Game Thread Invitational | Râlez, S'il Vous Plaît

El Topo

Spanish for "The Topo"
I voted CCS in the first hours of the game. It was very strange to see my random pick come up as one of the trains. Almost like scum were piggybacking on me.

None of that makes it any less likely that you're scum. You cast your vote early, then suddenly it gains traction, but not enough to prevent the death of your fellow scum member.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
None of that makes it any less likely that you're scum. You cast your vote early, then suddenly it gains traction, but not enough to prevent the death of your fellow scum member.

That's your argument? Not that it's shit that he did a weak vote early and actually camped on it?
 

RetroMG

Bergentrukung
Staff member
Vote count please

It hasn't changed since a few posts ago, but here it is for the new page:

VOTE COUNT:

CrimsonFist (3)
Faddy
Flatearthpnads
Hey_Monkey

Sorian (3)
Dusk Soldier
Karkador
Nin1000

El Topo (2)
Blargonaut
Nomadic Sparks

Nin1000 (2)
Kyanrute
Sorian

No Vote (5)
Bronx-man
cabot
CrimsonFist
Darryl
El Topo
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Sorian didn't pan out Yesterday because he's Mafia and they jumped onto CCS and forsook Kawl to realy save Sorian

El Topo helped amplify the CCS mindshare

nin's probably Town

so Karkador's probably the outlier Mafia who avoids the high-profile show
 

Dusk Soldier

Not contagious
El Topo and & Cabot are both here and pretty active, but both of you guys are just waiting on the sidelines in terms of voting.

What are you waiting for?
 

El Topo

Spanish for "The Topo"
Wait, looking at the vote count, it's Sorian and CrimsonFist. What was the argument again for Crimson and was there any argument brought forth against Sorian beyond Blarg's odd talk?
 

Dusk Soldier

Not contagious
Sorian didn't pan out Yesterday because he's Mafia and they jumped onto CCS and forsook Kawl to realy save Sorian

El Topo helped amplify the CCS mindshare
I do think that's a strong possiblity there. That would explain why there wasn't a harder push on Sorian. who was next in the vote count
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I don't buy it Blarg. Why would Karkador vote Sorian in that situation? Especially before CCS became a thing. If Sorian is scum Kark was setting up a 2nd scum train.
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
It's simple napkin probability, fools

What are the odds of two non-actives being Mafia?
vs.
What are the odds that there are Mafia within the CCS circle, now that we know Kawl was scum?

CrimsonFist? More like CrimsonFish, 'cause he's a red herring
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Kawl
El Topo
Karkador
Dusk Soldier

That's Mafia

Am I missing why you subbed me out for Dusk?

Also I'm clearly going to shift my vote to Crimson if this keeps up but I'd rather not do the same dance as yesterday, would rather see nin go or Topo as a secondary. Kark isn't a terrible choice when I take into account what Faddy just said but eh.
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Am I missing why you subbed me out for Dusk?

Also I'm clearly going to shift my vote to Crimson if this keeps up but I'd rather not do the same dance as yesterday, would rather see nin go or Topo as a secondary. Kark isn't a terrible choice when I take into account what Faddy just said but eh.
Doing so would just reinforce that selfishness you know

not a good look
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
I cannot believe anyone would be baited into voting against CrimsonFist and think themselves as voting in Town's interests
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Self-preservation isn't selfishness in mafia and it's not like my look matters if I'm tied for the lynch anyway.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Is there any reason you aren't voting yet cabot? It's clear you're here.
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
OiPhAeo.gif
 

RetroMG

Bergentrukung
Staff member
VOTE COUNT:

CrimsonFist (4)
Faddy
Flatearthpnads
Hey_Monkey
Blargonaut

Sorian (3)
Dusk Soldier
Karkador
Nin1000

Nin1000 (2)
Kyanrute
Sorian

El Topo (1)
Nomadic Sparks

Blargonaut (1)

El Topo

No Vote (5)
Bronx-man
cabot
CrimsonFist
Darryl
 

cabot

Why.
VOTE: Sorian


Pretty annoying situation, but I am ok with voting Sorian, cause as good as he is, I cant trust him.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
VOTE: CrimsonFist

Yeah, no.

Should have followed monkey, this is as dumb as voting Kawl yesterday.
 

RetroMG

Bergentrukung
Staff member
Final Vote Count

Sorian (4)
Dusk Soldier
Karkador
Nin1000
cabot

CrimsonFist (3)
Faddy
Flatearthpandas
Sorian

Nin1000 (3)
Blargonaut
Hey_Monkey
Kyanrute

Blargonaut (1)
El Topo

El Topo (1)
Nomadic Sparks

No Vote (3)
Bronx-man
CrimsonFist
Darryl
 

Hecht

Like dubstep for my bootyhole
DAY 2 ENDS

Melody the candy striper watched as the patients once again stripped naked and danced merrily to songs from the acclaimed album, Mechanical Animals.

Turning to an orderly she asked, "Hey, have you guys seen Valerie today?"
The orderly sighed and said, "No, we're short handed today. I think Val is out on some sort of journey or something."

