Game Thread MafiEra Mafia Ultimate Day 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

Catalina (3 votes)
Pazzo the Ghost Clown - #452
Yami Bakura - #455
Illuminati Member 2 - #483

Yami Bakura (3 votes)
San Franpsycho - #317
Lightning Strikes - #319
Captain Skunkbeard - #321
Illuminati Member 2 - #322 #483

Illuminati Member 2 (2 votes)
Zordon - #490
Thresh - #495

Captain Skunkbeard (1 votes)
Baba Yaga - #316

Barack Obama (0 votes)
Baba Yaga - #127 #316

Not voting: Cinderella, Bob Ross, Minecraft Steve, Rita Repulsa, Illuminati Member 5, Blue Ranger, The Ghost of Stealin Stan, Pink Ranger, Honey, Catalina, Illuminati Member 3, Goldar, Rey, Barack Obama, Captain Picard, Illuminati Member 4, Carl, Tommy V, Black Ranger, Barney, Niko, Kool Aid Man, Q, Michael, Spider-Man, Claude

Post Counts:
Illuminati Member 2: 46 Thresh: 44 Minecraft Steve: 39 Barney: 33 Captain Skunkbeard: 27 San Franpsycho: 27 Baba Yaga: 25 Black Ranger: 25 Illuminati Member 4: 23 Zordon: 22 Lightning Strikes: 21 Yami Bakura: 21 Pink Ranger: 17 Blue Ranger: 16 Bob Ross: 14 Pazzo the Ghost Clown: 13 Claude: 10 Catalina: 9 Carl: 7 Honey: 7 Cinderella: 6 Rita Repulsa: 5 Illuminati Member 5: 1 Illuminati Member 3: 1 Spider-Man: 1


Click here to go to the Vote Tool!


Sleep time
 

Zordon

Costume Account
So you don't think it's weird to just be like "Oh look I have vital info, but you are not getting it until D4, haha"
VOTE: Illuminati Member 2

lmao
THIS SHOULD SATSIFY YOU AS AN ANSWER.

BUT IN MY OWN WORDS: NO, I DO NOT FIND IT SCUMMY. A LITTLE FRUSTRATING, YES, BUT THERE IS NO NEED FOR SCUM TO DO SUCH A THING HERE.
I wonder if Kawl will even show
I HOPE HE APPEARS JUST TO OVERRIDE AND THEN LEAVES WITHOUT A WORD.
 

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
This is going to be so hard.

Let's turbo no vote and get back to knowing what's going on.

No Vote
This post by itself seems genuine, "I got info I'm dying to spill but I don't know if this is the place, fine
Yep and I was going to crack this entire game wide open with a prepared post but because of costumes I can't say what I know because I will want to reference it later without getting mod killed by geno.
This one shows Catalina wants the credit for the revelation, that tells me Catalina cares more about how good the info makes Catalina look than how good the info is in general for town, maybe.

I'm to scared to share anything will tell you tomorrow. Don't worry about it.
Scared, but not scared enough to just not mention it yet.
everyone telling me to share now is wrong because you don't know what i know. this is info better had on a regular day and im asking for some trust here.
Fair, but also a step in the "Just let me live".
 
So you don't think it's weird to just be like "Oh look I have vital info, but you are not getting it until D4, haha"

i don't like teasing information and being coy about it but i don't think it's a reason to scum read on someone. those that are trying to put pressure on cata look a little sus to me because i'm not sure they all have pure motivations.
 

Zordon

Costume Account
This post by itself seems genuine, "I got info I'm dying to spill but I don't know if this is the place, fine

This one shows Catalina wants the credit for the revelation, that tells me Catalina cares more about how good the info makes Catalina look than how good the info is in general for town, maybe.


Scared, but not scared enough to just not mention it yet.

Fair, but also a step in the "Just let me live".
FROM A SCUM POINT OF VIEW WHY WOULD THEY SAY THIS AND PAINT THE TARGET ON THEMSELVES WHEN WE ARE ALL WEARING MASKS. THEY NEED ONLY LAY LOW TO RIDE THROUGH THE DAY AND INTO THE NEXT. INSTEAD, THEY ANNOUNCE THEY HAVE GREAT INFORMATION TO SHARE AND WISH TO HURRY ALONG TO BE ABLE TO SHARE IT. EVEN BEFORE ANNOUNCING SUCH A THING THEY MAKE IT CLEAR THAT IS THEIR GOAL BY SUGGESTING A 'NO VOTE'.

THEY ARE NOW ASKING TO LIVE IN ORDER TO SHARE SAID INFORMATION.

I ALSO FIND IT UNFORTUNATE THEY ARE UNWILLING TO SHARE IT. BUT I FAIL TO SEE HOW AND WHY SCUM WOULD TAKE THIS ACTION TO BRING ATTENTION TO THEMSELVES IN A BRAND NEW DAY 1 SITUATION.
 
This one shows Catalina wants the credit for the revelation, that tells me Catalina cares more about how good the info makes Catalina look than how good the info is in general for town, maybe.
I don't want credit for the revelation. The info is less useful if shared in this costume thread.
Scared, but not scared enough to just not mention it yet.
Im scared of getting Mod killed By Geno tomorrow if i reference specific night events from today.
Your misunderstanding my entire motivation either through Ignorance or Malice.
 

Pazzo the Ghost Clown

Costume Account (He/Him)
Pazzo thinks we can come back to this tomorrow when they share the info. Pazzo does not think they are worth pressuring any longer. Pazzo saw what they needed to.
 

Lightning Strikes

Costume Account (He/Him)
I don't want credit for the revelation. The info is less useful if shared in this costume thread.

Im scared of getting Mod killed By Geno tomorrow if i reference specific night events from today.
Your misunderstanding my entire motivation either through Ignorance or Malice.
ok then i would suggest just dm'ing geno straight up and ask "is this post ok" and then he could be like "yes" or "no"
 

Baba Yaga

Costume Account (He/Him)
So you don't think it's weird to just be like "Oh look I have vital info, but you are not getting it until D4, haha"
That's literally just tomorrow, so no it's not weird. Scum trying to buy time for a single day sounds fruitless.

I do think it's pointless of them to even bring it up today though.
 

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
FROM A SCUM POINT OF VIEW WHY WOULD THEY SAY THIS AND PAINT THE TARGET ON THEMSELVES WHEN WE ARE ALL WEARING MASKS. THEY NEED ONLY LAY LOW TO RIDE THROUGH THE DAY AND INTO THE NEXT. INSTEAD, THEY ANNOUNCE THEY HAVE GREAT INFORMATION TO SHARE AND WISH TO HURRY ALONG TO BE ABLE TO SHARE IT. EVEN BEFORE ANNOUNCING SUCH A THING THEY MAKE IT CLEAR THAT IS THEIR GOAL BY SUGGESTING A 'NO VOTE'.

THEY ARE NOW ASKING TO LIVE IN ORDER TO SHARE SAID INFORMATION.

I ALSO FIND IT UNFORTUNATE THEY ARE UNWILLING TO SHARE IT. BUT I FAIL TO SEE HOW AND WHY SCUM WOULD TAKE THIS ACTION TO BRING ATTENTION TO THEMSELVES IN A BRAND NEW DAY 1 SITUATION.
So you are saying scum or neutral players never tease stuff to get one more day and get closer to their win condition? Or setup claims unprompted so they can point them out later to prove how town they are? Ok, fine, sorry for trying to actually putting pressure on someone I believe might not have the interests of town in mind.
 

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
I don't want credit for the revelation. The info is less useful if shared in this costume thread.

Im scared of getting Mod killed By Geno tomorrow if i reference specific night events from today.
Your misunderstanding my entire motivation either through Ignorance or Malice.
You can ask Geno now what would be ok to share and reference during the day. Just look at sorian constanly lawyering any and all restrictions.
 

Zordon

Costume Account
So you are saying scum or neutral players never tease stuff to get one more day and get closer to their win condition? Or setup claims unprompted so they can point them out later to prove how town they are? Ok, fine, sorry for trying to actually putting pressure on someone I believe might not have the interests of town in mind.
THOSE ARE NOT MY WORDS. IF CATALINA IS A NEUTRAL AND THIS WAS THEIR PLAY IN ORDER TO WIN THEN I WILL SAY TO THEM, "WELL DONE".

SCUM HAVE NO REASON TO PLAY THIS CARD SO EARLY. THERE ARE STILL MANY OF US LEFT STANDING AND THEY COULD NOT WIN TOMORROW.

I SIMPLY THINK YOU ARE MISREADING A SCARED TOWN REACTION AS A SCUM ONE. HOWEVER, YOUR EAGERNESS TO JUMP ON SUCH A CLAIM DOES NOT SIT WELL WITH ME.
 

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
That's literally just tomorrow, so no it's not weird. Scum trying to buy time for a single day sounds fruitless.

I do think it's pointless of them to even bring it up today though.
That is why I thought it was worth pursuing, to see the motivations. I guess "Geno might kill me" is good enough, but is that really it?

I have a hard time coming up with reasons why the info would be useless while we are on the costume game when it can easily be re-contextualized in the main game.
 

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
If anything Catalina can reveal sensitive info now as town and not be afraid to be killed for it by scum during the next few days, if scum has no direct way of finding out who catalina is. If it's something like a watch or a cop shot, the anonymity surely is a good thing? Maybe it's just me.
 

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
THOSE ARE NOT MY WORDS. IF CATALINA IS A NEUTRAL AND THIS WAS THEIR PLAY IN ORDER TO WIN THEN I WILL SAY TO THEM, "WELL DONE".

SCUM HAVE NO REASON TO PLAY THIS CARD SO EARLY. THERE ARE STILL MANY OF US LEFT STANDING AND THEY COULD NOT WIN TOMORROW.

I SIMPLY THINK YOU ARE MISREADING A SCARED TOWN REACTION AS A SCUM ONE. HOWEVER, YOUR EAGERNESS TO JUMP ON SUCH A CLAIM DOES NOT SIT WELL WITH ME.
I really can't take anything you say seriously when Catalina is literally your lover partner, come on.
 

San Franpsycho

Costume Account (She/Her)
Three, I have a thingy.

Did you send me the thingy? Would you like the thingy carefully returned to you in the same manner?
 

Zordon

Costume Account
If anything Catalina can reveal sensitive info now as town and not be afraid to be killed for it by scum during the next few days, if scum has no direct way of finding out who catalina is. If it's something like a watch or a cop shot, the anonymity surely is a good thing? Maybe it's just me.
I AGREE WITH THIS AS WELL. CHECKS ARE BETTER GIVEN TODAY UNDER ANONYMITY TO BE SAFE. THIS MAKES ME BELIEVE THAT CATALINA'S IS DIFFERENT IN SOME WAY.
I really can't take anything you say seriously when Catalina is literally your lover partner, come on.
ARE YOU SURE IT'S NOT THE CAPSLOCK?

BUT I DO UNDERSTAND. I DID SAY AT THE BEGINNING OF THIS THAT I AM A BIASED PARTY. HOWEVER, IF I BELIEVED THAT CATALINA WERE SCUM I WOULD WILLINGLY THROW MYSELF ON THE SWORD FOR IT. MY ROLE IS NOT VERY POWERFUL IN THE GRAND SCHEME OF THIS GAME.
 

Minecraft Steve

Costume Account
i dont understand why catalina brught the info up in the first place but town does make mistakes

its a large game, im ok shelving this ntil later and evaluating then. zordon seems resoinble so far, killing posibly 2 townies over perceived meaning behind bringing info up seems a waste
 
I find the mod kill excuse kind of week for obvious reasons, it's not super hard to ask Geno what is and isn't allowed and he's been pretty direct that using your role information is 100% fine, you are good all the way before "I am X"
 
Idk who my partner, Spider-Man, is and said person is not making a huge effort to talk in partner chat. I am fine voting out my partner btw if it comes to that. Thresh does not fear this modifier.
 

Spider-Man

Costume Account
GOD @Geno im sending you so many therapy invoices omg

if this games doesn't burn me out it'll be a miracle

omg so much fuckery about omg how long is this going to last
 

Baba Yaga

Costume Account (He/Him)
Idk who my partner, Spider-Man, is and said person is not making a huge effort to talk in partner chat. I am fine voting out my partner btw if it comes to that. Thresh does not fear this modifier.
Deathproof soft? Sus.
 

San Franpsycho

Costume Account (She/Her)
Idk who my partner, Spider-Man, is and said person is not making a huge effort to talk in partner chat. I am fine voting out my partner btw if it comes to that. Thresh does not fear this modifier.
I think it will not be hard to decipher
 
You can ask Geno now what would be ok to share and reference during the day. Just look at sorian constanly lawyering any and all restrictions.

Geno says some of the stuff I have to say could be slightly problematic to talk about in the game thread tomorrow especially if if word it bad. Even if scum kill me tonight your going to find out part of it real soon anyway. Another part you can infer from my P.M. tomorrow so its all good if I die.
 

Spider-Man

Costume Account
Oh now I remember this game,

this is the game that Randomless ate my soul and blended in so well with thread and then i voted him off and gave scum the win

OH SHIT!
 

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
Geno says some of the stuff I have to say could be slightly problematic to talk about in the game thread tomorrow especially if if word it bad. Even if scum kill me tonight your going to find out part of it real soon anyway. Another part you can infer from my P.M. tomorrow so its all good if I die.
Would it be ok too if we vote you out, or only if you get killed by scum?
 

Zordon

Costume Account
Geno says some of the stuff I have to say could be slightly problematic to talk about in the game thread tomorrow especially if if word it bad. Even if scum kill me tonight your going to find out part of it real soon anyway. Another part you can infer from my P.M. tomorrow so its all good if I die.
GOOD. AS LONG AS WE CAN STILL FIND THE INFORMATION IN CASE YOU DIE. HOPEFULLY IT WILL NOT COME TO THAT.
Pazzo thinks Spider-Man is the fake
I WOULD AGREE
 
Vote: Illuminati Member 2

none of the votes on catalina was great but this vote and additional comments were the worst of them
 

Minecraft Steve

Costume Account
i think spider-man is the fake between them n honey

if they real somehow i find it hard to believe the lovers pairs are entirely randomly selected
 

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
Vote: Illuminati Member 2

none of the votes on catalina was great but this vote and additional comments were the worst of them
You couldn't be voting me in good fate for trying to actually follow a lead, put pressure, following through and getting a relatively satisfactory conclusion out of it. It's like you don't want me to scum hunt

Vote: Claude
 

Spider-Man

Costume Account
If that wasn't a tip off that's pretty damn good impression of who I think you're impersonating

simple but effective
 
You couldn't be voting me in good fate for trying to actually follow a lead, put pressure, following through and getting a relatively satisfactory conclusion out of it. It's like you don't want me to scum hunt

Vote: Claude

that wasn't scum hunting, that was fishing like you were scared something might come out
 

Zordon

Costume Account
SPIDER-MAN NEEDS TO WORK ON HIS FUNKY DUDE SPARKS IMPRESSION. IT FALTERED VERY QUICKLY.
Do you folks think scum knows who everyone in their team in their costumes are, or are they also in the dark?
THAT SEEMS UNFAIR TO SCUM AS THEY COULD VOTE OUT THEIR OWN. I WOULD BE SURPRISED IF THEY DID NOT KNOW WHO THEIR TEAMMATES WERE.
 

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
that wasn't scum hunting, that was fishing like you were scared something might come out
If I was afraid something was coming out... why would I encourage Catalina to put it out there? If you are going to suspect me over something at least make it make sense with what actually happened in the thread.
 
I have spoken to Spider-Man privately and I do kind of agree with Zoltan in that this feels like a bad impression but they passed all my testing so I have to assume they are who they seem to be
 
If I was afraid something was coming out... why would I encourage Catalina to put it out there? If you are going to suspect me over something at least make it make sense with what actually happened in the thread.
you immediately went to accusatory on them as if you were trying to discredit them from the start. your approach to that whole thing was not townie.
 

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
you immediately went to accusatory on them as if you were trying to discredit them from the start. your approach to that whole thing was not townie.
This is bullshit and you know it. Look at why I voted. I want town to get the info if it exists. This was pressure, I got my answer, I actually encouraged Catalina to get answer to Geno, and left Catalina alone when Catalina mentioned the info will come out regardless of a kill or a vote.

So you are either not reading or making a weak excuse to vote me out because you don't care if I'm scum or not, you just want me out.
 

Zordon

Costume Account
I have spoken to Spider-Man privately and I do kind of agree with Zoltan in that this feels like a bad impression but they passed all my testing so I have to assume they are who they seem to be
PERHAPS YOUR EXAMINATION NEEDS TO BE UPDATED.

HOWEVER, THEY SEEM HARMLESS FOR THE TIME BEING. I SAY LET THEM HAVE THEIR FUN IN IMPERSONATING WHO THEY WISH.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom