Pair Thread Petey Piranha / King Boo Kart

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Welcome to Mario Kart: Double Dash! All rules from the main thread apply here as well.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Jman I'll be honest: I haven't really played Mario Kart. Maybe once or twice. I have no idea who these characters are, so I'm happy to be King Boo-- he is a king :-D

I made an avatar for the game but it might look better on you than me since it's mainly your avatar... let me know what you think!

H2AnNt7.png
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
What's the purpose of breadcrumbing? I've never done it. Feel like it would be better to wait & see what we get, in case it ends up being a role that we wouldn't want mafia to know is still out there
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Jman I'll be honest: I haven't really played Mario Kart. Maybe once or twice. I have no idea who these characters are, so I'm happy to be King Boo-- he is a king :-D

I made an avatar for the game but it might look better on you than me since it's mainly your avatar... let me know what you think!

H2AnNt7.png
Looks certaInly problem I have no idea How to change avatar. I don't know how ingot my original on there.

I wanted to be Petey since piranha plant was my fake claim in Mario mafia
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
What's the purpose of breadcrumbing? I've never done it. Feel like it would be better to wait & see what we get, in case it ends up being a role that we wouldn't want mafia to know is still out there
It's mostly a way to go back and say you were telling the truth about a claim because you secretly hinted early and ideally no player picks up on said breadcrumb.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Petey is yours!

You just go to your profile and mouse over your avatar image, there's an option to edit. No pressure though!
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Hmm, I feel like that's mostly discredited as a way to make yourself seem truthful since mafia does it so often with fake claims? I would personally rather not breadcrumb, in case e.g. a doctor or cop dies early & mafia picks up on our breadcrumb & kills us
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Save it I guess? If you'd rather not switch avatars it's cool, in no way a required part of the game XD
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Hmm, I feel like that's mostly discredited as a way to make yourself seem truthful since mafia does it so often with fake claims? I would personally rather not breadcrumb, in case e.g. a doctor or cop dies early & mafia picks up on our breadcrumb & kills us
Ok
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Cool, ty for the info. Got to make sure the town doesn't get too far into solving with flavor, then.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Cool, ty for the info. Got to make sure the town doesn't get too far into solving with flavor, then.
I'm Mario Mafia Mario and Luigi were scum while villains were town so flavor could mean something but we should wait for flips before worring about it.


Also heads up just like every game of this season I am most likely not going to say anything in the first few hours.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
NP, I'm frequently gone for long periods and I never announce it in advance, we all have stuff going on.

Looking forward to playing with you!
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
One thing I want to try to watch for is people being inconsistent about what was said in their pairs chats.. I'm assuming that the mafia have one big chat, so they might get confused about who supposedly said what
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Going to catch up now.

Monkey's vote on me seems odd. I'm not gonna say anything for now and see if she explains further.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Yeah, Monkey's vote is based on nothing. She must be testing to see what our reaction is
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I could see Geno doing that as town or mafia-- more concerned about Muffian's weird reaction. Still catching up btw, only here sporadically
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
NP, but I would back off on Dr. Monkey at this point. She was trying to get exactly this type of reaction from you. Though why she was trying for that, I'm not sure..
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Talk about being great as scum, I'M great as scum. I won as scum three times in a row as a first-time player, and two of them were clean sweeps. Of course, I'm too polite to brag about it.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Not sure chuggs is scum but I think this is legit scum hunting by Zeke and feel good about the Sophia Zeke combo so far.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I know I'm tunneling on Monkey but I just can't shake the bad feeling and wanna keep pressing it at least today.

No need for you to follow me on my tunnel if you feel different about VA and monkey Let the thread know your view does not match mine.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Agree that there's no need for us to always be in concert, but I do agree with you that Monkey is acting weird. Not really in the context of her prod on you, but more overall. I think of her as a really positive player who tries hard to get the town to work together, and I'm not seeing that attitude of leadership from her so far. That said, it's not even a full calendar day into the game. Reads are more likely to be wrong than right.

I think maybe pulling back a little and looking at other players/letting other people pick up the thread on Monkey and VA could work, not because I don't find them suspicious, but because I think it's interesting to see who picks up on it. Like MrHedin's post right now (BTW I have no idea why people are voting for Chuggs, his posts seem normal).

What do you make of Sorian/Muffin's claim, is it real or a joke? Where did they even actually claim?

BTW I'm travelling (safely in a car!) today, will not be around much.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Safe travels.

Re reading the beginning to better wrap my head around the claims will post more about sorain/muffin and Geno/terra later.

My keeping my vote on VA /Monkey is not about the initial prod but the response afterwards that has not instilled confidence. I remember going after Monkey hard when she popped up in easy allies but she very calmly responded to my post with logic that makes sense. The logic is fine this time but something feels off about how she's responded to multiple people.


I would not be voting Monkey yet if this was a solo game But VA being a bit inconsistent so far pushed me to make the vote on the pair.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I still think it's possible Dr. Monkey and VA are mafia. I mean, it's pretty clear that her frustrated reaction was genuine, and I can see where she was coming from, but the initial reads still don't fully make sense to me. I feel like watching VA more closely might help, going to try to read his posts carefully.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I went back and looked at the post where Sorian claimed, seems obvious it was a joke. It does feel like the discussion is weird today.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I still think it's possible Dr. Monkey and VA are mafia. I mean, it's pretty clear that her frustrated reaction was genuine, and I can see where she was coming from, but the initial reads still don't fully make sense to me. I feel like watching VA more closely might help, going to try to read his posts carefully.
I don't think it's worth going after them today. Just something to keep our eyes on.

I don't like how Monkey completely shut down Launchpad talking about it. It's fine to be done with it yourself and not talking about it but She really wanted launchpad to look away.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Yeah I agree. It's not going to happen today, but we should keep an eye on VA & Monkey. I think her shutting Launchpad down was a genuine reaction though-- she was annoyed by the situation & didn't want a retread, which I think either mafia or town would feel? Her making that post if anything drew more attention to the situation, so I don't think it was a strategy.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I'm just beginning to read through the past 5 pages now, sorry, wasn't kidding about only being around sporadically until after Christmas. What did zipped say?
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Wow, and I see it's a 3 way tie, zipped/zeke, maddy, and Chugg/Hedin. I think Chugg/Hedin is town, IDK about you? Were you talking about the thing where you thought it was weird zipped assumed he would be a wagon when he didn't have many votes? That's NAI to me.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Probably I will vote for faddy. If they're telling the truth and are trackers, we'll get the role & can track knowing that mafia think the tracker is dead.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
On the other hand, tracker is a difficult choice for a fake claim, which makes me think maybe they're telling the truth
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Very confident chuggs is town . I am fine Voting faddy. Worse case he was telling the truth and we are the tracker now.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Sounds good. I'll be around more next day, especially if we get that 48 hour night phase
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Yeah. Talk about last minute votes! There'll be a lot to go over. Excited for the flip..
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I'm not even sure who it ended on. Vote tool says faddy, but I think it might not be working & it's actually zipped.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
You are now a 3-shot Tracker. During the night, you can track a pair by sending the gamerunner the command TRACK: <NAME> to see who, if anyone, they visit. This ability is limited to three shots.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Just submit your track vote using the highlight command so I know when it’s an actual vote and not just discussion. Each player gets a vote.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
First thoughts two Karts Not to track.

1. Chuggs. Chuggs will be truthful about who he sends a message to scum or town.

2. Zeke. If the doctor claim was fake desperation I assume real doctor will out that kart so a track is not needed
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Agree about Chuggs. I somehow missed that zipped/zeke claimed doctor. I need to reread a bit before coming up with my thoughts on tracking options. However, since it's three-shot, I think we should track tonight. With only 15 pairs it's very possible we'll die before using all three shots, so we shouldn't conserve them.

As the only member of the kart who gets the references, tell me which track we should vote for!
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I don't know how much time for re-reading I'm going to have, on second thought. The real question is whether we should track someone who had attention on them yesterday, or someone who flew under the radar. Assuming that the goal is to ideally catch mafia performing the kill or being caught in a lie, but it would also be nice to be able to confirm the claim of a town player-- normally I would say to go after a less in-the-spotlight player, but everyone knows the tracker is dead, so mafia will be bolder than usual.

I would suggest: Monkey and VA, Salva & nin, Geno & Terraforce, or ATP and Launch.

I'll just vote whatever you do for the track vote, probably!
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
VOTE:Daisy Cruiser

Still thinking about who to track Sin flew under the radar but the other options you listed are good . Still thinking about it.

Also merry Christmas Hawthorn and Natiko.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Merry Christmas you two! Mafia has been a pretty great escape for me this year, so glad to have met such nice murderous online friends.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Time for me to have Christmas dinner, relax, go to sleep, wake up & drive 4-5 hours, probably in time to get home just as actions close..


vote: Daisy Cruiser
track: ATP


Jman, I'm cool with changing that to Dr. Alexander or Genoforce, just change it if you want to. See you on day 2..
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
We are in danger if we reveal we can track but it's a small game (role wise) and I don't want to die without giving the APT launchpad info. Plus we might get doctor healed once so we should get at least 2 tracks off even if we reveal today.

Also it's possible launchpad and ATP visit monkey and are not the killer but we still gotta bring it up.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I think one of us should just say we 100% know launchpad and atp killed monkey but don't say how just to see the reaction from those two and read other players reactions.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I really should have waited to talk with you before starting the Gambit I feel so bad. You deserve a better teammate.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
The reason I want to say it's a red check and not a track at first is I want to see if atp or Launchpad naturally give a reason for visiting Monkey/VA without knowing we tracked them.

If we say we tracked them they will have to claim to give an excuse on why they visited so a claim will come either way but if we say red check maybe they lie and say they did something else thinking the tracker is dead

We will tell the thread the truth before they got majority (majority is still fairly high)
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Hey Jman. I just got online. Let me catch up & then I can weigh in on the best course of action? There's plenty of time. Say nothing yet!!! Got to work out the smartest way to do this. Sorry I was delayed!
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Hey Jman. I just got online. Let me catch up & then I can weigh in on the best course of action? There's plenty of time. Say nothing yet!!! Got to work out the smartest way to do this. Sorry I was delayed!
I should not have jumped the gun I get so eager and excited.

Your the Brain I'm the heart
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
OK, now I see you pm'd me that you did say something, and I see you hinting at it in the thread.. still reading
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
It's ok, just chill for a bit and let me catch up, and we'll decide together how to proceed from where we are. We're both the brain!
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
Take your time.

The post here is the main reason I want to pretend it's a red check and wait on revealing we are a tracker.
The reason I want to say it's a red check and not a track at first is I want to see if atp or Launchpad naturally give a reason for visiting Monkey/VA without knowing we tracked them.

If we say we tracked them they will have to claim to give an excuse on why they visited so a claim will come either way but if we say red check maybe they lie and say they did something else thinking the tracker is dead

We will tell the thread the truth before they got majority (majority is still fairly high)
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
OK, I'm caught up.

First of all, take back all that stuff you said in the main thread about being a bad teammate! Don't be so down on yourself!

Second, I agree that we definitely want Launch and ATP to check in before revealing our track result, because we want to see if they'll volunteer info about visiting Dr. M & VA for non-nefarious purposes.

You tagged Launch & asked him for his catch-up thoughts as one of your first posts, so he may have guessed that he's the subject of the red check.

I'd rather avoid lying as much as possible for a couple reasons: we want to have credibility & we don't want to turbo Launch and ATP if they're innocent, which is possible.

IMO the safest course of action is to lie low for a bit & see if either of them volunteers the info about their night action without being prompted or hearing that they're the subject of the red check. I just won't post. I feel like lying & saying that you're still waiting to consult with me might be a bit un-sportsmanlike, but IMO not actually against the rules, you could also not post yourself for a bit. Just see what happens.

Then, depending on what they say before being brought to the spotlight, we could either continue your gambit or come out with the truth. But first let it percolate a bit.

What do you say? Too drawn out?
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Like, if they visited Monkey & VA to protect or investigate them, you would think that they would reveal that info on seeing the death, without being in the red check hot seat, since it might be helpful.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Hmm, Launchpad posted again but without revealing any night actions... curious to see what ATP will say
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I'd rather avoid lying as much as possible for a couple reasons: we want to have credibility & we don't want to turbo Launch and ATP if they're innocent, which is possible.
I don't think we have to worry about losing credibility much They all know I love Gambits. plus I already lied I don't think retracting the red check now vs after saying Atp is scum makes a huge credibility difference.


Atp getting turbo is a real concern. Majority is 14 I can watch the thread close and retract the red check quickly once votes get around 9?

We can chill and see what atp has to say at least for a few hours.


Final point Gambits are fun Hawthorn! We get to have Fun!
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I am going to post Hawthorn is not here yet and I want to hear from everyone before revealing red check ✔ does that sound ok.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Sorry, here's the post I was typing before:

Well, the difficulty is if they do turbo and it turns out they were the doctor & mafia used a strong kill, or something terrible like that LOL

Looks like we're agreed on waiting a bit before coming forward, see what gets said..

One possibility would be for me to come forward & say that it's not a "traditional" red check but we have very very good reason to believe allthingslaunch is mafia & we need to hear claims from them immediately, then you could be like "no hawthorn, I WOULD describe it as a red check", kind of use the disagreement between us so it's slightly unclear what we're actually saying?

I do want to do it in a fun way, and I knew gambits would get involved when I got paired with you XD ... feels pretty fun already TBH

The reason I say to just stop posting without explaining that I'm not here yet is b/c attention's already drifted away from our check, which is just how we want it to be-- don't want to refocus on the fact that we're not revealing it until we do. All IMO of course!
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Case in point: they're establishing who was switched right now, which will hopefully pre-establish whether launchpurple was switched or not, so that they can't use that as an excuse when caught.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
BTW, I noticed Launchpad claimed that he couldn't catch up fully over the 72-hour night phase... in HVV3, when we were cult together, my strategy, which we both agreed on, was to pretend to be taking longer to catch up as a replacement than I really was. Of course it was Christmas, but it's still interesting in light of our result.

ATP felt kind of off too, but I don't have anything specific to point to there. Ambulance... I remember him saying that he thought he wouldn't enjoy being in the mafia, though there could be any reason to want to be replaced & I shouldn't speculate.
 

jman1954goat

Linked the Fire
I like the self argue.you saying it's not really a check and then me coming in and saying No it's 100% a red check might create enough doubt so no turbo happens.

Demanding claims from them right away might be a little to obvious though.We want them to claim without us asking them so they don't have a good lie for visiting monkey.

We want other posters to demand claim or for them to self volunteer.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I hear that.. I think I can steer in the direction of encouraging a claim without saying "I demand a claim"-- ok, looks like we have a good strategy for when we come forward, but I still want to wait a while & see what discussion develops before we lay down our bombshell. Particularly I'm really hoping the switch convo gets resolved. Also to keep an eye on Launch & ATP
 
Top Bottom