Scooby Doo 2: Mafia Unleashed - This time there are costumes!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Hyde Monster

Costume Account (They/Them)
i don't like this lightning strike train. i amready did the firstvote, i have the power to have this vote!
 

San Franpsycho

Costume Account (She/Her)
There's nothing wrong with voting a low poster in a costume game, especially with no regular vote tool. It's a lot easier to hide. Unless there's a real day 1 gotcha you might as well get rid of people who are forgettable and blending.
 

Wax Phantom

Costume Account (He/Him)
I know everything is nai on day one

but my reasoning on char gon is just a gut feeling and I don't feel comfortable with a costumed elder god whatever in the game after day `
 

Gnome

Costume Account (He/Him)
There's nothing wrong with voting a low poster in a costume game, especially with no regular vote tool. It's a lot easier to hide. Unless there's a real day 1 gotcha you might as well get rid of people who are forgettable and blending.

Yeah, I don’t really have a problem with it either, but Lightning Strike just straight up hasn’t posted at all, and that’s not going to give us any info. I’m just kind of letting it ride for now because I fully expect it to collapse once he shows up though.
 

Wax Phantom

Costume Account (He/Him)
If Lightning Strike is who I think they are, me and them would absolutely having a shitpost competition or day one thunderdome of shitposts

sooooo flying low gives them cover actually
 

Frankenstein

Costume Account (He/Him)
This is how I know you're not Sparks, he would've tagged someone not even in the game lol

VigilantFrailBream-size_restricted.gif
 

Char Gar Gothakon

Costume Account (He/Him)
Do you believe that I saw the tags and forgot it was me because I forgot my name? Lmao. Anyway yeah like I said this is fake af and pretty obvious at that. Also funny how you voted me with some made up bullshit right AFTER I outed you, hilarious.
Vote: Wax Phantom
My gut tells me we have scum here.
 

Frankenstein

Costume Account (He/Him)
Do you believe that I saw the tags and forgot it was me because I forgot my name? Lmao. Anyway yeah like I said this is fake af and pretty obvious at that. Also funny how you voted me with some made up bullshit right AFTER I outed you, hilarious.
Vote: Wax Phantom
My gut tells me we have scum here.

Just for the record, I was the first person to call out the cosplay, although admittedly not as directly as you did.
 

Frankenstein

Costume Account (He/Him)

Spooky Space Kook

Costume Account (She/Her)
Looking at some of the low post count people, and this is what I see.

[He/Him] Technicolor Phantom|Tech has 1 post in the game so far and it's just this

Hey let's no eliminate

[He/Him] Lightning Strikes|Lightning - UTC has no posts at all


[He/Him] Cat Creature - UTC - Has posted several times but only in meows


[He/Him] Baba Yaga - UTC - Only has these 2 posts

This is my first custome game. I'm vanilla. Do I need a mentor?

Snow Ghost who do you swear allegiance to?


[He/Him] Ghost Bear - UTC - Is up to 5 posts but they are mostly around the start of the day focused on shaggy and not claiming


Looking at all of these and trying to figure out which could be scum trying to slide by, I think I have to land here for now.

VOTE : Cat Creature

Some of these feel like genuine low activity and there's a chance they'll come by later in the day and stand out in a good way, but Cat Creature's bit is a good cover for not making connections with people in the game that could be used later on.
 

Wax Phantom

Costume Account (He/Him)
Never heard of day zero cop

and

you just picked me out of a group of people that might have scum

and

so you think Im scum

little sus of your claim of day cop
 

San Franpsycho

Costume Account (She/Her)
Looking at some of the low post count people, and this is what I see.

[He/Him] Technicolor Phantom|Tech has 1 post in the game so far and it's just this



[He/Him] Lightning Strikes|Lightning - UTC has no posts at all


[He/Him] Cat Creature - UTC - Has posted several times but only in meows


[He/Him] Baba Yaga - UTC - Only has these 2 posts






[He/Him] Ghost Bear - UTC - Is up to 5 posts but they are mostly around the start of the day focused on shaggy and not claiming


Looking at all of these and trying to figure out which could be scum trying to slide by, I think I have to land here for now.

VOTE : Cat Creature

Some of these feel like genuine low activity and there's a chance they'll come by later in the day and stand out in a good way, but Cat Creature's bit is a good cover for not making connections with people in the game that could be used later on.
Why would you pick the one person in this group who is actually doing something memorable?
 

Technicolor Phantom

Costume Account (He/Him)
Eh, no point in trying to figure out who Wax is. It's just busywork. The Char vote almost seems too obvious from scum, though.

Also too obvious is Boo jumping on the Lightning wagon.
 

Char Gar Gothakon

Costume Account (He/Him)
Scum is more likely doing sparks rp
Yeah, like I looked at the previous costume game and mafia games Sparks was in and he lived a few days at least, it's easy for scum to try and imitate that for a bit, god forbid if they have a role like Geno's last costume party and escape to another body mid game.
 

