Gossip Thread MGS Mafia |Gossip| Night 2

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
tumblr_p0ui1cUI5C1s87zieo3_500.gifv
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
I'm actually in the middle of a WoW raid but will be done in an hour or so, but I have thoughts and lots of them!
 
Awesome. I was nervously waiting to see who had invited me.

Well ill get the ball rolling, what do you think of chuggs saying I visited jman n1 then jman dying?
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
I don't think you're on the same team as Chuggs, that's something I'm very confident on, so I don't think you killed him with the Fox Die, as I'm assuming that's what killed him (targeted at night, dies at the end of the next day phase). So you could be on this fabled second scum team, or you could be town (doctor, cop, etc etc), or a neutral.

And this brings me to the 2nd scum team, do you believe that? He said we'd notice something missing from the role reveal, the only thing missing I can see is a potential night kill but dunno if that would be explicitly in his role in particular. His team can put a bomb on people, can infect them with fox die, does the other team simply get a night kill and that's it? Saying that, if flavour matters then the DARPA chief being a godfather would indicate to me that Liquid Snake would either be neutral or on a second team, so I guess it's potentially true but I dunno if I'd focus on that though until we see someone flip or if someone gives us that info in the thread.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
This is my ability by the way, I don't have anything else, no passives or anything. Last night I invited Ephidel, mainly because she seemed to suspect me just a tiny bit so we had a really good discussion and sharing thoughts. I'm trying to invite as many townies as possible to this chat, if I do invite scum it won't be the end of the world because I won't be sharing info between people but I'm still trying to keep it as town as possible. You going for Chuggs day one and today and him flipping scum made me lean town on you do thought you were a good person to get in here.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
Oh yeah, each chat gets deleted once the day starts, that was something I want sure on until the start of day two but that's how it works so anything you say in here won't be seen by anyone other than me.

Ephi linked me to a similar chat from a previous game where the person was actually an arsonist who could invite a new person each day but they all stayed in the chat, then they could light it on fire killing all of them. That's obviously not me since Ephi isn't here tonight :laughing:
 
Okay cool, just wanted to see where you were at. I am town. I might be able to prove it tomorrow.

As for the 2nd scum team its interesting, obviously there is no mention of a kill command, but like you say I'm not necessarily sure that would be in a pm. I'm sure I've played scum before where we all had elaborate roles like chuggs there and none of us had a specific kill command 8n our pm. Anyone of us could do the faction kill though.

Would I be surprised if there are two scum teams in a mgs game, no. Can I believe chuggs is throwing this all out there just to try and shade everyone so that we can't town confirm monkey or myself, definitely.

So I'm unsure exactly is what I'm saying lol.

Who did you invite n1?
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
Yeah I think the strongest link to there being a second scum team is Chuggs was Sigint and a Godfather. I would expect someone like Liquid to be a Godfather but that may just be overthinking it.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
What do you think of maol?

I saw Faddy say something about the conversation between Maol and Chuggs looking awkward now after he role revealed. So that's something I need to go back and read, before that I didn't really have a read on him. The main thing I have against him was that I was feeling much better with the people on the Chuggs vote than I was on the Kenny vote mid-afternoon. And Maol was on the Kenny vote.
 
I saw Faddy say something about the conversation between Maol and Chuggs looking awkward now after he role revealed. So that's something I need to go back and read, before that I didn't really have a read on him. The main thing I have against him was that I was feeling much better with the people on the Chuggs vote than I was on the Kenny vote mid-afternoon. And Maol was on the Kenny vote.

Obviously maol vigorously defended chuggs early d2 then sort of disappeared. Then chuggs calling him a cop when I know he lied about me makes me nervous. Like calling him a cop does put a target on his back for sure, but it also means a doctor might try and protect him. And it gives maol an out for why he was defending chuggs so hard.

If chuggs was telling the truth about two teams and he is in a team of three say, I could easily see his two mates being maol and vere. Vere because of how ambulance played early on.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
I just had a thought that makes me lean hard town on you and monkey. When Chuggs mentioned the small scum team theory on day one that was almost certainly a signal to the other team of there is one. Anyone on that team will have understood his message. That means you and monkey are very unlikely to be on that second team since you pushed Chuggs so much.

I think at least one or two on the second team will have tried to save him with their votes.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
Obviously maol vigorously defended chuggs early d2 then sort of disappeared. Then chuggs calling him a cop when I know he lied about me makes me nervous. Like calling him a cop does put a target on his back for sure, but it also means a doctor might try and protect him. And it gives maol an out for why he was defending chuggs so hard.

If chuggs was telling the truth about two teams and he is in a team of three say, I could easily see his two mates being maol and vere. Vere because of how ambulance played early on.

Vere is someone I don't really trust because of ambulance then some of his own posts. He voted for Kenny even though his post didn't sound like he believed it, threw some shade at Chuggs too which is a bit of cover.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
That's interesting, could definitely be a breadcrumb. Hadn't thought of that. So you feel strongly ephi is town?

Not strongly, at the end of the night phase I was still null on her, but now leaning town after today and her posts and vote. She was really cautious in here which I think is fine, I thought my ability was obviously town but I learned from her that it might not always be!
 
I'm still fairly new to mafia so I don't know how common a gossip chat is for scum but I don't think I've encountered it in any game I've played so I'm pretty happy to assume you are town. I think your play has been fine, I think i lumped you in my null but kinda good category. I've also had town vibes from ephi.
 
Okay that makes sense

I'm metal gear acid, a jack of all trades deck.

I have a deck of 15 cards with different powers, once I use one its discarded, start if each day I draw cards, I must always have 3. Once I've drawn all my cards I'll die at the end of that phase.

Some of the powers are pretty dope but I've not drawn them yet.

I also plan to play a card tonight.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
Ah that's pretty interesting! So Chuggs lied about you visiting Jman? Makes sense since he knew Jman was about to die and was probably annoyed you were all over him from day one haha
 
Yeah, unless I was redirected I targeted chuggs, but it was a delayed action, would have taken effect tonight so not even sure I would have been shown as moving n1.

How do you feel about Leo?
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
I'm wondering if Chuggs targeted himself night one because he knew he was under suspicion a bit and thought he might catch a cop, which would align with Maol defending him after a green check and Chuggs knowing he visited. No idea how your thing would work, I would assume you wouldn't show as visiting.

Leo is a lot like vere I think. It wouldn't surprise me if the patriots were vere, Chuggs and Leo.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
I'll have to read his posts from today but off the top of my head it seemed similar to vere just opposite votes bit similar reasoning. I'll be home in an hour so will sit down and read day two again.
 
Its mostly just feel, he seemed to genuinely engaged in the game. From my own experience being scum, starting off knowing the answers it can be hard to fake genuine engagement with the game, you forget to ask the right questions because you already know the answers. I've disagreed with a lot of Leo's opinions but I think they were genuine, where as someone like kalor, the way he latched onto maol d1 for meta reads just reminded me of me as scum looking for one thing to latch onto to make it look like I'm doing work and forming opinions.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
I'll be surprised if Kalor and Hawthorn aren't scum. I have a feeling Hawthorn is on the second scum team if there is one because she wanted to defend Chuggs but not go all in. Kalor was where my vote was before Chuggs posted for the day but that post was so scum I had to move over.
 
Yeah Hawthorn is definitely looking iffy to me to, would not be surprised at all.

If you could roleblovi someone tonight who would you choose?
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
I'd block Hawthorn. Was just looking at how the votes ended up and she said she would move her vote to Chuggs even though it would look bad on her (did she know?) and never actually moved the vote, it's still on Kenny.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
Before I read day two again I think it's important that I try to figure out if there are one or two scum teams. So let's look...

If flavour means something this game, which I have a feeling it does, then Sigint being a Godfather means it's unlikely Liquid is on the same team, is Liquid neutral then? He's certainly going to be in this game and won't be town. Could it be Liquid, Solidus and Ocelot on one team?

I do think Chuggs saying "the scum teams could be small" was a message, they used him to put it out there because he was the Godfather so if he was investigated he'd come back as town. I don't think that was a play to confuse us if we ever looked at his posts after he flipped, it was to say "hey, don't kill me". Maybe one of the team's has an ability where they can communicate if they target one of them.

What if what was missing from the role reveal on his death was the full win condition? It only lists the patriots, but what if Liquids team is actually there too? This is trickier to believe because why give them up like that unless he really was frustrated by the kill on Aeleus.

The Patriots get two kills, but one of them would have been quite easy to counter if Jman was still hidden, so having the Fox Die as well (which I assume is untraceable since Jman didn't say anything about having it) makes sense. Which leaves Liquids team to have the night kill.

Us being able to vote him out quite easily with only a minimal pushback suggests to me that his team isn't that big and the other team wasn't prepared to put themselves in the firing line to defend him.

Evidence against two teams. Well we haven't seen anything about the others yet and we only have a clue because Chuggs said it.

I think there is another team though, I think the kills they have and Chuggs post on day one makes me believe that. So that's what I'll keep in mind when I reread this.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
This is rough after reading the last ten or so pages, tomorrow I'll have a look at splitting people into likely town / scum / null

DrMonkey - Pushed hard on Chuggs, I feel like a player in the second team wouldn't do this, I feel like they would have understood his message about the small scum teams. Maybe they would have bused him a few days later but not day two. Hard town lean.

ATP - Same as Monkey but from day one, hard town lean.

Kalor - Has a strange town/mafia list (also picked up on by FateShirou) with no info. Said he thought Chuggernaut, Maol, Zeke, Nin were scum, started with an early vote on Chuggs, changed to Kenny when it got close, then unvoted. Thinks Faddy, Monkey, Leo, Ambulance, Sky, are town. Slight scum lean.

Maol - I actually am convinced he's the cop. He's defending Chuggs pretty hard but had a bit of an argument with him day one, I think Chuggs watched himself and caught Maol, who switched to defending Chuggs because of the green check. Him saying it in the thread is because they need him dead tonight rather than at the end of the day tomorrow from Fox Die.

Leo - having Hawthorn as top town is weird I think, has a pop at Chuggs, null with a slight town lean

Funky Dude Sparks - Leaning town, was pushing Chuggs yesterday

Hawthorn - scum read Chuggs day one, backed off day two. Didn't expect Chuggs to be in contention day two, was day one just a light bit of busing for when one of them flipped? Keeps asking about Aeleus kill, which doesn't really matter? Honestly feels like she wants someone to pin it on Sparks or something since Aeleus went for Sparks day one. Said she would change her vote to Chuggs when momentum had swung to Chuggs even though it would make her look bad, didn't change vote. " If I had to guess a scum team of, say, like, 7 players I would guess Zeke, Ynnek, Zem, Ephi, ATP, one of Kopite or Kalor, and one nin, Zipped, or LP. " really odd sentence and a bit of a poor list. Pinging weird questions to specific people.

HP - has a bomb, not part of the Patriots scum team, has a well timed vote on Chuggs. Doesn't buy the fake reveal

SkyOdin - mentions a second scum team, would you do that if you were scum? Felt he was pocketed day one by Chuggs, felt Kenny's read post was good and even defends it a little but ends with a vote on Kenny which is odd.

Stan - happy with a Chuggs vote early in the day but switched to Kenny instead when it's really close between Chuggs and Kenny.

Zeke - really wanted a Chuggs flip

Fanto and Faddy - I feel like these two are hinting at being masons or linked in some way? town lean

Kopite and Ephi - two well timed votes on Chuggs

Nin - didn't buy Chuggs' fake role reveal

FateShirou - nothing in particular but feels townie to me

Ambulance / vere - Has a post where he shades Chuggs quite a bit but votes Kenny with the reasoning being - " My vote will land between Chuggs and Kenny, because even if the former feels off, when I think of their interactions Kenny seems to be much more proactive. I'm more sure of Chuggs being scum if Kenny flips scum then the reverse, and want to start here. " which seems an odd way to go about it. Need to re-read the "awkward conversation" between Ambulance and Chuggs tomorrow.
 
That's some good work, Hawthorn's scum list looks extra bad with me you and Ephi on there.


So are we thinking every night they can inject someone with foxdie, then that person dies at the end of the following day. I can't remember exactly how foxdie works in the games.

The way the bomb thing is written makes me think they won't go off until all non patriots have them, then they all go off we die and patriots win.

There is still a part of me that is unsure if there are two teams. Aeleus could in theory of been killed by a vig and then that would be immediately counter claimed, like the only way chuggs can be sure it was a scum nk is if it was his team that did it.

The kill also makes sense to me from a chuggs scum perspective because normally n1 you are killing monkey or maol. But both were pretty tight with chuggs at eod so he might have thought its in my interest to keep them alive, having two strong players in your corner is a valuable asset. Also the longer someone like monkey stays alive the more suspicions fall on her.

Taking those two out the equation of a night kill, the next person on my list was Aeleus.

I honestly wasn't shocked when I saw the aeleus kill because of my belief one of my fabled power trio was scum.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
Yeah I think that's how the Fox Die will work, in the games they're a timed thing so it makes sense that's how it works. Maybe they get to choose when they activate it, that's really the only difference I can see.

I think you might be right on the bombs, I don't think HP not dying soon means he lied about the bomb which I think some people might jump to, I wouldn't say that in the thread though and wait to see who brings it up because that could be scum trying to get us to vote HP out as "he must be scum, he's not dead yet" kind of thing.

I'm not 100% on there being two teams, I just think it makes a bit of sense if Liquid Snake is his own team. He could be a neutral as well, or could be part of the patriots but that doesn't make sense flavour wise (if that is important, I think it is from what we've seen so far). I also think there's going to be some weird stuff going on with this being a MGS game. But you're right as well, it's not something to dwell on, we need to keep looking at people that look scummy regardless, or if we think people are town, not look at them too much until late in the game or we get a team Liquid flip.

Interesting stuff on Aeleus, tbh I wasn't that surprised because of how active they were day one, I think there was an element of trying to pin it on Sparks because that's who they kept targeting. That makes me think of Hawthorn keep bringing up the question about why Aeleus was killed as well.

My feel good they're town list would be:

Monkey
ATP
Ephi
Maol
Faddy
FateShirou

Most likely town:

Leo
Fanto
Nin
Zeke

Null, could be scum

LP
Neki
Vere
Stan
Kopite
Zipped
Kenny
SkyOdin


Likely scum:

Kalor
Hawthorn
 
The only thing with flavour is mgs is not short of characters, yet jman was coolant spray, ty was an unlock able easter egg


There is no gaurentee liquid is even in the game
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
I was thinking about the bomb, if it's how you say, then would scum keep giving out bombs? It's practically clearing those people as not the Patriots. They could try and trick us by not putting it on anyone one night then claiming it's on them. I guess it comes down to how the bombs work and at least we have HP to see.
 
Hmm that's interesting, I didn't think of that. Clearly they are planting bombs on people, it's in the pm and we had a defuser, but is it possible like the foxdie the person doesn't know they have a bomb on them. Of course that would mean HP is scum.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
Yeah definitely a possibility. I said it in the thread to Jman that the bomb stuff seems really easy to counter if the person just comes in the thread and say they have a bomb attached to them. Chuggs being a watcher makes that harder because he could just target whoever they put the bomb on and see Jman visiting. I think that's the counter to the counter, just unlucky Jman outed himself before Chuggs died.

I think let's see if HP dies, if not then see if anyone claims being targeted by a bomb. I still lean town on HP simply because that play on day one feels too risky.
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
Who do you think will die tonight? I'm thinking Monkey will get the fox die and Maol a bomb so the doctor can't save them, then a random night kill, I think even you might be a target for that because of the push on Chuggs, hopefully not though! I wonder if town has someone who can cleanse the fox die, but hard to do if the person doesn't know they're infected.
 
Yeah monkey or maol is who I would go for if I was scum.

I'm hoping that chuggs shading me means I'll live, if I'm the kill they will wee I'm town and know chuggs was just being salty lol
 

Zem

This is how we solve the game. Good old Google.
tenor.gif


It's been a pleasure! Let's hope we both survive and no one too important dies. Preferably another neutral!
 
Top Bottom