Spectator Thread MGS Mafia |Spec| Naked Raiden Isn't In This

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I’ll be honest, I was thinking Chugg was sus D1 for the same meta reasons Monkey pointed out and I probably would’ve gone along with that right now, so I’m very glad Hawthorn is pushing against that instead.
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
Happy Birthday Maol!!

black-cat-cake.jpg
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Hmmm, Chuggs seems like the go-to today unless something crazy happens. :/

Any bets on who the other wagons will be? Everything is so spread out right now.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Happy (belated) birthday, Maol!

☹ I think that was my worst performance to date.
Nah, you’re being way way too hard on yourself. Big games take so much effort to keep track of everything with, and it's super exhausting. We all just try to do do our best.

If you want to talk about worst performances, some of us here live with some truly colossal screw ups in our game history. I think struggling to engage and subbing out isn't even a blip to some of the stuff I've had blow up in my face.

That's what you need - a big screw up that'll make everything that comes after seem like an improvement!
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
If you want to talk about worst performances, some of us here live with some truly colossal screw ups in our game history. I think struggling to engage and subbing out isn't even a blip to some of the stuff I've had blow up in my face.
Absolutely. I've had rough moments, like drawing the blank to end all blanks in Super Mario D1, but I don't think I'll ever top (or want to top, frankly) my terminal case of foot-in-mouth in Marvel Heroes where I called out what I thought was a gambit before going home, eating dinner and logging back on to realise that I'd completely misread the situation and made myself look dubious as all hell because of it. Sometimes things go well, sometimes they don't - that's just the way it goes.

Dr. Monkey said:
Why is the watcher claim MGSV flavored in an MGS game?
No idea - I suggest asking Tony Hawk, pro JOAT.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Absolutely. I've had rough moments, like drawing the blank to end all blanks in Super Mario D1, but I don't think I'll ever top (or want to top, frankly) my terminal case of foot-in-mouth in Marvel Heroes where I called out what I thought was a gambit before going home, eating dinner and logging back on to realise that I'd completely misread the situation and made myself look dubious as all hell because of it. Sometimes things go well, sometimes they don't - that's just the way it goes.


No idea - I suggest asking Tony Hawk, pro JOAT.
Yeah I got a good chuckle out of MGSV flavor somehow being the oddball out after just the flips that have been seen.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Quite an eventful day end there.

I haven't been following along super closely, but I'm guessing we're not supposed to know why Jman died yet?
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
My speculation:

Scum has a power that let's them kill a townie every time there is a turbo?
 

malus

#1 official chartmaker
Wow, Chugg really was Scum.

Also this looks super suspicious now:
Stantastic said:
[quotes Jman]
Someone who shouldn't be sleeping now change this image to "guess I'll FOXdie" pls
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
TheChuggernaut said:
I'm Venom Snake. Going to keep this a bit vague just in case I don't die.

I'm a watcher, but I can only use the watch on certain nights. I have to spend the nights I'm not watching at Mother Base. I don't currently have any information that would be useful. I have a passive ability as well, but I'm not going to say what that is.
TheChuggernaut said:
So I wasn’t going to out them, but that Aeleus kill was weak as fuck and I don’t respect them as a concept. Town, there’s two scum teams. If you don’t believe me, look for what’s missing in my role PM. We’re aware of them, I don’t know if they’re aware of us, but they do probably suspect we exist.

Liquid scum team, Maol is clearly the cop who got a green check on my godfather role, so maybe do something about that instead of accidentally killing the neutral with your boring low info kill, you fucking goobers. Also ATP said hello to Jman last night so that’s probably important.
W o r l d
S o l d
 

malus

#1 official chartmaker
Monkeys conversation with Leo looks a bit weird to me. It feels like she's trying to pressure him into voting Hawthorne instead of Zeke there without directly engaging with the Zeke read. Her dismissal of Faddys case as just "two Towns tunneling each other" also doesn't sit right with me.
If Zeke is Scum, I'd definitely put Monkey into the very potentially Scum camp.
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
loosely, I don't feel like Hawthorn's scum. I feel like Zeke and Vere are 2 separate members of either scum team, if Chuggs is to be believed
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
yep, Zeke and Vere's never been near each other with their votes... except to unite against Hawthorn, currently. Maybe one scum team, probs the Patriots, knows who the "non-Patriots" are, but the non-Patriots don't know them? Apply that to Zeke and Vere's vote patterns and that might explain them
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Dr. Monkey said:
let me help you out with a tl;dr
Zeke claimed vanilla Solid Snake
Vere claimed mason, no flavor claim
Haw Haw claimed a friggen fulton and she's a jailer (targeted forced commute)
Kalor won't claim
Lots of people are fighting
it's a damn mess
considering that scum!Chuggs claimed as VENOM SNAKE without any counter-claim, that means scum's got fake names handy; Zeke claiming as SOLID SNAKE... and Vanilla? tiny red flags I'd be punching Zeke over if I was in-game, IMO

Vere claimed Mason and also a Monkey, also way too convenient a claim claimed after Aeleus' flip. Y'all need pressure there

Hawthorn claimed as Fulton Recov. and her stated Power(s) relatively fits that Role-name flavour-wise; and she didn't seem to know the lore behind it, so I'm inclined to believe that she's really that, or else it's a use of a fake Role-name over her truthfully stating what her Power(s) are. NAI? I'm willing to believe on the side of = Town here.

side-eying Kalor

proxy soldiers fighting proxy wars

SkyOdin said:
The scum team that isn’t the patriots needs a roke like that. Something versatile to make up for a smallish team. Something that can shut down town or protect their own team from the Patriot’s bombs and viruses. A jailer could likely double as an interrogator or recruiter.

If I have to get into flavor (weak as that is), fulton recovery is something Big Boss does. It is the tool of people who create Outer Heaven and build Metal Gear. It is a tool to kidnap soldiers and build an army.

I 100% see it as a scum role.
ehhh I don't buy that at all.

Fulton Recov. is a tool as said, but IMO not an inherently evil one; Sky says in the context of MGSV it's a kidnapping & grand theft device which yeah I guess, but you could also say it's used in MGSV to rescue/save ppl and things from danger? If you wanted to be impartial/considerate like a good Town you'd add that. This sounds like twisting flavour to make Haw look explicitly bad. Sky has an agenda here

I'm actually majorly scum-reading Sky now because of this post of his
 
This was a very fun day to keep up. I was sussing Haw at dat start, but the claims really changed the landscape. Surprised Zeke got through with that vanilla claim. Not that it’s an outlandish role, but the claim itself felt off.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
This was a very fun day to keep up. I was sussing Haw at dat start, but the claims really changed the landscape. Surprised Zeke got through with that vanilla claim. Not that it’s an outlandish role, but the claim itself felt off.
Yeah, I'm shocked he wasn't in more of a running there.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Surprised Zeke got through with that vanilla claim. Not that it’s an outlandish role, but the claim itself felt off.
It was certainly a convenient claim for him. I know 'Vanilla's a unique role if there's only one of them' can be a thing in RM games, but do we see it all that often in this community? I think I've seen it once or twice, but more often than not I think our RM games tend to be all-PRs.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I haven't played a game of Mafia with you lot since the old place and I've just spent the better part of my day catching up on everything in MGS so far.

I am very confused.
It is a very absurd game lol
 

malus

#1 official chartmaker
Monkeys push on Leo feels super disingenuous. To me it seems like Leo is one of the people who are actually interested in solving the game, but somehow he's not contributing enough? And she wants him to restate his Scum reads but with different terms, how does that help anyone?
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
hmm.

Hawthorn says she Commuted Dr. Monkey during N2, when there was a Deathless Night. The Commuted can't be hit by any Night-actions, but they're also stopped from doing any Night-actions too, yes? But I don't really think Hawthorn Protected Dr. M here, I'm thinking she interrupted Dr. M.

I'm really thinking Dr. M is scum.

I'm thinking she's on the scum team that can Night-kill (I'm thinking one scum team is a standard-ass scum team that does regular Night-kills, and the other scum team is full of slow-building weapons of mass destruction [FOXDIE]/[POISON] & [BOMBS]).

Dr. M has been mostly Town-read from the start; I'm thinking their team would let her perform the Night-kill then, because there's not much attention being directed towards her. And/or maybe her scummates are in the general limelight of being-stared-at, so she's the safest player amongst them to do their Night-kills currently.

And I've also noticed the majority of her posts this game are full of either: exasperated pleas for ppl to stop claiming (which is actually scummy IMO; if ppl want to throw their cards onto the table, I'd allow it, just gives me more info to work with towards scumhunting), exasperated pleas for ppl to stop with the flavour discussion (but only after Sky pushed Hawthorn to death with it), exasperated pleas for ppl to NOT study vote patterns, exasperated statements about how exasperated she is with this game and how tough/tiring/long the game is/will be... in general, just a lot of what appears to be frustrated slapping of Town "to act more Town", it feels like she really wants to assert herself as Punished Monkey [A former doctor in search of a Town to lead].

And I'm gonna throw in SkyOdin being scum with her too:

Dr. M & Sky were the final 2 votes that got Ty4on ousted D1-end.

Dr. M & Sky were both voting against Ynnek before the revival

Dr. M & Sky were both voting against Hawthorn at one point, before Dr. M switched

Dr. M & Sky are currently both leading votes against Leo

when Fate asks Dr. M about her opinion on Sky's flavour use against Hawthorn, she immediately deflects; saying no I don't scumread him at all but look at Kalor though

some shit's going on there
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Funky Dude Sparks said:
SkyOdin why did you bring up fulton flavour role discussion right as we were voting for Zekesters?
THE PLANETS (sort of) ALIGN???

SkyOdin said:
Huh? What are you talking about?

I only mentioned flavor as an admittedly weak addendum to an argument that was principally based on game mechanics. And that was in a post made well after the Zeke lynch had lost steam and it was definitely Hawthorn vs. Kalor. You should at least get the facts of the game in order before building a theory.
"buh? wha? go back inside Sparks?"

nah Sky, you mentioned flavour to ensure Hawthorn got voted out, didn't ya

SkyOdin said:
I was going to post something when Sparks pinged me about that, but I lost my train of thought. I think I’ll go dig for some leads.
"ahhh Sparks I can't believe you've done this you caused me to drop all my reads and I can't pick them up again"
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
I haven't played a game of Mafia with you lot since the old place and I've just spent the better part of my day catching up on everything in MGS so far.

I am very confused.
oh & Welcome back btw! You were in Animal Crossing [Mafia] right? I wasn't in that game meself but I remember it
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
So does Zeke count as the token vanilla in a bastard game if he's not really all that vanilla?
Zeke’s role did have a fairly minor perk it could access... but it wasn’t what he said and he never successfully did it. He just lied lol Question is whether his lie will help or hurt?
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Zeke’s role did have a fairly minor perk it could access... but it wasn’t what he said and he never successfully did it. He just lied lol Question is whether his lie will help or hurt?
If he was right, it could be a good call to action. If he wasn't right...
 

malus

#1 official chartmaker
Honestly, none of the players on that list Zeke provided are on my Scum radar. But then again, I would have voted Zeke yesterday, so maybe it needs some calibration.
 

Hobohodo

Say it five times fast
oh & Welcome back btw! You were in Animal Crossing [Mafia] right? I wasn't in that game meself but I remember it

Thanks! Yep, Animal Crossing was my first mafia game. I had to go back and look through the archives to see what other ones I took part in (Archer, Vampire the Masquerade and Bloodborne all on GAF) as I'd completely forgot the themes to all of them.

Really curious what Zeke's minor ability was.
 
Tried to keep Monkey from killing me basically the whole game lol. Was trying to stay alive long enough so the roster would shrink to a point where I would even have a shot at convincing people she was scum.

Both her and Chuggs being scum sucked ass lol. Assuming I'm right about her, this doesn't feel like town Monkey at all.
 
second

today is a lot and I'm gonna need a minute
she's only doing this because the game is getting to the point where PoE can solve a lot of it. How long have her and Faddy been scheming this Zeke's flip will be tailored bit. Poor LP. This is probably the point of the game where town needs a mass claim.

And everyone's forgotten how she was emphatically stating how Leo and HP needed to be solved like, two phases ago.
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
she's only doing this because the game is getting to the point where PoE can solve a lot of it. How long have her and Faddy been scheming this Zeke's flip will be tailored bit. Poor LP. This is probably the point of the game where town needs a mass claim.

And everyone's forgotten how she was emphatically stating how Leo and HP needed to be solved like, two phases ago.


Yeah, rest of my scum team seems to have picked up on it too. She’s throwing shade in every direction she can and pressuring players that are easily pressured. It’s very unMonkey
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Hey spec thread. Bit of a relief to be fully dead!

That said, I have high hopes for Hawthorn as a replacement.

I'm sorry I let you down! It can be tough for me to defend myself against arguments like "you would be playing better if you were town" because I feel like the only response is "well, maybe I'm not as good a player as you think I am! Those other games were flukes and I really am this bad!" It's more fun to defend myself when I am actually mafia.

Leo you're the only one making any sense right now please keep up the fight. i swear if they vote you out tomorrow i will go into the thread and throw down.
Monkeys push on Leo feels super disingenuous. To me it seems like Leo is one of the people who are actually interested in solving the game, but somehow he's not contributing enough? And she wants him to restate his Scum reads but with different terms, how does that help anyone?
Hawthorn says she Commuted Dr. Monkey during N2, when there was a Deathless Night. The Commuted can't be hit by any Night-actions, but they're also stopped from doing any Night-actions too, yes? But I don't really think Hawthorn Protected Dr. M here, I'm thinking she interrupted Dr. M.

I'm really thinking Dr. M is scum.

Agree with all of this. Reading Dr. Monkey vs Leo in the last day phase brought me around to suspecting her. But I was definitely aware when I commuted her that it could be a roleblock instead of a doctor save. I liked that the role had a built-in hedge. That was why I lied that I couldn't protect the same player twice in a row. I was going to commute Monkey again the next night and go from there.

Disappointed to see that Zeke was town though... I really wanted to be right about that god damn gif XD
 
Top Bottom