Frankenstein

Costume Account (He/Him)
Yeah, like I looked at the previous costume game and mafia games Sparks was in and he lived a few days at least, it's easy for scum to try and imitate that for a bit, god forbid if they have a role like Geno's last costume party and escape to another body mid game.

It would be interesting if wax was scum because scooby snack monster was very quick to buy the act, despite everyone else being like, yeah but no.
 

Technicolor Phantom

Costume Account (He/Him)
RP is NAI. Costume games are rare and are a chance to let loose and try something different. It's not detrimental to your scum team.

The unspoken expectation is that you drop the act later when we actually require you to play mafia.
 

Char Gar Gothakon

Costume Account (He/Him)
RP is NAI. Costume games are rare and are a chance to let loose and try something different. It's not detrimental to your scum team.

The unspoken expectation is that you drop the act later when we actually require you to play mafia.
RP is not NAI what the hell? You'd be ok with someone dropping the act day 3 and suddenly being like "Yeah ok was joking guys."
Geno did what now?
Geno had a role that allowed him to steal an account, leaving the old one behind.
 

Scooby Snack Monster

Costume Account (He/Him)
my two cents

[He/Him] Technicolor Phantom|Tech has 1 post in the game so far and it's just this
if Phantom is going for the low effort coast scum strategy, they don’t let their only contribution be that for 24(?) hours of game time. that was probably a joke given...

Eh, no point in trying to figure out who Wax is. It's just busywork. The Char vote almost seems too obvious from scum, though.

Also too obvious is Boo jumping on the Lightning wagon.
RP is NAI. Costume games are rare and are a chance to let loose and try something different. It's not detrimental to your scum team.

The unspoken expectation is that you drop the act later when we actually require you to play mafia.
these two more recent posts. technicolor isn’t asleep at the wheel here. if it’s the player I think it is, this is expected and I wouldn’t want to waste a D1 on that.

[He/Him] Baba Yaga - UTC - Only has these 2 posts
more shots on goal, but again too light to make a case there.

[He/Him] Ghost Bear - UTC - Is up to 5 posts but they are mostly around the start of the day focused on shaggy and not claiming
5 posts and little content - maybe a little higher on my hit list than the other two, just because he had more opportunity to say something meaningful and didn’t.

Some of these feel like genuine low activity and there's a chance they'll come by later in the day and stand out in a good way, but Cat Creature's bit is a good cover for not making connections with people in the game that could be used later on.
not sure Cat Creature is it, but I am curious how far he will take the charade.
 

Lightning Strikes

Costume Account (He/Him)
The idea of voting for an inactive is that at least you get the flip which will hopefully give you some information. I'm not saying voting an inactive is the best option, I'd rather not do it myself, but I am saying it's better than a no vote.
So You Rather Not Vote for an Inactive Yet.
VOTE: Lightning Strikes
Lightning has barely posted and there's already some votes so I'll hop on this train for now.
You Vote a Player with Zero Posts? If you really were interested in solving the game Why not go after an active player instead of a Literal Non Poster?

Preferring to Vote an Inactive than No VOTE is Fine but Those are not the only two Options and You know this. Were a Full 24 Hours from day end and a Comment like this as if you cant start pushing and active player yourself Reeks.

Your Either Scum or Willfully playing Lazy and counter to the Philosophy you yourself Presented.
Vote:BooBeard
@Lightning Strikes are you flying low for a reason?
I had to find a new Computer or download new Browser to sign in on because my regular mafia locations that I play Auto log me into My regular account. I can't even remember How I posted my pre-game Post.
Eh, no point in trying to figure out who Wax is. It's just busywork. The Char vote almost seems too obvious from scum, though.

Also too obvious is Boo jumping on the Lightning wagon.
Yeah Figuring out who players are without knowing the full field feels like a waste of time. We should either Not worry about who is who and just focus on playing Mafia and solving based on peoples actions.

Or the only other way is everyone Mass claiming there real Identities Which I am fine with. This identity secrecy only Helps mafia anyway.

I am jman1954goat by the way no point in keeping that a secret.


I heavily disagree that BooBeard being mafia is too Obvious. I don't think they understood how suspect there Vote was going to look. Too him they explained there reasoning well and probably assumed it would get read as normal activity.

Maifia make bad plays and bad Post all the time let's stop over estimating them. This is not a bold sceem where you can use excuse mafia would not do that. this is just routine activity post were the player was sloppy.
 

BooBeard

Costume Account (He/Him)
So You Rather Not Vote for an Inactive Yet.

You Vote a Player with Zero Posts? If you really were interested in solving the game Why not go after an active player instead of a Literal Non Poster?

Preferring to Vote an Inactive than No VOTE is Fine but Those are not the only two Options and You know this. Were a Full 24 Hours from day end and a Comment like this as if you cant start pushing and active player yourself Reeks.

Your Either Scum or Willfully playing Lazy and counter to the Philosophy you yourself Presented.
Vote:BooBeard

I had to find a new Computer or download new Browser to sign in on because my regular mafia locations that I play Auto log me into My regular account. I can't even remember How I posted my pre-game Post.

Yeah Figuring out who players are without knowing the full field feels like a waste of time. We should either Not worry about who is who and just focus on playing Mafia and solving based on peoples actions.

Or the only other way is everyone Mass claiming there real Identities Which I am fine with. This identity secrecy only Helps mafia anyway.

I am jman1954goat by the way no point in keeping that a secret.


I heavily disagree that BooBeard being mafia is too Obvious. I don't think they understood how suspect there Vote was going to look. Too him they explained there reasoning well and probably assumed it would get read as normal activity.

Maifia make bad plays and bad Post all the time let's stop over estimating them. This is not a bold sceem where you can use excuse mafia would not do that. this is just routine activity post were the player was sloppy.
This is not sus at all. /s

Why did you just start typing like jman now, and not with your initial post in the thread?
 

Frankenstein

Costume Account (He/Him)
Jman, normally you just never post the first half the day because you just don't and that's all your reasoning, but this time you wanted to post but couldn't?
 

Lightning Strikes

Costume Account (He/Him)
Why did you just start typing like jman now, and not with your initial post in the thread?
I do not see anything Wrong with my Pre-game post.

It was just a check in post to get day Started. ( because you need to post or send PM to check in.)
Jman, normally you just never post the first half the day because you just don't and that's all your reasoning, but this time you wanted to post but couldn't?
About Half and Half. the start of the Day was very much Normal thread watching. I would have posted hours ago But it was Too inconvenient too Find a Place to post without Logging out my regular jman account.

I have a good spot now to Post so I can reply fairly regularly now.
 

Lightning Strikes

Costume Account (He/Him)
By the Way just because you know my name doesn't mean you should say Jman

Whenever possible please refer to me as Lightning Strikes or just Lightning if you Don't want to type the Full thing out.
 

Cat Creature

Costume Account (She/Her)
[He/Him] Cat Creature - UTC - Has posted several times but only in meows
meow
Shame on you Spoopy Kock, how do you expect a cat to speak in anything but meows?!
meow!
Yeah scum is not doing some weird cat rp.
meow!
I sincerely hope Cat Creature only communicates in meows for the rest of the game
hmmmmeow...
The unspoken expectation is that you drop the act later when we actually require you to play mafia.
...meow :(
 

The Ghost of Stealin Stan

Costume Account (He/Him)
Anyone could be rp’ing so No point in claiming early (looking at you party pooper jman).

Let’s try a train on someone who’s active and making connections, but not analyzing or solving.

vote: Pazzo
 

Wax Phantom

Costume Account (He/Him)
@Cat Creature

You wacky cat man creature hybrid motherfucker

You're gonna skate free on day one and that's fine


that's great inactive motherfuckers get boot'd to the shadowrealm from beyond


BUT ME


ME!!!!!1111!!!

You are a disctraction from the real scum team killin in the shadow

Climb in that tree branch and stay there bich
 

Woodsman

Costume Account (He/Him)
I agree with you that a shot in the dark is as good a place to start as any. I'm just tired of this Day 1 no vote discussion every game, sorry.

That said:
VOTE: Lightning Strikes
Lightning has barely posted and there's already some votes so I'll hop on this train for now.
I don't really like this vote. Nothing wrong with hopping on others trains, but if your only argument is the train itself existing it seems kind of lazy.

So You Rather Not Vote for an Inactive Yet.

You Vote a Player with Zero Posts? If you really were interested in solving the game Why not go after an active player instead of a Literal Non Poster?

Preferring to Vote an Inactive than No VOTE is Fine but Those are not the only two Options and You know this. Were a Full 24 Hours from day end and a Comment like this as if you cant start pushing and active player yourself Reeks.

Your Either Scum or Willfully playing Lazy and counter to the Philosophy you yourself Presented.
Vote:BooBeard

I had to find a new Computer or download new Browser to sign in on because my regular mafia locations that I play Auto log me into My regular account. I can't even remember How I posted my pre-game Post.

Yeah Figuring out who players are without knowing the full field feels like a waste of time. We should either Not worry about who is who and just focus on playing Mafia and solving based on peoples actions.

Or the only other way is everyone Mass claiming there real Identities Which I am fine with. This identity secrecy only Helps mafia anyway.

I am jman1954goat by the way no point in keeping that a secret.


I heavily disagree that BooBeard being mafia is too Obvious. I don't think they understood how suspect there Vote was going to look. Too him they explained there reasoning well and probably assumed it would get read as normal activity.

Maifia make bad plays and bad Post all the time let's stop over estimating them. This is not a bold sceem where you can use excuse mafia would not do that. this is just routine activity post were the player was sloppy.
I can agree on the points about BooBears vote, but claiming ones identity seems really unnecessary. It's just another piece of information that doesn't need to be disclosed openly and is probably better kept secret. Pushing for others to reveal it doesn't sit right with me.
 

Woodsman

Costume Account (He/Him)
Yeah, like I looked at the previous costume game and mafia games Sparks was in and he lived a few days at least, it's easy for scum to try and imitate that for a bit, god forbid if they have a role like Geno's last costume party and escape to another body mid game.
That seems like a rather big leap in reasoning.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom