Yup, this was me.Muffin if this is your doing you have to let me know. For my sanity.
For that plan to work I hope you have worked on the not believing part :P
Is it? Okay, to be fair, in my last game malus/rac were scum with gossip as side power and 2 shots iirc. But I've also seen Town Brazil who could put other people in chats with two shots in HvV2.2-shot is pretty small too for a gossip so that kinda stinks...
Yeah agreed, though I always have a hard time reading D1. My main takeaway concerning town reads, coming from Doggy Style mafia, Geno seems the same as that game where he was town, and he's generally a pretty good player imo.I think we'd be better off sharing opinions/reads here in case the other dies during the Night. I'm currently rereading Day 1 so just kinda gathering some thoughts and ideas and I'll leave em here.
Probably Geno to share reads, or someone like Ynnek who I think I had the least contact with so far in Mafia games.Who would you have picked if you didn't pick me?
Yes, I send the command the day before.Goodnight! o/
After reading Day 1 again I'd agree with you on Geno. He seems pretty forthcoming with his thoughts despite not liking Day 1 and nothing he has done has come across as scummy.
This is more for curiosities sake and you absolutely do not have to answer but do you submit your command during the day phase to start the gossip chat? I think that's how it works but google isnt giving me an answer and im too tired to try and hunt down more info
I think he's a liability. He's way more concerned about being liked by everyone than scumhunting and that makes him flip-flop on his opinions and say things as safe as possible in an attempt to remain in the game while throwing light shade as follow up to proper accusations to make it seem like he agrees with people. That makes him both easy to sway and unhelpful to town.
2 hours to go. Best case scenario is we hit scum with Spark, and scum is not making an effort to save him because they can't come up with a better alternative or a good defense/they tried (ynnek's post) and then immediately withdrew because of the slip up?
Worst case scenario this is town lunching town and they're just sitting in the back.
shrug
Knowing something other people don't isn't anything to necessarily be suspicious of, especially not Day 1. I'm still partially wary of him for what I read as pre-emptively trying to cast suspicion re: the briefcase thing, but I'm much more wary of people trying to saying information asymmetry is bad on Day 1.
1) Lmao. Are you really still on me wanting to vote you because of the briefcase thing? Cause that's a misleading interpretation of my logic at best.
2) One thing I'm noticing that jumps out a bit is Geno's playstyle. It's been ages since I've played period, so it's entirely possible it's a style thing, but Geno has had very very meaningless comments so far this game. He's engaged with: Nin, and you. Nin he was ok voting for out of the gate because Geno finds it hard to read Nin. They had some back and forth together but it never really went anywhere. Felt a little staged and meaningless to me. When interacting with you he was very flippant and again void of directly interacting much other than "Yeah a vote on sparks would be ok".
To that end, despite the fact that I'd normally like to stop with pressure votes at this time frame...
Vote: Geno
What're your overall reads here?
Then there's a jumble of Stan, Chuggs, Royal, nin, Ynnek, Kalor,
For...some reason.Mmn yeah, I disagree with the sparks lunch, I think he hasn't been as jumpy and unpredictable as usual and that may make him look weird but not scum to me
I would go Geno but unlike nin he only has one vote and this stalemate would keep going so as I am finding nin off too
Vote:nin
Didnt know we're gonna reuse the same chat. Is that intentional?Enjoy your evening, gossips.
I think that's what she meant when she said posts are not deleted? I'm not used to this either.Didnt know we're gonna reuse the same chat. Is that intentional?
Yeah I thought that means I can keep looking back at this chat, as can Sneeks, but we two were getting a second one again. That's how I know it at least.I think that's what she meant when she said posts are not deleted? I'm not used to this either.
Turm is acting mega shady, so if next nights results arent him dead or he has satisfying investigative results, he's pretty lynchable.Anyway I'm pretty mad at myself for being wrong about nin again, and Stan left which gets scum closer to a win :/. What are your thoughts?
Yeah ngl the claim is the only one saving Turm. I agree on Royal, I didn't really think Fireblend was weird D1 but D2 he's been pretty scummy. Chuggs I need to reread tomorrow but I wouldn't be surprised if a 3rd member was Chuggs or Kalor.Turm is acting mega shady, so if next nights results arent him dead or he has satisfying investigative results, he's pretty lynchable.
And I'm considering a connection between Royal and Chuggs as scum team, maybe throw Fireblend in the mix. At least thats what that day end is telling me.
Yup, agreed. How many scum you think? I'm thinking 3 since we had a neutral.Also still have some doubts regarding Kalor in my mind. He has been playing extra effortless.
That's funny, if you'd have asked me who I think is towniest besides you, I also would have named Sneeks and Fran.I'm sure on you, Sneeks and Fran, I'll be very very surprised if any of you turned out to be scum
It's probably because we've both played with them a lot and know their playstyles pretty much.That's funny, if you'd have asked me who I think is towniest besides you, I also would have named Sneeks and Fran.
Three seems about right with a neutral. I'm trying to think of a few combinations right now.Yup, agreed. How many scum you think? I'm thinking 3 since we had a neutral.
I don't remember Chuggs as scum at all in recent memory, last game he suicided so I don't really count that, idk if he would've done something like that but knowing him he does play dangerously sometimes. Then again Flush wasn't really needed saving since 2 of his voters moved on me so maybe it was genuine. I could easily see Ynnek and Captain as scum too tbh, both seem to be cruising a lot, Ynnek was a bit more active D1 and Captain I need to reread but I remember him going with the flow a lot.Three seems about right with a neutral. I'm trying to think of a few combinations right now.
I can see Turm - Chuggs - Royal or Kalor - Chuggs - Royal working out for example. Or exchange Chuggs for Fireblend. Chuggs saving Royal like that with his nin vote may be too obvious to do for scum.
I had Captain in mind for a little bit but I'm not sure about it. Ynnek got dangerously high to a lynch on D1 and on D2 also for a time, so that might indicate something, I agree. I barely know Ynnek from previous mafia games so it's hard to read him for me.I don't remember Chuggs as scum at all in recent memory, last game he suicided so I don't really count that, idk if he would've done something like that but knowing him he does play dangerously sometimes. Then again Flush wasn't really needed saving since 2 of his voters moved on me so maybe it was genuine. I could easily see Ynnek and Captain as scum too tbh, both seem to be cruising a lot, Ynnek was a bit more active D1 and Captain I need to reread but I remember him going with the flow a lot.
I was scum with him once in a Bill and Ted mini mafia iirc, I might reread that but no promises because I'm a bit busy these days.I had Captain in mind for a little bit but I'm not sure about it. Ynnek got dangerously high to a lynch on D1 and on D2 also for a time, so that might indicate something, I agree. I barely know Ynnek from previous mafia games so it's hard to read him for me.
Yeah up to 2 seems about right, I don't think all 3 piled up on nin, the third one probably being on me. Idk I don't wanna see too omgus but I don't like Fireblends reasoning to vote me haha.Looking back at the nin lynch, discounting you, Sneeks and Fran, there were Royal, Chuggs and Ynnek on the lynch at the end. I think there might be up to two scum there.
It isn't a very solid vote, so scumFire might have coordinated with Turm, or townFire was just not fond of the other options and wanted another vote to escape to. Hard to say for now.Yeah up to 2 seems about right, I don't think all 3 piled up on nin, the third one probably being on me. Idk I don't wanna see too omgus but I don't like Fireblends reasoning to vote me haha.
Maybe yeah, although a better justification would be nice haha.It isn't a very solid vote, so scumFire might have coordinated with Turm, or townFire was just not fond of the other options and wanted another vote to escape to. Hard to say for now.
Good points overall, I have nothing more to add. I really hope Fran isnt playing a really good scum game or something, because I'm pretty confident in the reads we discussed so far.Maybe yeah, although a better justification would be nice haha.
Anyway reread Captain, D1 he seemed to be trying a bit, the funniest part is that he also said that it's not excusable to do the bare minimum to get to the minimum post count without it being questioned, which was basically him D2 where he speculated a bit about how malus died and did very little otherwise. If turmoil is indeed a cop he's not 100% clear because godfather but I'll let it go for a bit, slight scum lean to scum lean for him.
Chuggs D2 said he felt nin was town yet he ends up voting for him just because of the bp claim? That's sus, why did he feel the need to join a wagon? Could've voted Kalor since that's who he wanted dead, like, he says quite a few times he'd vote Kalor and ends up on Ynnek who was after him, why? Why not prioritize Kalor if that's who he wanted dead most, it's not like Ynnek was in a state where he could be easily voted out and he felt voting there was good. Chuggs is probably scum, but I wouldn't lynch before Flush who is my biggest scum read now. If Chuggs flips scum then I'm confident Kalor is as well.
Yeah lol, I'll say it was a deserved win if that's the case.Good points overall, I have nothing more to add. I really hope Fran isnt playing a really good scum game or something, because I'm pretty confident in the reads we discussed so far.