A more serious take on this:
-1) Pretyping this all since I might be sleeping when the day starts.
0) I strongly believe that once I die, the recruitment power dies with me. Cult is almost impossible to kill otherwise. Me getting the power should just have been a safety mechanic that eliminates some remote scenarios in which it is possible for Cult to lose on N1.
1) I am a Soup Vendor, nothing but your ordinary FV with a coat of paint. I gave some soup to Faddy on N1 (I was young and town then!) and he got it. I mentioned soup in a post on D1, it ain't the biggest crumb ever, but it is there. The soup does nothing. I do not know the message that the recipient gets, so we cannot lie about receiving soup as long as Faddy can disprove it. I imagine that the message might just be the standard "You got some soup!" in red, but there is no way to know that.
2) As a townie, there is no reason for me to ever do anything but give out soup. I have now broken this rule. If I was a good little townie, once everyone has shown up, I should set out to seek the missing soup. I will effectively need to soft claim and name my target. You were my target and I did not soup you, so before I say anything, I want to hear your take on our plan of action. Do I lie and say I targeted someone else? Do I dare to say that I targeted you? Or do I just say nothing and hope that nobody cares about such a minor detail as a bowl of missing soup?
3) I fear that if I out my connection with the soup, someone will make the connection that my missing action could just be me getting in front of the missing soup. No soup? You never gave it out, you filthy cultist you. Lying about the target easily sets up a cascade of lies that cannot be controlled. Saying that I targeted you will attach you and I and once one of us flips, you know where everyone else will be looking next.
Silence seems like the best option to me. It means that I will have issues once mass claim comes around, but lets worry about that when we get there. I have an excuse for the crumb, should it ever come up.