The Chat Room

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
We should have more town reads in a game like this. Insert sad/angry face.

If Faddy uses his command, do we trust it? I assume he would be able to talk here.
 
The Claim List 2: The Squeakquel (Presented by Aeleus)

Verified Powers List:
-Sawneeks: Scum Roleblocker
-Sorian: Scum Redirector (2 random shots, 2 controlled shots)
-Bae: Scum StrongNinja (infinite strong shots, infinite ninja shots, 1 hybrid shot) likely used ninja shot N1 and strong shot N2

-Terra: Amnesiac Cop (checked Sorian N1, D2 Sorian announced a red check. checked ? N2, D3 Nobody announced check)

Claimed Powers List:
-Sparks: Bathroom Jailer (can force people into the bathroom, didn't use ability N1 or N2)
-Faddy: Innocent Giffer (Innocent child who upon reveal can only post gifs/images)
-Zeke: Auction Fan (Can join any auction, confirmed knowing of auction items on N2)
-Wee: ??? (Receives messages each morning, has a day command to grant immunity to typical roleblocks)
-Fanto: Tracker (Tracked Bae N1: No movement)
-Ketkat: Bomb defuser (Trying to stop a bomber, claims to have defused a bomb in the Quarters N2)
-Nin: Vanilla
-Ynnek: ??? (Can confirm Fantos track on Bae's no movement N1)

Mysteries:
The True Bathroom (Fran claims being in the bathroom commutes the player + blocks day actions the next day, does it?)
Wee claimed switched from Bathroom to Library beginning of N1
The Bomber (Legends (or Ketkat) tell of a mysterious bomber planting bombs in rooms to kill townies, apparently they planted a bomb N1 and could be Monkey, Malus, Chuggs, Maol, Nin or Nicole)
Terra's Final Check (Terra must have checked someone N2, who did he check and what happened to it?)
The Thief (Zeke claims his BP vest was stolen from him N2 by an item thief, does such an malicious entity truly exist?)

Case Closed:
The Auction (Players from a certain room are given coins to bid on 'helpful' items)
The Night 3 Nightmare (The Bad happening appears to be a bomb defused by Ketkat, huzzah!)
The Rooms (the rooms appear to host auctions and have bombs planted in them)
The Mysterious Note (it appears the note was an alignment check sent by Terra revealing Sorian was scum, as luck would have it Sorian himself revealed the check!)

Bathroom Commutes:
N1: Weemadarthur (apparently moved out beginning of night)
N2: Aeleus, Weemadarthur (aeleus reports highlighted message, wee confirms it)
N3: Nin

Auctions:
N1 items: Book, Tea, Spy kit (10 coins)
N1 players (in kitchen): TWE, Zeke, Ketkat, FEPs and Sparks: Ketkat won a ban from voting, FEPs won motion detector (used N2 on Terra, detected movement), Zeke won a BP vest
N2 items: Hidden Camera, Stoumach Medicine, Ballot
N2 players (in rec room): Monkey, Fanto, Kalor, Zipped, Vere, blarg + Zeke: Fanto won a miller role, Monkey won a double vote, Vere won ???
N3 items: Old sign, Horse, Taco Bell
N3 players (in quarters): Aeleus, Fanto, Maol, Wee, Ketkat, Stan, VA + Zeke
 

Verelios

Were-elios
We should have more town reads in a game like this. Insert sad/angry face.

If Faddy uses his command, do we trust it? I assume he would be able to talk here.
Well, so far as looking elsewhere I'll trust it, but that's a good point on if his PR only extends to the game thread. Might be worth testing.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I can ask him, since it just keeps attention on me and doesn't put any on either of y'all. I can pitch it as just general suspicion of Faddy, too, who I'm sure will be unwilling to answer many questions about the role.
 
I can ask him, since it just keeps attention on me and doesn't put any on either of y'all. I can pitch it as just general suspicion of Faddy, too, who I'm sure will be unwilling to answer many questions about the role.
I can push too, I've brought it up in the past so it wouldn't look out of place.

And happy birthday!
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Now all three of us have powers over life and death... (pretty weak one in my case)

I need advice on what to bid, either of you happen to be expert gamblers?
I confess to wanting to know what the horse does but I'd go 8 on the old sign, which will be less popular, I bet, and 2 on something else.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
If Narf lets us die now it'll be confirmed he hates birthdays and fun in general.


I'm in a similar position, feels like a player who'd eventually be lunched via POE if we get to that point so I want to strengthen my read on her?

Any idea on who you're planning on recruiting. Ideally someone who is town and can contribute to discussion is some way, of my town reads I think Kalor might be a good idea.
I'm thinking there are a few choices. Galaxy brain decision would be Fanto because scum might not hit him to evade protection. Kalor is also a fine choice by how Sorian tried to push him, but I'm not entirely convinced he was in any danger aside from being a third wagon.

Who else are you guys thinking about?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I can push too, I've brought it up in the past so it wouldn't look out of place.

And happy birthday!
I think if we both bring up "would it work in other chats" it'll look weird but then again it might make people think we're lovers, since I've townread you from early on.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Now all three of us have powers over life and death... (pretty weak one in my case)

I need advice on what to bid, either of you happen to be expert gamblers?
Echoing monkey, I'd go 8 or 9, 8 for the popular and 9 for unpopular choice.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Hm...It feels like it would be unlikely for any of the people in the quarters to go all in after what happened yesterday especially Zeke and Fanto are more likely to bid in the 7-9 range. Maybe you could go all in on one item you want?
 
We should have more town reads in a game like this. Insert sad/angry face.

If Faddy uses his command, do we trust it? I assume he would be able to talk here.
I believe Faddy can use the command because if it was him or a scum mate going why send the roleblocker to die while giving you a death sentence.

My worry is that he's creating a narrative of it being either he doesn't have the power or he's town. If he uses it sooner the narrative will eventually become whether or not we trust the claim.
(the gif thing might just be to make the claim sound more reasonable, because wouldn't it absolutely suck if you got that role and you could only post on mobile, would that be something brought up in review?)
 

Verelios

Were-elios
I believe Faddy can use the command because if it was him or a scum mate going why send the roleblocker to die while giving you a death sentence.

My worry is that he's creating a narrative of it being either he doesn't have the power or he's town. If he uses it sooner the narrative will eventually become whether or not we trust the claim.
(the gif thing might just be to make the claim sound more reasonable, because wouldn't it absolutely suck if you got that role and you could only post on mobile, would that be something brought up in review?)
Policy lunch before lylo is the only way I'd let Faddy stay around posting images. It's too much chance.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
You can post images and gifs on mobile, it's just harder. It would depend on the reviewers. It does make me think, outside of this, that it's something we should talk about after if it's the case because some people really do hate that/can't easily do it. But that's administratormonkey talking, not gameplaying monkey. For now, I say: Faddy has been weird, Faddy has not been very townie, Faddy needs to put up or shut up.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
So, I'm of the opinion that Zipped was telling the truth about moving last night so between Fanto and Blarg, someone is lying.
 
So you now know mine and Vere's roles, you also now know that we learnt of monkey's role the night of her death.

Sideyes Vere hard.
-------------
Blarg is scum, no doubt.

Auction isn't in my room by the way, will report if I win the giveaway.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
I say that because Zipped can change around the facts however he wants (blatantly lied about the process, lol. Dodged a bullet Aeleus), but his biggest goal is to get 4 players tagged, and he was likely on the cusp of doing that before getting lunched. There's no reason he wouldn't have moved.
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
I still feel pretty good about Fanto so I'm inclined to think it's Blarg.

Catching up, the numbers thing for Aeleus's role is clever and I'm glad I never thought too hard about it.

I feel good about both of you so I'll claim in a bit once I have time to write it up.
 
I say that because Zipped can change around the facts however he wants (blatantly lied about the process, lol. Dodged a bullet Aeleus), but his biggest goal is to get 4 players tagged, and he was likely on the cusp of doing that before getting lunched. There's no reason he wouldn't have moved.
Yeah it's a good thing that Zipped was killed despite how cool the role was (and that Blarg should've been the one who died)

This is a neutral who could lead to 4 deaths so how do we feel about the bomb in spite of that? I was always speptical but now I really am.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
So you now know mine and Vere's roles, you also now know that we learnt of monkey's role the night of her death.

Sideyes Vere hard.
-------------
Blarg is scum, no doubt.

Auction isn't in my room by the way, will report if I win the giveaway.
Still legit shook about Monkey's death. I thought about it and really did expect her to self-protect. She was target number 1. But by her usual actions I'm guessing she made a chance on Fanto being the target and protected him instead.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Yeah it's a good thing that Zipped was killed despite how cool the role was (and that Blarg should've been the one who died)

This is a neutral who could lead to 4 deaths so how do we feel about the bomb in spite of that? I was always speptical but now I really am.
I'm really wondering about Nin and ket at this moment.

I kind of feel like it's all a smokescreen and there is no bomb. Or maybe that's what I want to believe.
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
Okay, I'm a room mover. I've probably brought up the idea the most in the main thread and I've basically said exactly what my role is proposed as theories.

I can move someone from one room to another during the day, so I send the action during the day and they get moved at day end.

Day 1: I moved Wee out of the bathroom as a test of the role. Didn't really have a reason beyond that since they were the only one in the bathroom.
Day 2: I moved Zeke into the same room as me to test if they caused the auctions, and I wanted to try and get an item.
Day 3: none because of the turbo and I didn't submit it in time
Day 4: I tried to put TearablePuns in the bathroom but Turmoil filled up the second spot right at the end, and my role doesn't swap people out if the room is full.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
I think more than them, I'm suspicious of Tearicole who seemed overly invested in it D3 (please don't beat me to death for coming around late Monkey, lol) and has wanted to pick it up at every chance.
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
About the bomb stuff, part of me was thinking that the bomb is a preset mod move rather than done by a player. Then a player in this case was given a role to defuse it.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Okay, I'm a room mover. I've probably brought up the idea the most in the main thread and I've basically said exactly what my role is proposed as theories.

I can move someone from one room to another during the day, so I send the action during the day and they get moved at day end.

Day 1: I moved Wee out of the bathroom as a test of the role. Didn't really have a reason beyond that since they were the only one in the bathroom.
Day 2: I moved Zeke into the same room as me to test if they caused the auctions, and I wanted to try and get an item.
Day 3: none because of the turbo and I didn't submit it in time
Day 4: I tried to put TearablePuns in the bathroom but Turmoil filled up the second spot right at the end, and my role doesn't swap people out if the room is full.
Huh...Sparks claim D1 didn't raise any alarm bells?
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
I was 100% wary of Sparks and I still am. But it made sense for there to be multiple roles related to the rooms and theirs was way more limited.
 
Wee won the Old sign and Malus won the horse, told you all we shouldn't just let anyone enter these things (talking about malus)
 
So including us kyanrute, weemadarthur, faddy, aeleus, ynnek7, maolfunction, kalor, ketkat and Zeke are in the auction.

So many players means there's going to be lots of discarded bids like last time, maybe we should bid middiling amounts on multiple to try and pick em up.
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
I might go 0 7 3. The binoculars might let you spy on someone and see what they do one night and the pen might let you leave a will with actual game information. Not sure what the Netflix account could be.
 
I might go 0 7 3. The binoculars might let you spy on someone and see what they do one night and the pen might let you leave a will with actual game information. Not sure what the Netflix account could be.
I might go 6 4 0 then
 
With Fanto in the jail who do you think will end up the NK target, I definitely see myself as a possibility, especially if I'm right about blarg. Doubt either of you are likely to go.

Any ideas on who you're adding to the night chat tomorrow vere? I think Fanto wouldn't be a bad idea especially if you can use your item to heal him the next night.
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
I wouldn't be surprised if I was on the chopping block soon but probably not tonight since I imagine they'll focus on claimed roles for now. Ynnek could be dangerous for them, or they'll intentionally avoid sharing the same room.

Fanto would be a good choice for this chat.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
With Fanto in the jail who do you think will end up the NK target, I definitely see myself as a possibility, especially if I'm right about blarg. Doubt either of you are likely to go.

Any ideas on who you're adding to the night chat tomorrow vere? I think Fanto wouldn't be a bad idea especially if you can use your item to heal him the next night.
Yeah, I think they'll be going after claimed roles so we're safe.

I have to think on it, but you guys make a good case for Fanto. It's just that he's very likely to die the next day =/.
 
Yeah, I think they'll be going after claimed roles so we're safe.

I have to think on it, but you guys make a good case for Fanto. It's just that he's very likely to die the next day =/.
Can't you use your item to heal him? So we get at least 2 nights with him and maybe stop a kill.

Who are both of your current scum contenders by the way? Mine haven't really changed since last night.

Stan staying on blarg is interesting.
 
Him being Fanto
If Vere's unable to to use his item to protect him next night that's a good alternative, want me to push for only one person to be in the bathroom (though it wouldn't surprise me if the taco bell fills up the bathroom)
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Can't you use your item to heal him? So we get at least 2 nights with him and maybe stop a kill.

Who are both of your current scum contenders by the way? Mine haven't really changed since last night.

Stan staying on blarg is interesting.
I have three orders of pairs for scum currently from most likely to least.

Blarg definitely feels like scum, and he's just above Nicole on my wary list.

And I've come around to 50/50 on Proto Chuggs and Malus(this depends on if he's able to 'prove' that he's reliable today, since I bet he'll collab with Fanto) being a possibility.

My lower order for scum would include either Stan or Zeke.
If we keep one spot free in the bathroom tomorrow, I could move him in there.
That's an interesting idea. I'll echo leaving one spot free in the bathroom.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
If Vere's unable to to use his item to protect him next night that's a good alternative, want me to push for only one person to be in the bathroom (though it wouldn't surprise me if the taco bell fills up the bathroom)
I can try to heal him if he doesn't get into the bathroom.
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
Hopefully there's no sudden bomb in the biggest room since there's like 8 people there.
 
What's the point of a sparks expert if you don't even listen to them!!!

AAAAHHHHHHH!!!!!

I'm guessing neither of you submitted your day commands.
(with nin turning out to be an override it now looks like I have the most boring role)
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
I didn't submit anything.

That was frustrating to catch up on because part of me now wants to policy lynch Nin tomorrow because doing a override for shits and giggles is the last thing town needs right now. Especially when there was no real reason to suspect Sparks.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
What's the point of a sparks expert if you don't even listen to them!!!

AAAAHHHHHHH!!!!!

I'm guessing neither of you submitted your day commands.
(with nin turning out to be an override it now looks like I have the most boring role)
Fanto is lost to us friends. What do you think of Zeke and Kyan from this? I'm more likely to feel worse about Zeke since Kyan seemed somewhat uncertain about it.
 
Fanto is lost to us friends. What do you think of Zeke and Kyan from this? I'm more likely to feel worse about Zeke since Kyan seemed somewhat uncertain about it.
Can't you still heal him?

Honestly so pissed that Nin was insulting Sparks while actively gamethrowing (if he is town)
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
I feel pretty uncertain about Zeke right now. He was one of the people I was planning on rereading later before the day ended prematurely.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Can't you still heal him?

Honestly so pissed that Nin was insulting Sparks while actively gamethrowing (if he is town)
Could, I meant to the chat.

Ugh, I really don't know what to think about the gamestate right now. Masses of people are going AWOL because they're at a comfortable position with 3 scum and a neutral dead without considering the game.
 
I think tonight should give us decent intel on Zeke's role.
A) We know Zeke at the very least knows what items are in each auction
B) He's only won the auction when he was actually in the room where it was happening
C) With only me and him in the auction tonight there's no way he doesn't either get an item or at least force it to goto a gif bot raffle.

The question after than is whether his role is town. I'm mainly neutral on him but the mess up of calling Sorian a scum switcher gives him some towncred imo.
 
Could, I meant to the chat.

Ugh, I really don't know what to think about the gamestate right now. Masses of people are going AWOL because they're at a comfortable position with 3 scum and a neutral dead without considering the game.
Follow wee's lead, reread starting from day 1 and reflect on the state of the game.The only thing we're really at risk of is a hypothetical bomb as long as we don't go mad.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Follow wee's lead, reread starting from day 1 and reflect on the state of the game.The only thing we're really at risk of is a hypothetical bomb as long as we don't go mad.
Yeah, I probably will. Yesterday was just a bit much for me.
 
nvxDoaD.png
 
So actually playing the game, lets look at votes! (I really need a malus graph right now)

Major problems for me when considering voting are:
A) Who supported the rival trains for Sawneeks D1
B) Who supported voting Terra or Kalor D2
C) Who was absolutely comfertable with Zipped v Blarg

Nin: On Sawneeks early, stayed on Bae during the pull towards kalor and the Sorian check. Turboed Bae D3. Late on Zipped D4, and awfully override Sparks D5.
Hasn't voted town once. Once he made a decision he seems to stick with it. How likely was he to bus his team mates 2 days in a row? That with the claim makes me feel null to town vibes only going on voting record.

Death gives info on those who pushed him

----------------------------
Chuggs: Late game push on Wee D1, switched to Terra. Mid day vote on Kalor then switches back to Terra, goes back to Kalor due to Sorian's push in a vote I remember disliking. Vote on Bae D3 happens after Fanto's claim so no brownie points there. Immediate vote on malus before subbing.

Turmoil7: After subbing in joke votes blarg, follows by pushing for an info lunch on Zipped then goes for a weird thing about finding a second place in feps. D5 pushes to turbo Blarg, after blarg dies has very weak votes on Malus and TP.
Both have sketchy voting records them and Stan being the only alive people I don't townread on the Terra train D1 (Chuggs was the first vote so less likely an attempt to create a rival train, at time of voting Sneeks had 3 votes). 4th vote on kalor and made it within 1 vote of Baes train, changes to Terra as kalor loses steam and Terra gains it bringing it 2 votes higher than bae. Upon switching back to Kalor with the overdramatic 'fuck it' post the votes were Terra 7 and Bae 6 so the vote brought Terra to tie with Bae. Was it too risky to have a scum leave a train which was currently keeping another member alive in order to start a new one with another scum member, making them both look back if they switched back to Bae to save them? When I actually look at the votes by themselves my answer is 'maybe?'. Chuggs votes after that aren't interesting and Turmoil doesn't seem that involved in the game (I think a SK turmoil acted similar?)

Death gives info on feps and malus?

------------------------------
Stu: Voted Nin for fluffy posts, called out by Sorian for being a 'shit vote' (so happy I don't have to put up with stuff like that now that he's dead, always extremely aggrivating), subbed out fairly soon afterwards.

Loki: Ties with Sneeks with a vote on Terra (now both at 4). Stays on him till EoD after the competing wagons (that's the actual term!) became Sneeks V TWE V Zeke. Votes Terra again D2 competing with Kalor at 4 and Bae at 4. Subs out D3 but they'd have voted Bae anyway so doesn't really matter.

Stan: Late vote on Blarg D4 tightening the race between Blarg and Zipped, stupid hijinks with Sparks D5
Stu and Blarg are pretty fine tbh, Stu is always weak D1 and I kinda like some of the posts Stan had around Blarg and Sparks. Loki is the interesting one, defends Sneeks D1 but ignores the wagon competing against scum D2 instead furthering another town wagon. Overall one of the more suspicious.

I'll try to look up feps and Nicole later, anyone else you guys recommend?
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Malus feels like scum to me. It's likely that his first vote on Saw was a bus, and every other vote thereafter was about riding Chuggs. I can guess they might be roomies. Also, notice that Malus dropped his confirmation plan after Monkey died and hasn't brought it up again besides to waffle. He's stalling.
 
Malus feels like scum to me. It's likely that his first vote on Saw was a bus, and every other vote thereafter was about riding Chuggs. I can guess they might be roomies. Also, notice that Malus dropped his confirmation plan after Monkey died and hasn't brought it up again besides to waffle. He's stalling.
Can you link the post about his confirmation plan, I can't remember it
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
For being about to start day 6, I still don't have decent reads on a large amount of players. The replacements certainly haven't helped but it feels like town have gotten too content after the game opening so well so they aren't posting as much, which in turns allow scum to post less.
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
Scum/neutrals will be in

Malus
Maol
Turmoil
Stan
Whoever the second person that encouraged the override was.

I don't see Nin being scum. Maybe neutral but the override only makes sense if it came from an item.
 
Scum/neutrals will be in

Malus
Maol
Turmoil
Stan
Whoever the second person that encouraged the override was.

I don't see Nin being scum. Maybe neutral but the override only makes sense if it came from an item.
What makes you more wary of Maol than TP or FEPs?
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
What makes you more wary of Maol than TP or FEPs?

I was going off the top of my head and I may have forget they were in the game, especially TP. Tearable would be on that list as well then.

FEP seems fine to me. Might feel differently on a reread.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Maol doesn't seem very scummy. I know it's a bastard game but I don't think a day vig would be scum...but I'm now confused on how Monkey could have confirmed his towniness.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
@Aeleus Good play mate! Got em! I guess that means Ket's role does have a basis.

Of the remaining scum I'm thinking they could be in

Turmoil (1)
Ynnek (3)
Kyaaaaa (4)
Stan (2)
Feps (2)

Ordered from most to least likely.
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Hm...who has a bad schedule? Stan isn't playing.

Loki is good people, but I expect her to be more active than she was as town. Didn't build confidence.
Lol at this history
I'm actually unsure about Wee. I wouldn't be surprised if she turned out to be neutral or scum.

Why don't you think she'd be scum?
Just because when we met I was scum you never see me as anything else
C9H13NO3, as in the chemical formula of Adrenaline.

I really hope Scum wasted ages thinking about that :P
Beautiful.
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
The data didn’t specify it was a day command
What's the point of a sparks expert if you don't even listen to them!!!

AAAAHHHHHHH!!!!!

I'm guessing neither of you submitted your day commands.
(with nin turning out to be an override it now looks like I have the most boring role)
Day commands are hard, i almost forgot mine today
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Scum gossips have been done, but that doesn’t mean they can’t be done again.

So today seems to have truly cleared maolfunction and ketkat. Turms still needs to go as I believe he is mafia. Then we prob have 1 left.

I suspect maol will die, too scary for scum to keep.
 
Top Bottom