffin the best chance since zeke could still tunnel natiko. Zeke NK would be setting up no confirmed (save for soft confirm/role claim Stuart), and hoping that gryvan and natiko don't follow stuart? I don't see it happening though. Zeke seems far more malleable than Stuart
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Yeah, I just feel like any situation where Stuart is alive will result in Muffin dying haha. If he thinks there's some person he can kill that could make Stu doubt himself, or make others doubt Stu, then maybe that's what he wants to do instead?
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
Blarg is a good player but he rolls out different gimmicks per game to make him confusing. He can be very obvious in some games though. If he is town you can trust him to do the right thing in the later game.
As for Coolest being compard to Blarg. They are actually poles apart in my mind. Blarg is extremely logic driven in his play. It can be hard to see that when he is playing the fool but he is always working in a logical way. Like in GoT when he claimed neutral he knew he had to do it because logically he was mafia from the way he played up to that point. He knew he had no town cred left.
Coolest is much more random than Blarg and doesn't think within the scope of the game. He is careless or carefree in his play. Take his death here, he hammered knowing there could be a bomb and doing so cost town a lynch. Yeah he got scum but it wasn't overall a good move.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
How was Zeke confirmed? He just avoided the mafia bomb. Why isn't bomb stopper just a fake claim Grizzly gave to scum. Logically it fits. Town have a BP and Governor. Giving mafia an extra kill doesn't feel too out of balance imo.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Yeah, I guess I could have expanded a bit on what I think about Blarg's play. A lot of it is that he was very difficult to read (for me) due to the gimmicky nature of his posts. The fact that his claim seemed too good to be true, and obviously that Girlofgotham wound up being the second Neutral, are the only things that really made him Scum in my mind. I hope that seeing him as Mafia in my first game will help now in the future because I really do want to see what it's like when he's Town.
Z-beat
only here for the flavor
Bitter resentment rising
Using double quotes for partial sentences seems to be your tell. You do it when you're nervous
Using double quotes for partial sentences seems to be your tell. You do it when you're nervous
This almost happened by accident
Last edited:
lol
Z-beat
only here for the flavor
On second thought, this is true. Killing Stuart and letting Natiko potentially jump at Zeke for not wanting to hammer when the bomb was actually about to explode would be the best course of action. It’s unlikely that that would gain traction either way with gryvan there suspecting Natiko, but eh.
This game is far from being over.
Like Faddy said Zeke messed it up, he is not confirmed now. Leaving Stu alive will be a certain death sentence for scum.
Zeke, Natiko, gryvan, Muffin - there would be enough mistrust to construe something. Only chance for town would be Natiko not falling for the Zeke lynch (which I hope is likely). I could also see a Natiko push, but I don't know if the rest of town would fall for that. Gry felt safe yesterday, unlikely town will turn against him.
Like Faddy said Zeke messed it up, he is not confirmed now. Leaving Stu alive will be a certain death sentence for scum.
Zeke, Natiko, gryvan, Muffin - there would be enough mistrust to construe something. Only chance for town would be Natiko not falling for the Zeke lynch (which I hope is likely). I could also see a Natiko push, but I don't know if the rest of town would fall for that. Gry felt safe yesterday, unlikely town will turn against him.
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
To me, I feel like muffin is in trouble
- kill zeke, Nat loses the person he suspects, doubt he'd turn on stu. maybe gry?
- kill nat, zeke and gry lose the person they suspect, doubt gry would turn on stu maybe zeke.
- kill gry, zeke loses someone who agreed on nat. muffin might try to push that angle but stu won't bite probably
maybe this is just spec chat reasonings haha but for me, I'd kill stu for certain because that's the only thing that could save him probably.
- kill zeke, Nat loses the person he suspects, doubt he'd turn on stu. maybe gry?
- kill nat, zeke and gry lose the person they suspect, doubt gry would turn on stu maybe zeke.
- kill gry, zeke loses someone who agreed on nat. muffin might try to push that angle but stu won't bite probably
maybe this is just spec chat reasonings haha but for me, I'd kill stu for certain because that's the only thing that could save him probably.
Soooon the day will start.
Wonder what Muffin will try when the day starts.
Wonder what Muffin will try when the day starts.
If Stu is alive, that isn't happening. If he's dead...
Well, hopefully town remembers how things went last phase.
I have a 100% win record so far (won as scum, town has won whenever I've been town as well). I hope to keep it lol.
my mind boggles. haha.
Lol Stu is playing around.
I agree. Might be because we're outsiders looking in but it feels very obvious.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Ello all. Muffin is last scum correct?
Correct!
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
It looks like it to me.
Natiko's opening is where I would have been as well. Killing Zeke is a gift. Killing Stuart would have got a confirmed town and definite Muffin vote out the game. If anything Muffin should be arguing he had to kill Stuart and that is why he isn't mafia.
He could also reasonably push all remaining 3 as mafia.
Natiko lol claiming vanilla
gryvan mason claim with janitored player
Zeke bomb defuser who didn't stop the bomb
Last ditch effort by Muffin here.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Yeah, it's a long shot, and I highly doubt Gryvan is going to believe Muffin over Stu. Natiko will probably come in and laugh while voting for Muffin when he gets back.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
O,only regret is hammering zbeat early.
Sat what you guys want about me not hammering Brazil. I wasn’t sure on brazil. We both were sure on muffin.
I wonder how the game would have went if Stu wasn't BP...
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
On N1 scum was about to kill Nicole but they then moved to Stu. Would have been wildly different game if they had killed Nicole N1.
Oh wow. That would have been very different.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
So that explains why muffin and Brazil blew up about me going on about the reaction thing day 2. Lol
Probably going to have ti wait a bit til Gry is there and Nat is back. Should be soon hopefully.