Spectator Thread MGS Mafia |Spec| Naked Raiden Isn't In This

If I hadn't been murdered inside monkey's pocket I was gonna bring you back to life
I'm glad you didn't lol. I spent too many hours trying to figure out how I was going to convince people that some of the most town read people in the game are all scum, while also trying to convince Monkey she had me pocketed and feed her a steady stream of disinformation.
 
I'm glad you didn't lol. I spent too many hours trying to figure out how I was going to convince people that some of the most town read people in the game are all scum, while also trying to convince Monkey she had me pocketed and feed her a steady stream of disinformation.
The only thing I've read since my death are the role PMs, were you secretly scum?

(Personally I would have loved to have been revived ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ )
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
I can't believe ppl are letting faddy move on with this tailored pm stuff lol. Can't believe faddy got town points for tunneling me for 4 days.

The course of action was to flip me, see that I'm telling the truth and go after whoever was on my wagon.


I'm glad you didn't lol. I spent too many hours trying to figure out how I was going to convince people that some of the most town read people in the game are all scum, while also trying to convince Monkey she had me pocketed and feed her a steady stream of disinformation.
Never gonna get monkey w/o a red check from a cop. Even monkey would probably convince town to flip the cop first to make sure the claim is real.

You had me as your only town read before. What happened?

Ynn voters

Thinking over the ynn thing where he was pushed to use his power.
— I still believe scum wanted him to waste it and you were one of the main ones saying defuser is just as important as a doc

Eod of day with hawthorn. Your uncertainty seemed like an act.

===

To the scum who pushed me:
tenor.gif


to the town who allowed it to happen:
Learn from it and stop being lead around
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I'm sorry I let you down! It can be tough for me to defend myself against arguments like "you would be playing better if you were town" because I feel like the only response is "well, maybe I'm not as good a player as you think I am! Those other games were flukes and I really am this bad!" It's more fun to defend myself when I am actually mafia.
No, you played super well! I think you got railroaded for bad reasons, but that’s just how it goes sometimes. You (seemingly) blocked scum from getting a kill, even! I couldn’t have asked for a better replacement.

I could also totally relate to you coming off more guarded due to the role you had; I was intending to play the same way going in, but I just didn’t have the energy for it.

Also, sorry you had to pick up some of my slack, especially with that comment I made before leaving.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
No, you played super well! I think you got railroaded for bad reasons, but that’s just how it goes sometimes. You (seemingly) blocked scum from getting a kill, even! I couldn’t have asked for a better replacement.

I could also totally relate to you coming off more guarded due to the role you had; I was intending to play the same way going in, but I just didn’t have the energy for it.

Also, sorry you had to pick up some of my slack, especially with that comment I made before leaving.

Thank you!! That does make me feel better.

And yeah, our role was a bit tough. I bet there was mafia in the group that jumped on that comment from you though. It was obvious to me that you were just saying you were town, come on.
 
I did suggest to zem that if monkey was alive today we needed to start looking at her, but I guess she is just to persuasive.

Though I wanna know if Leo is town because the way she went at him really made me raise an eyebrow. It just seemed like she was shouting at him but nothing she was saying really made sense.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Agree with all of this. Reading Dr. Monkey vs Leo in the last day phase brought me around to suspecting her. But I was definitely aware when I commuted her that it could be a roleblock instead of a doctor save. I liked that the role had a built-in hedge. That was why I lied that I couldn't protect the same player twice in a row. I was going to commute Monkey again the next night and go from there.

Disappointed to see that Zeke was town though... I really wanted to be right about that god damn gif XD
Between last game and this one if you ever see someone making a bad push on Leo they are probably scum and should be voted out immediately.
 
I did suggest to zem that if monkey was alive today we needed to start looking at her, but I guess she is just to persuasive.

Though I wanna know if Leo is town because the way she went at him really made me raise an eyebrow. It just seemed like she was shouting at him but nothing she was saying really made sense.
I'm pretty sure Leo is town. I was using him as sacrificial bait to convince Monkey to keep me alive so I could help her persuade people to kill him. I even tried to link Fanto to him for an even juicier potential target down the road.

It was unfortunate he started pushing back against Monkey only after I set him up and thus, a good ally for me down the line, but c'est la vie
 

Hobohodo

Say it five times fast
About all this tailoring talk,

My experience with a Tailor is just that it would change the role alignment on an investigation but ultimately the role reveal in a death post would show the actually true alignment. But Faddy is trying to push that the entire PM has been made up, is there precedent for that in these games?

Just trying to grasp how big of a story he's trying to push here.
 
About all this tailoring talk,

My experience with a Tailor is just that it would change the role alignment on an investigation but ultimately the role reveal in a death post would show the actually true alignment. But Faddy is trying to push that the entire PM has been made up, is there precedent for that in these games?

Just trying to grasp how big of a story he's trying to push here.
he's basically saying Zeke is a reverse death miller, an extraordinarily rare role that basically never gets used even in the most bastard of bastard games lol
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
huh. Maybe someone FOXDIE-infected LP first (action order-wise), then LP visited Kalor?

But flavour-wise, FOXDIE only kills certain people it's engineered to kill, yeah? Maybe some players can be infected with FOXDIE but it does nothing to them / doesn't even notify them they had it, but if the carrier visits someone who is FOXDIE-susceptible that's when the Mod notification happens?
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Zem said:
[...] "Have I voted for scum since the start of day three?"

The answer was Yes [...]

[...] Which leaves Vere, Fanto, Kalor, Leo, and if you believe Faddy, Zeke. There could also be more on this list of course. [...]

[...] On night 2 where there was no nightkill or bomb ATP roleblocked Verelios, we dunno if that was why but that was the info [...]
OK????? DO THE THING
 
Monkey immediately going to role cop to explain why I'm dead and not her should raise some red flags.

Also her shading zeke using my power role to say well atp could do something similar so zeke maybe was tailored should raise eyebrows too. I also could bring someone back to life like Kenny, I could commute someone like Hawthorn etc. If anything it gives Zeke's claim more credence imo.

Town cores be damned from now I'm fighting monkey every step of the way every game!
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
The longer a 'town leader' stays in play, the more I find myself wondering why they haven't been silenced yet.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
The longer a 'town leader' stays in play, the more I find myself wondering why they haven't been silenced yet.
The serious answer is many scum teams are aware that town will often turn on the louder, more active players while said active players are more apt to be protected at night (and thus a riskier night kill).
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
The serious answer is many scum teams are aware that town will often turn on the louder, more active players while said active players are more apt to be protected at night (and thus a riskier night kill).
Very true, although it doesn't do much about my paranoia... which pretty much proves your point.
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Vere is the optimal flip Today IMO.

He links to self-Watcher Kalor and would offer insight into the FOXDIE situation if it's actually a delayed infection by Vere, not LP's alleged doing

The way he staggered his whole claim of Sleepwalking Mason is sus as fuck

He's on ATP x Zem's shit list of ppl who might be scum according to Psycho Mantis Q&A

ATP Roleblocked him and a Deathless Night occurred, OK!?

that's just too much contention points against him compared to everybody else
 

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
tbh? not a bad call at that point in the game. he was going to be a contender for a vote so better to sacrifice himself and bring back the defuser.

It felt weird being a bit disappointed that the first night kill was Neutral, then a no kill night, followed by a scum kill.

I was really hoping to have a few good options to pick from by the time I had to claim, lol.
 

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
As soon as you claimed I thought bullshit! I'm the reason there is no spec access! Hence being sole person to vote after your claim

I figured there might have been a couple reasons for no spec. Was thinking that maybe someone was The Sorrow and that all dead players joined a chat with them or something.
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
HOW IS LP LEADING WHEN THEY HAVE CONFIRMATION OF A SCUM BETWEEN VERE, KALOR, FANTO & LEO???????????????????????? WHY ARE THEY TRUSTING KALOR'S ACCUSATION AGAINST LP WHEN THERE'S REASON TO BELIEVE HE COULD BE SCUM?????
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
okay, BIG BRAIN break:

Who's claimed to be FOXDIE'd so far? Leo from N1, then Kalor from N4, yeah? And if there's 2 scum teams who don't know who each other are?

According to Chuggs' Role PM, part of the Patriots Win condition is when all non-Patriots are infected with FOXDIE.

So what if Leo and Kalor are actually Chuggs' scummates / The Patriots? And they're claiming having being infected with FOXDIE as a way to identify themselves to the non-Patriots?
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
LP has no reason to visit Kalor after what Kalor claimed as self-Watcher, that's an absolute suicide mission with no gain(s) whatsoever (unless LP needs to fulfil a Win condition regarding visiting Watchers??)

It's so bleeding obvious LP was forced to visit Kalor last Night, IMO

Claiming LP FOXDIE'd Kalor is just the icing on that concerted scum effort cake against him
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
oh shit; unless, like Chuggs was, ALL the Patriots are Watchers (Illuminati all-seeing eye style??) and non-Patriots know that?? (or guess it?)

So maybe LP is non-Patriot scum, so after Kalor had outed himself as a Watcher-type, non-Patriots felt it was worth the risk to run out into the open just to have Patriot!Kalor infected??
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
OK, also the wording in Chuggs' Role PM...

"[...] when all non-Patriots have a Bomb planted, OR when all non-Patriots are infected by FOXDIE."

I missed this earlier, but doesn't this wording mean that the PATRIOTS are the ones who are infecting the NON-PATRIOTS with FOXDIE? And in the lore of course, the Patriots made FOXDIE, forgot that too.

But this whole time, I've been parsing "when all non-Patriots have a Bomb planted" as "the non-Patriots are the ones who plant Bombs". But that's incorrect when you see it beside the "infection" wording?

The Patriots are the Infectors, AND the Bombers, right?
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
because if the non-Patriots are the Bombers, that means the Patriots' Win condition (according to Chuggs' Role PM) is fulfilled by the actions of the non-Patriots / the 2nd scum team = meaning they have a mutual Win condition, which can't possibly be, yeah?
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
okay, BIG BRAIN break #2:

Some people are inanimate objects; items, yes?

And what happens to items?

Items get used.

Maybe someone has a Role that can USE people who are items/equipment, force them to do stuff.

Maybe that's what happened to LP (who claimed as THERMAL GOGGLES) to Kalor?
 

Hobohodo

Say it five times fast
okay, BIG BRAIN break #2:

Some people are inanimate objects; items, yes?

And what happens to items?

Items get used.

Maybe someone has a Role that can USE people who are items/equipment, force them to do stuff.

Maybe that's what happened to LP (who claimed as THERMAL GOGGLES) to Kalor?

Oooooo, I like that.
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Maybe LP as the THERMAL GOGGLES has his own Power as himself (which is his claimed "random Role Name learned every other Day"), but unaware to him, there's somebody out there who has a list of all the ITEMS they themselves can use, and that person gets a different utility/Power when using the ITEMS-people on targets

So they used LP to safely "look" at Kalor for whatever reason... but this "User", as I'll call them, is the one with FOXDIE, so that's how Kalor got infected
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Stantastic said:
Right so i guess nobody cares that Sparks apparently fucked up literally every single aspect of his supposed role then?

Even the part where what he should have said for his fake claim was one people in the thread had already talked about.

Just nothing means anything because its sparks and were all still commited to entertaining him making a mess of this every time?
Just because someone's apparently botched their Role-claim, botched their Role-claim, botched their Role-claim, botched their Role-claim, botched their Role-claim and botched their Role-claim doesn't make them actually Mafia, Stan, there are better/higher-priority targets around
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
For LP when you get here

Turns out it doesn’t matter how well hidden you are when scum has an ability that forces you to use your PR in the dumbest way possible. You did good, man. Not much we can do when we spend the whole game getting PR fucked.
 
Top Bottom