Game Thread Invitational | Râlez, S'il Vous Plaît
- Thread starter Hecht
- Start date
Not a load of time this morning. Will check in before day's end.
1. BiscuitFreak69 [-] (Darryl) - Strikes me as town. Maybe a little tunneling and not as much broad focus, but when he pulls back to look broadly, seems to have a fair eye and is trying to solve. Would not lynch today.
2. Blargonaut [m] - This is a weird Blarg but strikes me as town. Would not lynch today.
3. Bronx-Man [m] - Absent but at least came in with a reason. Would not lynch today.
4. cabot [m] - is cabot. I always want to trust cabot and I also never trust cabot and I'm having a hard time getting past that meta read with game play. Would probably not lynch today because i want to see where he goes.
6. Dusk Soldier [m] - Where'd he go? Threw some shade around, commented on a given, disappeared. May change my mind if/when he comes back, but that feels scummy and certainly not like scumhunting.
7. El Topo [m] - Had him as town d1 but am less sure today. No real read.
8. Faddy [m] - I have no reason to be suspicious of Faddy at this time. Would not lynch today.
9. flatearthpandas [m] - Waiting to see what feps does as we come to the close of this phase. Mostly town feelings but keeping an open mind here.
10. hey_monkey [f] - is still not scum. somedaaaaaaaaaay
11. Karkador [m] - On my watch list. Not sure I'd make him a lynch candidate today. In fact, I think, like cabot, I want to see more interaction before I decide, but there's time yet today.
13. Kyanrute [m] - One of my strongest town reads.
14. Nin1000 [m] - Probably town. Addressed him a few times with the misreading the thread so won't repeat. Would not lynch today.
15. Nomadic Sparks [m] - A tough one this time. Also addressed him a few times. Possible lynch, but not strongly.
16. CrimsonFist [m] - Where'd he go? Would possibly lynch.
17. Sorian [m] - So scummy (in a Sorian way) that it almost seems too obvious. Watching him. Would possibly lynch today.
vote: Dusk Soldier
1. BiscuitFreak69 [-] (Darryl) - Strikes me as town. Maybe a little tunneling and not as much broad focus, but when he pulls back to look broadly, seems to have a fair eye and is trying to solve. Would not lynch today.
2. Blargonaut [m] - This is a weird Blarg but strikes me as town. Would not lynch today.
3. Bronx-Man [m] - Absent but at least came in with a reason. Would not lynch today.
4. cabot [m] - is cabot. I always want to trust cabot and I also never trust cabot and I'm having a hard time getting past that meta read with game play. Would probably not lynch today because i want to see where he goes.
6. Dusk Soldier [m] - Where'd he go? Threw some shade around, commented on a given, disappeared. May change my mind if/when he comes back, but that feels scummy and certainly not like scumhunting.
7. El Topo [m] - Had him as town d1 but am less sure today. No real read.
8. Faddy [m] - I have no reason to be suspicious of Faddy at this time. Would not lynch today.
9. flatearthpandas [m] - Waiting to see what feps does as we come to the close of this phase. Mostly town feelings but keeping an open mind here.
10. hey_monkey [f] - is still not scum. somedaaaaaaaaaay
11. Karkador [m] - On my watch list. Not sure I'd make him a lynch candidate today. In fact, I think, like cabot, I want to see more interaction before I decide, but there's time yet today.
13. Kyanrute [m] - One of my strongest town reads.
14. Nin1000 [m] - Probably town. Addressed him a few times with the misreading the thread so won't repeat. Would not lynch today.
15. Nomadic Sparks [m] - A tough one this time. Also addressed him a few times. Possible lynch, but not strongly.
16. CrimsonFist [m] - Where'd he go? Would possibly lynch.
17. Sorian [m] - So scummy (in a Sorian way) that it almost seems too obvious. Watching him. Would possibly lynch today.
vote: Dusk Soldier
flatearthpandas
Round Moon Bears
Against dusk soldier. Against kawl vote.
As said before, voting inactives or ccs votes.
Vote: bronx-man
As said before, voting inactives or ccs votes.
Vote: bronx-man
flatearthpandas
Round Moon Bears
Kawl voters
flatearthpandas
Round Moon Bears
I said earlier why not dusk. If someone can put a good argument for monkey or blarg I'm now open. Still leaning Sorian. Like i said, not leaning El topo or nin
flatearthpandas
Round Moon Bears
But inactives still good and bronx still bad
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
VOTE: Dusk Soldier
2 for 2 let's gamble
2 for 2 let's gamble
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
but fep, Kawl was Mafia
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
Personally, I find it amusingly hypocritical of you to be voting Bronx after you say that
amusing
amusing
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
computer show me Dusk Soldier Yesterday
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
Kyan I'll vote out El Topo if you help
Kyanrute
kyan-rute
What about the other parties of team murder CCS?
flatearthpandas
Round Moon Bears
Maybe we misunderstand each other?
Literally thread hasn't evolved. No defense for monkey. Blarg can go either way. But i feel safer voting off bronx. Blarg has done some things i like. Bronx, not so much
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
I'm willing to TURBO nin
Sorian's been super defensive over nothing and deserves pressure
I understand
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
I think Faddy's innocent
flatearthpandas
Round Moon Bears
Then let's turbo!!! Lol. Useless
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
so you agree with me?
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
Why should I listen to me through a filter of you
flatearthpandas
Round Moon Bears
Yeah, that why I'm voting nin
flatearthpandas
Round Moon Bears
Whoops.
Vote: CrimsonFist
Vote: CrimsonFist
cabot
Why.
The timing here is suspect. Plus why would Kark check the thread at that time if he thought it hadn't started? It wasn't near a deadline time.
Also within ten minutes of his name being mentioned by 3 players.
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
coward(s)
cabot
Why.
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
pot calling the kettle black sheep
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
So what are you insinuating exactly
cabot
Why.
do you think the remaining scum had votes out?
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
ehhhh
So how does CrimsonFist fit in with Mafia!Karkador
So how does CrimsonFist fit in with Mafia!Karkador
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
so cabot you agree with Faddy then?
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
So cabot, what do you think about the players on the CCS train, if inactivity and not outnumbering was what got Kawl?
cabot
Why.
I'd say Sorian or nin are the best bets of finding scum in the CCS pile.
I still feel okay around Topo, though he's been too quiet this phase.
Faddy I am uncertain on, but I'm not sure if a scum would really start that discussion on day 1 regarding why were we chosen. It's too easy a bait.
I still feel okay around Topo, though he's been too quiet this phase.
Faddy I am uncertain on, but I'm not sure if a scum would really start that discussion on day 1 regarding why were we chosen. It's too easy a bait.
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
And how do you feel about heymonkey's Jailed claim? Do you believe it?
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
Why?
Man, usually I have so much more quoted in the morning. The conversation is only now actually moving on a bit.
Optimally, I would not lynch either today anyway. Blarg isn't reading scum at all and I'm really not in the mood for the distraction of having to vote him away. Monkey I'm less sure of but I'm not overly suspicious of anything. She's clearly analyzing the thread. cabot also seems fine.
Disappointed that Topo still hasn't responded to me and I really find that sarcasm last night odd. Happy to see more Dusk votes only for the fact that it is a spot that needs pressure.
Keep in mind day ends today, would like more activity leading into day end.
Optimally, I would not lynch either today anyway. Blarg isn't reading scum at all and I'm really not in the mood for the distraction of having to vote him away. Monkey I'm less sure of but I'm not overly suspicious of anything. She's clearly analyzing the thread. cabot also seems fine.
Disappointed that Topo still hasn't responded to me and I really find that sarcasm last night odd. Happy to see more Dusk votes only for the fact that it is a spot that needs pressure.
Keep in mind day ends today, would like more activity leading into day end.
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
maybe I'm just getting better at manipulating your perception of my productivity Sorian
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
alright
relatively prompt
politely attentive
informative yet not too opinionated
yeah good job cabot
cabot
Why.
I'm more trying to prod him just now, I dunno he needs to post some content so I can get a read.
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
Who's scummier CrimsonFist or Dusk Soldier
It's not your productivity at all.
Eh, probably about equal? Slight nudge to Dusk since he's actually been kept up with the thread and is absent. Crimson still doesn't appear to have read the thread.
flatearthpandas
Round Moon Bears
Crimson.
Dusk is at least consistent.
Crimson is replacing nothing with nothing. Would guess neutral at this point. Flips tell us there may be a neutral.
Dusk is at least consistent.
Crimson is replacing nothing with nothing. Would guess neutral at this point. Flips tell us there may be a neutral.
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
people get serious
We really should be getting rid of one of the CCS crew. After Kawl's flip there's no sense in targeting out of that circle right now
UNVOTE
VOTE: El Topo
Topo tried to push CCS to get heat off Kawl, that's a tell
We really should be getting rid of one of the CCS crew. After Kawl's flip there's no sense in targeting out of that circle right now
UNVOTE
VOTE: El Topo
Topo tried to push CCS to get heat off Kawl, that's a tell
Nomad Sparkster
This is some wild shit maynard
CrimsonFist might as well not be playing
Any vote for Bronx and Crimson is just prod vote
Any vote for Bronx and Crimson is just prod vote
Nomad Sparkster
This is some wild shit maynard
Vote: El Topo
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
So who do you really want to lynch?
? The generic win cons tell me nothing about there being a neutral.
El Topo
Spanish for "The Topo"
I think that's an interesting claim, given that Sorian and Kawl were tied for votes when I gave my post.
cabot
Why.
Kark
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
so you and Sorian are Mafia then
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
I could do that.
flatearthpandas
Round Moon Bears
They don't. Hence why i asked why people were so sure about vig.
