Scum Thread Evil League

Stantastic

Our Badminton Stanpion
Ah my bad, today has left me bloody tired so i think im predisposed to crankyness right now.

Now excuse me while i refuse to acknowledge that misunderstanding in public view.
 
Sorry Lanuch but I feel like I'd be the same way if I was town as nothing people have posted would make me vote for Polt or Jman.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I went ahead and voted for Launch too-- I wanted to vote for him earlier so I can move it later in a less suspicious manner, I remember Maol saying in transistor that that can be a good tactic when voting for a mafia teammate.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I’m not overly worried. I’ll fake claim if it starts getting close and even if I die, it’s not a big deal.

I think Kopite made a good argument on why I’m not scum, and that’s what I was going for. This is how I usually play town, kind of all over the place.


Sorry Lanuch but I feel like I'd be the same way if I was town as nothing people have posted would make me vote for Polt or Jman.
What about Verelios? Can you make a case there?
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I'll come over to Verelios if need be, I left a lot of outs by saying I need to read over the thread etc. You only have one non-mafia member voting for you LOL
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I'll come over to Verelios if need be, I left a lot of outs by saying I need to read over the thread etc. You only have one non-mafia member voting for you LOL
damn I hate this team! :laughing:

It's not a successful game unless I come within a few minutes of getting lynched.
 
btw I MAY sub out in a bit.

I'm still feeling down today so if I don't feel better by EOD, I'll sub out. Just a warning incase I do.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
don't kill me before you leave pls

Seriously, sorry to hear that. Hopefully you feel better. I'd be sad to see you go.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Sorry to hear that Stu!

Launch I don't think you're going to be killed, I think we're still in too much of a flurry
 
Oh god i didnt think Stu and Hawthorn would both join the launch train lol. I'm short on time but I could attempt to squeeze a move onto Polter if need be.
 
So sorry scum mates but I am out now. I just feel too... urgh to play. FML :(

Have fun, I'll be rooting for you guys from spec.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
No worries, Stu, and we'll try to do a good job for you! Not going to say bye in the thread because I'm pretending that I'm not reading it XD
 
I have to go and I couldnt form my argument to move off Launch since I've been busy all day, so I hope town just narturally moves off of him before EoD.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
You could always say that you find all the main trains a distraction & switch to someone like Malus or another quiet player before leaving? But only you know if that's in character for you, don't risk it if not
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
The worst case scenario is I die, and Stu's replacement + Terra get immense town cred. However, if it's coming down close, I plan to move to Poltergust at the last minute.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I'm saying that to reassure myself because I'm actually very nervous. I'm watching the thread, but trying not to post too much. People might get spooked about these trains if it's too quiet for too long.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I wish I could get in there and defend you, but I feel like that would almost be more suspicious. We have to come up with some reason for people to go after poltergust. Or maybe Natiko will unvote when he gets here..
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I wish I could get in there and defend you, but I feel like that would almost be more suspicious. We have to come up with some reason for people to go after poltergust. Or maybe Natiko will unvote when he gets here..
I don't want anyone to do anything on my behalf except Natiko be like "aight let me unvote while I reread" and figure out somewhere else to vote. You've done enough, Hawthorn. Stay where you are.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I know you're right, it's just against my instincts! Don't think I'll post again today most likely. Also it looks like poltergust is pretty checked out, I think he'll push ahead of you
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Okay, better than last time when he had role claimed serial killer lol
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I didn't want to mention it because it'd be weird if you had this piece of information too quickly, but you and I are also in an alliance. Most of that is inconsequential to what is currently going on with me in the hotseat, but it's worth noting.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Hi Natiko! I remember you from some of the past games I read when I found this community, glad to be on a team with you

The other thing is that there have been some updates explaining the rules & how movement/alliances/attacking works. I think there's still a general state of confusion about the risk mechanics
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I'm going to put feelers out to see if anyone can give me something strong enough to bite on. Otherwise I think I'll just stick to the current vote with the argument that Stu was up to date when he checked out with only a couple hours left in the phase so it's better than anything I can come up with in that amount of time. I can unvote to 'prevent ties' as well should it be needed to save you.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I'm going to put feelers out to see if anyone can give me something strong enough to bite on. Otherwise I think I'll just stick to the current vote with the argument that Stu was up to date when he checked out with only a couple hours left in the phase so it's better than anything I can come up with in that amount of time. I can unvote to 'prevent ties' as well should it be needed to save you.
Right on.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
This game gonna turn into a super petty fest at each day end huh lol
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Pretty dumb, but oh well. Kyan got two territories but the rule states one so I guess he has a special ability or something.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Meanwhile in Geno's head...

"I said I'd be back in a few hours, leave me alone Jman" :laughing:
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Some thoughts on night actions:
  • As Natiko well knows, coming to close to getting lynched means I’m a likely candidate to be watched/tracked/investigated tonight, so I believe I should stay put tonight.
  • Jman is also a likely candidate to be watched tonight, so while I think roleblocking him would be the optimal move, I think it could backfire on us. For Natiko, Jman soft-claimed some stuff, basically that his ability has some drawbacks for town, that it’s a role we will never guess, and that he basically cant be killed at night. I think we should instead use the investigation ability on him N2.
  • As for who to kill, Chuggs is as usual an easy target because he’s going to be a de facto town leader. I’d throw Hedin, Kyanrute, Verelios in there as potential dangers as the game goes on; bonus points that the latter two were on my train. Off the top of my head, I think Uzzy and Ambulance are good low information kills, but they will get attention as the game goes on anyway.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I keep forgetting Zipped is confirmed lol we don’t have to worry too much about having him out there, we can get him N3 or something
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
That was a dramatic day end to read back over!

We have two long range kills-- Stan's and mine, mine is my bonus for having my home territory of Ukraine, which I count as having because I allied with Weemadarthur, as far as my understanding goes.

Agree that Launchpad should stay put tonight.

Couldn't we investigat Jman tonight? Find out what his unguessable role is? I'm not worried about being caught visiting him if he's alive in the morning, I feel like he's a pretty natural magnet for people.

My read of our night kill ability, including the long range kills, is that it kills territories not players. So to actually eliminate a player we have to use it on someone who has only one territory and doesn't have an alliance partner for the general to flee to. This narrows the field a lot.

Geno: If player A and Player B are in an alliance but are NOT adjacent, and player A's only territory is wiped out, will player A's general still flee to player B's distant lands? Or will player A die? I wanted to ask this during the day, but didn't want to clear up any confusion that might be happening XD
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
That was a dramatic day end to read back over!

We have two long range kills-- Stan's and mine, mine is my bonus for having my home territory of Ukraine, which I count as having because I allied with Weemadarthur, as far as my understanding goes.

Agree that Launchpad should stay put tonight.

Couldn't we investigat Jman tonight? Find out what his unguessable role is? I'm not worried about being caught visiting him if he's alive in the morning, I feel like he's a pretty natural magnet for people.

My read of our night kill ability, including the long range kills, is that it kills territories not players. So to actually eliminate a player we have to use it on someone who has only one territory and doesn't have an alliance partner for the general to flee to. This narrows the field a lot.

Geno: If player A and Player B are in an alliance but are NOT adjacent, and player A's only territory is wiped out, will player A's general still flee to player B's distant lands? Or will player A die? I wanted to ask this during the day, but didn't want to clear up any confusion that might be happening XD
RE: Jman, it’s a risk and at this point, I’m feeling kind of Maol-y and risk adverse. I’ll defer to the rest of the team

RE: faction kill, I’m reading it like if the general is in that territory we target, that General/player dies. May need Geno clarification.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Faction Kill: You can normally attack an adjacent territory taking it over instantly with the command Kill: Territory, if the general is on it then it kills the player. You can also install puppet territories with 3 battalions instead of taking it over yourself, the mafia collectively owns these territories and can privately attack with them other players independently of your normal attack.
Check the bolded
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
So if I'm reading all this right:

Stan can attack SEPARATELY from the faction kill if desired, but it won't be a 'kill' attack, just will try to take over territory. Stan's long range move is specifically for the faction kill and is one shot.

Hawthorne has a long range modifier for the faction kill so long as the alliance remains intact. The faction kill targets a territory but if the player's general is on that territory they will be removed from the game.

Without the use of the long range faction kills we are limited to only being able to kill a player who has their general in an adjacent territory to us.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Players with generals on a territory with no scum neighbors and at least 3 town neighbors:
  • Chugg - 3 players (Jman, Ambulance, Uzzy)
  • Uzzy - 3 players (Nin, Chugg, Ambulance)
  • Fran - 4 players (Kalor, Tearable, Kyan, Muffin)
  • Kalor - 3 players (Fran, Tearable, Weemad)
  • Nin - 3 players (Uzzy, Ynnek, Reki)
  • Reki - 3 players (Nin, Ynnek, Weemad)
  • Tearable - 4 players (Kalor, Fran, Kyan, Weemad)
I think that's everyone. Might be good to pop someone in this pool while we have the safety of a couple nights of long range kills that are free.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Note this is based on the map from the day before so idk what all may have changed. I just knew the Malus stuff from day end.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
So if I'm reading all this right:

Stan can attack SEPARATELY from the faction kill if desired, but it won't be a 'kill' attack, just will try to take over territory. Stan's long range move is specifically for the faction kill and is one shot.

Hawthorne has a long range modifier for the faction kill so long as the alliance remains intact. The faction kill targets a territory but if the player's general is on that territory they will be removed from the game.

Without the use of the long range faction kills we are limited to only being able to kill a player who has their general in an adjacent territory to us.
I think you’re reading that right.

Players with generals on a territory with no scum neighbors and at least 3 town neighbors:
  • Chugg - 3 players (Jman, Ambulance, Uzzy)
  • Uzzy - 3 players (Nin, Chugg, Ambulance)
  • Fran - 4 players (Kalor, Tearable, Kyan, Muffin)
  • Kalor - 3 players (Fran, Tearable, Weemad)
  • Nin - 3 players (Uzzy, Ynnek, Reki)
  • Reki - 3 players (Nin, Ynnek, Weemad)
  • Tearable - 4 players (Kalor, Fran, Kyan, Weemad)
I think that's everyone. Might be good to pop someone in this pool while we have the safety of a couple nights of long range kills that are free.
Forgot to look at the map. I think you’re right, and actually Fran is a good player in that pool I was looking at. I think with the exception of Chugg, everyone else there has a chance of getting lynched on any phase.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I would lean towards Chugg, Fran, or Reki of that group if that's what we want.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Yes, what you both said is right-- we have to attack the territory with the general to kill the player, but the general won't flee from our faction kill-- I think. I got confused with the clarifications in the main thread on how the day attacks work.

I agree we should definitely start out with the long range kill. People were going back and forth even today about whether mafia have to attack adjacent neighbors, it would be great if they could argue about it all day tomorrow. Want to wait for the map update, but I like Chugg or maybe Fran of the people you listed.

The other thing is that our kill will install "puppet battalions" which I guess the other players will see as mafia battalions. I'm assuming the neighbors of the killed territory might be pressured to attack/eliminate the mafia troops, which IMO is fine, maybe it'll pick off a few of their troops through the dice rolls.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Also I looked at our win condition and it says "when all threats to mafia are eliminated". Is that normal? In transistor it said that we had to control 50% of the vote.

Look at that mind meld

I guess we all know the best moves for evil XD
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I did not notice that. I assume it's because town can attack us during the day so we probably have to dominate the map. I wonder if (this assumes we don't lose) there would be a point where it's just incredibly obvious who scum is but they just keep killing the remaining stragglers and control the vote? Who knows.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
@Geno, I was wondering, does me laying a trap qualify as movement? If so, would it just show up as movement in the territory I use it on, or would it show up as movement in the territory where my general is and the target owned territory?
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
@Geno, I was wondering, does me laying a trap qualify as movement? If so, would it just show up as movement in the territory I use it on, or would it show up as movement in the territory where my general is and the target owned territory?
And also, it says territory I own, but can I place it on territory an ally owns?
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I did not notice that. I assume it's because town can attack us during the day so we probably have to dominate the map. I wonder if (this assumes we don't lose) there would be a point where it's just incredibly obvious who scum is but they just keep killing the remaining stragglers and control the vote? Who knows.
Yes, I think you’re both right. I think we win when there’s no way for another play to kill us before we kill them, I.e. they need to traverse a long enough distance to attack us where we’d kill them before they get to us and they have no protection.

