I have no idea who you are.
TP mentioned him to me in our chat, he said tomorrow he might go there or Baba, I can't check now but d2 I think he voted Skunk, which makes me think he went there and for some reason didn't kill him.
You're getting ahead of yourself and contradicting yourself, if I were arso I would've doused jman since that's how you think it works. Jman isn't doused, 2nd of all why would I lie about Cat Creature being Fanto instead of taking the easy route and replacing Fanto with jman, I just forgot to target jman, that's all.
Just so you know, he didn't vote Skunk D2, went for Hyde, unvoted after mason claim, and didn't vote again.
You're right, he didn't vote there. I don't have access to the chat but he said something along the lines of Baba was a null read and Skunk was a slight scum read, he didn't really give reasoning behind the reads, like I said it was like 5 messages.
Ah, no. You could be arsonist. No names bullshit.
I just got to the part in D3 where you say that, so sorry for making you repeat yourself. It's a bit strange that Tech would consider a null and scum read to talk to given the risks of the role. If they did that they would have to be confident in their ability to sniff out scum. But I can't read the mind of a dead person so who knows.
I mean as scum I could easily say Jman instead of Fanto, changes nothing, I made a mistake, either I did it as scum fakeclaiming or as town, take your pick, what you are saying now is bullshit and you know it.
I think he probably wanted to utilize the vigilante part of the role before it was too late and people started questioning him, just my guess. Baba idk, if Skunk is scum I think Baba is probably not, if Skunk isn't then it might be Baba. I will echo the thoughts of others about town leaders being dangerous and needing a look, Sans was before but not as much now, Stan is taking that role. Mason pair is probably town, Snow Ghost needs a second look later in the game if a goon doesn't flip. As for what you said before about me wanting others to do the work, I literally don't have time, I work as a waiter from 1 pm to 1 am and normally can't look at my phone at all, all of this is at the risk of being fired, and I come back and the only person talking is Wax trolling me, a person who landed a believeable claim and is shitposting the whole time without the need to scumhunt, like I'm sorry I didn't land doctor and I landed a role I have to guess identities and do extra work, I haven't even had a chance to reread the game, until now I thought TP voted Skunk D2. If I survive today I'm replacing out, it's too much on me rn.
Yes, I have no way to prove this is a town role, you believe me or you don't.
Thanks for using your limited time on that answer then.
You even acknowledge here that JMan's an entity in this game. Yet you're thinking about guessing Baba or Neon? If you know a guaranteed one, okay you might have forgotten it, but now you clearly remember, why not now? Can you explain your reasoning here?
I think in my head I had jman as jman and not as lightning and is why I keep mentioning him but didn't guess him. Like yeah not that you guys reminded me I'm gonna guess jman tomorrow, it really just went over my head.
I'm still hyped out of my mind. FIRST WCF !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ok so we established real identity is important and scum probably has an ability that interacts with it.
Okay. Sorry I'm on you so much, I have a lot of questions after rereading you and I'm trying to get in your head.
Speed, I am Speed.
i dont care what anyone says, thats one of the best sci-fi films of all time
You caught up that fast? Wow.
It’s a very obvious guess in a costume game, got better evidence?
Scum confirmed
The theory from Stan doesn't fully gel with me, but it's definitely worth pointing out all the things that don't quite add up here for us with the supposed Gossip targets, something is definitely fishy there. Nothing about the Char role claim tells me he has to be Town here either, could be, but it could also be a total bullshit claim (very Geno claim tbh) or it could be a Scum role. The bit about him forgetting Jman is... a tough pill for me to swallow, unless I think of this as a bullshit claim he just came up with on the spot and later realized he goofed it a bit lol.
These accounts are fresh, just go to their profile and you'll see all their posts.
Oops your not a nes person that's skunk. Well skunk I'm impressed you caught up so fast.
It's not just forgetting its forgetting For 4 days in a row.
You need to click the "see more" button on the far right of the grey bar that shows up beneath the most recent posts it shows on the postings page.
The button to see the rest is in the lower right, its shaded almost the same color as the background, kind of how the spoiler tags are on here, but it does exist lol.
Same thoughts that's why I asked him to double confirm his powers work like that.
What if snacks was N1 gossip target and got told who TP was gonna invite next and that’s where the red check came from?
Since i’m thinking char gar isn’t town for sure, he could not have been n1 right? Or TP would have died earlier?
Oh, was he? Nvm then. very lost on the timeline here.
It IS fanto
Then my concept still stands! Gar claiming to be gossiped after gossip died could be a scum attempt to self clear….but all scum would have heard about the gossip’s abilities so it wouldn’t mean scum!gar had to have been directly selected. A teammate could have been. Doesn’t explain snacks not countering it tho. Anyway.
Can you tell me why? I keep waiting for someone to tell me why and that "I'll vote here but do absolutely nothing at all to pursue it" feels like a soft bus to me, but every time I ask I get nothing. I think this is the one place where I disagree with the prevailing thoughts in the thread, but I REALLY disagree.
A soft bus with a vote on Char Gar? Is that what you're talking about?
It's at the bottom and on the default theme it's super hard to see because it's like one shade different in color, but it's on the bottom right after you go to the profile and click "postings."
Or the earlier vote on SC?
Yeah. Because it's just a dead vote. It LOOKS a lot like the Hyde votes that happened but with no pressure, no nothing, right? No follow up. It's like this:
Huh... I'll be honest I completely missed that read list in #1366 when checking the ISO. That whole thing is kind of.... yikes. Lightning as the top Scum read? And shouting out the Arsonist as a possible reason (neutral hunting, big yikes). Gnome is also in kind of a happy place in that list, above a bunch of other people she's calling Scum instead.
The last thing I would do as an arsonist is douse anyone who is up my ass. It seems like a poor play. I expect the arsonist is one of the bumblefucks who is half ghosting the thread. This is a perpetual problem that is compounded by the costume structure, because you have:
That's very Sans behavior though in general. Not sure about the drop in activity, it's hard for me to judge without proper post count tracking.
I definitely agree with this, though I'd say I'm leaning Scum, call it 60/40 for me lol.
There's no profile for a scum. Especially when you're talking about the man who once STARTED A TRAIN on his own teammate for a slip that could have easily been saved (that was also a costume game).
You are one of the few who I personally found pretty obvious, haha. I did not know who Baba was until Geno outed there and then it clicked. A lot of people just blend, but you have a very off-the-cuff casual quality that is pretty unique.
Stan's theory is pretty convoluted. I was not sold on that alone - felt like a bit of a reach. And I'll say this - I said it before, too - the one hesitation I have is that Geno is doing absolutely nothing in this game and scumGeno at least buses in a pretty aggro fashion. That hasn't happened. If I have any hesitancy, it's there... but you can't do that if you're the arsonist, which could explain it.
It makes me feel marginally better that maybe I convinced someone, I guess!
I would like to address this.
Nah, no one's setting up flip chains and we're not doing this subtle manipulation. The fact of the matter is that your "pursuit" of Char was not pursuit at all and it reflects on you and will get read and parsed after he flips.