"Yeah, she lost her piece." Another piped up.

"Her piece?" Melody asked.

"Yeah, she lost her gun somewhere while she was traveling around the world, so she's out looking for it."

"That's odd."

"Well it was important to her."

"So you're telling me that Val treks for her piece?"

"Yep. Oh hey, someone is dead."

Blargonaut has died!

Greetings!

You are a Terrible Person. You are aligned with TOWN.

You do not have any special abilities, but you can vote!

You win when all threats to Town are eliminated.

The game thread can be found here: http://outergafia.net/index.php?threads/30/

Night 2 ends:
red_1509922800.png
 

Hecht

Like dubstep for my bootyhole
DAY 3 BEGINS

The surgeon walked out of the operating room, wiping sweat from his brow.

"Doctor, what happened?"

"The patient...he didn't make it. We found several contributing factors in his death - his skull was caved in by a guitar, his throat had been sliced open with a copy of Desire Walks On, and finally, he had been placed in a kiddie pool filled with barracudas."

"Oh my god, are you telling me..."

"Yes. Kyanrute died of a Heart attack."

Kyanrute has died!

Greetings!

You are a Terrible Person. You are aligned with TOWN.

You do not have any special abilities, but you can vote!

You win when all threats to Town are eliminated.

The game thread can be found here: http://outergafia.net/index.php?threads/30/

DAY 3 ENDS:
gre_1510095600.png


Majority is 7.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
So do we lynch Sorian first or Monkey.

Biscuit got a replacement but Bronx and Crimson are both still around despite not participating in chat.

Sorian was our majority choice. Crimson was second. I say we just turbo one of them, honestly. At this point, all of day 2 was useless. We have zero info without one of those flips. I won't argue too hard against a monkey lynch either.

Monkey, why were you arguing against lynching active players and then you kill an active player?

Vote: Sorian
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
I kinda wanna know what was up with The Topo's thought process towards the end of that, actually

why even go after Blarg that late in the day?

So why blarg

I don't want to turbo anyone until monkey responds here

The Topo put me on a scumteam with an override in Vampire, and given how strange the anti-Blarg sentiment appeared to me (okay yeah he could've been a scumread sure, but a top scumread? really?) I'm somewhat doubtful of monkey's motives here

I don't know if it's plausible that this could be a scum overriding a scum lynch, since that could appear too obvious. It could very well be scum overriding a town lynch to frame the rescued town
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
Scum override seems too obvious.

But I want the flip we collectively decided on. I want Day 2 to have some value. If Sorian flips scum, Monkey gotta go. But a lotta people gotta go, tbh.

Worm, you got a reason or you just figuring out highlight?
 

El Topo

Spanish for "The Topo"
I kinda wanna know what was up with The Topo's thought process towards the end of that, actually

why even go after Blarg that late in the day?

I voted for Blarg because I didn't agree with his strategy and thoughts. I felt that his proposal to lock us down to three suspects, leaving Faddy out of the group because he cast the first vote, was unreasonable and problematic. Furthermore I wasn't sold on the two main suspects, I even asked for reasons, but no one bothered to answer. Casting a late, possibly deciding vote on a candidate that I had not spoken much for or against, that I had not looked into, seemed dishonest and harmful.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I voted for Blarg because I didn't agree with his strategy and thoughts. I felt that his proposal to lock us down to three suspects, leaving Faddy out of the group because he cast the first vote, was unreasonable and problematic. Furthermore I wasn't sold on the two main suspects, I even asked for reasons, but no one bothered to answer. Casting a late, possibly deciding vote on a candidate that I had not spoken much for or against, that I had not looked into, seemed dishonest and harmful.

You hadn't looked into Sorian? Uh huh.
 

El Topo

Spanish for "The Topo"
The Topo put me on a scumteam with an override in Vampire, and given how strange the anti-Blarg sentiment appeared to me (okay yeah he could've been a scumread sure, but a top scumread? really?) I'm somewhat doubtful of monkey's motives here

I don't know if it's plausible that this could be a scum overriding a scum lynch, since that could appear too obvious. It could very well be scum overriding a town lynch to frame the rescued town

I think this might be too meta, but I don't think having a scum override was a good idea in hindsight. Furthermore I think while the override is certainly important, we should also look at the votes from yesterday in general and possibly look into what the (now dead and confirmed) town players thought and who they suspected.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I think this might be too meta, but I don't think having a scum override was a good idea in hindsight. Furthermore I think while the override is certainly important, we should also look at the votes from yesterday in general and possibly look into what the (now dead and confirmed) town players thought and who they suspected.

Classic scum move. Kill Kyan who was down a blind alley and now you are championing his reads?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
town guv was override. Eating with fam atm but will post more in a bit. Was gonna go for Sorian but Blarg's votes were baiting something and didn't know if he was trying to control narrative or bait scum. Decided to flip him to get the answer. Shakes up the game, too, I hope, which we needed in a bad way. We need to figure what to do with Crimson and Bronx too if they don't turn up today.

Back later.
 

El Topo

Spanish for "The Topo"
Did you give a detailed post for Blarg?

I gave my thoughts on his behavior in the thread, yes. You implied I had looked into Sorian, please provide evidence for that from D2, else you are a liar.
Also please explain why you kept your vote on Crimson Fist, even when it almost got him lynched (and you yourself even noted the momentum). I would love to hear your explanation for your behavior.

Classic scum move. Kill Kyan who was down a blind alley and now you are championing his reads?

Topo: "We should look at the votes."
Guy with suspicious vote: "Classic scum move."
 

Dusk Soldier

Not contagious
Scum override seems too obvious.

But I want the flip we collectively decided on. I want Day 2 to have some value. If Sorian flips scum, Monkey gotta go. But a lotta people gotta go, tbh.

Worm, you got a reason or you just figuring out highlight?
Yeah, I find it hard to believe scum would use an override this early in the game.

So confused at this.

Why waste a power like that on blarg?
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
I voted for Blarg because I didn't agree with his strategy and thoughts. I felt that his proposal to lock us down to three suspects, leaving Faddy out of the group because he cast the first vote, was unreasonable and problematic. Furthermore I wasn't sold on the two main suspects, I even asked for reasons, but no one bothered to answer. Casting a late, possibly deciding vote on a candidate that I had not spoken much for or against, that I had not looked into, seemed dishonest and harmful.

so you went to Blarg because you felt like he was being too assertive with a view you didn't agree with, essentially?
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I gave my thoughts on his behavior in the thread, yes. You implied I had looked into Sorian, please provide evidence for that from D2, else you are a liar.
Also please explain why you kept your vote on Crimson Fist, even when it almost got him lynched (and you yourself even noted the momentum). I would love to hear your explanation for your behavior.



Topo: "We should look at the votes."
Guy with suspicious vote: "Classic scum move."

I kept my vote on Crimson because that is who we should have lynched.

I'm not very pleased with monkey overriding into Blarg. A Sorian flip would have been more valauble or Kark or cabot.
 

karkador

Board Game King
town guv was override. Eating with fam atm but will post more in a bit. Was gonna go for Sorian but Blarg's votes were baiting something and didn't know if he was trying to control narrative or bait scum. Decided to flip him to get the answer. Shakes up the game, too, I hope, which we needed in a bad way. We need to figure what to do with Crimson and Bronx too if they don't turn up today.

Back later.

This is straight up nonsense
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
We've been down this road before. Scum doesn't get an override without some heavy consequences, thinking monkey is scum is non sense even if you do believe that Blarg shot was terrible (which it was)

Scum override seems too obvious.

But I want the flip we collectively decided on. I want Day 2 to have some value. If Sorian flips scum, Monkey gotta go. But a lotta people gotta go, tbh.

Worm, you got a reason or you just figuring out highlight?

You want the flip that we collectively decided on but then you vote for me?

Are you trying to sweep the Crimson conversation under the rug? Cause you sound full of shit.

VOTE: flatearthpandas

I think it's pretty clear who you're running the narrative with (Kark)
 

karkador

Board Game King
Come on guys, don't let yourselves get talked into this "that would be too obvious" trap. It's pretty clear that monkey used that command to save Sorian from getting lynched. There's no other way to interpret that.
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
to be clear, I wouldn't have brought up a scum override if the decision to take out Blarg over Sorian had actually made any sense to me whatsoever

obviously I wasn't around for the last phase so it may have made more sense in that context. I initially read through the thread chronologically, and I mentally had Blarg indexed as "lean town" before I got around to the flip. nonetheless, he mostly just read like Blarg screwing around to me.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
You want the flip that we collectively decided on but then you vote for me?

Are you trying to sweep the Crimson conversation under the rug? Cause you sound full of shit.

VOTE: flatearthpandas

I think it's pretty clear who you're running the narrative with (Kark)
What the fuck are you on about? You were the vote leader, who we collectively elected for lynch.
Final Vote Count

Sorian (4)
Dusk Soldier
Karkador
Nin1000
cabot

CrimsonFist (3)
Faddy
Flatearthpandas
Sorian

Nin1000 (3)
Blargonaut
Hey_Monkey
Kyanrute

Blargonaut (1)
El Topo

El Topo (1)
Nomadic Sparks

No Vote (3)
Bronx-man
CrimsonFist
Darryl
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
UNVOTE

Huh, you're right? I didn't actually read the vote count that was posted last because of the override, I didn't realize enough vote switched on that last minute that put me over.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I don't believe scum get a double lynch and an override. Or town PRs better be off the charts useful.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
That's weird that everyone shifted there now that I realize who had votes where it's all town though I think. They're either dead (Blarg), confirmed imo (monkey) or just a strong town read (cabot).

I'm still doing this vote

VOTE: flatearthpandas

this quick want to just go back to the status quo of yesterday and even a want to turbo smells like shit. I know you're wrong and all well and good that town can be wrong but this seems like a ploy to kill off a day quick.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
There were two people I wanted lynched fighting for the spot before we got robbed of either flip and almost any useful info.

Damn right I want to go back to yesterday's close.
 
Top Bottom