Also, I do think that last scenario is a possibility.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Oh Terra also can attack at night separately from the faction kill. So that leaves us with these decisions tonight:

Hawthorne: Faction kill someone
Launchpad: Trap Y/N, if so where
Natiko: Roleblock Y/N, if so who
Stan: Regular Attack Y/N, if so which space
Terra: Regular Attack Y/N, if so which space
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
So I was originally going to claim something with a night attack, and I think I can still do that, but I could claim my role is trap setter and just use that freely. Though I’m not sure I would use it tonight either way.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Also, I had openly suggested an alliance with Stu in the game thread, implying I had Congo as my bonus territory. I was going to try to take eastern Australia using a trap then a night kill, but it became a little harder. I didn’t realize he couldn’t get to Indonesia, so it takes more actions to accomplish it that way.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Hawthorne: Faction kill someone
Launchpad: Trap N
Natiko: Roleblock Y/N, if so who
Stan: Regular Attack Y/N, if so which space
Terra: Regular Attack Y/N, if so which space
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I would typically hold my RB since we have nothing to go off, but I'd be open to using it if for no other reason than I'm the weakest player on the board now thanks to Malus.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
The other alternative is for me to use my role investigation and someone else to do the faction kill, but that would mean that either Stan would have to use his one-shot ability or we would have to attack an adjacent property-- meaning IMO that we should only use it if we're really concerned about Jman.

I don't think Launch should trap tonight, I think he should stay quiet and hope to be investigated, because as I just put together he's a godfather again!

I'll look at the map more tomorrow morning (literal calendar tomorrow) and give more thoughts on the other possible night actions
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Nah, I think you always submit the kill. That alliance may not last forever. Lets take advantage while we can.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
It can't be dissolved without both parties' agreement, so i think I'm good for a while, but I don't mind doing the kill-- there are a lot of unknowns in this game, so I guess I shouldn't take the alliance for granted
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
The other alternative is for me to use my role investigation and someone else to do the faction kill, but that would mean that either Stan would have to use his one-shot ability or we would have to attack an adjacent property-- meaning IMO that we should only use it if we're really concerned about Jman.

I don't think Launch should trap tonight, I think he should stay quiet and hope to be investigated, because as I just put together he's a godfather again!

I'll look at the map more tomorrow morning (literal calendar tomorrow) and give more thoughts on the other possible night actions
What are the chances of rolling godfather again lol

As far as I can tell from here, Jman is the only player I would say is worth investigating/roleblocking right now, but again, I think he's going to be a hot target tonight. We know town has at least two types of investigative roles - alignment and movement. It's a high risk choice.

So Stan’s in a bit of a difficult spot in general. He can’t use a night attack without being in a small group of players suspected. I recommend he sit tight for now. That said, it sounds like him using a strongman attack would totally kill a player. We can certainly use that later. The universal kill should be something we keep in our back pocket.

Looking at Terra's role right now, I am seeing something we maybe should've discussed earlier - his investigation immunity. That's going to be suspect when an investigator gets a null result when LP has already claimed miller. We might have to get creative if it comes up, but hopefully it doesn't.

I'm going to advocate for Fran as the faction kill. He's adjacent to the most town players and he threw shade on me, Jman, and Verelios. It'll be great to see the consequences of that.

My suggested actions:
Hawthorne: Faction kill Fran
Launchpad: Trap N
Natiko: Roleblock N
Stan: Regular Attack N
Terra: Regular Attack Y/N, (I'll leave up to Terra; they are his battalions that will be put at risk)
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Fwiw Stan and Terra would be doing regular attacks - not NKs that can eliminate players. It should just be tantamount to the attacks we will see during the day phase. Players having that ability have already been confirmed by the rules. If they don’t attack now it should be because either A) they never plan to attack at night or B) they feel prepared to argue the players near them they felt were town enough to not be worth attacking and then not backpedal on that immediately in the day phase lol Stan will have one shot for attacking further away so he has the best argument for not attacking because inevitably he will have to “skip” a night from the public’s perspective.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I feel like everyone really deprecated attacking during the day. The general attitude seemed to be that you should attack only after asking permission.

If Stan and/or Terra attack, Stan should attack Kalor because there's no risk of killing him since he has two territories, so it's not as obvious of an anti-town move. By the same reasoning Terra should probably attack Verelios in whatever that country is where he has 2 units.

Personally I think either only one of them should attack or neither should. We don't want to come out of the night with everyone else having resolved not to use their night attacks because it's anti-town. But I leave it up to you two since it's your powers

For the kill, I like the idea of killing Fran, but the advantage of Chuggs to me is that it's easier to cast suspicion on his neighbors because they and their troop movements were topics of so much discussion yesterday.

My tentative preferences:

Hawthorn: Faction kill Chuggs
Launchpad: Nothing
Stan: Nothing
Natiko: Nothing
Terra: Nothing, or regular attack Verelios
 
Wow I missed one hell of an EoD. The way malus went out fighting the whole way down had me laughing my ass off.

So did Kyan get malus's territory because they were allies or something? I still don't know all the risk rules so that went over my head.

Personally I'd prefer not to attack, at least not this early into the game. I'd be fine with using Ninja for the factional kill if someone wants that, I'd just rather not attack normally tonight.

My idea is let Hawth kills chuggs while the rest of us chill out for now. Possibly allow Stan to go for kalor, if he's up to it because he only has three battalions there anyway so it wouldn't look super sus.
 
I think I'm probably safe from being scanned tonight, but my tentative fakeclaim was going to be a limited shot hider or commuter of sorts. Coincidentally the espionage/self-camouflage angle would fit my character as ninja would. Although obv not the main consideration for the claim.

I just know hider/commuter is a feasible role I could see Geno using but I don't necessarily expect to see it in a game like this with so many unique roles.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I feel like everyone really deprecated attacking during the day. The general attitude seemed to be that you should attack only after asking permission.

If Stan and/or Terra attack, Stan should attack Kalor because there's no risk of killing him since he has two territories, so it's not as obvious of an anti-town move. By the same reasoning Terra should probably attack Verelios in whatever that country is where he has 2 units.

Personally I think either only one of them should attack or neither should. We don't want to come out of the night with everyone else having resolved not to use their night attacks because it's anti-town. But I leave it up to you two since it's your powers

For the kill, I like the idea of killing Fran, but the advantage of Chuggs to me is that it's easier to cast suspicion on his neighbors because they and their troop movements were topics of so much discussion yesterday.

My tentative preferences:

Hawthorn: Faction kill Chuggs
Launchpad: Nothing
Stan: Nothing
Natiko: Nothing
Terra: Nothing, or regular attack Verelios
I think I made a bad assumption here, that night attacks would be anonymous. Even if Geno doesn’t tell players what happened, it’s going to be obvious from the battalion numbers.

I agree with you here, Hawthorn. I think Natiko would be right if town were in a different frame of mind, but there’s been a precedent set for attacking without warning because of Jman and doing it without communicating is going to get you scumread. It’s possible someone town is going to attack someone else tonight, but I think it should not be one of us because that person is likely going to get lynched.


Wow I missed one hell of an EoD. The way malus went out fighting the whole way down had me laughing my ass off.

So did Kyan get malus's territory because they were allies or something? I still don't know all the risk rules so that went over my head.

Personally I'd prefer not to attack, at least not this early into the game. I'd be fine with using Ninja for the factional kill if someone wants that, I'd just rather not attack normally tonight.

My idea is let Hawth kills chuggs while the rest of us chill out for now. Possibly allow Stan to go for kalor, if he's up to it because he only has three battalions there anyway so it wouldn't look super sus.
Whoever is the last vote on the lynch gets a single random territory from the lynched player. Kyanrute was the last vote on malus.
 
Top Bottom