Mario & Luigi's Brooklyn Apartment - Scum Thread

Fanto

Confirmed Town
nDc8RfM.png


Welcome to the Scum Thread!

Feel free to post your commands in here at night.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
waddup

Seems like it's first time being scum for both of us?

On that note, @Fanto, are there any rules to information we share in this chat? I know from Costume Party they just posted their whole role PMs, just wanted to make sure that was ok
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Yep, Mario

As Mafia, you share a factional kill you can perform once per night by posting the command KILL: <Player name> on your private thread. You can instead post the command Ninja: <Player name> to perform the kill while being undetected.

This command will replace the normal factional kill on that night.

Your roleblock have any limitations other than being one-shot?
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
There's only 11 players in sure we can brainstorm the characters that "have to be in" and come up with something.
Yeah, that’s probably a good idea.

I’d venture to guess there’s a neutral mixed in there, as well. Do you think it’s just villain flavor for town?

Possible names:
Bowser
Koopa Troopa
Bowser Jr
Bullet Bill
Piranha Plant
Blooper
Cheep-cheep
Spiny
Lakitu
Chain Chomp
Wario
Waluigi
Donkey Kong
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
It's super important we never reveal our real role names it will be obvious when one of us flip scum who the other scum is. I knew my scum partner was Mario before I opened the thread.
100%. It would be too easy. I think we need to push out role claiming as much as we can. We will need to lie eventually to win, but the more information we have at that point about which flavor/role we can’t claim, the better.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
100%. It would be too easy. I think we need to push out role claiming as much as we can. We will need to lie eventually to win, but the more information we have at that point about which flavor/role we can’t claim, the better.
To hard to tell if the town is Holland yet gonna have to see a flip it two. We should not have to worry about a fake claim on day 1 so we have time. How often do you usually post?
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
From speccing your last game, I think you and I also have a similar problem - we tend to post a lot and that’s a very townie trait. Town wouldn’t expect either of us to survive very long playing that way if we were town, which will become a problem late game. I think how we behave is going to be crucial and I’m not sure there’s any real solution there. Our best bet might be to sheep strong town and fall back a bit as the game progresses.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
From speccing your last game, I think you and I also have a similar problem - we tend to post a lot and that’s a very townie trait. Town wouldn’t expect either of us to survive very long playing that way if we were town, which will become a problem late game. I think how we behave is going to be crucial and I’m not sure there’s any real solution there. Our best bet might be to sheep strong town and fall back a bit as the game progresses.
my first game had multiple inactive scum so I was thinking maybe I could be very anti inactivity early game and make soft pushes to lunch low post count since that screwed me last time.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
my first game had multiple inactive scum so I was thinking maybe I could be very anti inactivity early game and make soft pushes to lunch low post count since that screwed me last time.
That might be the way to do it. Definitely putting out content-rich posts, but not running the show so you're not made an obvious target who won't die for some reason. I'm not super familiar with everyone else's playstyles in this game, but no one stands out as playing meta strongly like for example Dr. Monkey does, so that's a good thing for us in however we want to change up our playstyles.

The bad news for me is that there are at least two in the game who know my playstyle pretty well, so my shift can't be too abrupt. I can ease out of posting, feign that I'm losing interest in the game as it goes on.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
my first game had multiple inactive scum so I was thinking maybe I could be very anti inactivity early game and make soft pushes to lunch low post count since that screwed me last time.
sorry, I misread "anti inactivity" as something else lol

But I agree that's a valid approach. Just poking low activity folks wouldn't stand out to potential scum than someone who is actively reading and analyzing posts.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Also, given it's just the two of us, we should absolutely not bus.

I think we should definitely just play off what we see in the thread and interact with each other as it makes sense based on what we're saying. If what either one of us says makes sense, we back each other up; if we're talking total malarkey, we call each other out. It's not going to buy us any towncred if we were right about the other one being scum; it's either the opposite or it creates a WIFOM situation at best.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Also, given it's just the two of us, we should absolutely not bus.

I think we should definitely just play off what we see in the thread and interact with each other as it makes sense based on what we're saying. If what either one of us says makes sense, we back each other up; if we're talking total malarkey, we call each other out. It's not going to buy us any towncred if we were right about the other one being scum; it's either the opposite or it creates a WIFOM situation at best.
I just planed to act neutral toward you no strong feelings one way or the other so that I can pivot any direction we need as the game goes on.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Be really careful about implying you’re going to survive. That last comment was not anything folks will key in on, but something worth noting since a scum slipped on that in Costume Party and Natiko in particular caught it.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
It scared me that I'm talking a lot but it also feels natural to talk a lot (highest post count in Nier 300 posts in only 4 days) I'm trying to just play like myself.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
You’re doing good, I think it’s very consistent with your playstyle there. I just wanted to call attention that type of slip.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Be really careful about implying you’re going to survive. That last comment was not anything folks will key in on, but something worth noting since a scum slipped on that in Costume Party and Natiko in particular caught it.
Is Natiko good? Someone we need to kill early? Don't wanna make our night kill targets to obvious or easy to trace back to us.

Also what character was he or any players in this game in costume party? might read that game of i have time.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Is Natiko good? Someone we need to kill early? Don't wanna make our night kill targets to obvious or easy to trace back to us.

Also what character was he or any players in this game in costume party? might read that game of i have time.
Natiko was the game runner for that. The last scum made a slip and no one else caught it (in or out of the game).

he is definitely a good target to consider.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Natiko might be trying to bait players to see how they react with that last post. I wouldn’t take anything he says to heart.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I might be speaking more for myself there, I tend to get worked up in these games more often than I should haha
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Natiko might be trying to bait players to see how they react with that last post. I wouldn’t take anything he says to heart.
I am responding to all of nation's post to try and "read" him as scum or town just like I didn't back down from sorian when he question me day 1.

Don't worry i am not worked up at all just going through the motions interacting with people.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I am responding to all of nation's post to try and "read" him as scum or town just like I didn't back down from sorian when he question me day 1.

Don't worry i am not worked up at all just going through the motions interacting with people.
Sorry, I didn’t mean to imply you were. That was more directed at him saying most players are bad haha
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Agree. I’m probably in that group too
I think mafia is a very difficult game to play well consistently just like any social game. There's no perfect formula for success. It's all about reading people such is hard for me not being a incredibly social guy. But hey would not be as fun of it were easy so I'll just keep trying my best.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Yeah, that’s probably a good idea.

I’d venture to guess there’s a neutral mixed in there, as well. Do you think it’s just villain flavor for town?

Possible names:
Bowser
Koopa Troopa

Bowser Jr
Bullet Bill
Piranha Plant
Blooper
Cheep-cheep
Spiny
Lakitu
Chain Chomp
Wario
Waluigi

Donkey Kong
Been playing Paper Mario and a few more flavor names occurred to me:
Dry Bones
Koopa Paratroopa
Paragoomba
Boo

I bolded the names I think are for sure in the game. In Piranha Plant is in the game, I would bet that's a commuter role.

I think the Paragoomba and Koopa Paratroopa are probably safe bets if we were pressed to roleclaim for right now. We could just call those vanilla.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
If Piranha Plant*

As for other possible roles, my ninja kill implies some sort of motion detector. We should be on the lookout in D2 for anyone being a little cagey and possibly breadcrumbing it. Aside from doctors and cops, a motion detector could screw us over in the late game.

Also, since the standard for 11 player games is 3 scum, and there are only 2 of us, I think it's a safe bet there's a neutral out there. That's going to be a little harder to spot, but we should be on the lookout and avoid killing them ourselves if we can.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I would ignore coolspot's vote on you for the moment let's see how others react. Most likely won't gain traction and you don't wanna look too defensive.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I think Coolest and Maol are going to be good to keep around. They are drawing a lot of negative attention to themselves.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I think Coolest and Maol are going to be good to keep around. They are drawing a lot of negative attention to themselves.
I think I have to keep my vote and attention on Maolfunction for now I've gone after him so hard it would be strange to suddenly change coarse out of nowhere but I can change vote late in the day if a better option presents itself naturally.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I say just follow whatever your train of thought is. Since it’s neither of us on the chopping block, I’m not too concerned about coordinating anything. I’m more worried about blending and I think we’re doing a good job there so far.

whatever votes we put down, we just need to be able to justify it. In that way, it’s better we look at the game as it is unfolding rather than choose a target and try to fit a narrative to them. Town doesn’t need our help to slip up and cannibalize itself.

I’m probably going to keep my vote on Maol unless something drastic happens. I’ll do some posturing on not wanting a tie at day end in case I need to flip my vote. Town is going to scrutinize last minute vote changes, so keep that in mind. They always do it and it’s always pointless.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I say just follow whatever your train of thought is. Since it’s neither of us on the chopping block, I’m not too concerned about coordinating anything. I’m more worried about blending and I think we’re doing a good job there so far.

whatever votes we put down, we just need to be able to justify it. In that way, it’s better we look at the game as it is unfolding rather than choose a target and try to fit a narrative to them. Town doesn’t need our help to slip up and cannibalize itself.

I’m probably going to keep my vote on Maol unless something drastic happens. I’ll do some posturing on not wanting a tie at day end in case I need to flip my vote. Town is going to scrutinize last minute vote changes, so keep that in mind. They always do it and it’s always pointless.
That's a bummer last minute vote flips are my thing I purposely tied the vote with 2 minutes to go day 1 of Nier just to get people to react. I play very hard (way too hard lol)
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
It's cool if you go that route, but just be prepared to defend it. There's definitely a subset of folks who will just rely on reading that. I did it in the last game I played, even lol
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
That's a bummer last minute vote flips are my thing I purposely tied the vote with 2 minutes to go day 1 of Nier just to get people to react. I play very hard (way too hard lol)
To clarify when I am town i try to get the vote as close as possible end of day to force others to have to change votes .sorian and another person called me out on it but people forgot like 2 minutes later both time I pulled vote manipulation shenanigans.

When I am actually town again I will keep doing this strategy but for since I am scum I can play it more chill
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
To clarify when I am town i try to get the vote as close as possible end of day to force others to have to change votes .sorian and another person called me out on it but people forgot like 2 minutes later both time I pulled vote manipulation shenanigans.

When I am actually town again I will keep doing this strategy but for since I am scum I can play it more chill
Folks don't have near as much to look back on for you, so it won't matter either way. You can just brush it off as "that's just how I play" or not do it and say you're trying to not do that anymore. I think either way is fine. It's all WIFOM, after all.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I don't really want to make the Coolest train happen. I think he is helpful for us to stay hidden by causing problems. I'm probably going to end up moving my vote back to Maol if he stays in the lead.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I think the real reason Uzzy is playing reservedly is because she has a power role. Regardless of how many times she's posted, I feel the same way about her that CoolestSpot does there. That said, we might be able to get town to kill her D2 at this rate; it'll help to keep Coolest alive to make that happen.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I don't really want to make the Coolest train happen. I think he is helpful for us to stay hidden by causing problems. I'm probably going to end up moving my vote back to Maol if he stays in the lead.
Move your vote to maol since you respected him all thread. I will move my vote to Alexem somebody else will break the tie don't worry
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Voted after end of day by accident. Fran last comment about maolfunction and cool never playing together was my reason both will have major suspicion tomorow
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Voted after end of day by accident. Fran last comment about maolfunction and cool never playing together was my reason both will have major suspicion tomorow
Yeah, that was class. I think having a vote come in after day end is accidentally a great thing, actually.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Who we trying to kill tonight. Fran scared me the most because he recently played with me and I feel he can see through me the best he was totally right about me voting Natinko to try and day kill dangerous player but hitting him now would probably be way to obvious
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Here's who I think are good options:
Natiko - widely town read. He is my top choice to die, but I also think he's likeliest to be protected. On the other hand, I'm also being largely town read and I might be the protection target. I feel confident in saying it's between us two.
Fran - to address your post there, I think Fran is also pretty high on the town list. I think Natiko and him are at odds with each other as well, though, and that might be enough of a distraction to keep the two of them preoccupied. He also brought up the Maol/Coolest discrepancy, and that might have legs. If we focus on that slip and fall back on Coolest causing problems again, I think Fran can stay alive for tonight.
Verelios - I think Verelios is also largely town read, but that's definitely lower key than the above two. He would be a safe choice to NK, I don't see him being protected tonight unless someone goes by pure post count.

I think these players have enough heat on them that they're not worth looking at:
Uzzy
Z-Beat
Maolfunction
Brazil
CoolestSpot
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
We can take our time discussing, we don't need to make a decision right away if you need time to think on it also.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
oh, also to address your point of it being too obvious, it's just WIFOM. The town will be able to argue against itself to the point of not caring anymore. I don't think it's a big deal. I'm more worried about ability usage...
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
On the other hand, when Coolest and/or Maol flip town, Fran is going to look pretty bad, too.
We could kill Fran he flips town then the last thing he died saying was throwing suspicion on both cool and maol we could easily carry that torch ourselves after he is gone?
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
We could kill Fran he flips town then the last thing he died saying was throwing suspicion on both cool and maol we could easily carry that torch ourselves after he is gone?
That's a pretty good point there. There will be some that say it's too obvious, but we can navigate that and argue both sides.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I think I'm on board for Fran. How do you feel about the rest of the players?
Assuming your talking about killing Natinko is my number 1 but I assume he will be protected I feel the same about uzzy as a playtime but she has suspicion plus killing new players day/night 1 is just wrong. Verelios has highest post count when Fran and Natiko are eventually gone he is our shield of town wants to lunch "leaders" or high post count people.

If we really want to play it safe voting a random low poster who won't be protected is still an option.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Assuming your talking about killing Natinko is my number 1 but I assume he will be protected I feel the same about uzzy as a playtime but she has suspicion plus killing new players day/night 1 is just wrong. Verelios has highest post count when Fran and Natiko are eventually gone he is our shield of town wants to lunch "leaders" or high post count people.

If we really want to play it safe voting a random low poster who won't be protected is still an option.
uzzy as a role player
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Assuming your talking about killing Natinko is my number 1 but I assume he will be protected I feel the same about uzzy as a playtime but she has suspicion plus killing new players day/night 1 is just wrong. Verelios has highest post count when Fran and Natiko are eventually gone he is our shield of town wants to lunch "leaders" or high post count people.

If we really want to play it safe voting a random low poster who won't be protected is still an option.
Yep, definitely a good point that Verelios can give us cover if we let him live.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
We didn’t comment on it, but I guess it’s worth noting the reason Fanto didn’t give us any flavor names is because all the vanillas are Goombas
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Yeah, I was thinking of the reverse. Usually town would have had to kill the neutral ("all threats") to win, but I guess a survivor isn't really a "threat".
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Yeah, I was thinking of the reverse. Usually town would have had to kill the neutral ("all threats") to win, but I guess a survivor isn't really a "threat".
Obviously killing a town would be better this is not ideal but not a disastrous outcome unless I'm wrong (I might be ) Fran does not change the majority we need to hold this game. Our role on says (you win when mafia team holds majority of votes) Fran is not a member of mafia team.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Obviously killing a town would be better this is not ideal but not a disastrous outcome unless I'm wrong (I might be ) Fran does not change the majority we need to hold this game. Our role on says (you win when mafia team holds majority of votes) Fran is not a member of mafia team.
You're correct on that.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I'll probably end up on that train, but I'm going to meander a bit and pull back on meaningful contribution today.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I'll probably end up on that train, but I'm going to meander a bit and pull back on meaningful contribution today.
I am going to throw a little suspicion on you in response to malfunctions post just so it doesn't look like I never said anything negative about you all game.

Plus town me would put a little pressure on you.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I am going to throw a little suspicion on you in response to malfunctions post just so it doesn't look like I never said anything negative about you all game.

Plus town me would put a little pressure on you.
Actually never mind I have a more surreal way to phrase my response.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I am going to throw a little suspicion on you in response to malfunctions post just so it doesn't look like I never said anything negative about you all game.

Plus town me would put a little pressure on you.
Understood. I'm probably just going to blow both of you off, I don't think Maol's reasoning holds up even for my usual town playstyle
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I'm just going to talk around Maol for a few posts. He has no support and the more questions I ask, the more obvious it is his reasoning doesn't hold up.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I'm just going to talk around Maol for a few posts. He has no support and the more questions I ask, the more obvious it is his reasoning doesn't hold up.
Yep he is getting no support. I am still typing my coolest post right now (I type slow)
Looks like people might be taking a bit of the Fran bait we left. Verilios is right about Fran getting to close for comfort for me but he talks about me so briefly I doubt they will pick up. That's why I wanted to take the shot right away before he went harder on me making it so we can't kill him at night.
 
Top Bottom