However, anemic scum response to kawl makes me lean more towards a neutral. As you said earlier, makes more sense for four scum. As you said, makes more sense to protect kawl than bus.
cabot
Why.
gimmick?
I've given reasons before.
He's been quiet
He's not made a gambit yet
I highlighted his vote towards day end
I'm unsure how to read him going hard on Sorian yet, I'm past the point of analyzing Kark Sorian face offs.
You gonna give us some thoughts or just continue throwing shade at others.
nin1000
Chilean German Madman
Inactives
Dusk Soldier
Not contagious
Usually scum reads both threads, not just scum chat.
nin1000
Chilean German Madman
Outside of this safe space I would probably go for either Nomadic and or Hey monkey.
Hecht
Like dubstep for my bootyhole
Let me clarify this (and I'll update the OP). Majority will still "end the day," but the flip will happen at the scheduled time.
Dusk Soldier
Not contagious
Won't have much free time until 2 hours before deadline.
vote: Sorian
Don't see myself voting outside of the CCS crew today, so this will be a place holder vote until I get caught back up in the game.
vote: Sorian
Don't see myself voting outside of the CCS crew today, so this will be a place holder vote until I get caught back up in the game.
Who's your pick right now, Topo? I'm out and I'm sorry if I missed it.
karkador
Board Game King
These are really empty reasons to push a lynch on me. I haven't made a gambit yet? So your charge is, "he's trying to play decently and not make outrageous claims"?
I could see why that would worry you as a mafia player, but I haven't really come around to that accusation on you yet.
What you don't want to do is talk about substance. You are pretty clearly dismissing anything actually worth talking about today.
Instead, you're cheesing it by trying to make some metagame commentary about my activity - informed by ONE past game I was in.
The funny thing is, you weren't in LB2 - and I would expect that the mafia mates I had then would be the most familiar with my behavior (Sorian, who already brought it up). So where did you get your info from?
karkador
Board Game King
Is there still talk at that time, or not?
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
end of Day is always end of talk
cabot
Why.
Person acts out of character? Don't see anything particularly dodgy about that. You usually take the lead in the game with some semblance of a play, you've been mostly mute except when Sorian hits.
I know the games you played with me, and you were always at the forefront (NX gambit, Love Boat after catching out Blarg) and ones I specc'd (Batman)
I will be frank regarding you/Sorian whenever I see you two face off I seriously question if it's game related, you always go at each other. Sorian isn't my top target today but I'm alright if he goes to be honest, he should ideally be gone before endgame is a possibility.
Outside of that I don't think I can read anything game related from your arguments
What else?
You're basing things off what dead players did, which I think is pointless. You also think scum had some master plan to kill kawl, which I think is crap. You disappeared after plonking a vote on Sorian, which as scum is potentially a reason why Kawl bit it.
cabot
Why.
why Monkey?
Hecht
Like dubstep for my bootyhole
Correct. We're sticking to the schedule so that the weekend is good for the night phase.
karkador
Board Game King
Out of character, based on what? Who said I have to play the same way every time? These are goalposts that are very easy for you to move. That's the whole problem with this line of attack.
So we can establish you did not play in or spec Love Boat 2? That's the only game I've been Mafia in.
So I'll say again, the players who would be most familiar with my behavior and thought process in that game would be the Mafia team at the time (two of who are present in this game, Sorian and FEP). Sorian already made this comment early on in Day 1.
Now you're saying it, too. In fact, you're really really behind the idea. What convinced you to do this? Sorian's offhanded remark about it? You just failed to mention even spectating LB2.
So either he really really convinced you with one sentence, or you've discussed this behind the scenes with somebody.
El Topo
Spanish for "The Topo"
Absolutely. Your D1 vote, as you said yourself, was a principle lynch that you've stuck with.
cabot
Why.
Considering you've pulled stunts in 100% of games we've played together, and 100% of the ones ive seen you spectating, yes thats out of character.
You don't have to play the same way everytime obviously, but i don't feel like you've particularly acted different and towny in this game. You've just acted different.
I also chased you before Sorian made a comment, his comment came from me asking about you.
cabot
Why.
yes because i see scum in this person. Is that a gimmick?
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
^^^^
I would agree that JUST talking about inactives is lazy as hell and it ain't scumhunting. There's gotta be something else there.
But we've got a lot of people just hanging around. It's difficult to scum hunt in this particular game because it's the same few voices again and again. I doubt that's all town but most are. And that's gonna get in our way, too, cannibalizing each other.
But we've got a lot of people just hanging around. It's difficult to scum hunt in this particular game because it's the same few voices again and again. I doubt that's all town but most are. And that's gonna get in our way, too, cannibalizing each other.
Hmm. Idly wondering how many people have talked about more than three other players with any substance. Seems like a lot of people have been hyper focused on one or two or just doing drive-bys.